Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We fecking told you so. Brexit making us suffer.

413 replies

flashbac · 24/09/2021 22:08

Project Fear you said. Sunlit Uplands you said. Sovereignty you said. Can I buy food and heat my house with Sovereignty? Can I put sovereignty in my car's fuel tank? Can I?

It was common sense that this would happen. Common SENSE.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
EnidFrighten · 25/09/2021 08:04

[quote TheReluctantPhoenix]@Iggly,

I don’t think anyone (with half a brain) believed that, in the short term, which could be a decade, frictional costs of Brexit would not outweigh benefits.

However, being in the EU allowed us to mismanage everything important to an ongoing stable society (fair pay, education etc). We could cover over the cracks with our infinite supply of cheap Eastern European labour, regardless of the cracks to the fabric of society.

If the EU just consisted of the original Northern European members, I could buy into it, as there was, broadly, equality of income, law etc.

When you see pay and conditions being forced up for crop pickers, lorry drivers etc, I see this as a Brexit benefit. And not having infinite choice in Waitrose every time I shop there is a very small price to pay.[/quote]
@thereluctantphoenix

Immediate benefit was exactly what people were promised and what swung the vote for leave. Saying anyone with half a brain knew it would result in a decade of misery is equivalent to admitting most brexit promises were lies.

'Being in the EU allowed us to mismanage' is an amazing bit of mental gymnastics. We might have been running the economy on poor principles and failing to invest in education and training enough. If we mismanaged within the EU, why would we suddenly become better outside of it? It was the shitty choice of our own politicians. Nothing to do with the EU. We could have delayed freedom of movement for newly joined countries and then applied the limitations other countries have so people return after three months if not in employment. We chose not to.

It's not about having infinite choice in Waitrose. That's absolutely dismissive. Food shortages mean some people will go hungry because prices rise. Brexit will cause people to go hungry.

Iggly · 25/09/2021 08:04

Having said this, I think it's pointless talking about Brexit anymore. It's done. The majority voted for it and gave a clear majority to the government you have now

Brexit is not done. Brexit will take years to be “done” and can be “done” in different ways.

Alondra · 25/09/2021 08:03

I'm not British but always supported remain as I have family in the UK and couldn't understand why Britain will damage itself for no reason leaving the EU.

Having said this, I think it's pointless talking about Brexit anymore. It's done. The majority voted for it and gave a clear majority to the government you have now.

I don't think doing a U turn granting haulage visas is not going to solve the problem for the UK thou. Truck drivers are very sought after in the EU and prices are competitive. Few want to come back to the UK, they'll need to be paid 3 times as much to do so which then will be passed on consumers. Dover is a serious problem for truck drivers coming back to Europe with cargo. Lots of paperwork, delays and awful conditions with few dirty toilets. UK government/s need to begin solving problems instead of trying to reverse Brexit decisions that are conductive nowhere.

Beapot · 25/09/2021 08:02

@P0ntiacBandit

While Brexit is most definitely a factor, read up on the IR 35 reforms and lorry drivers. That's something no one is talking about and this is the primary reason why the lorry drivers are not continuing to work. Hopefully Rishi can stop the madness.
IR35 does make things fairer in other sectors though so I don't think it's all bad (aside from those who pay more tax now of course), but yes it should have been better considered in regards to sectors such as this where it made up for inadequate pay.
Droite · 25/09/2021 08:01

@EatSleepRantRepeat

If people had spent the last 5 years doing proper planning instead of batching and trying to overturn the result, recruiting and training British people in shortage jobs, and paying people decent wages in the first place we wouldn't be in such a mess. I'm not willing to live in a country which runs on exploiting poor Eastern Europeans and migrants because we won't pay the going rate for goods and services.
"People"? You mean the people who voted in the idiots who bore heavy responsibility for Brexit in the first place? Or do you mean those idiots. They are, after all, the people who said Brexit would all be wonderful and who had responsibility for the necessary planning.
daytripper28 · 25/09/2021 07:56

Were none of the many, many existing threads on this very subject good enough?

Nope Biscuit

TheReluctantPhoenix · 25/09/2021 07:55

@Pokhora,

Whether it was ‘about’ raising wages, that is certainly happening. Now, no one will conclude firmly that it will continue, but many sceptical journals are at least admitting it is a possibility.

cebr.com/reports/the-times-labour-shortage-is-forcing-pay-up-but-how-long-can-it-last/

www.google.co.uk/amp/s/www.independent.co.uk/voices/brexit-wages-hospitality-retail-pandemic-b1890591.html%3famp

P0ntiacBandit · 25/09/2021 07:54

While Brexit is most definitely a factor, read up on the IR 35 reforms and lorry drivers. That's something no one is talking about and this is the primary reason why the lorry drivers are not continuing to work. Hopefully Rishi can stop the madness.

JackieWeaverHandforthCouncil · 25/09/2021 07:54

Things will continue to get worse. I know a few vociferously pro-Brexit people IRL. Whenever anyone tried to warn them of consequences they screamed Project Fear’. They weren’t lied to, they wanted to hear what they wanted to hear.

Things have changed since then. One pretends the current issues aren’t linked to Brexit. Another one is trying to rewrite history and say they were against Brexit all along.

I wish to God there was some way that only Brexit voters paid the ‘price worth paying’.

Pokhora · 25/09/2021 07:46

The tories have already made a u turn on immigration. It anyone still thinks brexit was about raising wages and living conditions they are very deluded.
www.theguardian.com/business/2021/sep/24/supply-chain-crisis-tories-poised-turn-foreign-worker-visas?CMP=Share_AndroidApp_Other

FleetwoodRaincoat · 25/09/2021 07:44

Absolutely OP. Brexiteers are getting what they wished for. Tossers.

somewhereovertherain · 25/09/2021 07:41

@EatSleepRantRepeat

If people had spent the last 5 years doing proper planning instead of batching and trying to overturn the result, recruiting and training British people in shortage jobs, and paying people decent wages in the first place we wouldn't be in such a mess. I'm not willing to live in a country which runs on exploiting poor Eastern Europeans and migrants because we won't pay the going rate for goods and services.
You’re a clueless clown. No one was exploiting Eastern European migrants they came here to work, earn good Money and then go home, creating a better life for themselves in the process.

Considering there is 1.9 million vaccines now with accute problems in care, hospitality, haulage the problem is going to get worse, why?

Because we are an ageing society, we will need more immigrants then ever.

We could of course also slash and burn the benefits system but still wouldn’t solve the problem.

Then you add in the pandemic. Which was also perfectly predicable given the government had been planning for it till they took they resources from it to plan for a no deal Brexit.

Sadly we have a country full of morons like you.

Gubanc · 25/09/2021 07:40

@EatSleepRantRepeat

If people had spent the last 5 years doing proper planning instead of batching and trying to overturn the result, recruiting and training British people in shortage jobs, and paying people decent wages in the first place we wouldn't be in such a mess. I'm not willing to live in a country which runs on exploiting poor Eastern Europeans and migrants because we won't pay the going rate for goods and services.
Working here was never 'exploitation' more of an opportunity for Eastern Europeans who struggle to find jobs in their own countries.
Iggly · 25/09/2021 07:37

@MsJinks

If anyone thinks Johnson et al are keen on their mates having to pay more for labour and reduce their millions then they are sadly deluded. This is part of the problem of Brexit - letting the new style Tories run it. I think it’s disingenuous to say the Eastern European’s helped keep wages low and outside the EU we can combat that, as it’s not the full picture and we voted in a Tory government who have no interest in improving wages/lives of the majority- most don’t and can’t have a clue what the average person’s life looks like anyway, so it’s a great soundbite with no substance. There are already new immigration routes giving the lie to it. I’m also no economist but the natural consequence of sudden uplift in wages is sudden uplift in inflation, which also benefits no one. Any possible potential benefits of Brexit are never going to be carried out with this government at least - and to be honest I’m not sure why leavers are still happy with the way it’s been managed and the massively different outcomes to those promised.
This a million times.

If you let the vultures in, then you have carcasses. They want carcasses to feed on!

daisypond · 25/09/2021 07:34

Why would a foreign driver particularly want to work in the UK? The government announces this potential temporary visa, expecting that foreign drivers will be desperate to come here to work. I think that’s unrealistic.

Generallystruggling · 25/09/2021 07:29

The fact they’re now letting foreigners back in to work is absolutely fucking hilarious, I burst out laughing when I heard. Hope Brexiteers are as happy as I am.

KingdomScrolls · 25/09/2021 07:26

A friend of my husband's drives a tanker for a living. He said there are no fewer tankers going out this week than there have been usually, the media is causing the issue. The company who said they have a shortage of drivers, Hoyer, made a third of drivers redundant during Covid and now wonder why they won't go back.

I didn't vote for Brexit btw, but it's more complex than that.

MariaAngustias · 25/09/2021 07:26

Totally agree OP. Those who say get over it - why should we - you have caused great suffering and hardship for years to come and for what - a soddin' blue passport and become a joke in Europe. I am in Spain at the moment and there is no shortage of fuel or food - this has bugger all to do with the pandemic - Own Your Shit. Thats all.

MsJinks · 25/09/2021 07:26

If anyone thinks Johnson et al are keen on their mates having to pay more for labour and reduce their millions then they are sadly deluded. This is part of the problem of Brexit - letting the new style Tories run it. I think it’s disingenuous to say the Eastern European’s helped keep wages low and outside the EU we can combat that, as it’s not the full picture and we voted in a Tory government who have no interest in improving wages/lives of the majority- most don’t and can’t have a clue what the average person’s life looks like anyway, so it’s a great soundbite with no substance. There are already new immigration routes giving the lie to it.
I’m also no economist but the natural consequence of sudden uplift in wages is sudden uplift in inflation, which also benefits no one.
Any possible potential benefits of Brexit are never going to be carried out with this government at least - and to be honest I’m not sure why leavers are still happy with the way it’s been managed and the massively different outcomes to those promised.

Iggly · 25/09/2021 07:25

*EU

Iggly · 25/09/2021 07:25

And one of the aims of the hard Brexiters (ie - the winners) was to deregulate working conditions?

Yep and bring in cheap labour from non RU countries.

TheReluctantPhoenix · 25/09/2021 07:24

@RunningOnFumes,

Win/win is generally an illusion.

Of course it will be passed on. How would you like it if someone cut your pay by 50% so that others cost of living was held down? That is what has happened with these (and other) professions with Eastern European labour.

As I said above, an infinite supply of cheap labour has kept inflation checked for 20+ years, it has also meant that 90% of the growth has gone to the top 10% of earners.

Iggly · 25/09/2021 07:24

[quote TheReluctantPhoenix]@Iggly,

I don’t think anyone (with half a brain) believed that, in the short term, which could be a decade, frictional costs of Brexit would not outweigh benefits.

However, being in the EU allowed us to mismanage everything important to an ongoing stable society (fair pay, education etc). We could cover over the cracks with our infinite supply of cheap Eastern European labour, regardless of the cracks to the fabric of society.

If the EU just consisted of the original Northern European members, I could buy into it, as there was, broadly, equality of income, law etc.

When you see pay and conditions being forced up for crop pickers, lorry drivers etc, I see this as a Brexit benefit. And not having infinite choice in Waitrose every time I shop there is a very small price to pay.[/quote]
We didn’t have to go for the Brexit version that we did. That’s the problem. We could have listened to actual experts instead of trying to have our cake and eat it and fuck off the EU while at it.

RunningOnFumes · 25/09/2021 07:22

As anyone with any bit of sense knows, there was more than one way to do Brexit and our government went for the shit version. So, unless that version changes, Brexit is crap.

Yes, agree - though I also think the problems we now face were eminently foreseeable, so Brexiteers need to own what they've caused

RunningOnFumes · 25/09/2021 07:21

When you see pay and conditions being forced up for crop pickers, lorry drivers etc, I see this as a Brexit benefit

That pay rise will be passed onto consumers though won't it? Thereby exacerbating the cost of living crisis. So not exactly a win-win.
And one of the aims of the hard Brexiters (ie - the winners) was to deregulate working conditions?