Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

We fecking told you so. Brexit making us suffer.

413 replies

flashbac · 24/09/2021 22:08

Project Fear you said. Sunlit Uplands you said. Sovereignty you said. Can I buy food and heat my house with Sovereignty? Can I put sovereignty in my car's fuel tank? Can I?

It was common sense that this would happen. Common SENSE.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
x2boys · 25/09/2021 11:26

Ah, the Gary Neville that was brought up in the nice middle class village of Greenmount whose father was already well known locally as the being the chairman of Bury Football club, i was also brought up in Greenmount there are very few if any people that struggle financially., Although my circumstances are very different to his now

Iggly · 25/09/2021 10:52

@Dragon50

I’m a Prosecco socialist and I care about you and your family.

Why?

Because I walk among you.

No point in me having a good life if I’m affected by the disadvantages around me, robbed by the desperate, infected by people who have to work while ill, seeing a homeless person die at 9am outside my office ( pre pandemic).

I want my hospital clean, and my Waitrose staffed.

And… in case my life turns to shit (illness/death/divorce/fire and yes Im insured) I want a safety net in place.

There are loads of reasons as to why a well to do socialist will care about those less well off.

This a million times
Dragon50 · 25/09/2021 10:52

I’m a Prosecco socialist and I care about you and your family.

Why?

Because I walk among you.

No point in me having a good life if I’m affected by the disadvantages around me, robbed by the desperate, infected by people who have to work while ill, seeing a homeless person die at 9am outside my office ( pre pandemic).

I want my hospital clean, and my Waitrose staffed.

And… in case my life turns to shit (illness/death/divorce/fire and yes Im insured) I want a safety net in place.

There are loads of reasons as to why a well to do socialist will care about those less well off.

Iggly · 25/09/2021 10:19

Gary Neville’s article. I found myself nodding to a lot of it!

Stasiland · 25/09/2021 10:17

'champagne socialists' What's wrong with somebody well off wanting others to be affluent too or at least able to live a decent life ? But that awful british tendency to love doffing your cap at your social betters means you prefer toffs who've never known a days hardship. How weird....

Iggly · 25/09/2021 10:14

@EatSleepRantRepeat

yes, I’m a champagne socialist and I want everyone to be able to drink champagne if they work hard for it

You know that's not economically possible though, right? Wages for the producers of luxury goods have to be too low to actually afford them otherwise the price would spiral. Its a good example of why there will always be relative poverty. Champagne takes years to make and age in the cellars, plus the cost of the land and chemicals needed to grow them (and reserves in case of bad harvests). If the price was low enough for the grape pickers to buy willy nilly like some on here, they'd go under.

Look at UK childcare for a better example - nannies quite rightly want a liveable wage, then mums on here complain that their own liveable wage goes straight into the nanny's pocket.

Who said it’s not economically possible?

The Tories who want to keep it that way Smile

It is possible for everyone to have a decent standard of living.

It is possible for people to have different standards of living. This isn’t about everyone having champagne, it’s about everyone having the chance to.

Under the current system we have, it’s very difficult to accumulate wealth unless you already have it. That’s what Conservativism does - it preserves the wealthy, even if they really no longer should have it any more. Look at land as the obvious example. What reason is there for the Royal Family to continue to have all that land and property for example? Other than by dint of birth?

This isn’t about giving handouts. It’s about giving people opportunities. Genuine opportunity

EatSleepRantRepeat · 25/09/2021 10:09

yes, I’m a champagne socialist and I want everyone to be able to drink champagne if they work hard for it

You know that's not economically possible though, right? Wages for the producers of luxury goods have to be too low to actually afford them otherwise the price would spiral. Its a good example of why there will always be relative poverty. Champagne takes years to make and age in the cellars, plus the cost of the land and chemicals needed to grow them (and reserves in case of bad harvests). If the price was low enough for the grape pickers to buy willy nilly like some on here, they'd go under.

Look at UK childcare for a better example - nannies quite rightly want a liveable wage, then mums on here complain that their own liveable wage goes straight into the nanny's pocket.

Iggly · 25/09/2021 09:55

@Itinerary

How many rich Etonians do you know care about you and your family’s circumstances?

How many self-righteous well-heeled champagne socialists do you know care about yours?

Gary Neville summed this up. Something along the lines of “yes, I’m a champagne socialist and I want everyone to be able to drink champagne if they work hard for it”.

That’s not the philosophy of the Tories. It’s built into them that there will always always be poor people and no amount of anything will help them. Which is a pretty nasty way to think really.

Itinerary · 25/09/2021 09:47

How many rich Etonians do you know care about you and your family’s circumstances?

How many self-righteous well-heeled champagne socialists do you know care about yours?

SophieHMS · 25/09/2021 09:46

Leave voters. You could not make them up.

ittakes2 · 25/09/2021 09:45

You need to understand the transport system to understand why Brexit has a role but its not just Brexit. But don't take my word for it - read what the Haulage Association says about it. They have been telling the government for months that there was a problem - the new IR35 tax changes had a significant impact because the drivers earned less so left the industry, the lockdowns had an impact because replacement drivers could not be trained or tested, the pandemic had an impact because people wanted more home deliveries and yes Brexit had an impact because some drivers went home. The UK needs 100,000 more drivers - only about 12,000 went home because of Brexit. My husband hires haulage drivers so I know more than most.

This is exert from the Haulage Driver's Association press release published in April calling on the government saying the IR35 changes was really hurting the industry and calling on the government to act. Really if its anyone's fault the government has failed to act quickly enough.

28 Apr 2021 Posted By Josh Reynolds
The RHA is calling for urgent Government action to ease a growing crisis in driver shortages ~ made worse by the introduction of IR35 tax changes. Pallet firms in particular are having to extend-next day deliveries by up to five days.

The situation was critical even before the pandemic with many EU truckers heading home for obvious Brexit-related reasons. Add to that the complete failure to test new drivers during lockdown which left a backlog of thousands of tests - and potential drivers sidelined.
Covid-19 saw the introduction of IR35 delayed by one year but it’s now hitting many firms and drivers.

Full press release published here.
www.rha.uk.net/news/news-blogs-and-press-releases/press-releases/detail/driver-shortages-ir35-and-what-the-rha-wants

Rhubarbsoup · 25/09/2021 09:44

@toocold54

I suspect the lorry drivers applying for jobs paying £50k plus, with decent working conditions, are not complaining.

Please show me where the jobs advertising for lorry drivers that actually pay £50k plus are as I would be happy to apply?!

I know of 3 people who used to work as lorry drivers and were all ‘capable’ of making make £24k+ But this was in fact impossible to do unless they worked 6+ hours of overtime everyday which I believe is actually illegal as you can only drive a certain amount of hours a day.
They are given a time limit to do a certain amount of deliveries and it is almost impossible to get them done within your working hours.
I didn’t realise how bad delivery driving had become until quite recently.

Yes exactly, and conditions on the road are crap.

If we want to carry on transporting a lot by road (which presumably we do), the most sustainable thing is to invest in making changes that will attract a new generation of drivers, and retain and lure back the qualified ones we have already. At a minimum:

Companies should fund initial training, even if it has a return of service attached ie if you don't do x years you pay y percentage back- this opens training to a much wider range of people.

Medicals should be funded, or at the very least at minimal cost.

Less restrictive targets for deliveries, I know of course they aren't going to pay drivers to chill out, but now every minute is accounted for, every movement tracked, micro managing to the extreme and takes away a lot of what made the job appealing which was a bit of freedom. As long as the deliveries get done safely and in reasonable time, what's the issue.

Better and cheaper facilities such as showers and food at services, and sufficient numbers of safe parking so people aren't having to park up in laybys for the night, or shit at the side of the road as the toilets are closed.

Look into how to make rotas more family friendly. Some might not mind long periods away from home, but a lot leave because they reach a point they don't want that anymore, there must be a more effective way to manage manpower.

Itinerary · 25/09/2021 09:43

I'm not willing to live in a country which runs on exploiting poor Eastern European's and migrants because we won't pay the going rate for goods and services.

Hear hear. It's ironic that it's mostly remainers who insist they are oh-so-caring about workers from other countries. Most of the complaints on this thread are about inconvenience to oneself. There are actually worse HGV driver shortages in Germany and Poland, clearly not due to Brexit.

There are many British qualified HGV drivers who aren't currently working in the industry. They left the industry as they were undercut. Opportunistic employers found workers who would understandably work for less, to send money to their family in another country where it was worth far more in real terms.

Haulage companies have had plenty of time to adapt and improve their employment offers, but the government could have helped them more. A phased roll out of better wages and conditions, a large-scale recruitment drive. Obviously the pandemic hasn't helped, to say the least. Money rightly had to go to Health first, and lockdowns and furloughing disrupted most businesses.

toocold54 · 25/09/2021 09:29

Fridge is full of food, car full of petrol....🤷‍♂️

Nice Hmm

toocold54 · 25/09/2021 09:25

I suspect the lorry drivers applying for jobs paying £50k plus, with decent working conditions, are not complaining.

Please show me where the jobs advertising for lorry drivers that actually pay £50k plus are as I would be happy to apply?!

I know of 3 people who used to work as lorry drivers and were all ‘capable’ of making make £24k+ But this was in fact impossible to do unless they worked 6+ hours of overtime everyday which I believe is actually illegal as you can only drive a certain amount of hours a day.
They are given a time limit to do a certain amount of deliveries and it is almost impossible to get them done within your working hours.
I didn’t realise how bad delivery driving had become until quite recently.

Bunnyfuller · 25/09/2021 09:20

@worriedatthemoment

I haven’t said it’s all Brexit. But everything we’re experiencing at the moment is either directly caused by it, or is being made worse by it.

HGV drivers moving to other industries is not unique. People change careers all the time, and their reasons will be similar regardless of career. How much do they earn @worried ? You cited pay and conditions as the reason for the shortage, what are they actually paid?

Our children are coming to the end of their education so in exam years etc. To move now would disrupt that so we as a family have decided to wait until they are done. Added to which we’re anxious as to limits on where we will be allowed to settle following the country ditching freedom of movement.

Keeps those foreigners out tho, eh?

Alondra · 25/09/2021 09:20

I know someone who owns a property in Spain, planning to relocate there permanently, yet still voted Brexit. That is the kind of stupidity we are talking about

I know a couple with the same problem. They had a house in Almunecar (Granada) and were planning to early permanently retire there. They voted leave because "it was the right thing to do being British". Many of us tried to tell them the consequences, they didn't listen. They thought they will still be able to retire in their house after Brexit.

They sold it 3 months ago after failing to gain residential status.

NantesElephant · 25/09/2021 09:19

From the moment the Brexit vote came through, the government could have been predicting the upcoming labour shortages, for they were predictable, and funding apprenticeships and training schemes to fill the gaps in preparation. But no. The current batch of tories are incompetent and extremist group who don’t have the best interests of the UK at heart. Why they are still so high in the approval ratings is beyond my comprehension. I’d like to see the incompetent Starmer booted out and a centrist / left coalition who have set aside identify politics to deal with the real crises the nation faces.

toocold54 · 25/09/2021 09:18

Plenty of leavers I encountered are extremely well educated and very wealthy. They knew exactly what they were voting for. Remain voting was sky high in many working class areas.

You are correct but this was part of the problem.

We knew that leaving the EU would have downsides like shortages of workers and goods and would increase prices of goods and services which is why so many wealthy people voted to leave as they don’t care about rising costs as they can afford it, which seems really unfair. Whilst many working class people knew that they would struggle even more so voted remain.

CounsellorTroi · 25/09/2021 09:08

I know someone who owns a property in Spain, planning to relocate there permanently, yet still voted Brexit. That is the kind of stupidity we are talking about.

Iggly · 25/09/2021 09:08

@ittakes2

I am fascinated by these threads blaming Brexit on all our woes...Pandemic anyone? I guess its a sign people feel they are moving forward from the last 18 plus months.
The pandemic? How so? We’ve had 18 months of the pandemic and the worst of it has hopefully passed. People are getting vaccinated and things are slowly turning back to normal.

If it was the pandemic, this would not be be a new issue.

Maybe Brexit is difficult for people to understand because they don’t appreciate what links we had with the EU and what that meant. As those links break, then when issues come up like the shortage of HGV drivers and the energy price hike, the fact is that Brexit only makes it worse.

I’m sure there will be other issues later on down the line - which will be made worse by Brexit because as a country, we’ve completely cocked up how we interact with other countries for mutual benefit.

It’s funny how people crow about sources being biased/anti Brexit but they happily lapped up all the pro Brexit talk that was drip fed to them via Facebook etc without engaging their brain.

bizboz · 25/09/2021 09:07

If you want to worry yourself, go have a look at the import rules that we are legally obliged to put in place (You know.... those good ol' WTO rules). They have been put back twice by the current government (need 5,000+ vets sort of handicaps this a bit).

I was listening to a pig farmer in the radio a couple of days ago. She was saying that because of the lack of vets and also those with butchery skills in abbatoirs, many are simply unable to function at the moment. That means many pig farmers are unable to sell their stock. Several of these are likely to go bankrupt, then more pork will need to be imported, probably with import charges and from countries with lower welfare standards.

worriedatthemoment · 25/09/2021 09:06

@Bunnyfuller we don't even have mich of a shortage of the fuel tank drivwes according to many , couple companies had issues ( few petrol stations affected) everyone being twats and buying way more than they need has caused this , the media in the country have a lot to answer to

Whammyyammy · 25/09/2021 09:04

Fridge is full of food, car full of petrol....🤷‍♂️

DGRossetti · 25/09/2021 09:02

[quote TheReluctantPhoenix]@DGRossetti,

Coming from a completely unbiased source owned by a venture capital fund heavily invested in industry, whose target audience is predominantly young professionals in London.

Wonder why they are blaming Brexit…[/quote]
Whatever ...

Swipe left for the next trending thread