Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The idiotic Insulate Britain are at it again

114 replies

sst1234 · 24/09/2021 12:26

Now they have blocked the port of Dover. On top of Lorry driver shortage and commodity supply issues, these absolute criminals are causing yet more damage to the supply chain. And who suffers? Joe Public suffers yet more price hikes because virtue signalling, well healed, are damaging the country so no benefit whatsoever. None at all. Hashtag less than 1% of global emissions

OP posts:
CuriousaboutSamphire · 24/09/2021 16:34

Out of interest @fallintoautumn which bit of their ' manifesto' do you agree with?

I posted their 2 main demands upthread and neither are in anyway coherent or possible. Both utterly ignore the reality of the situation in they are shouting about.

And what has getting residential properties insulated for free got to do with disrupting a port?

LikeACatInTheDark · 24/09/2021 16:13

So how does insulating homes help with that?

Insulating all homes (whether it's free or not) would reduce our national energy use/emissions, surely? Or have I misunderstood the question?

sst1234 · 24/09/2021 16:00

[quote SillySausagee]@sst1234

As I have previously said, your assertion that the UK is responsible for less than 1% of global emissions is misleading as it does not take into account our vast demand for goods produced in high emission countries and their environmental cost. Please look a bit closer at what the statistics you quote mean.[/quote]
So how does insulating homes help with that? (Which is free anyway as others pointed out, so it’s a virtue signalling cause). I know what statistics I am quoting, your explanation makes no sense, it’s just the abstract rhetoric which is usually the default to response to any question.

OP posts:
LampLighter414 · 24/09/2021 15:49

If it gets me some free insulation I'm all for it!

SillySausagee · 24/09/2021 15:43

@sst1234

As I have previously said, your assertion that the UK is responsible for less than 1% of global emissions is misleading as it does not take into account our vast demand for goods produced in high emission countries and their environmental cost. Please look a bit closer at what the statistics you quote mean.

UniversalAunt · 24/09/2021 15:37

Not everyone who needs to get to hospital for vital &/or important medical treatments or other appointments travels in an ambulance with or without flashing blue lights.

Not every medical emergency requires an ambulance.

It is not for civilians to redirect emergency traffic around groups of illegal protestors. To assume such control is entitled authoritarianism.

UniversalAunt · 24/09/2021 15:12

‘ 10s of thousands of Britons die from air pollution and cold housing ALREADY’

Already there are many Govt Acts & Local Authority initiatives to minimise traffic pollution & fuel poverty for local residents & tenants. This is ongoing, irrespective of the antics of Insulate, XR et al.

FWBNC · 24/09/2021 15:02

[quote MagnificentOrangeElephant]**@Dontgetyerknicksinatwist She was paralysed. Her son was on the radio and said this. The hospital told him if she had got there in time the damage would have been minimal. These people are responsible for this.

Yes, she was paralysed. It is tragic, and should not have happened. But the reason she was in that car on that motorway is because our underfunded NHS could not get an ambulance to her for hours. There isn't a magic 90 minutes, but but the longer the root cause is untreated the greater the chance of repetition or extension. So time matters.

I don't know about Insulate Britain, but XR have a Blue Light Policy The media pretends they don't, because evoking the heart rending image of your mum in an ambulance is lazy, but sadly effective, journalism. They plan their actions to ensure emergency vehicles can get through. Given that the police were able to use the hard shoulder to get to arrest the protestors, if she had been in an ambulance they would have got through (and she would have had access to qualified personnel and emergency medicine on route)

So, are you angry about why a person in need of time critical medical treatment cannot get it? Or still just protestors.[/quote]
Jesus wept. It's possible to be angry about BOTH, but THIS thread is about the IB idiots, not the NHS!

UniversalAunt · 24/09/2021 15:02

‘ I'm in a top floor flat in social housing. I've stuck my head in the loft and there doesn't seem to be any insulation at all - should there be? confused’

Yes, there should be, or at least a very good explanation why not.

Get onto your landlord, sent a few pictures in to save unnecessary preliminary site survey.

We moved into a newly refurbished top floor flat, checked the loft for storage & noticed no insulation. Contacted landlord & matter was fixed immediately. Huge difference in how much energy required to heat the flat & far lower fuel bill so well worth you chasing this up.

Assume the matter has been an oversight.

Tealightsandd · 24/09/2021 14:53

And yes, I have I insulated the fuck out of everything and my house costs pennies to run. I just think everyone else should have that too.

Have what too? A secure home? Certainly having a home in the first place is needed in order to have an insulated home.

Next stage, the insulation. Excellent news. You want everyone to have it. How will you do that? Gather together friends and family with the skills to DIY it, or crowdfund a tradesperson? Either way, well done.

(Btw a true environmentalist wouldn't have children. The human race dying out is the only real way to save the environment. Insulate and XR aren't real environmentalists)

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 24/09/2021 14:51

Ive got so much insulation in the loft of my council house that i cant get up there. Even if i hadnt i still think they are a bunch of disruptive twats

sst1234 · 24/09/2021 14:49

@Summerhillsquare

The vitriol towards environmentalists on this thread is rather self defeating. Environmentalists are trying to save YOUR lives. 10s of thousands of Britons die from air pollution and cold housing ALREADY. In recent years people have been dying from heat exhaustion in heat waves. Thousands flooded out of their homes and businesses.

How do you reckon things are shaping up for your kids and grandkids with several degrees of warming? At least they are doing something for them.

And yes, I have I insulated the fuck out of everything and my house costs pennies to run. I just think everyone else should have that too.

So patronising and so misinformed. We should be oh so grateful to the ‘environmentalists’. What no environmentalist can ever is what difference do their actions make to climate change when UK contributes less than 1% to global emissions.
OP posts:
Tealightsandd · 24/09/2021 14:48

Oh and I assume they're not using crytocurrency. If ever there was an energy intensive bad for the environment activity, that would be it.

They also need to lead by example wrt use of fossil fuels. They're living a pre industrial life, I presume.

Bed when daylight goes down, up at sunrise. No artificial lighting, etc.

Modern tech? Perhaps one mobile phone or laptop for a more environmentally communication method than travel. But certainly not the most up-to-date upgraded models.

No imported food in their cupboards (no fridges, of course because that's not environmentally friendly). In season local produce only.

No new clothes. Remember, reuse and durability - make do and mend - beats recycling.

So let's see where they all are with that, and then we can look at what to do next.

I mean, we can't take people seriously unless they practice what they preach.

Summerhillsquare · 24/09/2021 14:45

The vitriol towards environmentalists on this thread is rather self defeating. Environmentalists are trying to save YOUR lives. 10s of thousands of Britons die from air pollution and cold housing ALREADY. In recent years people have been dying from heat exhaustion in heat waves. Thousands flooded out of their homes and businesses.

How do you reckon things are shaping up for your kids and grandkids with several degrees of warming? At least they are doing something for them.

And yes, I have I insulated the fuck out of everything and my house costs pennies to run. I just think everyone else should have that too.

BelleOfTheProvince · 24/09/2021 14:44

It's UK policy not to negotiate with extremists.

Rainbowsew · 24/09/2021 14:43

@Ilikewinter

But they wont succeed will they, the government is not going to give them what they want Meanwhile they are causing chaos to normal people trying to go about their daily lives.
Absolutely agree!
fallintoautumn · 24/09/2021 14:43

And I don't remember Priti Patel and the police being so concerned about the looney right-wing anti-lockdown or anti-vaxx protests.

Right-wing idiots = OK, left-wing idiots = imprison them.

fallintoautumn · 24/09/2021 14:40

I suppose the problem is really the government whose solution to the climate change is to push all the responsibility onto the general public (change your car, change your boiler) while trying to engineer a situation in which all our trade is no longer done close to home but with countries on the literal other side of the world, which will cause huge environmental damage.
The government should be making it easier for those on low incomes to insulate their homes, instead of these people just having to heat their homes more or choose between heat or eat.
But the government would rather spend our taxes to destroy huge sections of the countryside so their donors get a huge rail building project.
I am not on benefits but have draughty decades-old windows that I cannot afford to replace, so I guess I am using more gas to heat my home than I would do if I didn't have to find many thousands to replace them. In other countries, there is help for this kind of thing.

I don't agree with Insulate Britain's methods, but I do agree with their message and their right to protest. As a democratic country, we should be very concerned about this government's steps to remove our rights to protest and increase police power.

Tealightsandd · 24/09/2021 14:39

literally screaming from the rooftops about our inaction on the climate emergency

Perhaps they should stop screaming (they'll get sore throats) and do something practical instead.

Go round to people's houses and offer to insulate them for free.

Encourage smaller families (to tackle worldwide human overpopulation) with education and improved access to contraception.

I also assume, being as concerned about it all as they are, they don't drive or use planes themselves? Afterall, they must surely lead by example.

LoislovesStewie · 24/09/2021 14:37

What you don't do is prevent people going about their lawful activities including attending urgent hospital appointments. I don't give two hoots if the protesters think what they have to say is important, not when what I have to do could be urgent and maybe life-saving.

SpittinKitten · 24/09/2021 14:34

I know one XR/IBer whose first response when I told them about either the London benefit cap or bedroom tax being introduced (years back) was that that they should move down there and take up affordable housing in order to Do Activism about it 🤦‍♀️

Tealightsandd · 24/09/2021 14:34

Just think. All the taxpayer money spent on this lot. Policing and clean up costs, road diversions, etc. Imagine if, instead, it was used to fund keeping the £20 extra UC so desperately needed by people struggling to get by.

MagnificentOrangeElephant · 24/09/2021 14:32

@FWBNC Why are you defending these dangerous idiots?

I am not defending the action of Insulate Britain, but I am mindful (and this thread shows) that is it used as an excuse to pile in and bash all protestors. I find that incredibly worrying in a time where activists are literally screaming from the rooftops about our inaction on the climate emergency, and the science backs them up, and yet our government dithers and greenwashes.

What is the point in any of us writing to our MP, signing petitions, making any personal changes when the government and banks are investing our pensions and mortgages in continued fossil fuel extraction. The IPCC report says the only way to prevent a climate change disaster is to stop using fossil fuels immediately. And our government are still allowing further explanation of the Cambo oil field and preparing for in a new coal mine in Cumbria. So what do we do? How do we make our voices heard? It reaches a point where non-violent direct action is the only option left if you want meaningful change within the time we have left to us.

Tealightsandd · 24/09/2021 14:30

But the reason she was in that car on that motorway is because our underfunded NHS could not get an ambulance to her for hours

So there's two choices here. One, campaign (in a non obstructive manner) for a better funded and managed NHS. And use their own money for good, eg. donate to the NHS.

Or what they did. Actively make things worse.

As for the Blue Light Policy. There are 9 million people in London. Including, despite the best efforts of successive governments going back 30-40 years to socially cleanse London, many elderly, vulnerable, disabled, and poor. Then there's all the extra patients from outside London, who travel in to the specialist central London hospitals.

When roads are blocked and traffic delayed and diverted, particularly in an already overcrowded city, journeys to hospital are affected.

Bully for XR. They let the ambulance paas. When it finally gets there. Nevermind that, thanks to their actions, it's taken much longer to reach that point.

Insulate and XR rival Tony Blair and George Osborne in their hatred of the disabled and vulnerable. Their actions hurt people who have to get to hospital by car....because of their mobility needs or being too frail or unwell to use public transport.

Privileged mobs attacking the poor and vulnerable.

LoislovesStewie · 24/09/2021 14:25

There are idiots gluing themselves to tankers carrying petrol at the Port of Dover. I think I would leave them and let the tanker go with them stuck to it.