Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this an emotionally abusive relationship?

61 replies

ncforadvice21 · 24/09/2021 09:39

If you have postnatal depression and your partner continually makes comments such as "you can't keeping doing this" (when you cry or express frustration), and "I haven't got time for this", or just ignores you when you cry... would this be a sign of an emotionally abusive relationship? It's been suggested to me that this is the case and I should leave. But he's an excellent practical help with the baby and I have no one else, so I'd be isolating myself a lot if I left.

Just looking for thoughts and advice really.

Please no harsh comments, I'm at the end of what I can cope with emotionally and I have no one to talk to.

Thanks.

OP posts:
ButterflyAway · 24/09/2021 10:19

@ncforadvice21 you can get pissy that not everyone is giving you the replies you want, but I’d rather take the advice on someone who’s been there and made it through several times.

TheFoundations · 24/09/2021 10:18

If he's always been like that, OP, have you ever felt that he respects your boundaries? Have you ever felt that he cares about how you feel, about making a happy environment for the two of you, as a couple? Has he ever met your needs, emotionally?

ButterflyAway · 24/09/2021 10:17

@TheFoundations just get on with it is the advice I’ve been given by every counsellor, health visitor and doctor when I’ve been in the grips of it. It’s kept me alive and moving forward, i don’t consider it bad advice. Poor MH is a long term debilitating condition, it overtakes life if you don’t get on with things

ncforadvice21 · 24/09/2021 10:16

My partner would fit right in on this thread with some of the less compassionate posters!

Thanks to those who've shown some empathy. It's appreciated more than you know. X

OP posts:
TheFoundations · 24/09/2021 10:15

[quote ButterflyAway]@TheFoundations I don’t think there’s really anyone that’s going to turn around to a depressed person and tell them they need a break from supporting/helping them. I wouldn’t be able to do that, and no one that supported me would have either. It’d have made me feel like I was a burden and driven me further into suicidal thoughts. Similarly, it’s the reason I didn’t tell my sister I couldn’t cope with supporting her either when she went through months and months of it. It’s frustrating for both supporter and unwell person but you just have to get on with it til the worst is passed I think[/quote]
How do you think a person ought to deal with struggling with their partner's depression? Ignore their feelings until they are ground down to nothing? You don't have to say 'I need a break from you'.

'Just get on with it' is very poor advice. There are ways for either partner to take responsibility for themselves and make beneficial changes.

ThreeLittleDots · 24/09/2021 10:14

you’re both really as bad as each other

Hmm
ncforadvice21 · 24/09/2021 10:14

@ThreeLittleDots

Yes, it's emotionally abusive to withhold warmth, empathy and emotional support x

This is all I've asked him for. I've said if you just literally showed some warmth and comfort, even just a hug when I cry, anything, I'd feel probably 90% better. But he just doesn't.

OP posts:
ButterflyAway · 24/09/2021 10:13

You’re mad at him for being frustrated that you’re crying again, he’s frustrated that you’re crying again, you’re both really as bad as each other. You just feel more vulnerable right now because you’re dealing with PND and that amplifies everything.

ncforadvice21 · 24/09/2021 10:12

[quote ButterflyAway]@ncforadvice21 well if you end the relationship one of you moves out with the baby. It’s rare that’s the mother, so he would have to leave his baby and have small amounts of contact (due to the baby’s age). Not really a position someone that loves their child wants to be in[/quote]

Hence my reluctance to leave the relationship.

OP posts:
ncforadvice21 · 24/09/2021 10:11

I don’t think there’s really anyone that’s going to turn around to a depressed person and tell them they need a break from supporting/helping them.

Well I'd honestly rather he calmly said this to me, than snapped "I haven't got time for this" when I am crying.

OP posts:
ButterflyAway · 24/09/2021 10:11

@ncforadvice21 well if you end the relationship one of you moves out with the baby. It’s rare that’s the mother, so he would have to leave his baby and have small amounts of contact (due to the baby’s age). Not really a position someone that loves their child wants to be in

ThreeLittleDots · 24/09/2021 10:11

You don't need anybody else's permission to make the choices that are right for you and your child.

ButterflyAway · 24/09/2021 10:09

@TheFoundations I don’t think there’s really anyone that’s going to turn around to a depressed person and tell them they need a break from supporting/helping them. I wouldn’t be able to do that, and no one that supported me would have either. It’d have made me feel like I was a burden and driven me further into suicidal thoughts. Similarly, it’s the reason I didn’t tell my sister I couldn’t cope with supporting her either when she went through months and months of it. It’s frustrating for both supporter and unwell person but you just have to get on with it til the worst is passed I think

ncforadvice21 · 24/09/2021 10:09

@TheFoundations

I don't get very fat trying to raise issues though as he either talks over me, sits in silence and says nothing, gets defensive and raises his voice, or walks out

I think this is more the issue, really. Has he always been like this?

Yes.

OP posts:
ncforadvice21 · 24/09/2021 10:08

@ButterflyAway

Where have I said he should leave his baby?!

OP posts:
TheFoundations · 24/09/2021 10:08

I don't get very fat trying to raise issues though as he either talks over me, sits in silence and says nothing, gets defensive and raises his voice, or walks out

I think this is more the issue, really. Has he always been like this?

ncforadvice21 · 24/09/2021 10:07

@PumpkinsAndCats

Why don’t you leave then?

My ex had a mental illness and it was very hard to deal with, we broke up because of it.

For a few reasons:

  1. He's a very good dad and my baby adores him. I don't want to take that away from either of them.
  1. He's a very valuable source of practical support. I have no one else locally. I'd be struggling without him in a practical sense.
  1. I'm fucking terrified to make such a big step.
OP posts:
TheFoundations · 24/09/2021 10:06

@ButterflyAway

It could be that he’s fed up dealing with someone who’s mentally unwell. It is exhausting, it strips away all the joy in life and it becomes more of a carer responsibility than a partnership. It’s not abusive to have had enough.
How you deal with it is the issue, though. Having had enough is fine, and you need to deal with that responsibly. You could explain to the depressed person that you are tired and you need a break, and take yourself off for a few hours/days to recuperate, or you could tell the depressed person that you're sick to death of their mood, you wished they weren't there, and life would be better without them.

It's not the having had enough that's the issue.

ButterflyAway · 24/09/2021 10:06

You can leave if you don’t like his behaviour, why should he leave his baby just because your unwell?

Look I’ve been there. I saw everything through the lens of PND. I made everyone around me miserable because I thought it was my right to have support and help and work through the way I was feeling. I didn’t see how much I was hurting everyone around me because it was all about me and my mental health. Sometimes we really do have to pull our socks up and stop the dramatics. You have a reason for the way you feel right now, acknowledge it and focus on moving on from it.

ncforadvice21 · 24/09/2021 10:05

@TheFoundations

Yes I have explained to him how it makes me feel, he replies by saying "I do support you, I do this, I do that"... etc. He lists off the practical stuff he does for me and baby. He doesn't get that I mean he is lacking in empathy and emotional support. I don't get very fat trying to raise issues though as he either talks over me, sits in silence and says nothing, gets defensive and raises his voice, or walks out. Those are the typical responses.

OP posts:
PumpkinsAndCats · 24/09/2021 10:04

Why don’t you leave then?

My ex had a mental illness and it was very hard to deal with, we broke up because of it.

ncforadvice21 · 24/09/2021 10:03

@ButterflyAway

If he's had enough I wish he would just leave tbh than make me feel like this all the time.

OP posts:
ButterflyAway · 24/09/2021 10:01

It could be that he’s fed up dealing with someone who’s mentally unwell. It is exhausting, it strips away all the joy in life and it becomes more of a carer responsibility than a partnership. It’s not abusive to have had enough.

ncforadvice21 · 24/09/2021 10:00

@Babdoc

Well it certainly isn’t very supportive, OP. But if he is a practical type, he may genuinely be at a loss what to say or how to help when you are distressed and depressed. Perhaps emotional displays make him uncomfortable, and he feels panicked or inadequate at his own failure to “make things better”. Many men are practical problem solvers, rather than good at being an emotional support or a listener. What other support do you have? Are you on antidepressants, have you seen the GP and health visitor, do you have family or friends locally to whom you could talk about this?

I have a mental health team supporting me and I'm also on antidepressants. I have family but they all have so much of their own difficulties going on at the moment I don't want to bother any of them. They know I have PND, but I don't talk to them about the ins and outs. No friends who I could open up to, just superficial friendships where I pretend I'm fine.

OP posts:
PumpkinsAndCats · 24/09/2021 09:57

This on its own, nope, and neither would I leave someone for this if they are a good father and I would have no one if I left, unless you are going to drip feed more then this alone no isn’t abusive just sounds like someone who lacks understanding of PND or is being insensitive but abuse it a big leap, not everything is “abuse”