Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be surprised at some of the shoes parents but their kids in?

144 replies

Availableforbaking · 24/09/2021 08:58

Donning my tin hat and prepared to be told I’m highly unreasonable but here goes!

AIBU to be surprised at some of the shoes parents put their young DC in? Recently looking at the pile of shoes by a bouncy castle and saw several pairs of very uncomfy looking “ballet pump” type shoes or plastic flip flops, very few “proper” Clarks or StartRite type shoes.

A friend just passed me a bag of hand me downs for DD with several pairs of shoes in it, most of them felt like they would be really uncomfortable, eg very hard backs etc. I can’t imagine putting DD in any of them and will probably put them in the shoe recycling bin.

Another friend bought her DD some really hard flip flops from Accessorize as her main summer shoes. They would have given me blisters in minutes.

I’m not judging anyone who is trying their best for their DC and genuinely can’t afford better - the friends I have referred to are both wealthy and can definitely afford shoes.

I know brand new Clarks / StartRite are very expensive and fully appreciate not everyone can afford them - indeed I keep a close look on secondhand sites myself and have found several pairs of Clarks / StartRite that are immaculate (literally worn once or not at all) for cheap prices. I take DD to get feet measured & check shoes fit her properly.

90% of mine & my DC wardrobe is cheap second hand but I do feel proper shoes are important.

I also appreciate shoes from other cheaper shops may be just as good as Clarks etc - I’m just more shocked at the style/type of shoes I’m seeing, like I say lots of hard uncomfy looking ballet type shoes that offer no support.

I have an adult friend who has terrible feet due to ill fitting shoes as a child (her mother let her wear heels as a child in the 80s!) so it’s something I’ve very aware of.

OP posts:
Pigeonpocket · 24/09/2021 13:38

I'm more shocked by parents putting their children in shoes like Clarks and Startrite trainers with chunky soles - they're totally inflexible and not great for developing feet. A 0.5 inch thick sole looks reasonable to us but in comparison to the height of a child and their foot size, it's like us walking around in platforms!

The best shoes for children (medical foot issues aside) have thin flexible soles and wide toe boxes. Unfortunately fashion seems to win, so most kids shoes have chunky soles and narrow rounded toes. Shoes are rarely foot-shaped which is ridiculous when you think about it.

User5827372728 · 24/09/2021 13:34

@Indoctro

Do your boys have wide feet? As they are the only shoes my son with wide feet will wear!

Sylvvie · 24/09/2021 13:32

@girlmom21 at one point in my own life it was a choice between being able to pay the bills or feed my kids.

I don't know what world you live in but poverty, literal poverty where you have to make decisions like that ^^, is a reality for many people.

WeAllHaveWings · 24/09/2021 13:23

@Availableforbaking

Those of you who buy shoes from supermarkets or similar, do you measure feet at home? Or take them to a specialist shop to get measured then buy from elsewhere?
Don't be fooled by the marketing ploy that you need to get your childs feet expertly measured by professionals. The measuring is really just a guide where to start. Sizes between brands and even shoes within brands can vary widely.

You can do the rough measurement at home, then when in the shop (or ordering online) try them out yourself, there are youtube videos that will show you what to check when trying on shoes. Check where the toes are, if you can fit fingers in at the heel, feel if the width is too loose/tight etc.

manywildhorses · 24/09/2021 13:16

I only wore Clark’s as a kid. I have awful bunions.
I put my dc in ‘barefoot’ shoes that are flexible and lightweight. I like bobux for the cutest Chelsea boots and trainers and vivobarefoot. Now they’re getting a bit older most trainers are ok too. For parties they have ballet pumps but they’re worn for an hour or 2 every month or so. For school we get brogues or t-bar shoes. I hate the choice for girls and the fact that their feet get wet in most styles! Most clarks shoes are quite restrictive and inflexible I find though they are bringing out new ranges which are more promising.

All that said dc1 still looks as though she may develop bunions. So it’s probably hereditary more than anything. Their cousins on dh’s side wear flip flops, crocs, ballet pumps, cheap shoes etc and gave gorgeous feet as teens so who knows.

girlmom21 · 24/09/2021 13:15

@Sylvvie

Most people can't afford 60-80 quid a pair of shoes every 6 months to a year for their kids. YABU.
Most people can afford to put £10 a month aside for something as important as shoes. Maybe lots of people just choose not to.
KingdomScrolls · 24/09/2021 13:06

I have flat feet, my parents couldn't have afforded Clarks etc, my grandparents would buy my school shoes a good local shoe shop where I would be measured. DS has startrite , bobux, Geox, pediped and similar, feet measured and fitted at a local independent shoe shop, honestly costs a fortune. I think DH thinks it's a bit mad, but I've suffered from plantar fascitis as an adult and lower back and hip pain associated with having flat feet. I do agree though Clarke's are dreadful quality now.

Resilience · 24/09/2021 13:03

I've bought a variety of shoe brands over the years for my DC. Quality isn't necessarily related to brand. So I'd buy real leather for example, but not necessarily Clarke's. Some of the supermarket boys shoes were actually quite impressive. That said, my DC had textbook feet so no issues with sizing.

I did find that I had to buy boys shoes and pimp them up for DD though. Girls shoes are appalling quality in comparison to boys across most brands.

70isaLimitNotaTarget · 24/09/2021 12:58

ballet pumps are great shoes, many of the shoes people describe as "proper" are terrible shoes, based on misguided research of the 70's and 80's about how the foot develops. Support is not something a normal developing foot necessarily wants

Interested to know what you base this theory on sirfred
.

VitalsStable · 24/09/2021 12:57

I'd be more worried about kids in party clothes with dreadful black heavy shoes, it's a party, time to break out the sparkles and glitter.

FWIW DD wears kickers to school as she's got very narrow feet and other than when doing sport which she'll wear decent trainers for she'll be found in her favourite yellow sliders. She can run, jump, skip and dance in them without managing to injure herself.

Clarks and startrite are crap, they've just done a fantastic marketing job over the years convincing the naive parents that their kids foot health will go to hell in a hand basket if they've not been to their local shop, queued with all the other gullible parents and payed over the odds for shoes which are no better than those they could have bought on Amazon or at the local supermarket.

(European shoe makes are the best for kids with narrow feet)

BiBabbles · 24/09/2021 12:46

I have an adult friend who has terrible feet due to ill fitting shoes as a child (her mother let her wear heels as a child in the 80s!) so it’s something I’ve very aware of.

I wore and was trained to dance in heels in 80s as a young child. It is part of some joint issues. My spouse has more issues from wearing too small formal shoes too often as a child though.

My kids wore swim shoes when they were small when they needed to wear shoes, but didn't need to wear formal ones. A physio recommended them - inexpensive, protect the feet when it isn't a good option to be barefoot, but the flexibility of them mean the many joints and muscles of the foot move more than they do in normal shoes (and no toe gripping needed like flip flops). My older kids don't now, but we still do the 'can you stretch your toes all the way' test for any shoes.

I know some kids need the extra support, but I don't get the idea that kids need "proper" supportive shoes always. If your child can run around barefoot with no discomfort, then usually shoes are more around protection than support. For most, I would think those muscles and joints should support themselves.

Those of you who buy shoes from supermarkets or similar, do you measure feet at home? Or take them to a specialist shop to get measured then buy from elsewhere?

In a shop, I have my children try the shoes on - doesn't matter which type of shop it is. All I can recall have benches or seats these days, but I can remember trying shoes out on the floor as a child.

Online, yes I've measured their feet at home. We have whiteboards, they'd stand on them, I'd draw around their feet, we'd measure, then they'd try to draw or write with their feet, we check the size guide many websites have. It's worked well.

BreatheAndFocus · 24/09/2021 12:41

Clarks shoes are pretty poor now. Not worth the money. Startrite are tons better. I often use Startrite Outlet to get bargains.

I agree, OP. Proper shoes are crucial for growing feet. My DS’s father buys crappy ones and I put them beside the Startrite ones and there’s no comparison. The crappy ones look worn quicker, they’re not wide enough (even though my DS has average width feet), the space for the toes is the wrong width, they have no room for growth….

Shoes for my DC is one thing I won’t compromise on. I save money elsewhere but always get good shoes for them.

RiotAtTheRodeo · 24/09/2021 12:39

I hate flip flops because I've seen one too many child try to run in them and then the front of the sole get caught bends backwards causing them to splat on their face.

DeepaBeesKit · 24/09/2021 12:37

A friend out her DC in little havaiana thong flip flops all summer. I would see them walking along the road with the DC stumbling and tripping, stubbing toes and struggling with them, and yet mum continue to put them on the child all summer.

But you know, her kid, her choice

Ozanj · 24/09/2021 12:34

DS prefers sandals right now (he’s 21 months old) and Crocs are not only cheaper they last longer than Clarks. For trainers I’m going to try Bobux next - they get rave reviews on MN.

Dutchesss · 24/09/2021 12:28

I used to cringe at toddler groups when new walkers were put in rigid Clarks shoes indoors to play. Barefoot is best for developing and growing feet. Young children's feet grow so fast that the exact sizing some places give is irrelevant.

Dartfordwarblerautumn · 24/09/2021 12:28

@GrumpyMiddleAgedWoman

I work in a school and it drives me mad when girls (it's always the girls) are put, by parents who can afford to buy them shoes that actually fit, into shoes they literally fall out of when they run. We're the ones who have to swoop in with ice packs and plasters. It's not fair on the DC.
I agree with this. I was looking at uniform adverts on TV over summer, and girls showing shiny new slip on ballet/court shoes-flat with quite a low cut at the front, I can never keep shows like that on for walking. I simply don’t know how it can be safe for girls to run around, kick a ball, skip, dance or all the things we want kids to do to keep moving. They need a strap across the foot at the very least. But really that low cut in British weather? They are going to get soaked socks/tights within minutes in being outside after rain It is ridiculous
Sylvvie · 24/09/2021 12:23

Most people can't afford 60-80 quid a pair of shoes every 6 months to a year for their kids. YABU.

Ski4130 · 24/09/2021 12:15

A snapshot of the shoes my children used to wear to parties would not be indicative of the shoes they wore all the time. The thought of telling any of mine to pop their sensible shoes on for a party makes me howl!
Also, what a weird thing to fixate on!

HoppingPavlova · 24/09/2021 12:08

I know brand new Clarks / StartRite are very expensive and fully appreciate not everyone can afford them

Huh? What age are you talking about? These were all around when mine were kids and they had one pair they wore when they went somewhere they had to have covered feet. Apart from that it was bare feet wherever possible and if not then we stuck them in thongs (flip flops in your terminology) that had little elastics on the back until their feet learnt to walk in regular thongs properly (it’s a skill). We, along with everyone I know, could afford Clarke’s etc several times over but no way kids would be wearing them on a day out to a bouncy castle, I’d expect a big pile of little thongs! When they get to school they wear ‘proper’ good quality shoes 9-3, no issue with kids feet outside of this.

RonObvious · 24/09/2021 12:03

Another vote for Clark’s girls shoes being appalling. The boys shoes are okay (if overpriced), but the girls shoes aren’t fit for purpose.

Rugsofhonour · 24/09/2021 12:02

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

girlmom21 · 24/09/2021 11:59

Clarks shoes are shit.

DD (2) pretty much lives in her Adidas gazelles. She has really wide feet so Clark's said to size up but never had the sizes they said to size up to (and their range is shocking and ugly).
She can comfortably put the shoes on by herself and they look cool as well as being good quality.

We took her to Clark's for her first measurements and bought her shoes there - we took her back after a couple of months later when they were getting too tight and they measured her smaller than the too-tight shoes...

We then took her to matalan (just as the sizes are easily accessible) to try on various sizes then went to Schuh and bought the correct size. Now when she needs new shoes we just size up. Schuh are good at checking they fit nicely too.

Garriet · 24/09/2021 11:58

My mum religiously put me in Clarks shoes when I was young.

I have the worst feet of anyone I’ve ever met. I can barely wear shoes at all, and constantly have blisters/burning soles. Maybe if she’d put me in shit shoes they’d be more robust?

RosiePosieDozy · 24/09/2021 11:55

They were probably wearing party shoes.

I would buy Clarks or Startrite for school but out of school, I wouldn't put my children in Clarks/Startrite trainers, maybe only boots from those shops. I think these shops are good for school shoes and for baby/toddler shoes but after that age, I would buy what I would say are 'proper' trainers like Nike and Adidas.

Swipe left for the next trending thread