Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Will the gas crisis herald a new era of green fuel.or not?

67 replies

malificent7 · 24/09/2021 04:38

Just been thinking that if fosdil fuels are going up in price will it incentivise governments to turn to green fuel. There used to be a solar panel initiative....what happened to that? Perhaps the silver lining to all this is that green fuel is the only viable option.
However obviously i'm worried about gas price rises and the effect on normal families.

OP posts:
CandyLeBonBon · 25/09/2021 16:05

@UsedUpUsername they really are. They are widely used in the construction industry. They're just expensive for domestics developers who want to see the biggest financial returns which is why, even when they are included at planning level, they are always vetoed to leverage profits.

A good system with adequate storage can absolutely power and entire family home.

UsedUpUsername · 25/09/2021 15:17

[quote CandyLeBonBon]@UsedUpUsername photovoltaics are much more sensitive than standard solar panels and work on overcast days as well. The addition of a battery means you store energy for later use. They're not the same as big standard solar panels used to heat water etc. [/quote]
I can’t imagine those batteries being very effective though?

I mean, you’ve every right to go this route. But I think it’s kind of impractical

notimagain · 25/09/2021 10:55

Stating the obvious but there are solar panels and there are solar panels and I sense perhaps some confusion creeping in.

There solar panels used to heat water which work by circulating a fluid through panels exposed to the sun and then subsequently through a heat exchanger (coil) in your hot water cylinder.

There are then the photovoltaic panels/cells which (via the magic of semi-conductors) convert sunlight directly to electricity.

Coogee · 25/09/2021 09:23

photovoltaics are much more sensitive than standard solar panels

A standard solar panel is an array of photovoltaic cells.

CandyLeBonBon · 25/09/2021 09:06

@UsedUpUsername photovoltaics are much more sensitive than standard solar panels and work on overcast days as well. The addition of a battery means you store energy for later use. They're not the same as big standard solar panels used to heat water etc.

CandyLeBonBon · 25/09/2021 08:59

@Proudboomer

I live close to the Rampion wind farm. There is a massive expansion plan for it so it covers the coastline from Brighton to Bognor. There is a lot of opposition to it as nimbys complain it will be a blight on the seascape. I don’t see what they are complaining for the view is nothing special to be blighted in any event.
Same! I can't see the issue really!
UsedUpUsername · 24/09/2021 19:03

@Proudboomer

I live close to the Rampion wind farm. There is a massive expansion plan for it so it covers the coastline from Brighton to Bognor. There is a lot of opposition to it as nimbys complain it will be a blight on the seascape. I don’t see what they are complaining for the view is nothing special to be blighted in any event.
Why not a natural gas facility? Would only blight a small part of the landscape.

But I’m biased. I truly loathe the sight of those hulking towers.

DGRossetti · 24/09/2021 18:48

Very much agree with you on all of that but the problem is it’s been claimed for years that controlled contained fusion for domestic power generation is just around the corner but here we are in 2021, not quite there yet.

It has been for at least 40 years - or as long as I've been following it.

Proudboomer · 24/09/2021 12:12

I live close to the Rampion wind farm. There is a massive expansion plan for it so it covers the coastline from Brighton to Bognor. There is a lot of opposition to it as nimbys complain it will be a blight on the seascape. I don’t see what they are complaining for the view is nothing special to be blighted in any event.

UsedUpUsername · 24/09/2021 11:52

@flowerycurtain

Based on the local opposition to a recent solar park on land around here I'd say not.

People care about going green until it affects the countryside view they thought they'd purchased.

Yes who cares about environmental degradation?

Tbh the land usage of renewables is horrible and not talked about enough. Far less land is used for fossil fuel or nuclear power plants. More efficient from a variety of considerations

EatYourVegetables · 24/09/2021 11:48

I wish but I’m not optimistic.

Biker47 · 24/09/2021 11:08

Hopefully nuclear power is looked at again, the last nuclear station connected to the grid was in 1995, and all of our current nuclear stations are owned by EDF so effectively owned by the French state, 4 of the 7 currently active are due to be shut down in three years time.

flowerycurtain · 24/09/2021 10:55

Based on the local opposition to a recent solar park on land around here I'd say not.

People care about going green until it affects the countryside view they thought they'd purchased.

notimagain · 24/09/2021 10:46

@HarrietsChariot

Well we're getting closer to nuclear fusion being a source of "unlimited" power. Until that comes along we're at the mercy of fossil fuels and nuclear fission power stations. Maybe shutting all the coal mines wasn't such a good idea, it's left us very vulnerable to the whims of the Russians.

So-called "renewable" energy is very unreliable, unless someone invents batteries capable of storing and reusing energy on a huge scale.

Very much agree with you on all of that but the problem is it’s been claimed for years that controlled contained fusion for domestic power generation is just around the corner but here we are in 2021, not quite there yet.
HarrietsChariot · 24/09/2021 10:19

Well we're getting closer to nuclear fusion being a source of "unlimited" power. Until that comes along we're at the mercy of fossil fuels and nuclear fission power stations. Maybe shutting all the coal mines wasn't such a good idea, it's left us very vulnerable to the whims of the Russians.

So-called "renewable" energy is very unreliable, unless someone invents batteries capable of storing and reusing energy on a huge scale.

HasaDigaEebowai · 24/09/2021 10:19

We are just installing solar panels with a battery. They go on next week. This should mean we generate a large percentage of the electricity we use and they work even in shading. EON are currently doing three years interest free credit (or at least they were before the energy market went bonkers).

ConcernedAuntie · 24/09/2021 10:12

@DGRossetti

What happened after the 1970s ? We've been here before.
Ah yes. The three day week. I remember it well. Still able to carry on working on the no power days with my hurricane lamp, manual typewriter, coat and hat. We just worked through it as well as we could. I worked for a local authority so no choice really.

Trouble is these days work places are entirely reliant on energy to power computers and machinery which makes it impossible.

The building I worked in was an old isolation hospital so it got quite spooky after dark with all the flickering shadows.

At home we just had sandwiches or heated up soup and baked beans on a camping stove. Read a lot of books by candlelight and the aforesaid hurricane lamp. It was quite peaceful actually because you couldn't do ironing, hoovering and the like.

MangoFeverDream · 24/09/2021 09:47

@GlobalForce

Until very rich individuals and the big polluting countries start changing their ways things will carry on getting bad for us all.

We watch them jet around in space preparing a business for other rich people to rocket around the earth and the fob us off by telling us they paid some poor people money to plant a few trees. They don't want to life the life they need to live, and many of them lecture and blame us not themselves.

They carry on living in huge mansions with a large staff and massive energy consumption to maintain said mansion and lifestyle, they don't want to change and they will set the rules so they do not have to change.

Ok but individuals add up more than a few billionaires. You could kill them all and emissions wouldn’t change.

You’ll be fine. There won’t be any sort of apocalyptic climate change—if anything, we’ll be better able to adjust to climate change if we are living in a rich and productive society.

Gingernaut · 24/09/2021 09:40

Solar panels work and they can be connected to the National Grid, but the issue is that power fluctuates with sunshine.

Short winter days and grey overcast weather will affect the amount of power going back to the grid and not always be at useful times.

Power use goes up in the evenings when people go home.

GlobalForce · 24/09/2021 09:39

Until very rich individuals and the big polluting countries start changing their ways things will carry on getting bad for us all.

We watch them jet around in space preparing a business for other rich people to rocket around the earth and the fob us off by telling us they paid some poor people money to plant a few trees. They don't want to life the life they need to live, and many of them lecture and blame us not themselves.

They carry on living in huge mansions with a large staff and massive energy consumption to maintain said mansion and lifestyle, they don't want to change and they will set the rules so they do not have to change.

ISeeTheLight · 24/09/2021 09:38

I don't get why new builds in the UK are allowed to be built with virtually no renewable energy systems. I grew up abroad - Western Europe - since about 5-10 years there ALL new houses have to have things like rainwater collection to be used for toilets, ground / air source heat pumps, ventilation systems (this helps with energy usage), etc. Gas boilers are very much on the way out there.
Meanwhile our UK new build has none of those things.

SprayedWithDettol · 24/09/2021 09:33

We live in a village without gas, so need bottled for my range cooker and oil for heating. We are going to be doing a lot of work on our house over then next 2 years and plan to include solar panels (we have a lot of roof so this shouldn’t be a problem) and an air source heat pump. The latter will require a fair bit of modification to our house (old and in parts single skin brick), but the environmental upside makes it a no brainier.
It will be expensive and will mean that some other plans might not happen, but to reduce our carbon footprint it is imperative.
The government should be insisting that all new builds now follow this path.

UsedUpUsername · 24/09/2021 09:29

@CandyLeBonBon

I think there's going to be a massive uptake in photovoltaic roof panels and battery storage. It should be mandatory in all new builds now IMO
Not gonna be useful in the dead of winter, that’s for sure. People still die for lack of heat in the UK and is unfortunately way too common in the rest of the world. Too much is taken for granted here
UsedUpUsername · 24/09/2021 09:25

@malificent7

Just been thinking that if fosdil fuels are going up in price will it incentivise governments to turn to green fuel. There used to be a solar panel initiative....what happened to that? Perhaps the silver lining to all this is that green fuel is the only viable option. However obviously i'm worried about gas price rises and the effect on normal families.
Fossil fuels are going up in price will lead to it being financially viable to frack again. UK would be better off importing natural gas from US and Canada than Russia.

Personally I hope this leads to an open-mindedness about nuclear power. We need stable sources of power, not intermittent renewables.

RosyPoesy · 24/09/2021 09:22

The problem with solar panels is that they’re too expensive. The schemes that offer subsidised solar panels basically mean the company owns the panels and they rent your roof from you. Which is absolutely no good because you don’t want to give away ownership of your own roof! Various green initiatives like insulation etc are usually only available to the poor or those on benefits. The government could make more green electricity but that’s between them and the energy companies, it’s beyond the control of the normal person who just flips the switch to turn their light on.