Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Today's ruling re Down's Syndrome

693 replies

Shirazboobaloo · 23/09/2021 21:09

Sorry to hijack AIBU for this but can someone explain this ruling to me please?

What I can't understand (from press reports) is how this has "come to this".

Who is Heidi Crowther and who are those supporting her?

I am genuinely confused but don't know where to ask

OP posts:
Teapiggies · 24/09/2021 23:09

@Spink

The Anti NIPTers I know aren’t so much against early screening as against early screening when poor info is given about the screened-for condition.
I can’t help but feel anti-NIPTers are assuming the information is ‘poor’ because it isn’t producing the results they personally want to see. It doesn’t work that way. Even if the information is poor, that shouldn’t enable people to make decisions about whether a pregnant woman can have knowledge about her pregnancy or not - that’s incredibly controlling.
Spink · 24/09/2021 23:05

The Anti NIPTers I know aren’t so much against early screening as against early screening when poor info is given about the screened-for condition.

Krabapple · 24/09/2021 23:04

I am usually very pro choice but how can you abort up to delivery? I honestly don’t understand this. Surely it would be better to give birth and then give up care? How do you abort a full term baby?

Teapiggies · 24/09/2021 23:04

[quote Mjfdrjjbf]@Teapiggies - no it’s not particularly balanced, but my point is that the information that’s given at the moment isn’t balanced. Frankly I’m not that invested in whether more babies are born with DS, but I do think that an overly negative and medicalised view needs countering. One thing I’ve really noticed over the last few weeks is every time someone with a family member with DS says it’s been a positive experience, lots of people jump in and tell them their lived experience must be the exception. From knowing lots of families with DS if that’s the case I’m meeting a hell of a lot of exceptions.

On NIPT: www.downs-syndrome.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/2020.FactChecker_NIPT.pdf

I’d be interested in finding the source data (I can’t remember where I originally read it) but DSA have it at less than 50%[/quote]
What information is given at the moment? Do we know?

lifehappened · 24/09/2021 23:03

I know I'll get jumped on, but I agree with her. I also totally respect everyone who disagrees as we are all allowed our opinions

Spink · 24/09/2021 23:02

Following up on the NIPT comments - I had a NIPT but was advised to have a diagnostic test (CVS) as the NIPT is not considered conclusive

Teapiggies · 24/09/2021 23:00

I find the anti-NIPT campaign even more incomprehensible than this one if I’m honest. I can somewhat understand why they feel the way they do about the termination laws (although I disagree), but to want to prevent women even having knowledge about their own pregnancies?! What gives them that right?

I also struggle because a lot of people who are anti-NIPT actually received a postnatal diagnosis after having the first trimester screening themselves. Why is it they feel they had the right to testing (even if it didn’t produce an accurate result for them), but other women don’t?

It all seems to be on morally shaky grounds.

Spink · 24/09/2021 22:59

@Mjfdrjjbf I just wanted to say hello :)

LangClegsInSpace · 24/09/2021 22:58

@cloudacious

motor but this option is never used anyway, it just uselessly exists causing pain to those who have it hard enough. If it's never used, it's not undermining anyone's rights to remove it or level up.
What do you mean it's never used?

There isn't a separate specific rule for DS. There isn't a list of conditions.

The law says abortion past 24 weeks is legal if 'two registered medical practitioners are of the opinion, formed in good faith, that there is a substantial risk that if the child were born it would suffer from such physical or mental abnormalities as to be seriously handicapped.'

Just because it hasn't been used for DS for a good few years doesn't mean it's never used. Of course it would undermine women's rights to remove it.

Mjfdrjjbf · 24/09/2021 22:57

@Teapiggies - no it’s not particularly balanced, but my point is that the information that’s given at the moment isn’t balanced. Frankly I’m not that invested in whether more babies are born with DS, but I do think that an overly negative and medicalised view needs countering. One thing I’ve really noticed over the last few weeks is every time someone with a family member with DS says it’s been a positive experience, lots of people jump in and tell them their lived experience must be the exception. From knowing lots of families with DS if that’s the case I’m meeting a hell of a lot of exceptions.

On NIPT: www.downs-syndrome.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/2020.FactChecker_NIPT.pdf

I’d be interested in finding the source data (I can’t remember where I originally read it) but DSA have it at less than 50%

Spink · 24/09/2021 22:53

Sorry it’s taken me a while to respond. Doing dinner & bedtimes, and spider clearance..

Clymene “The average intelligence quotient (IQ) of children with DS is around 50, ranging between 30 and 70. Remarkably, a small number of patients have a profound degree of ID, whereas others have a mild degree” this is from Mégarbané, A. et al, 2013 The intellectual disability of trisomy 21: Eur J Hum Genet.
Mild learning disability is usually used to describe an IQ of 50-70, moderate is 35-55. IQ measures generally are tricky in this population though, not least due to verbal components of the tests -verbal functioning is commonly affected in DS, but not just as a result of cognitive ability but also hypotonia and differences in facial structure - that basically make talking more difficult.

To pick another example from your account of DS - yes, around 50% of children with DS have congenital heart problems but most can be treated (if needed) within the first years of life - my daughter is in that 50% and though when she was very small, her heart defects affected her ability to feed, they resolved without treatment by the time she was 3. In our local DS group, none of the children have ongoing heart problems and a couple needed surgery in the first year of life, which went well. Of course that’s not true for everyone, but still, that 50% stat is not as scary as it first seems.

To the couple of people picking up on my mentioning the 90% overall abortion rate for pregnancies identifies as high risk for DS - It’s difficult to know the quality of info that people base their decision on. It is a painful and difficult choice to have to make, whatever you decide. The information I was given by the screening team and my doctor was great; balanced and compassionate, and I still went backwards and forwards about what to do. I would not condemn anyone for choosing to terminate in those circumstances. But my experience of being given decent info is (anecdotally, from other parents in the DS community) not common. More than that, most parents were repeatedly asked to consider termination even after they stated they’d made a decision to continue with the pregnancy. So, yes, a lot of parents in the DS community feel that people don’t have access to accurate information. Of course people can do their own research, but it’s an emotional and overwhelming time and not easy to do a deep dive into the research.
If termination rates stayed at 90% even if good quality information was routinely available, I’d be surprised but rest a lot easier than I do now.

LangClegsInSpace · 24/09/2021 22:46

@Teapiggies

Many parents of DS children have been hurt and saddened by this and what it says about society's attitude to their children.

But this isn’t about society’s attitude to their children, is it? It’s about other women and their potential children.

If it was truly about bringing the termination gestation limit in line with one another, they should campaign for routine NIPT testing for all pregnant women who want it. That way there will be much fewer late diagnoses and women will have the opportunity to terminate early if they want to.

But something tells me they won’t.

Heidi Crowter was also involved in the 'Don't Screen Us Out' campaign against NIPT.
Teapiggies · 24/09/2021 22:42

only 50% accurate for women in their 20s

Are you sure??? That doesn’t sound right to me at all?

Teapiggies · 24/09/2021 22:40

@Mjfdrjjbf it’s a lovely book, but it isn’t exactly ‘balanced’ information so to speak.

The thing is, nobody can tell a woman how her baby with DS will fare in life, medically or socially. It seems the level of medical issue don’t necessarily correspond to the level of social function, so it’s all just a waiting game. Some women will be happy to see how things go & think optimistically. Others won’t be comfortable with such an unknown. I doubt ‘balanced information’, in whatever format that takes, would radically change the termination rate because it wouldn’t provide enough reassurances for those women who are risk averse. But that’s just my hunch, I could well be wrong.

Mjfdrjjbf · 24/09/2021 22:35

@Teapiggies - also, a note on NIPT!

I don’t agree NIPT should be further restricted as I think restricting info about a woman’s pregnancy is a bad thing. But 2 important points - it’s still only screening, not diagnostic and is only 50% accurate for women in their 20s (more babies with DS are born to women under 35 than over 35 due to higher birth rate in that group, so this is relevant.). Plus, a woman may well be happy with a DS diagnosis but not with anomalies that show up later in the 20w or later scans. I don’t think NIPT is the panacea some people think it is.

It’s all a bit of a minefield. But the more that’s acknowledged the better!

Mjfdrjjbf · 24/09/2021 22:20

@Teapiggies positiveaboutdownsyndrome.co.uk/nobodytoldme/

Mjfdrjjbf · 24/09/2021 22:18

@pointythings agreed, and the prevalence of early onset dementia is the thing that upsets me most when I think about my child’s future. But I have no idea what advancements will be made in dementia prevention and care in the next 40 years as it’s a very well funded area of research, plus I’ve got a hell of a lot of amazing and rewarding times to get through with my child before we have to worry about that. Im not pretending it’s all rosy but there’s also a bigger picture

Saskatcha · 24/09/2021 22:15

A simplistic way of looking at it but, in essence, most babies would, at the 24 week mark, have the right to be cared for by their local authority (as opposed to their mother having a right to terminate) if the mother was not able to care for the child. I am not sure why a baby should be denied this right because they have Down’s syndrome.

Mjfdrjjbf · 24/09/2021 22:12

@Teapiggies Really good question and to be perfectly upfront here, I had a postnatal diagnosis so didn’t have to go through this. But PHE policy is to present screening/diagnostic results in a neutral manner (“chance of DS” not “risk of DS”, no “I’m sorry”), and that v often isn’t followed. Currently - and you can see it on this thread - many parents hear about a very worst case, medicalised model of disability. “Your child has an x% chance of y condition”. Some of that information is valuable, but it’s important to recognise that a) many people with DS are v healthy (my child for instance has never had a hospital admission) and b) a medicalised model is only some of the picture. So I’d also advocate proper information about the lived experience of DS. The charity Positive About Down Syndrome do this brilliantly (and follow it up with exceptional support - they really do the leg work in supporting families and children). They have an online book called Nobody Told Me which is worth a read. It’s obviously a particular view and they, to a degree, have an agenda (it’s not a particularly anti choice agenda but they are, obviously, quite positive about DS!) but it’s a very useful counter to a laundry list of medical problems which may or may not happen.

LJAKS · 24/09/2021 22:11

I was offered a termination on medical grounds at 37 weeks when they found out my daughter had CDH. I was told that she would never be able to live a normal life, that she would be tube fed, on oxygen and likely to need round the clock care. She is and requires none of those things. She's a perfectly healthy child who attends mainstream school and functions completely independently. She goes to dancing, swimming, rainbows. At her last check up her lungs had grown and developed to the point that a junior doctor wouldn't be able to tell there had been an issue from a chest X-ray.
She is in no way "incompatible with life" quite the opposite. The issue I have with the ruling is that certain conditions make late term abortion absolutely fine, where it isn't without said conditions. It's the discrepancy that irks me. Should be the same across the board. It's either 24 weeks or it's term

pointythings · 24/09/2021 22:02

@Mjfdrjjbf I also agree - training for clinicians should change to ensure that no undue pressure is exerted on women. Just as women should be trusted with the decision to abort, so should they be trusted with the decision not to do so.

In terms of the care and health needs of people with DS, I agree that things have come a long way - but the prevalence of young onset dementia in that population as compared to people without DS is still much, much higher. That is absolutely something that should be considered in the process of making a decision.

Lockdownbear · 24/09/2021 22:00

@Clymene

Removing women's right to choose is central. The woman interviewed on WH today with spina bifida wants the government to stop plugging folic acid. Because she thinks it demonises SB when actually it's not the most important thing about her.

She glossed over the fact that most people with SB have severe incontinence issues, hydrocephalus, and other neurological co-morbidities. As well as lower limb paralysis.

I totally understand that people who are living their best life with perinatal disabilities hate the idea that women may terminate if they know their baby has that condition. But it's not their job to police other women's families

Fucking hell!Angry

Spina bifida was very common in the 70s, everyone seemed to know a kid in a chair with spina bifida. I also know a kid who had spina bifida but had surgery and was OK except incontent.

18 weeks with my IVF baby, phone call your baby is high risk of spina bifida. Fuck! However thinking about the above I can cope with that as long as its mentally OK we'll cope.

Then I googled - fuck that's the easy end of the stick - some spina bifida isn't compatible with life.

I eventually got an apology MW had screwed up baby was fine but OMG! My heart goes out to every mum and dad who've been told your baby has a problem.

Teapiggies · 24/09/2021 21:51

@Mjfdrjjbf I agree that once a woman decides to continue the pregnancy, medical staff should stop asking her (as long as she knows she can change her mind at any time).

Regarding the info, what do you think women should be presented with in an optimum scenario?

Mjfdrjjbf · 24/09/2021 21:43

@Teapiggies the law is widely known in the DS community because it’s not uncommon for women with a confirmed diagnosis of DS to be repeatedly asked whether they are sure they want to keep the baby, including until late in pregnancy. I know a number of women who’ve been through this (asked multiple times up until full term if they are sure they want to keep the baby as it’s “not too late”) - it’s traumatising for them and really, really poor care.

FWIW I think it’s a bit of a separate issue - I think the choice should remain, but I also think the info that’s given to women and the way women with babies with DS are often (not always) treated during pregnancy is horrific.

HarrisMcCoo · 24/09/2021 21:37

@Mjfdrjjbf

I’m probably going to regret wading into this but

Firstly, those who’ve shared stories of TFMR, I’m sorry for your loss and thank you for sharing.

I’m pro choice and think the court made the right decision.

I also have a child with DS. A lot of the information being shared on this thread about DS is wildly out of date and incorrect. I know a lot of families with children with DS. The idea that the norm is non verbal, aggressive, doubly incontinent… is simply untrue. There are elements of parenting a child with additional needs that are challenging, but also a lot that is hugely rewarding. Understanding and education of people with DS has come on hugely and more and more people of Heidi’s generation and younger are achieving things that would have been unthinkable a generation or two ago. A lot of research has been done on the “Down syndrome advantage” - it’s generally considered to be one of the easier disabilities to parent. The vast majority of families with a member with DS are proud of them and think they are a positive influence (again this is research based not anecdotal)

It is STILL a woman’s legitimate choice whether to carry any pregnancy to term. But please let’s not perpetuate out of date stereotypes of DS to reinforce that - abortion on demand should be acceptable without generalising or exaggerating the challenges faced by a minority group.

Your personal experience is very similar to the professional capacity in which I looked after those with DS years ago....all that I remember is most needed support with some daily living skills but really were not into having huge emotional outbursts, and it was possible to hold a conversation. No where near some of the grim stories being portrayed here on this thread. I am not going to deny there are exceptions though, just like any other disability.