Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Today's ruling re Down's Syndrome

693 replies

Shirazboobaloo · 23/09/2021 21:09

Sorry to hijack AIBU for this but can someone explain this ruling to me please?

What I can't understand (from press reports) is how this has "come to this".

Who is Heidi Crowther and who are those supporting her?

I am genuinely confused but don't know where to ask

OP posts:
Motorina · 25/09/2021 19:28

I love @pointythings list and @LangClegsInSpace addendum. That would truly be a positive step forward.

LangClegsInSpace · 25/09/2021 19:24

This is the NIPT offered by NHS:

www.nhs.uk/pregnancy/your-pregnancy-care/screening-for-downs-edwards-pataus-syndrome/

Mjfdrjjbf · 25/09/2021 19:21

@Pongo101 it’s being brought in in some Trusts. But see previous posts, more info is good but it’s definitely not the answer to everything for lots of reasons

Pongo101 · 25/09/2021 19:20

It also claims 99% accuracy

LangClegsInSpace · 25/09/2021 19:20

Good wish list.

I would add, better support for adults with disabilities of any kind.

This is an unusually reasonable and productive thread for AIBU!

Mjfdrjjbf · 25/09/2021 19:19

*- Retraining of clinical staff so that they trust women to decide and stop pushing for termination after they have heard 'No'.

  • Better support in every way for families who have a child with disabilities of any kind
  • More visibility in the wider community so that the stigma is addressed
  • Levelling up of the age where termination is allowed - because let's be honest, it isn't going to change anything. No women is just going to have a termination at 38 weeks for the lolz*

YES YES YES. Everything in this post. This all would make the world a better place.

Pongo101 · 25/09/2021 19:19

@LangClegsInSpace harmony isn't available on the NHS unfortunately, it's a combination of a detailed private scan and from my understanding (not a scientist so can't say exact how the blood test works) analysis of the baby's dna in the mothers blood. So you can tell the chromosomes from the test.

pointythings · 25/09/2021 19:12

There's a wish list of what we need, isn't there:

  • Retraining of clinical staff so that they trust women to decide and stop pushing for termination after they have heard 'No'.
  • Better support in every way for families who have a child with disabilities of any kind
  • More visibility in the wider community so that the stigma is addressed
  • Levelling up of the age where termination is allowed - because let's be honest, it isn't going to change anything. No women is just going to have a termination at 38 weeks for the lolz

What we don't need are restrictions pushed by someone who has people with an agenda behind them.

LangClegsInSpace · 25/09/2021 19:08

No one can have her - she’s mine Smile

Thank you for your very thoughtful posts Flowers

LangClegsInSpace · 25/09/2021 19:07

Any pregnancy can also end in a mother having disabilities she didn't have before, and not enough is talked about that.

Yes, I was just thinking about this in relation to my earlier post about the criteria for abortion before 24 weeks.

Being denied bodily autonomy is always likely to be injurous to women's mental health.

Full term pregnancy and childbirth is much more likely to be injurous to your physical health than ending a pregnancy in the early weeks.

Two medical practitioners must decide if the continuance of your pregnancy would involve risk, greater than if the pregnancy were terminated, of injury to your physical or mental health.

In the early weeks of pregnancy that's a no brainer.

Mjfdrjjbf · 25/09/2021 19:04

Thanks @pointythings. I do understand why many people in the DS community feel so strongly about it, particularly those who’ve had appalling antenatal experiences and feel they had to fight against repeated pressure from clinicians to terminate. I’m lucky I didn’t have to go through any of that with a postnatal diagnosis. It’s not black and white.

I’d strongly push back against people who say “why would someone not want my baby” though. It’s not about my child. No one can have her - she’s mine, and I feel incredibly lucky that she is. My bigger concern is the unintended consequences that would have impacted people on this thread who’ve shared their stories of TFMR.

Mjfdrjjbf · 25/09/2021 18:54

@Embracelife I know it’s a bit of a technicality but there’s screening for DS early in pregnancy, not diagnostic testing (NIPT is also screening not diagnostic). Around 12% of babies born with DS had low chance screening results. And another 40-50%’s mothers opted out of screening either at the start of didn’t go forward with a diagnostic test having had a high chance result (over 1 in 150).

It’s important because there’s a risk DS is framed as a lifestyle choice, which I would then be worried is used an excuse to not fund services properly.

LangClegsInSpace · 25/09/2021 18:32

@Pongo101

Was reading this thread and thinking about how I paid almost 500 quid for the harmony test at around 12 weeks. It was an expensive way to know as soon as possible whether my child had ds or other conditions or not.

So if the abortion limit had changed, people like me with enough money in the bank would be able to afford the test. Waiting for things to become clearer on the 20 week scan would be left to the people who couldn't afford earlier private testing.

Those financially better off would be less likely to have a pregnancy with ds beyond 24 weeks.

Those financially worse off would be unable to afford testing and therefore more likely to have a pregnancy with ds beyond 24 weeks.

It would be the people who already needed support in the first place now needing more support than ever. The vulnerable would become more vulnerable. DS children would be more likely born into families on the breadline than families who could afford the additional support and resources that these children would need.

I thought they were offering NIPT on the NHS now. Is Harmony something different?

(I agree anyway because as time goes on there will be advances in other types of early screening and they are bound to be available privately first.)

pointythings · 25/09/2021 18:31

*@Mjfdrjjbf * honestly it would be so great if you could speak with Heidi and her team. Because you see it with such clarity and compassion.

CallMeNutribullet · 25/09/2021 18:21

People on this thread are going on as if women given the chance would have terminations past 24 weeks left right and centre.

An abortion past 24 weeks involves a traumatising still birth and the people who make the difficult decision to do this often do so to stop their very much wanted child having a short and brutal èxistence filled with pain.

Treaclepie19 · 25/09/2021 18:03

I know that's not DS but I think its relevant when people keep saying you can find things out easily early on.

Treaclepie19 · 25/09/2021 18:02

Not only that @Pongo101 but the NIPT and similar can't test for many things.
My NIPT came back fine. My baby still had deletions of chromosomes that meant he was incredibly poorly. We had an amnio but it's why we didn't end up finding out the issue until 22+4.
So lots of people would end up being close or after the 24 weeks.

Embracelife · 25/09/2021 18:02

But yes there is testing for down syndrome so you can avoid "that" specific DS journey thru testing and termination if you wish. But you cannot test for every similar or worse condition.

Embracelife · 25/09/2021 17:58

"if I can avoid going down that road as a parent myself, I will."

You can only plan so much.
You can test all you like and have a severely disabled child.
Having the option prenatally to decide what you do or don't want is fine
And of course option should be there to decide or not on your pregnancy.

but a little disingenuous to believe you can avoid every disability or difficulty.....you cannot.

It s more

"if I find out prenatally there is an issue i will abort."

"If I find out prenatally there is any issue at all I will abort"

That s every woman s choice...

That s why I fall on make it legal for any issue ... any including the woman s wishes. the numbers post 24 weeks will always be small

"If i find out postnatally there is an issue I will.... "
...Will what?
You can not avoid all issues.
Your parenting journey may go down that road anyway
Parenting may be challenging or not.
Some parents are challenged even with a child with no issues...

Sirzy · 25/09/2021 17:50

That’s a good point pongo and exactly why we can’t take away choice from women.

Mjfdrjjbf · 25/09/2021 17:48

@Pongo101 this is a really good point. The current laws are in place to protect women who for all sorts of reasons have unequal access to healthcare

Pongo101 · 25/09/2021 16:36

Was reading this thread and thinking about how I paid almost 500 quid for the harmony test at around 12 weeks. It was an expensive way to know as soon as possible whether my child had ds or other conditions or not.

So if the abortion limit had changed, people like me with enough money in the bank would be able to afford the test. Waiting for things to become clearer on the 20 week scan would be left to the people who couldn't afford earlier private testing.

Those financially better off would be less likely to have a pregnancy with ds beyond 24 weeks.

Those financially worse off would be unable to afford testing and therefore more likely to have a pregnancy with ds beyond 24 weeks.

It would be the people who already needed support in the first place now needing more support than ever. The vulnerable would become more vulnerable. DS children would be more likely born into families on the breadline than families who could afford the additional support and resources that these children would need.

Thisisworsethananticpated · 25/09/2021 16:11

Mjfdrjjbf

Thanks for your voice and your perspective
Really really pleased to hear you on this thread
And I’m happy that your DD is great 😊

I’m bailing out of the discussion
My views on this topic are emotional and from my heart rather than logical
I also was totally smitten with a DS child in my sons class (I did a lot of help) so I’m probably , definitely biased

SionnachRua · 25/09/2021 15:59

I didn’t want a child with DS. I didn’t care about the severity or any comorbidities. I just didn’t want a child with the condition.I would do the same with autism if such a test existed. I would have felt guilty about it if it came to that, but the guilt is preferable to the reality of having a child with DS.

I feel exactly the same except that I wouldn't and don't feel an ounce of guilt. There's a lot of judgement heaped on parents and siblings of people with disabilities who don't subscribe to society's view of disability as 'such a blessing in your life'. It's uncomfortable when people can't just handwave the real problems away.

Speaking from experience there. I feel like I've had a hard enough road with autistic sibling as it is and if I can avoid going down that road as a parent myself, I will.

Lockdownbear · 25/09/2021 15:15

One advantage of DS is it can be picked up very early and often is. Parents have choice, if it's a risk they want to carry, nobody has the right to say a parents decision is right or wrong. They made the decision based on the knowledge and belief that they have.

Other conditions are more difficult to pick up either from blood test or scans. And remember things go wrong along they way too. Those women should still have the right to decide with the best information they can get.