Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Today's ruling re Down's Syndrome

693 replies

Shirazboobaloo · 23/09/2021 21:09

Sorry to hijack AIBU for this but can someone explain this ruling to me please?

What I can't understand (from press reports) is how this has "come to this".

Who is Heidi Crowther and who are those supporting her?

I am genuinely confused but don't know where to ask

OP posts:
Lockdownbear · 26/09/2021 00:58

@Whitefire I think I had more blood tests with my 4 yo than I did with my 10yo.
They definitely did bloods, for spina bifida, Downs, Edwards? maybe and something else, began with a P that I'd never heard off.
I don't remember get those with the first.

Two of the things were life limiting if I remember rightly.

Whitefire · 26/09/2021 00:09

My last pregnancy was 10 years ago, then it was a scan (?? Fold) and blood test. Is what is offered now different?

I didn't have it, at the time the NHS literature said if you wouldn't have invasive testing don't have the non invasive. Also (imo) a risk number is still fairly meaningless. I did however have a separate and specific heart scan with all three, that would probably have been a better indicator of any possible issues.

LangClegsInSpace · 25/09/2021 23:29

Why are you talking about US law, UsedUp? There's a good potted history of UK law in the judgment. The time limit in the UK has nothing to do with Roe V Wade.

I think we should be giving anything based on US law a very hard swerve, given how that's working out.

ellyeth · 25/09/2021 23:29

I don't believe in forcing women to have abortions - as they once did in China - or of, in effect, forcing them to have their babies adopted - which was common practice in the 50's - as was denying women contraception. I also don't believe in making women go through a pregnancy and labour when they do not, for whatever reason, feel able to, or want to, do it. They are all examples of the state taking control of a woman's body, to the possible detriment of her health and mental well being.

Lockdownbear · 25/09/2021 23:00

And as you may be aware, 24 weeks is actually quite late among Western European countries, where the limit is around 12-16 weeks for healthy fetuses.

What's the limit in Europe where the mothers life is at stake?

ISpyCobraKai · 25/09/2021 22:34

UsedUpUsername
Terminations just before 24 weeks, as in 23+5 don't necessarily mean the woman has to give birth.
It can be done under general anesthesia.

UsedUpUsername · 25/09/2021 22:10

Ethical guidance is fine. That's not the same as having a strict cut-off date. There's nothing ethical about that

Why don’t you think it’s ethical? The point is to give a time when we can start to consider the fetus. Viability is the obvious point to do this.

You say 'hard no', I say 'hard cases' - the circumstances of the tiny number of women and girls seeking late abortion for non-medical reasons are harrowing

After 24 weeks (actually a bit before), the way to extract a fetus would be harrowing in any case. You know it and I know it. Giving birth to a dead fetus is preferable how?

*If this child's pregnancy had been known about earlier, but after 24 weeks, do you think she should have been denied an abortion?

Do you think a late-term abortion would really take all her trauma away? It’s a grim business however you slice it and one route is not obviously better than the other. Hard cases are not magically solved this way—I could throw back cases where the child never knew she was pregnant until someone took her to hospital.

Because this has nothing to do with the rights of the woman, who is the person subject to the law

And here we have it. You don’t believe in giving the fetus some rights at 24 weeks (how Roe v Wade balanced things) so we are clearly not going to see eye to eye here.

Because viability is not a 'point', it's a percentage chance of survival which has nothing to say about the amount of intervention a baby in the lucky half of the percentage needs to survive and nothing to say about the likely quality of life or continuing care they may need

I don’t see how this contributes. The point is that this is around the point a fetus can survive outside the womb. It’s an arbitrary point, but is useful when setting protections for the fetus.

And as you may be aware, 24 weeks is actually quite late among Western European countries, where the limit is around 12-16 weeks for healthy fetuses.

It’s not a suitable norm for the UK (nor the US) due to social reasons, much more endemic poverty for example.

Because technological advances are likely to push 'viability' progressively earlier and each time this happens, women's reproductive rights will be further curtailed

The 24 week limit was set by Roe v Wade in the 70s and technological advances has not changed this, so I think this fear is unfounded tbh

LangClegsInSpace · 25/09/2021 21:50

Thanks Mjf, I'll have a proper read in the morning.

Iwouldlikesomecake · 25/09/2021 21:47

Just to clarify: Harmony IS NIPT as is Panorama. They are brand names essentially. NIPT is just non invasive prenatal testing (cell free fetal dna testing) so you are looking at fetal dna in mum’s blood. It’s used for other conditions by genetics departments and there are studies looking at using it for other conditions that you can currently only diagnose by CVS/Amnio.

The ‘accuracy’ isn’t straightforward. It’s most accurate for trisomy 21 and less so for T13 and T18; it is most accurate in the cohort of women who have had a high chance combined screening or quadruple test before opting for NIPT (ie there are fewer false positives or negatives) compared with the general pregnant population.

It’s a useful tool- as it’s more accurate for women with a high chance initial screen so it gives a bit more information. But it isn’t diagnostic. However if you have been TTC for years, the NT is low and your chance is 1:125 then it is just that bit more accurate to help you make that decision to go for diagnostic testing or not.

I firmly agree that if a woman has said she is committed to continuing the pregnancy she should be supported in that- and that means not ‘offering’ termination at later gestations. No matter if the outcome is inevitable that the baby will die. It’s the woman’s choice.

And that means it’s still got to be the woman’s choice if she wants to have a baby AT ALL.

LangClegsInSpace · 25/09/2021 21:47

@UsedUpUsername

Levelling up of the age where termination is allowed - because let's be honest, it isn't going to change anything. No women is just going to have a termination at 38 weeks for the lolz

Hard no. The rarity of something isn’t an argument against this. We still need ethical guidance. Why not the point of viability?

Ethical guidance is fine. That's not the same as having a strict cut-off date. There's nothing ethical about that.

You say 'hard no', I say 'hard cases' - the circumstances of the tiny number of women and girls seeking late abortion for non-medical reasons are harrowing.

If this child's pregnancy had been known about earlier, but after 24 weeks, do you think she should have been denied an abortion?

www.thesun.co.uk/news/15404373/girl-11-gives-birth-britains-youngest-mum/

'Why not the point of viability?'

Because this has nothing to do with the rights of the woman, who is the person subject to the law.

Because viability is not a 'point', it's a percentage chance of survival which has nothing to say about the amount of intervention a baby in the lucky half of the percentage needs to survive and nothing to say about the likely quality of life or continuing care they may need.

Because technological advances are likely to push 'viability' progressively earlier and each time this happens, women's reproductive rights will be further curtailed.

Mjfdrjjbf · 25/09/2021 21:45

@pointythings

* Or alternatively we could trust women to make good decisions and behave ethically*

Oh go on, let’s do this Grin

pointythings · 25/09/2021 21:44

@UsedUpUsername

Levelling up of the age where termination is allowed - because let's be honest, it isn't going to change anything. No women is just going to have a termination at 38 weeks for the lolz

Hard no. The rarity of something isn’t an argument against this. We still need ethical guidance. Why not the point of viability?

The point of viability is a complex beast. What exactly do you mean - the point where a large majority or babies are born without severe and lifelong disabilities? Because that sits above 24 weeks. Or do you mean the point where they survive at all, which sits between 22 and 24 weeks, but that would force some families to live with children who have long term serious problems, with all the social and financial implications that come with that.

And beyond that of course, if you argue for a full cut-off at the point of viability you are still forcing women to give birth to babies who have long term health issues, you are still forcing women to give birth to babies who will not live.

Or alternatively we could trust women to make good decisions and behave ethically. As far as I can recall, there was one woman in the last few years who wanted a termination at 38 weeks for non-medical reasons. She was not permitted to have one because she was found to be seriously mentally ill. Let's allow the system to work. There's plenty of ethical guidance built in already.

Mjfdrjjbf · 25/09/2021 21:30

@LangClegsInSpace I think it looks good. All the normal caveats - there needs to be mandated training with time set aside to do it and funding for that. And it needs to be followed - PHE guidance around neutral language in screening has been in place for a while and often isn’t. Plus a lot of challenging biases of people (clinicians) who a) only really see people with DS when they need medical care and b) are likely to place a disproportionately high value on conventional measures of intellectual ability (I’ve definitely had to work my way out of this bucket!!)

You might be interested in this doc from DSUK which is a survey of 1400 parents of children with DS and their experiences of ante and postnatal care. Obviously not totally unbiased (but then it’s only DS organisations who are collecting this info) but a big sample size and reflective of what I’ve heard anecdotally.

downsyndromeuk.co.uk/flipbook.html

rhowton · 25/09/2021 21:27

We had a Harmony test at 10 weeks to rule out chromosome disabilities. My DH and I decided before we fell pregnant that we would terminate if they had DS or one of the three they test for. If we had found at out at 20 + weeks, we still would have terminated. Whilst a termination would be awful and upsetting, especially after 24w, I still wouldn't want to take the risk.

LangClegsInSpace · 25/09/2021 21:15

^The absolute focus on solely "down patau Edwards" is misleading
As tho once those three ruled out you got some kind of guarantee on your fetus/baby^

No, women are not stupid.

We take the best information we can find to evaluate our risks and options. We know the available information is never complete.

No woman thinks she is guaranteed a healthy baby. Aside from the properly evidenced risks, we are constantly bombarded with new things that could maybe possibly potentially harm our babies.

UsedUpUsername · 25/09/2021 21:14

Levelling up of the age where termination is allowed - because let's be honest, it isn't going to change anything. No women is just going to have a termination at 38 weeks for the lolz

Hard no. The rarity of something isn’t an argument against this. We still need ethical guidance. Why not the point of viability?

Embracelife · 25/09/2021 21:08

Agreed Langcleg.
Give all information
Do not pressure either way

LangClegsInSpace · 25/09/2021 20:58

This is the new consensus statement referred to in the judgment:

www.rcog.org.uk/en/guidelines-research-services/guidelines/consensus-statement-prenatal-screening/

It looks good to me, I'd be interested in what others think. The following paragraphs are highlighted in the statement:

Some parents whose babies have been identified as having a higher chance of Down’s syndrome, Edwards’ syndrome or Patau’s syndrome, and who have decided to continue with the pregnancy, have reported being asked repeatedly if they want further diagnostic tests or an abortion.

They report having their decisions challenged and being pressured into changing their minds.

This should not happen.

Parents should have the scope to change their minds, but not be pressured into doing so – their decisions should be accepted and respected at all times.

I have read things which suggest this has been a genuine problem and I agree, this should never happen. No woman should be pressured, either to end or to continue a pregnancy.

This appears to have been the basis of the second claimant's argument in this case. She is the mother of a young child with DS (the third claimant) who argued that this pressure violated her Article 8 rights to private and family life. She's right about that but it's not clear what remedy she was seeking through this case. It has nothing to do with the remedies sought - to reduce the time limit to 24 weeks in all cases.

I remember when the 'don't screen us out' campaign was running. They denied being against NIPT as such, they said they just wanted unbiased information and better support to be provided to women before it was rolled out. On the face of it, this consensus statement, published well within the timeframe of the initial NHS roll-out, is exactly what they were campaigning for, or at least the solid start of it.

I can't find anything on their website that welcomes this statement or even makes any comment on it, it's just on to the next thing - reducing time limits.

Embracelife · 25/09/2021 20:52

[quote Mjfdrjjbf]**@Embracelife* I know it’s a bit of a technicality but there’s screening* for DS early in pregnancy, not diagnostic testing (NIPT is also screening not diagnostic). Around 12% of babies born with DS had low chance screening results. And another 40-50%’s mothers opted out of screening either at the start of didn’t go forward with a diagnostic test having had a high chance result (over 1 in 150).

It’s important because there’s a risk DS is framed as a lifestyle choice, which I would then be worried is used an excuse to not fund services properly.[/quote]
Good point.
The nipt pathway mentioned
Is only after high chance..so some could slip through.

"
All women in these areas who have a combined or quadruple screening test taken on or after 1 July 2021 and receive a higher chance result now have a choice of:

no further testingNIPT screeningprenatal diagnosis (PND)

But again
There are many other deletions and rare conditions which won't get detected prdnatalky
Or severe autism
Or c p from brain injury at birth

The absolute focus on solely "down patau Edwards" is misleading
As tho once those three ruled out you got some kind of guarantee on your fetus/baby

Sirzy · 25/09/2021 20:18

Even with having the testing though there too often seems to be a stigma around it and an idea people shouldn’t want to know

Pongo101 · 25/09/2021 19:55

Great news that these tests are now being covered!

Lockdownbear · 25/09/2021 19:41

I don't know about Harmony but I definitely had bloods to check for various things including spina bifida.

It has crossed my mind to about women who's pregnancy could be putting their own life at risk too.
Beyond 24 weeks I imagine in most cases the baby would be delivered and given its best chances in an incubator.

Which is possible why 24 weeks is given as the last date for a healthy baby to be terminated.

Treaclepie19 · 25/09/2021 19:38

That's brilliant!

Treaclepie19 · 25/09/2021 19:29

I had to pay for my NIPT in 2018. I hope it is freely available now. Even though there was a problem identified and we had it through the NHS we still had to pay. Not cheap either.