Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Today's ruling re Down's Syndrome

693 replies

Shirazboobaloo · 23/09/2021 21:09

Sorry to hijack AIBU for this but can someone explain this ruling to me please?

What I can't understand (from press reports) is how this has "come to this".

Who is Heidi Crowther and who are those supporting her?

I am genuinely confused but don't know where to ask

OP posts:
olivehater · 23/09/2021 21:55

It was the right decision. You can terminate for any abnormality after 24 weeks. You can’t start picking and choosing. It is wrong to force a woman to give birth to a Down syndrome child if they don’t want to. Are we really going to force this life on a mother? It’s easy to say well they can give them up for adoption. How many people can do that once they have given birth. It would have set an extremely dangerous precedent and sent a terrible message to women.

SnackSizeRaisin · 23/09/2021 21:55

The law as it stands is correct in my opinion. Most people do find out about the ds sooner. It's a minority that need to make the decision later for whatever reason. It isn't done lightly. In this case the rights of the mother trump those of the unborn child. And most people with ds are not high functioning, and are likely to need a lot of care, have a shortened life, have other medical problems alongside. If all ds people were like heidi then obviously it would be different

tiggerwhocamefortea · 23/09/2021 21:55

I'm pro choice but with modern medicine and testing now there isnt/ shouldn't be a need to wait until 9 months to terminate. DS risk is tested at the 12 week scan and most results even if a CVS or amnio is required is then done by 16-20 weeks - there should be little reason to have the procedure done any later than the standard 24 week abortion limit?

Suzy39 · 23/09/2021 21:55

Just to add, it was my 20w abnomoly scan that flagged congenital defects, up until then all screening and scans were perfect. Sadly, our little boy's brain had not developed due to a placental interuption during development and was not compatible with life. He had carried on growing and was perfect in every other way.

AlexaShutUp · 23/09/2021 21:54

I am struggling to work out what to think on this one. I am pro choice and support a woman's right to make decisions about her own body. At the same time, I can see the argument that babies with DS do not have any less right to live than any other babies.

MultiStorey · 23/09/2021 21:54

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

MyPatronusIsACat · 23/09/2021 21:52

I am glad they ruled against her. She had no right telling other people what to do with their unborn child.

Suzy39 · 23/09/2021 21:52

I agree with some of the posts above that most of the messages being reported imply that women are citing 'Downs Syndrome' as a reason for termination. This condition has a wide range of mental and physical impact including vital organs which may be life limiting.

I had a TFMR at 24 weeks (and due to the nature of the prognosis, could have waited longer for further tests ) however the only difference between 24 and 34 weeks is that we would have needed an inquest. It is medical diagnosis and prognosis that are taken into account, not condition per se, in the legality of administering a termination or compassionate induction and gaining the support of two medical professionals.

It pisses me off that anti-abortionists are implying that things like gender and 'minor' disabilities will be acceptable up to birth - and realistically, who would voluntarily choose a termination (induction, full labour, post mortem, funeral, inquest attendance) at this stage of pregancy over information that can be obtained at 9 to 12 weeks.

The media portrayal is horrendous.

FuckingFlumps · 23/09/2021 21:51

Anyone who says they are pro choice and follows it with the word but is not pro choice!

It isn't anyone else's choice apart from the women who is pregnant. It is her decision and hers alone. The fact anyone else thinks they can weigh in on the argument and dictate that a women should give birth to a child is immoral and inhumane. Angry

PeterPomegranate · 23/09/2021 21:51

@owlbethere

She’s a woman with DS who lives independently and sees the law where you can terminate a pregnancy up until birth for a severe disability as a human rights violation against disabled people.

I see her point, and I understand that from her POV as a high functioning person with DS it’s awful to think someone like her can be terminated due to their disability…however I am pro-choice and that means being pro-choice even when it’s not what I would choose to do.

This is my position too.
Kittii · 23/09/2021 21:51

What is the justification for treating DS differently from other disabilities? If you can't terminate after 24 weeks for other disabilities why can you do so for DS? It suggests that DS is somehow "worse" than other disabilities. My friend has a daughter with DS and honestly she has the best quality of life. She is constantly happy and thinks the world revolves around her. As her Mum said, who wouldn't want to feel like that every day of their lives?

shouldistop · 23/09/2021 21:50

@Clymene that's what I thought. So who are these disabled viable babies that this is all about then?

Henrysmycat · 23/09/2021 21:49

DSydrome is a spectrum and you might not know how disable it’d be until later on. Not everyone can raise or want a severely disable child. Good or bad, people are people.
Heidi Crowther is a hardcore Christian and she’s more inclined the prolife way.
I refuse to believe, after experiencing something relevant, that the NHS hasn’t really thought about it with their extensive ethics knowledge.

I think NHS knows what they are doing and they are refusing to bend over to the erosion of woman's rights. Next thing, we’d be looking for back street abortions like we are freaking Texas.

Clymene · 23/09/2021 21:49

@shouldistop

I wonder how many women actually terminate after 24 weeks due to DS?
The court heard that none have in the last 10 years
BiteyCatII · 23/09/2021 21:49

I am glad the ruling was against her for the reasons theunamedcat gives. I think to have found in Heidi‘s favour would indeed violate human rights - the rights of pregnant women not to continue a pregnancy if their baby is found to have severe disabilities. No woman is going to make that decision lightly and for those that end up having a very late abortion it must be unimaginably difficult.

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 23/09/2021 21:49

I doubt there are many women out there who terminate after 24 weeks. Also those that do have probably found out as the pg has progressed that there are far more problems with the baby's health/development then they first thought.

Covidworries · 23/09/2021 21:48

@Ginger1982

Most disabilities dont become apparent until after birth. And parents have to cope.

A parent not wanting a DS child would still have choice. The choice to screen at 12 week scan, the choice to abort before 24 weeks.

A mum who suddenly decided they didnt want their child at 24 weeks and a day can not abort a child in most circumstances. But a mum expecting a DS child could decide to abort at 38 weeks.

Disclaimer this is different to parents who find out at 35 weeks that their child is missing a vital organ and wont survive outside the womb or will have servere health issues that can not be treated.

Embracelife · 23/09/2021 21:48

@Shirazboobaloo

Thanks all - how does this relate to screening? I had assumed most people who knew that DS likely would be aware sooner?
Not always. P s there are many other conditions which lead to learning disability some with more severe outcomes as a norm There is focus on down syndrome because it is one of the easiest to be screened for tho now screening cN look for others Downs patau Edwards trisomies haVe always been lumped together tho D,S has much more varied outcome. Very rare for Palau or Edwards to survive beyond a year or two; profound disability

down syndrome outcome is much more varied and people can live to 60s and become actor etc (or not) with majority able to be walking talking reading etc

Cuddlyrottweiler · 23/09/2021 21:48

People with DS can be killed up until the moment of birth. Which is sick af whether you're pro life or not. People with disabilities are quite often against screening. Deaf people, autistic people have been vocal about not being screened for. It's saying that the world be better off without them, that they deserve to die because of who they are. Who would be happy about that?

tootiredtospeak · 23/09/2021 21:46

I am not sure what is right here though morally. So you refuse to allow a woman the right to terminate her pregnancy therefore her options are to give the baby up to SS for adoption. I dont know the statistics on adopting children with disabilities but raising a child with a disability is incredibly hard. So adding in adoption for both the adopting parents and the child themselves is fraught with difficulties. Not least the child knowing that their mother didnt want them due to the disability.

Mum2jenny · 23/09/2021 21:46

Ultimately anyone can walk away from a hospital after giving birth and the hospital has to deal with the baby.
I couldn’t but many do this.

Sirzy · 23/09/2021 21:46

The numbers who terminate after 24 weeks is very low. For such a decision to be made it’s going to involve a lot of discussion and counselling from those who are aware of the situation that family face.

abcdeg · 23/09/2021 21:46

@cloudacious

People saying Heidi has been manipulated are incredibly disablist and rude. She's articulate and perfectly capable of taking this position.

Personally, I don't think DS should be a special case re abortion and is not a reason to terminate a viable baby. It isn't that kind of disability. We expect every other woman to go through with a viable pregnancy after viability because choice is not the only ethical consideration. No one needs to bring up a baby if they don't want to but no, it is wrong to kill a child who is recognisably a baby and could lead a fulfilling life (as Heidi demonstrates, clearly inconveniently for some).

Exactly- anyone who disagrees must be coerced. She can't think for herself, obviously, despite headlining the whole thing.

She's obviously going to be passionate and invested in the topic if she has DS herself. The fact she doesn't agree with some of you, PPs, doesn't mean she's being manipulated

Horst · 23/09/2021 21:45

Other things that crop up not just ds are reasons for aborting after 24weeks.

I’d argue that actually 24weeks is too early for viability. Just because we can make 24weekers survive many then actually end up with health issues caused by being born so early if they do actually survive. This is that whole life at any cost. Rather than quality of life thing again.

UndertheCedartree · 23/09/2021 21:45

I think @Covidworries explains it well. I have a friend with a DS child and she has said how 'doom and gloom' all the information she was given about DS was and how they were spoken to about it. And she's found it to be the complete opposite.