Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Today's ruling re Down's Syndrome

693 replies

Shirazboobaloo · 23/09/2021 21:09

Sorry to hijack AIBU for this but can someone explain this ruling to me please?

What I can't understand (from press reports) is how this has "come to this".

Who is Heidi Crowther and who are those supporting her?

I am genuinely confused but don't know where to ask

OP posts:
enjoyingscience · 23/09/2021 22:17

It is absolutely the right decision.

As early as possible, as late as necessary. Watch out for attacks on early screening too - that was a theme a few years ago.

Carboncheque · 23/09/2021 22:16

’It terrifies me that so many people think women should be allowed / encouraged to terminate pregnancy for any reason’

It terrifies me that so many people think women should be forced to give birth.

BiteyCatII · 23/09/2021 22:16

Babdoc. My teacher friend would totally agree with you as some of her pupils with DS need to be fed via PEGs, a fair few need hearing aids and communicate by signing, some are visually impaired. Some have both hearing and sight impairments . A few have seizures and quite a few have ADHD and severe behavioural issues (biting, hitting, throwing things, running off - without the cognitive ability to learn why it’s not ok to do these things and to respond to attempts to modify these behaviours). Their lives can be very hard indeed.

Suzy39 · 23/09/2021 22:16

A feticide treatment is delivered (hence the need for an inquest where the mother abd two medical professionals are questioned by a judge to ensure there is no criminal activity similarly to that of switching off a life support)

DeepaBeesKit · 23/09/2021 22:16

Ground E is the abortion criteria which covers fetal abnormality. There were 229 abortions under this grounds is 2020 post 24 weeks.

Many of those will be for abnormalities not viable with life.

Lalliella · 23/09/2021 22:16

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

ComtesseDeSpair · 23/09/2021 22:15

It is absolutely shocking that a viable baby can be aborted at all!

But look at orphanages in countries where abortion is restricted - full of unwanted disabled children. Life for many unwanted disabled children isn’t the type Heidi has, and many would argue it would have been merciful for them to have not been born in the first place.

Treaclepie19 · 23/09/2021 22:14

*stated

Iusedtoliveinsanfrancisco · 23/09/2021 22:14

Same rules for all.

Treaclepie19 · 23/09/2021 22:14

Some of you actually have no clue, do you.
I have friends who have only recently confided in me that they didn't realise I'd have to make the decision to end my pregnancy. That they didn't realise I'd have to have my baby's heart stopped with an injection. That I'd have to give birth.
If you honestly think any of that is something people do lightly...
As I've stayed, it wasn't downs syndrome but I really can't believe how quickly some people jump to mothers being monsters for making these decisions.

Carboncheque · 23/09/2021 22:13

’DS isn't singled out within the law, as the campaign would have you believe. It refers to disabilities likely to cause severe physical or mental impairment. Some consider Downs Syndrome to be a severe impairment.’

This ^

FuckingFlumps · 23/09/2021 22:13

[quote Covidworries]@FuckingFlumps but currently not every woman has the right to abort up to birth? So why is that?
So i think what you are saying is the law needs ti change so that every pregnancy can be terminated up to birth ?[/quote]
Yes I would support that change in law because it would mean that many women who find out very late just before the cut off would get more time to make an informed choice rather than a rushed choice.

I know many would say that would mean many healthy babies would be aborted at near term but truthfully we all know that is utter nonsense. Its just not a valid argument.

whynotwhatknot · 23/09/2021 22:13

So the mother has to give birth then what-put the baby up for adoption who are going to adopt a DS child-very few

thats the cruel thing that would come out of it

newusername2009 · 23/09/2021 22:12

I am not sure Heidi feeling her life is worthwhile indicates she has been manipulated. Abortion law tells her that her life and the lives of other people with DS are not important at all compared to all others - no manipulation needed to provoke some feeling.

It is absolutely shocking that a viable baby can be aborted at all!

notanothertakeaway · 23/09/2021 22:12

It terrifies me that so many people think women should be allowed / encouraged to terminate pregnancy for any reason

We talk so much about encouraging diversity, and yet the prospect of raising a child with downs syndrome or similar is so terrible? I wish we could offer better support and respite to those families

HeartsAndClubs · 23/09/2021 22:10

Thing is it’s a lot easier to think about this at the 24 weeks stage because you’re only halfway through the pregnancy, but given that a pregnancy where disability is detected can be terminated until birth how do people reconcile that?

Let’s look at it from a different perspective?

You’re pregnant with a baby who has been diagnosed with DS at around the 20 week mark. You’re not sure about termination, so you continue with the pregnancy but you do some research, and eventually decide at 38 weeks that you’re going to terminate the pregnancy, so you make the appointment. However, the night before you are due to go in you go into spontaneous labour and the baby is born at home. Given you were going to terminate this pregnancy, should it be ok to kill the baby because it was born early and before the appointment for the termination could be completed?

While terminations at 38 weeks are vanishingly rare and people will use that as a reason to dismiss the argument, the fact is, they’re legal, so anyone could decide to terminate what is a completely viable pregnancy. Not just one where assistance would be needed at birth, but a pregnancy where the baby would be born, potentially be able to latch on, bf, go home in the next couple of days.

Do people really think that is ok purely because there is a disability involved? Something as simple as say, a club foot?

ComtesseDeSpair · 23/09/2021 22:10

@AlexaShutUp

They shouldn't. But rolling back abortion rights is not how to address it. What needs to happen is that abortion should be available until the last minute for all women, for any reason.

@Clymene, I get where you're coming from, but I would also struggle with the idea of making abortion available to all women until the pregnancy is full term. I am absolutely pro choice but I couldn't support that. For me, I think it comes down to the point at which the foetus has a reasonable chance of surviving independently of the mother... they then become a viable person and have rights of their own.

But the reality is, even if abortion to term were legalised, it would be phenomenally rare. Women simply don’t get to 25+ weeks of pregnancy and decide they want to terminate healthy pregnancies, whatever certain factions want to claim about women who have abortions willy nilly because they’ve decided they want to go on holiday or whatever. If they do get to that stage, they usually have significant mental health issues or very specific personal circumstances, and late term abortion already exists for them.
AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 23/09/2021 22:10

How do they terminate full term pregnancies?

Covidworries · 23/09/2021 22:10

@FuckingFlumps but currently not every woman has the right to abort up to birth? So why is that?
So i think what you are saying is the law needs ti change so that every pregnancy can be terminated up to birth ?

HotPenguin · 23/09/2021 22:10

@sar302 makes a good point - perhaps the reason for late stage abortions of babies with DS is because they are found to have particular severe defects later in pregnancy. But in that case I would argue the abortion isn't due to DS, it's due to e.g. a serious heart defect.

Just10moreminutesplease · 23/09/2021 22:10

Surely the issue is equality? Either abortion should be allowed at any stage regardless of reason, or it should be 24 weeks for all babies that are viable?

Having a different rule when ds means that foetuses with ds are afforded less rights than those without.

herculesoffline · 23/09/2021 22:09

@Kittii

What is the justification for treating DS differently from other disabilities? If you can't terminate after 24 weeks for other disabilities why can you do so for DS? It suggests that DS is somehow "worse" than other disabilities. My friend has a daughter with DS and honestly she has the best quality of life. She is constantly happy and thinks the world revolves around her. As her Mum said, who wouldn't want to feel like that every day of their lives?
DS isn't singled out within the law, as the campaign would have you believe. It refers to disabilities likely to cause severe physical or mental impairment. Some consider Downs Syndrome to be a severe impairment.
reprehensibleme · 23/09/2021 22:09

Kitii, I have a friend who's son has DS. He is doubly incontinent, non verbal, has severe epilepsy and many other health issues. He is now in his early thirties.

My friend has no relationship with her daughter (older child) because all her time and effort was spent caring for her son to the detriment of her relationship with her daughter. Her husband left when their son was four because he couldn't cope.

Dfriend gets next to no respite. She's permanently exhausted, sad, worries about what will happen to her DS if she dies or is incapable of looking after him. It's no life.

If she had her time again she wouldn't hesitate to abort. And I wouldn't blame her for one second. The court made the right decision.

Whatwentwronghere · 23/09/2021 22:09

There are no winners at all here, the poor babies, the poor women, and even the poor medical staff having to do that.

I've always said I'm pro choice but this case has made me question myself.

SnackSizeRaisin · 23/09/2021 22:07

But the way things have evolved is that because abortion is available having a disabled child is seen as a “choice”, and therefore doesn’t need any government/ societal support.

Well that's rubbish - plenty of disabilities are not detectable before birth. We still don't support disabled people enough. The two things are unrelated. In fact it tends to be hard-line pro lifers who also don't agree with a generous welfare state to support all these babies.

In addition, looking after a disabled child can be a life sentence for parents regardless of the amount of support. And many of these people are effectively abandoned once their parents die and can no longer care for them

Swipe left for the next trending thread