Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Today's ruling re Down's Syndrome

693 replies

Shirazboobaloo · 23/09/2021 21:09

Sorry to hijack AIBU for this but can someone explain this ruling to me please?

What I can't understand (from press reports) is how this has "come to this".

Who is Heidi Crowther and who are those supporting her?

I am genuinely confused but don't know where to ask

OP posts:
womaninatightspot · 23/09/2021 22:38

Within that 229 the statistics do say that 55% are due to congenital defects. 27% due to chromosonal defects. DS can cause congenital defects so there may well be some crossover but the numbers are really low.

It must be an awful decision to make and I honestly believe it should be between a woman and her doctors.

olivehater · 23/09/2021 22:37

That is a terrible example Covid worries. For goodness sake. DS is life limiting whether they heart condition or not.

Slobbering · 23/09/2021 22:36

As early as possible, for any reason! This isn't about DS, this is about limiting women's body autonomy. Pro choice is just that, personal choice.

FuckingFlumps · 23/09/2021 22:36

@ShushShushShush

There are so, so many people on this thread with opinions about something they know absolutely nothing about, and they should be grateful they know nothing about the experience of TFMR and the horrific distressing, traumatic experience that it is.

I am so sorry to all of the other TFMR mums on this thread and others like it, where the hugely painful loss of our beautiful, precious babies, has been reduced to us being "killers" and "murderers". Where we are judged by those who have no idea at all if the hell we have been through.

Agreed.

I'm sos sorry people don't seem to have even an ounce of compassion when discussing such an emotive topic. It's somewhat ironic that they claim it be so compassionate towards the unknown feutus but show absolutely no regard for the poor women having to make those difficult choices.

I'm so sorry for everyone who has endured such heartbreak and then had that decision steam rolled over by the ignorate idiots claiming to be so 'pro choice'. Flowers

GingerScallop · 23/09/2021 22:35

@ComtesseDeSpair

It is absolutely shocking that a viable baby can be aborted at all!

But look at orphanages in countries where abortion is restricted - full of unwanted disabled children. Life for many unwanted disabled children isn’t the type Heidi has, and many would argue it would have been merciful for them to have not been born in the first place.

but this is not true for all countries. my country hardly had orphanages until the 1990s when being an orphan was monetised by development aid.
pointythings · 23/09/2021 22:34

No woman should be forced to have a child against her will - whether with or without disabilities. If a woman feels she cannot cope with raising a child with Downs or any other disability, she should not be forced to do so. The law needs to stay as it is, but I would support levelling up rather than restricting down, especially since the evidence clearly shows that late term abortions are extremely rare and are for serious medical issues. Heidi and her family are hardline Christians and faith should not intersect with the law.

Going on about how there is screening is all very well, but the screening and diagnostics system is not perfect. Some women will fall outside the current 24 week timeline before they find out their baby has a serious medical issue. Those women should also have the choice to terminate or not. A friend of mine was diagnosed at 26 weeks - her baby was very much wanted, but had a condition incompatible with life. Had this ruling gone the other way, cases like hers would have been next. This case was always about chipping away at abortion rights.

Lastly, stop idealising people with Downs syndrome. While some live happy, fulfilled and productive lives, many do not. And the prevalence of dementia in people with Downs is horribly high - far, far higher than in the general population. That is aside from all the other possible health issues that come with the condition.

The law is not perfect, but the alternatives are all far worse. I sincerely hope Heidi loses her appeal too.

ShushShushShush · 23/09/2021 22:33

There are so, so many people on this thread with opinions about something they know absolutely nothing about, and they should be grateful they know nothing about the experience of TFMR and the horrific distressing, traumatic experience that it is.

I am so sorry to all of the other TFMR mums on this thread and others like it, where the hugely painful loss of our beautiful, precious babies, has been reduced to us being "killers" and "murderers". Where we are judged by those who have no idea at all if the hell we have been through.

Covidworries · 23/09/2021 22:29

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

FudgeFlake · 23/09/2021 22:28

@Kittii

What is the justification for treating DS differently from other disabilities? If you can't terminate after 24 weeks for other disabilities why can you do so for DS? It suggests that DS is somehow "worse" than other disabilities. My friend has a daughter with DS and honestly she has the best quality of life. She is constantly happy and thinks the world revolves around her. As her Mum said, who wouldn't want to feel like that every day of their lives?
And what is the plan for your friend's daughter with DS when your friend passes away or becomes unable to help her continue to have 'the best quality of life' and believe that 'the world revolves around her'?

Anna Furedi on Jeremy Vine earlier put the case for all abortion to be on an equal time limit no matter what the trigger very well.

RunningFromInsanity · 23/09/2021 22:27

Heidi is naive that all DS babies will be as high functioning as her.
Many won’t, as a PP has described above.

As soon as possible, as late as necessity.

(PS, you can’t be pro choice if you have a ‘but’ after)

SnackSizeRaisin · 23/09/2021 22:26

Do people really think that is ok purely because there is a disability involved? Something as simple as say, a club foot?

Club foot can require multiple painful surgeries and even bilateral amputation. Would you choose that for your child? Perhaps you would but another parent may not. It is a brave decision to spare a child that suffering as well. It's perhaps harder in some ways than letting things run their course

owlbethere · 23/09/2021 22:26

@Covidworries

Im pro choice too BUT a pregnancy can not be terminated after 24 weeks in most cases. After 24 weeks if the fetus isnt viable is different BUT DS shouldnt be a reason to terminate. Currently a DS baby can be terminated up to term and that isnt right as DS doesnt mean the child isnt viable or would be unable to servive outside of the womb. Plus DS isnt the only thing a child can be born with that causes learning difficulties but most learning disabilities cant be checked in the womb so the ruling has been a kick in the face for the DS community by stating their life isnt as important as a non DS life regardless of any oyher disabilities or not.
It CAN mean that it is incompatible with life or would die very soon after birth. DS has a wide array of severity. I had a friend who’s baby with DS lived just 5 mins. I have another friend who’s child with Patau syndrome (which all the literature says is always fatal) is 8 and thriving. Chromosomal conditions are wildly unpredictable, and if a person feels they can’t cope that is their right.

It’s also true that only a tiny number of terminations take place after 24 weeks.

somethingwittynotshitty · 23/09/2021 22:26

@Covidworries

Its not manipulation. In most cases DS is screened initially at 12 week scan and people are offered extesive screening if fetus classed as probably DS. All this is done in almost all cases well before the general abortion cut off of 24 weeks.

The law already protects life limiting health problems that can be terminated after 24 weeks if needed.

What they are asking is that abortion after 24 weeks for DS (unless other life limiting health problems) is stopped in line with non DS pregnancies. Drawfism, missing limbs arent reasons that allow abortion after 24 weeks so why DS?

As your last sentence simply isn't true, I'm going to assume that everything you write is unreliable and I would encourage others to ignore you too
myheartskippedabeat · 23/09/2021 22:26

It's an individual decision to terminate a pregnancy whether the baby has downs or doesn't have downs

Everyone needs to calm down over This

People make choices for all sorts of reasons and should never be judged

Treaclepie19 · 23/09/2021 22:25

Thank you BiteyCatII

BiteyCatII · 23/09/2021 22:23

Treaclepie19. I’m so sorry. I’d not judge any woman for making the decision to end their pregnancy. Those who think it’s a decision taken lightly are deluded. It’s an unimaginably heart wrenching thing to have to go through 💐

DeepaBeesKit · 23/09/2021 22:23

Bear in mind within the 229 abortions under ground E in 2020 many will be foetuses where it is clear they will not survive post partum.

A family member was in this position.a scan identified serious abnormalities (not DS) incompatible with life. She had to choose between carrying to term and her baby dying almost immediately post partum, or terminating. Medical professionals recommended termination as it would be lesson the health impact on her own body, given the baby could not possibly survive.

ISpyCobraKai · 23/09/2021 22:22

As early as possible, as late as necessary, for any woman, for any reason.

AlexaShutUp · 23/09/2021 22:20

@Just10moreminutesplease

Surely the issue is equality? Either abortion should be allowed at any stage regardless of reason, or it should be 24 weeks for all babies that are viable?

Having a different rule when ds means that foetuses with ds are afforded less rights than those without.

It's so difficult, isn't it? I totally agree with you about the need for equality and I'm very uneasy about treating disabled babies less favourably, but I also feel that it's wrong to force women to go ahead with a pregnancy if they feel ill equipped to care for a child with complex medical needs.

Then again, it also feels wrong to force a woman to go ahead with any pregnancy if they feel ill equipped to care for any child. But on the other hand, I cannot support aborting a child at a stage when their life is independently viable.

Making women give birth and putting the child up for adoption doesn't seem like the right answer either - it's very easy to say but I don't think many women would find it at all easy to live with, knowing that your child is out there somewhere. And there aren't enough adoptive families available anyway.

I honestly can't decide what's right and I'm glad that the decision doesn't rest with me.

DeepaBeesKit · 23/09/2021 22:19

DS isn't singled out within the law, as the campaign would have you believe. It refers to disabilities likely to cause severe physical or mental impairment. Some consider Downs Syndrome to be a severe impairment.’

This.down syndrome can vary in severity. Many of the very capable DS spokespeople, actors etc we see coping well with it may have milder or mosaic instances. Some are incredibly severely impacted. Many DS pregnancies miscarry naturally for this reason.

I don't think anyone takes the decision to abort lightly, especially not after 24 weeks.

SnackSizeRaisin · 23/09/2021 22:19

Having a different rule when ds means that foetuses with ds are afforded less rights than those without.

That is true, but the rights of the mother also need to be considered. Should a woman be forced to give birth to a child she doesn't want?
Also it's not as simple as you suggest. A woman with a healthy pregnancy has from about 5 weeks to 24 weeks to make the decision. A woman with a severely disabled baby probably doesn't find out until around 18-20 weeks at the earliest. They may then need further testing, counselling. They may not find out until much later. So to apply the same cut off to both is impractical.

Holly60 · 23/09/2021 22:18

@Clymene

Heidi has been manipulated by people who want to stop women from getting abortions.
Well that’s insulting. Are you not crediting Heidi with being able to hold and articulate her own views?
AutumnColours9 · 23/09/2021 22:18

A termination after a certain stage (21 weeks?) would involve injection of the fetal heart to ensure the baby is not born alive due to the legal and ethical implications if it was born alive.

I think very few women abort after 24 weeks and none 'at full term in the birth canal'. Almost all would be for very severe abnormalities.

I think the way to reduce abortion for DS would be to improve society and support. But some people don't just feel they cannot cope but they feel it is questionable to bring a baby into the world knowing it will have extra challenges potentially severe.

I once read a case where a woman had a baby with downs already then found out her next child also had downs. She terminated. That doesn't mean she doesn't love her child but she didn't feel she could cope with another child with special needs and thought it unfair on her existing child.

Another story that stays with me is the one where two babies were born one night. One was healthy boy and one was child with downs. The boy grew up to be Hitler and the other child was a joy to the local community.

These questions are so hard that it is best to let people decide for themselves.

Suzy39 · 23/09/2021 22:17

@Lalliella a fetcide is done injecting the heart in utreo with analgesia

hatgirl · 23/09/2021 22:17

It was the right decision but that's not to say that underneath that there aren't huge issues with the choices facing families with children with disabilities and I agree with the discrimination aspect but I don't feel that can our weight the right of a woman to have control over her own body.

What actually needs to happen is for parents to have the reassurance that if they do have a child with disabilities that they will be well supported by the state, with proper support, respite, education, healthcare etc for their disabled child.

The out of work stats for mothers of children with disabilities are horrific. As are divorce rates for parents with children with disabilities.

That's what needs to change, not the law on terminations.

Swipe left for the next trending thread