Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Today's ruling re Down's Syndrome

693 replies

Shirazboobaloo · 23/09/2021 21:09

Sorry to hijack AIBU for this but can someone explain this ruling to me please?

What I can't understand (from press reports) is how this has "come to this".

Who is Heidi Crowther and who are those supporting her?

I am genuinely confused but don't know where to ask

OP posts:
ThumbWitchesAbroad · 24/09/2021 02:47

I know this is an incredibly fraught and emotional subject but I think Heidi has a point.
DS can be a life limiting illness and can have comorbidities, the most common of which is the hole in the heart which will most likely need surgery. But with proper treatment and care, people with DS can live a relatively long life (I don't believe they usually get past about 60, with rare exceptions).

I don't think that people should be allowed to terminate a baby with DS after the standard 24w. There are enough tests available prior to that to determine whether or not the baby has DS, so the decision can and should be made well before term. But I have never been in that position, so I can't know what I'd do or feel. I have a friend who has been in that position, who chose to go ahead, and her child is utterly delightful.
I understand that some people can't handle the idea of a child with disabilities - but then their responsibility to themselves is to test early as needed.

goawaystormy · 24/09/2021 02:45

A baby (unborn or otherwise) or foetus or whatever you want to call it, is not part of “a woman’s body”, it’s an individual life and just because it’s dependent on a woman to live until it’s born does not make it “her body”

It doesn't matter if it's not actually her body. It's dependent on her body, and therefore, by her own bodily autonomy, she has the right to stop anyone or anything (foetus/baby or otherwise) using her body. It's not her fault something relies on her, is essentially leeching off her. Why do her rights to bodily autonomy suddenly not matter? FGS we can't even take the organs from dead people to save others lives without the permission of the DEAD person because they have a right to bodily autonomy. Why are the rights of dead people more sacred than the rights of women?

As early as possible as late as necessary.

No one has the right to 'leech' off another human for survival, no matter how much or little it would affect the person being leeched off. It's why we don't have forced blood or bone marrow or kidney donations, no matter how many lives it would save. Bodily autonomy is sacred and cases like this, all the notions of 'I'm pro-choice but' chop away at it.

No one has the right to any other persons body. That includes leukaemia sufferers who just need the right bone marrow transplant, kidney patients who only need one kidney, and don't you most people have 2 and could survive fine with just one, liver patients - they only need half and the donors liver will fully regenerate in afew months, and foetuses who depend on another's body to sustain them.

GreenUp · 24/09/2021 02:45

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Alonelonelylonersbadidea · 24/09/2021 02:29

I think it is a red herring or Trojan horse in many ways.
In my opinion, it's irrelevant what issues a foetus has or doesn't have. I don't give a damn. I don't care if screening can effectively remove something - a type of people, from the world. It's a woman's choice. And should be up until birth for any reason imo. It's not my right to force her to carry a baby and look after it or suffer putting it into a care system that is already buckling under.
This decision was a just one.

RinkyStinky1 · 24/09/2021 01:54

Good decision. Considering that post 24 week abortions for ALL medical reasons (not just DS) are less than 1% of abortions carried out, the number after 24 weeks for DS will be incredibly small. With regards specifically to DS, knowing how high or low functioning a child with DS will be can't be known before they're born. There are a myriad of possible issues;

Heart defects
Gastrointestinal defects.
Immune disorders.
Sleep apnea.
Obesity.
Spinal problems.
Leukemia.
Dementia.
Increased risk of developing Alzheimer's disease.
Associated other health conditions - endocrine problems, dental problems, seizures, ear infections, and hearing and vision problems.

And that's all before you consider how lacking the country is for good, quality, accessible services for the Disabled in general, or indeed whether an already existing family unit can take on the additional needs. No woman should be made to feel guilty or denied access to abortion when considering all the above. Not one.

ArcheryAnnie · 24/09/2021 01:54

If Heidi is against abortion, then she doesn't have to have one. It's not her place - or anyone else's place - to say that other women should be forced to carry on with pregnancies they don't wish to.

Very, very few women will ever take the opportunity to terminate very late. When they do, they should be offered swift support and care, not be forced to act as vessels and given no control over their own bodies.

cloudacious · 24/09/2021 01:54

Nobody carries a baby to 24 weeks without loving it and dreaming of its future.

That's simply not true and shows a very limited understanding of why women may seek late terminations.

They have all my sympathy but I don't believe they are all justified. There does come a point when society should also consider the ethics of ending the life of an unborn child.

Most posters here seem to be comfortable with terminations for any reason up to birth. That is a different conversation to having different ethical guidelines for terminations relating to dusability. You can't discuss both things together without constant misunderstandings.

Aorh · 24/09/2021 01:53

The right decision was made.

I am so very glad this lady has a voice. I am not glad about the way this was portrayed in the media. It was implied that the current law had women deciding that they wanted to “get rid of” their otherwise healthy baby at 39 weeks. The statistics and experiences of women whose babies have significant disabilities are very different.

I had a TFMR at 22 weeks after our 20 week scan (and follow ups) showed us our son wasn’t going to make it. I could easily have been a post 24 week termination.

The current law covers far worse conditions than DS, although the variety of ways that can impact people is significant, everything from causing miscarriage/stillbirth, through to a healthy adult.

The law covers women who find out there is a major problem after their 20 week scan. It covers those who know there is a problem but have been monitoring and hoping for a miracle that didn’t come. It covers those who have struggled with their decision to terminate, but know it is best for them, their baby, their family.

No woman chooses a late term abortion for any other reason.

In 2020, there were 236 post 24 week abortions. I can’t see that data, but assume the majority of those are closer to 24 than 40 weeks. Of those, some Bavaria, I’m sure, has DS. Others, like my son, would have had far worse conditions.

I also believe this change would be counter intuitive. I think rushing women into a decision after a DS diagnosis is more likely to result in them terminating than not. Those women who decide to monitor their baby’s health would no longer have that option.

This law is used in exceptional circumstances, which is why the definitions need to be broad. Most people are fortunate enough to never find themselves in one of those exceptional situations.

My days of having Bavaria are behind me, but I hope the law remains to protect women like me in the future. I had the right to decide that I didn’t want to have a later term still birth. I had to right to choose to spare my son a short life of suffering. I am so grateful I had that right and that this is not being taken away from women like me.

N0PE · 24/09/2021 01:44

I have a disability that women often choose to have an abortion for. It's one with various degrees of disability so you could end up having a child that needs 24/7 care their whole life.
I am 100% behind women choosing to have an abortion - it doesn’t devalue my life, I don’t feel like anyone thinks I'm worth less. Their choice is what's right for their life and no-one else should get a say.

Lockdownbear · 24/09/2021 01:30

Nobody carries a baby to 24 weeks without loving it and dreaming of its future.
Not every woman gets her 20 weeks scan on time, maybe a more detailed scan at a different facility, discussions with consultants, time to think, make decision, get the procedure booked and carried out. I can easily see how it can be over the 24 weeks.

But if you remove that exception then your forcing women to rush the decision. In some cases it will be very black and white that a condition isn't compatible with life. The more grey the more scans and discussions are required.

I can't even work out who'd want to adopt a severely disabled child. If they become ling term Foster carers then they get rest-bite and holidays. And when it becomes too much the council need to find them a home.
If people adopt them they become their problem and they need to fight for support.

HappyHippoWhatAMess · 24/09/2021 01:26

Here is the tricky point, I think - from the POV of the fetus as a living being, the week before the birth and the week after there is almost zero difference in their development

But there’s a huge amount of change that happens at birth! The placental circulation is lost, blood flow redirects through the lungs which have to go from fluid filled to air filled, open up and stretch out their blood vessels, lung blood pressure falls, the path of blood through the heart changes, oxygen saturations go from 50% to 90% and brain activity changes in response. And these changes are much more difficult to achieve in babies with Down syndrome, which is partly why they don’t survive very well being born preterm- the equivalent survival of an average 24 weeker is pushed to over 28 weeks if the baby has Downs.

PieMistee · 24/09/2021 01:04

I agree. It's a little like saying a pregnancy of a girl in a country as fucked up towards women as Afghanistan currently is should terminate as their live will be so burdeness.

ellyeth · 24/09/2021 01:01

In my view, it is up to the woman to make that decision. Women are allowed to have abortions for all sorts of reasons and some of those reasons might not be palatable to others, but she is the one who has to go through pregnancy, labour and the responsibility of caring for a child up to adulthood and beyond.

Not all people with Downs Syndrome are as able as the young woman who brought this action. Some require a great deal of lifelong support and some have significant health problems too. Not all parents have the emotional and physical resilience to deal with this, especially people who have other child care responsibilities or who are in a low income household and need to go out to work.

LobsterNapkin · 24/09/2021 00:56

I wonder if autism was a similarly variable, single chromosome mutation how would things pan out?

People would lose their shit, even though many people with DS have a much better quality of life than many people with autism.

Anyway, I think to understand this you have to understand why the law restricts post-viability abortions in the first place. The fact is that while most people do not consider a fetus just a nothing as you get close to the birth. People begin to see it more as a living thing that requires protections, maybe the same as an infant, or maybe more like a pet, depending on their POV, but a living creature in any case. So the law at that point looks to balance the good of the mother against that of the baby.

Here is the tricky point, I think - from the POV of the fetus as a living being, the week before the birth and the week after there is almost zero difference in their development. You could choose to do a section the week before and what you would be holding would be a perfectly normal infant, disabled or not. It's an arbitrary date developmentally except so far as in the week prior, the mother's body is in the picture as well, which then affects the mother's bodily autonomy. So it's not about the infant, so much as about the mother, and the exceptions are meant to reflect that.

What disabled people are afraid of is that the logic around the value of the disabled will be followed to it's logical conclusion, as is so often the case when social changes like this happen. The question then becomes, if it is ok to want to abort a disabled infant, who may have a perfectly reasonable QOL, a week before the birth, why not the day it's born, when the infant is no different than 24 hours previously? That sounds like it's crazy on the face of it to most people, they recoil, but historically that is not an unusual approach,. People can and have thought this way, frequently. It could equally be justified in terms of cost and responsibility for the parents. And as euthanasia becomes more accepted, for more things, it is difficult to say that western culture could never go in that direction - there is a reason many disabled people are also very alarmed by that kind of legislation.

It really gets into the issue of, who has a life worth living?

PieMistee · 24/09/2021 00:50

I think abortion laws should be equitable for those that have a manageable disability to those that have no visible disability.

PrincessFiorimonde · 24/09/2021 00:49

Heidi Crowter's activism would do much more for the lives of people with Downs if she used her platform to advocate for improved social care and support for these individuals. That - unlike this legal case - could make a real difference.

Totally agree with this.

GiantHaystacks2021 · 24/09/2021 00:45

I think women should make their own decision on that.
She doesn't have the right to dictate to others, just because she has Downs Syndrome.

bridgetreilly · 24/09/2021 00:30

@pantsandpringles

I’m in favour of a woman terminating for that reason, or a variety of other reasons, or even no real reason at all. Because no one owns their body and until a fetus can survive on its own, then its up to the woman if she wishes to continue with the pregnancy or not

This law is about foetuses that can absolutely survive on their own, though. Current law allows termination up to birth in these cases, not the normal 24 weeks. That is the whole point of her argument.

SemperIdem · 24/09/2021 00:21

@Staffy1 it isn’t an individual life, that’s the whole point.

SemperIdem · 24/09/2021 00:16

I’m extremely pro-choice, I think the law should reflect “as early as possible, as late as necessary” more fully. I wouldn’t hesitate to abort a fetus with DS - my priority is my already existing child.

Staffy1 · 24/09/2021 00:13

A baby (unborn or otherwise) or foetus or whatever you want to call it, is not part of “a woman’s body”, it’s an individual life and just because it’s dependent on a woman to live until it’s born does not make it “her body”. If a termination is done for the sake of the unborn child that’s one thing, but I just think it’s odd that people keep going on about it being a woman’s choice about what to do with her body and no mention of the actual baby.

EmeraldShamrock · 24/09/2021 00:07

It is difficult.
I've had experience with both sides a family member terminating a baby girl with DS and an uncle who had a very fulfilled life until he was 44, he had an amazing personality.

I've a cousin too he isn't independent, his elderly parents do a great job, he can't walk anymore, he has regular carers, he eats a lot he is extremely heavy.

There are a few DC with DS in my DC school they are very independent.
But it isn't my decision to judge a woman who terminates a late baby with DS.

Motorina · 23/09/2021 23:54

I echo those who say that the stereotype of the happy smiling downs syndrome child is just that. A stereotype. And not a particularly representative one.

Others have outlined clearly how much more complex and disabling the condition can be. I don't intend to repeat that.

I add that, in my experience, even if a child meets the 'happy, smiling, loving' stereotype, then their adulthood can be bleak. There's two reasons for that. Firstly, DS is strongly associated with early onset, severe dementia, which not infrequently causes real confusion, violent outbursts and inconsolable distress to the individual.

Secondly, this happens just as the parents get elderly and are no longer able to cope with an adult-sized child who is confused, distressed, agitated and violent. I have seen a number of individuals go from being loved, happy and well-cared for to deteriorating rapidly in a residential setting, in really a very few years.

I make two arguments. Firstly, late-term abortions are thankfully rare. No woman chooses to have a TFMR lightly. It's a heartbreakingly awful outcome to a much wanted pregnancy. As such, it should be a decision made by the woman with the assistance of her doctors, and noone else.

Secondly, Heidi Crowther's activism would do much more for the lives of people with Downs if she used her platform to advocate for improved social care and support for these individuals. That - unlike this legal case - could make a real difference.

SionnachRua · 23/09/2021 23:46

And to answer your question OP, I bet Heidi is funded by the American pro-life religious groups. They're so fond of interfering in other countries legal/democratic systems. Any Irish person around for the abortion ref will remember it.

SionnachRua · 23/09/2021 23:42

I'm delighted the ruling went the way it did. Women are not there to be breeding machines to maintain the population of people with DS. If a woman wants to carry on with that pregnancy, that's great for her and I hope her/child get all the supports they need (they won't but that's another story). If she decides raising a child with DS isn't what she wants, I'll back her decision 100%.

In future maybe we'll have the ability to test for other conditions while the foetus is in the womb and I hope women then will also be able to exercise choice over their bodies and futures.