Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Today's ruling re Down's Syndrome

693 replies

Shirazboobaloo · 23/09/2021 21:09

Sorry to hijack AIBU for this but can someone explain this ruling to me please?

What I can't understand (from press reports) is how this has "come to this".

Who is Heidi Crowther and who are those supporting her?

I am genuinely confused but don't know where to ask

OP posts:
Covidworries · 24/09/2021 07:27

@Itsanewdah

But what if your child was born with a severe need that wasnt screenable ie extreme autism with other disabilities and health complications? What if this was picked up on tests done in first week could euthenasia be used then? Or at any point in life that the severity became aparent?

What if we get the the stage of screening for autism, deafness, blindness in pregnancy? Would those be reasons to abort after 24 weeks. Each of thise can be be result in people who can live fulfilling lives or come with other health problems which can be long term or require high support? Equally, many can have enriched lives and contribute to society for the greater good.
Where do we draw the line?

Both situations have the potential to be slippery slopes on the one hand we do not want a society where there is a risk of making abortion ileagal or where life limiting/incompatable with life fetus can not have late stage abortion.

On the other hand we dont want a society where diversity and acceptance becomes less, where any disability can be screened for and aborted. Or where thise in car accidents arent treated because their injuries may cause them to have disabilities.

I dont know because it is complicated and i worry about the future of people choosing to abort based on deaf, blind, autism etc

Itsanewdah · 24/09/2021 07:20

I know this may be controversial but sometimes I feel that some people who have disabilities but are high functioning often try to promote ideas ( or are used by others to further their own agenda) about the lives of a whole spectrum of other individuals and their families.
So true. A friend’s 15 teen is a more severe case. Massively cognitively impacted, and severely autistic. He doesn’t sleep a lot, is nonverbal, very very strong and quite aggressive. Life was hell for everyone until he moved out in a specialist institution. But now there is a lot of guilt. Not quite the happy, smiling stereotype of down syndrome we are used to.

sashh · 24/09/2021 07:18

People saying Heidi has been manipulated are incredibly disablist and rude. She's articulate and perfectly capable of taking this position.

Have you seen her interviewed?

Basically she says it makes her sad, and that's it. I wish one of the interviewers had the balls to interview her as an adult and not as a child. To ask some real questions.

Un;ess you mean what she tweets from court? That's not her.

As for living independently, I think that's a matter of opinion.

easterndreaming · 24/09/2021 07:12

I feel that opposing the law, especially using DS as an example was detrimental.(personally I agree with the decision that was reached). DS is on a spectrum and having a child is not just having a cute baby, toddler, it's a commitment that lasts until adulthood, especially when individuals are not self sufficient. Choosing to go ahead with such an uncertain outcome before birth is a much bigger decision. It's like jumping blindfolded without knowing where you will land. I know this may be controversial but sometimes I feel that some people who have disabilities but are high functioning often try to promote ideas ( or are used by others to further their own agenda) about the lives of a whole spectrum of other individuals and their families.

Itsanewdah · 24/09/2021 07:06

What people also forget is that Down syndrome varies massively. Some people are very mildly impacted. The people with down syndrome most of us are familiar with are relatively mild cases. Some are massively impacted (physically, cognitively or other things like co-occurance of autism which isn’t rare at all) which impact life of everyone around them massively and can make for extremely challenging individuals. Comparing Down syndrome with dwarfism or missing limbs really not appropriate.
I know I couldn’t do a child with a more severe case justice

countrygirl99 · 24/09/2021 07:03

At one stage I might have been reluctant to abort for DS, I don't know for sure because I never had to face the decision. Then I don't some time helping at a social club for adults with LDs. I really don't know how some parents cope. In the end I had to leave because 1 young man with DS took a liking to me snd couldn't understand that it wasn't OK to slam me against a wall to try and "have a kiss". That "kiss" involved grinding his pelvis against me as well. One of us had to go and I had other options, he didn't. That group ended up with no female helpers for that reason. Goodness knows how his parents coped.

LynetteScavo · 24/09/2021 06:48

Unless the law is changed to allow abortion of any baby up to birth, the law is disabalist.

Pikamoo · 24/09/2021 06:43

@DifficultBloodyWoman

Look at the alternatives.

If a woman cannot choose to have an abortion, she is being forced to give birth against her will.

I do t want any woman to be forced to give birth against their will. I wish the language around this would change to reflect that.

Pro-lifers are forced-birthers.

Every woman should be allowed to make her own choice. I won’t force my beliefs on you. You can’t force yours on me.

How do you think late term abortion happens? Its not just take a pill and the baby disappears. It's essentially giving birth but your baby is not alive. Pretty much always due to tragic circumstances.
anon12345678901 · 24/09/2021 06:34

Great decision from the judges. A woman has the right to retain her body autonomy and make the choice what is best for her.
I wouldn't want a DS child and if I found out after 24 weeks I would want to terminate. I don't apologise for that.
It is no one else's decision what a woman chooses to do. Focus on your own uterus. Heidi does not have the right to decide for others simply because she has DS.

herculesoffline · 24/09/2021 06:30

I've posted this on the thread already but just want to reiterate that the law does not mention DS, only severe impairment. The campaign implies that there is a specific clause in the law regarding Downs Syndrome, and this has been pointed out to them many times.

The law mentions "severe impairment", and it's arguable that Downs Syndrome is not as severe an impairment as many parents and clinicians believe it to be. The judgment on what constitutes severe impairment is deliberately left out of the law which allows discretion by clinicians and parents.

I don't know if I would terminate if my baby had DS, and I have supported and worked with people with DS. But even if I personally wouldn't, i want to protect those rights of women to end their pregnancies if their baby is likely to have severe physical or mental impairment.

Also there's a lot of people mentioning babies born at 24 weeks being able to "survive on their own". They cannot. The medical intervention required for babies born below 32 weeks to survive is immense and overwhelming. The cut off for actually being able to survive in their own is much, much closer to 37 weeks. I say this as the mother of a preemie born at 26 weeks.

Shoxfordian · 24/09/2021 06:26

I think it’s a good decision by the courts

It’s an attempt to try to reduce the rights of women to abort children for whatever reason they want to. I don’t think any civilised country should force women to give birth to children if they choose not to.

herculesoffline · 24/09/2021 06:18

@Pixxie7

I think this was specifically aimed at Down’s syndrome who as we all many can grow up and leave perfectly normal lives.
The law does not mention Downs Syndrome.
DifficultBloodyWoman · 24/09/2021 05:49

Look at the alternatives.

If a woman cannot choose to have an abortion, she is being forced to give birth against her will.

I do t want any woman to be forced to give birth against their will. I wish the language around this would change to reflect that.

Pro-lifers are forced-birthers.

Every woman should be allowed to make her own choice. I won’t force my beliefs on you. You can’t force yours on me.

LaBellina · 24/09/2021 04:26

We agree with each other @Pikamoo.

Pikamoo · 24/09/2021 04:20

That right to care doesn't mean the baby gets to stay inside the mother. If she doesn't want to be pregnant then either c section or induce delivery. If the baby is too early to survive, too bad - that's an abortion. If the baby can survive then it's birth.

Pikamoo · 24/09/2021 04:18

@LaBellina

People also forget it’s about the bigger picture, if the court ruled in her favor, the door would open to others who want to limit women’s right to abortion for other reasons. It’s a slippery slope.
If it's a slippery slope in one direction it's a slippery slope in the other direction too. DS is a spectrum and people with DS can and do live fulfilling lives (especially with proper state funded support). Whats the cut-off point where you say "ok, this baby has a right to live"? Because you can't decide that a healthy baby doesn't have that right which is why there is a 24 week limit on abortions (the point where the baby can survive without the mother).

What about a baby who has a gene that means they'll probably end up with a debilitating illness in, say, their 20s? Is their predicted quality of life sufficient that they can't be denied their right to life?

Don't mistake me for being anti-abortion as I'm not at all. A woman can say at any point that she doesn't want to be pregnant anymore and that should absolutely be honoured. But if the baby can survive without the mother then it should have a right to care.

MimiDaisy11 · 24/09/2021 04:12

It obviously benefits prolifers to have Heidi front the campaign but I don’t think it means she’s been manipulated. I think we should give her the respect that her views are her own even if we disagree.

LaBellina · 24/09/2021 03:53

*have the right to say

LaBellina · 24/09/2021 03:52

@Pikamoo

I think a woman has the right at any point to say "I don't want to be pregnant anymore" but doesn't have the right to say "and the baby can't live". If the baby can't survive without the mother then there's nothing the state can do but if the baby can survive without the mother then it has the same right to treatment and care as anyone.
I mean the right of the woman to have an abortion should always prevail above the right of the fetus to not be aborted. Ofcourse if the fetus can survive with medical support after terminating the pregnancy this should absolutely be given but my point is that women should as you say, “I don’t want to be pregnant anymore”
LaBellina · 24/09/2021 03:50

People also forget it’s about the bigger picture, if the court ruled in her favor, the door would open to others who want to limit women’s right to abortion for other reasons. It’s a slippery slope.

Pikamoo · 24/09/2021 03:50

I think a woman has the right at any point to say "I don't want to be pregnant anymore" but doesn't have the right to say "and the baby can't live". If the baby can't survive without the mother then there's nothing the state can do but if the baby can survive without the mother then it has the same right to treatment and care as anyone.

LaBellina · 24/09/2021 03:45

*trying to take away

LaBellina · 24/09/2021 03:45

People forget it’s not about ‘baby’s right to live’. This isn’t about Heidi, she has absolutely zero right to dictate other women what to do with their body. It’s so hypocrite to say she is doing this for human right reasons, when she’s actively trying to take women’s human right to bodily autonomy.
I have zero sympathy for this entitled point of view and I am glad she lost the case.

Bumpitybumper · 24/09/2021 03:39

Having had some personal experience of DS in the family, I am very wary of those who seek to underplay or minimise the impact that the condition can (and often does) have on the individual with DS and their family.

It's interesting that they have chosen someone like Heidi who is clearly extremely high functioning to be the face of this movement. She is obviously articulate and seems to care deeply about the issue but I would also argue she has one of the more socially acceptable forms of the condition. Like how they use young children and toddlers with rosy cheeks and bright eyes in a disproportionate amount of literature you see on DS.

What you see less is the non verbal adults with DS that need full time care. You rarely see the obese middle aged person with DS suffering early onset dementia. You don't see the elderly parents fretting and worrying about what will happen to their child with DS when they are no longer around. You don't see the frustration and anger of some higher functioning adults with DS who want to live 'normal' lives and through a combination of lack of support from government services and limitations due to DS, simply can't access so many things that most adults take for granted.

Generally I am pro-choice and believe in the woman's ability to choose what happens to her body, but I am an even bigger proponent of it in cases such as this due to the high level of additional demands a child with DS can place on a mother and their families. I don't think it's at all desirable for women to have unwanted babies in general for a myriad of reasons and unfortunately the future for an unwanted baby with DS is potentially even bleaker due to an overburdened state system and a reluctance of people to adopt children with higher needs. I can't stress enough from what I have seen how involved most families are with their adult children with DS. This is a lifetime commitment and should only be made willfully and with a full understanding of what it means now and in the future.

Pixxie7 · 24/09/2021 03:28

I think this was specifically aimed at Down’s syndrome who as we all many can grow up and leave perfectly normal lives.