Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Today's ruling re Down's Syndrome

693 replies

Shirazboobaloo · 23/09/2021 21:09

Sorry to hijack AIBU for this but can someone explain this ruling to me please?

What I can't understand (from press reports) is how this has "come to this".

Who is Heidi Crowther and who are those supporting her?

I am genuinely confused but don't know where to ask

OP posts:
Suzy39 · 26/09/2021 21:01

@ISpyCobraKai

Suzy39 I had one at 23+5. I didn't have to give birth. It was a BPAS clinic that I went to 14yrs ago.
So you must have had a C section?

Babies that geststion are 25cm in length and between 1 and 1.5lb. They don't get taken away by fairies.

olivehater · 26/09/2021 20:14

Pointythings No I don’t think it would happen. And you wouldn’t get many people to do it. But the 24 week cut off makes it’s simpler for everybody. It feels right and we aim to diagnose abnormalities before or close that date as well. For instance a repeat anatomy scan needs to be done by 23 weeks. We aim for fast referral to fetal medicine if we pick anything up at the 20 week scan. The majority of the things we pick up at this stage tend to be minor or catastrophic. The screening for chromosome abnormalities is earlier. But occasionally you get people that initially refused screening but when faced with say a heart abnormality decide they need screening such an amnio. So you are picking up DS with extra complications.
The really late feticides I have seen have often because they were waiting on the results of an MRI, frustratingly, normally severe forms of spinabifida where it was necessary to work out of the fetus could survive or not.
It’s just feels odd to change the law to increase the legal termination for healthy fetuses just the set some sort of example.

RobertaFirmino · 26/09/2021 20:08

@Balonzette

The idea that a baby can be aborted up to birth is absolutely horrifying.
I find the idea that a baby can be born into a life where it will know nothing but excruciating pain far worse.
Embracelife · 26/09/2021 19:56

My personal view is that rather than termination on demand at any gestation, we should have termination on demand until (for example) 28 weeks, and induction on demand thereafter. At this point there is a very good chance of the baby surviving without major health issues, and finding a home for them shouldn’t be too difficult as there is huge demand to adopt small heathy babies

So what do you mean?
Like forced adoption?

But surely prem babies need help like NICU
They don't just survive with no help
Why would you allow forced prem babies?

Lockdownbear · 26/09/2021 19:51

I was thinking that too induction on demand really isn't a good idea for either Mum or Baby.
For a healthy baby it's lots of medical intervention and risks of disability.
For an already poorly baby, who knows if it will be easier or worse, I can't imagine it would be easy.

Tillysfad · 26/09/2021 18:26

My personal view is that rather than termination on demand at any gestation, we should have termination on demand until (for example) 28 weeks, and induction on demand thereafter. At this point there is a very good chance of the baby surviving without major health issues, and finding a home for them shouldn’t be too difficult as there is huge demand to adopt small heathy babies

It certainly seems like the answer until you start considering the doctors who would be asked to go against everything they're trained to do-bringing babies into the world who would struggle needlessly and face expensive, painful NICU care with greater risks of long term damage. They would never ever do it

pointythings · 26/09/2021 18:21

And this thread is an example of MN at its finest - reasoned debate and mutual respect.

pointythings · 26/09/2021 18:20

olivehater but in reality it would be for something like severe foetal abnormality. Do you really believe that women would just decide to have late terminations for no reason? The one case in recent years where a woman demanded termination at 38 weeks when her baby was healthy was someone who turned out to have very serious mental health problems, and the termination was not granted.

Mjfdrjjbf · 26/09/2021 18:01

@Suzy39 and @ISpyCobraKai I’m so sorry for your loss

Mjfdrjjbf · 26/09/2021 18:00

@olivehater that’s a really good point and I’m ashamed to say something I hadn’t given much thought to. In practice I suspect it wouldn’t ever really come up but of course clinicians need protection too.

I think if I had to sum up this thread - it’s very, very complicated and difficult, and any simple answers will be wrong.

I really appreciate that so many people have contributed different viewpoints though, even when for some people that will have been really painful.

ISpyCobraKai · 26/09/2021 17:06

Suzy39
I had one at 23+5.
I didn't have to give birth.
It was a BPAS clinic that I went to 14yrs ago.

olivehater · 26/09/2021 16:47

It’s OK to say level things up by allowing termination up to any age but medical professionals still have to do it. They are more able to justify it if it has a severe medical abnormality.
I myself have assisted feticides with ultrasound over 30 weeks gestation for very severe cases that took time to get a diagnosis. They are awful for everyone involved. They are few and far between. I remember the obstetrician shaking whilst doing one. I am happy to be involved and believe women that should have this option but no I would refuse be involved if it was not for a fetal abnormality.

Suzy39 · 26/09/2021 16:30

@ISpyCobraKai

UsedUpUsername Terminations just before 24 weeks, as in 23+5 don't necessarily mean the woman has to give birth. It can be done under general anesthesia.
No it isn't Hmm

You are induced and give birth naturally. Only if there is medical reason would a c section be performed (under local). How do I know? I had one.

I am going to leave this thread as the dumb-ass comments are really starting to rile me from people who know nothing of what they are saying.

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 26/09/2021 14:37

The only thing this debate makes me feel is complete gratitude that I’ve never been in the position to have to make a decision like this.
The thought of full term terminations does upset me but I’m sure it upsets the mother much more. I don’t think I can make any judgement when it’s such an extreme situation that I have no experience of.

FuckingFlumps · 26/09/2021 14:35

@Balonzette

The idea that a baby can be aborted up to birth is absolutely horrifying.
Yes imagine getting so close to birth and having to make such an awful and yet brave choice to prevent the suffering of a likely much wanted child before it is born.

Thank goodness in reality it very rarely happens and that you've never found yourself in such harrowing situation to have to make such a horrifying choice. Hmm

ScumbagDave · 26/09/2021 14:31

I know it must be such a painful choice for the parents who choose to abort a short time before birth. It must also be awful for the doctors. I know a junior doctor who said that when they were training and some of them had to assist at later term abortions, it was just traumatic.

While the decision has to lie with the mother, the affect on other people is difficult to ignore.

Also yes, you can't compare DS and conditions like Edwards. I know people who have had both (different families). The Edwards baby died almost immediately. So heartbreaking. The DS baby went on to mainstream school and has a very full life. Not minimising the experiences of parents to DS children who aren't as fortunate. It can vary so much, I know.

Balonzette · 26/09/2021 14:24

The idea that a baby can be aborted up to birth is absolutely horrifying.

LangClegsInSpace · 26/09/2021 14:20

You say never to ‘personhood’ but the fetus already has some rights and considerations according to most legal systems. Its not something that will happen, it’s already happened.

You want to change the status quo, basically.

Go and read the judgment.

This case failed because the judge confirmed that a foetus does not have personhood or rights

www.judiciary.uk/judgments/crowter-v-secretary-of-state-for-health-and-social-care/

Embracelife · 26/09/2021 10:55

[quote Lockdownbear]@Whitefire I think I had more blood tests with my 4 yo than I did with my 10yo.
They definitely did bloods, for spina bifida, Downs, Edwards? maybe and something else, began with a P that I'd never heard off.
I don't remember get those with the first.

Two of the things were life limiting if I remember rightly.[/quote]
Patau and Edwards are trisomies
Babies rarely live beyond 12 months

Down syndrome highly variable and can live to 60s and be one cbeebies presenter...but wide variation in presentation

UsedUpUsername · 26/09/2021 09:56

My personal view is that rather than termination on demand at any gestation, we should have termination on demand until (for example) 28 weeks, and induction on demand thereafter. At this point there is a very good chance of the baby surviving without major health issues, and finding a home for them shouldn’t be too difficult as there is huge demand to adopt small heathy babies

Iirc wasn’t the limit in the UK a bit later after it was first decriminalised? I want to say it was around the 26 week mark?

Teapiggies · 26/09/2021 09:53

@UsedUpUsername

Levelling up of the age where termination is allowed - because let's be honest, it isn't going to change anything. No women is just going to have a termination at 38 weeks for the lolz

Hard no. The rarity of something isn’t an argument against this. We still need ethical guidance. Why not the point of viability?

My personal view is that rather than termination on demand at any gestation, we should have termination on demand until (for example) 28 weeks, and induction on demand thereafter. At this point there is a very good chance of the baby surviving without major health issues, and finding a home for them shouldn’t be too difficult as there is huge demand to adopt small heathy babies.

I would keep the law in place with regards to babies with disabilities however, purely because there simply isn’t the demand to adopt them and they are less physically robust to endure a premature birth.

Is this unfair? Yes. Is it the compassionate option? Yes. I would rather take an uncomfortable stance that actually leads to better outcomes than assuage my own conscience and turn a blind eye to how it actually affects people.

UsedUpUsername · 26/09/2021 09:52

@pointythings

The problem with giving a foetus personhood after 'viability' is that it has horrific unintended consequences for the woman. This has already happened in the US - look up the case of Marshae Jones. Women who have late miscarriages will end up under scrutiny at the most horrific time in their lives - did she do something to induce it? Did she exercise too much or otherwise engage in risky behaviour? That's where the personhood option takes us and it must never happen.
So the Marshae Jones case is weird all right. She was shot in the stomach by another woman during some sort of altercation.

Ordinarily her shooter would be jailed for killing her unborn child. But they couldn’t prosecute the shooter because of ‘Stand Your Ground’ laws and moved to indict Marshae instead. Thankfully it was dismissed. Fodder in America’s culture wars, sadly.

I understand your point but I don’t think giving the fetus zero rights is the answer. Obviously you feel differently.

You say never to ‘personhood’ but the fetus already has some rights and considerations according to most legal systems. Its not something that will happen, it’s already happened.

You want to change the status quo, basically.

pointythings · 26/09/2021 09:30

The problem with giving a foetus personhood after 'viability' is that it has horrific unintended consequences for the woman. This has already happened in the US - look up the case of Marshae Jones. Women who have late miscarriages will end up under scrutiny at the most horrific time in their lives - did she do something to induce it? Did she exercise too much or otherwise engage in risky behaviour? That's where the personhood option takes us and it must never happen.

UsedUpUsername · 26/09/2021 06:51

@Lockdownbear

And as you may be aware, 24 weeks is actually quite late among Western European countries, where the limit is around 12-16 weeks for healthy fetuses.

What's the limit in Europe where the mothers life is at stake?

It of course varies, but it’s generally extended for physical/mental health. A poke around here on various barriers to access in Europe can be found s here: europeabortionaccessproject.org/
UsedUpUsername · 26/09/2021 06:45

@LangClegsInSpace

Why are you talking about US law, UsedUp? There's a good potted history of UK law in the judgment. The time limit in the UK has nothing to do with Roe V Wade.

I think we should be giving anything based on US law a very hard swerve, given how that's working out.

What is the 24-week limit based on in the UK if not viability?