Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Today's ruling re Down's Syndrome

693 replies

Shirazboobaloo · 23/09/2021 21:09

Sorry to hijack AIBU for this but can someone explain this ruling to me please?

What I can't understand (from press reports) is how this has "come to this".

Who is Heidi Crowther and who are those supporting her?

I am genuinely confused but don't know where to ask

OP posts:
Covidworries · 24/09/2021 09:48

This has got me thinking about premeture births. We know statistically a child born at 24/25/26 weeks can survive but is more likely to have ongoing health issues or learning disabilities or disabilities due to being premeture.
The survival rate is through extensive medical intervention. Often the procedures done could be classed as causing pain.

Left without medical care the child would likely die at this stage. With care they could survive but need ongoing support throught life, they could have to be peg fed, deaf, blind, behavioural issues etc etc all due to the premature birth.
Are all premature births given life saving care or can a parent decide they want to medical team to do nothing?
A baby born at 23.6 weeks is left i understand ?
We were at risk of premature labour and was told we needed to get to 24 weeks for medical care.

Ozanj · 24/09/2021 09:45

@Jas1985

I was recently diagnosed as autistic so this case has become more emotive for me in recent months. There are researchers who would like to find a pre natal test for autism, and fear what the implications of that would be. However, I’ve been pro choice since I was able to understand what that meant. I think there’s better ways to tackle ableism in society than rolling back already precarious reproductive rights.

The specifics of this particular proposal cemented my opinion. BPAS have come out against it as it would be the first law to recognise a fetus as having human rights independent of the person carrying it. That sets a dangerous precedent in my opinion

Not the same as Autism. The vast majority cases of Autism are on the low to moderate end of the spectrum. The vast majority of cases of DS are on the severe end of the spectrum. The higher IQ DS people who can hold down jobs, complete degrees and communicate meaningfully to the media are the tiniest minority.

Also if you banned all these late terminations you could end up with Edwards and Patau babies being made to suffer unecessarily. In ancient times these babies were often drowned to be kind to them - in fact the cyclops myths were based on that - far kinder to abort them while still in the womb.

We should all be fighting for earlier diagnosis so women aren’t forced to give birth to dead / non-viable babies.

godmum56 · 24/09/2021 09:44

@Staryflight445

It’s not horrible *@godmum56* it’s true. It’s probably why many couples choose to not get the screening during pregnancy too, cause you know… happy, bubbly independent outcome.

It’s incredibly sad.

It is true, but I am aware that folk who may be reading this are people with from birth disabilities and it must be pretty horrible for them to feel that their lives and what was their futures are being discussed in this way. I would hate them to feel dismissed as "the acceptable face of disability"
Generallystruggling · 24/09/2021 09:44

Also should add that only 0.1% of abortions in the UK are performed over 24 weeks so a vanishingly small amount. It isn’t a decision anyone would take lightly.

Generallystruggling · 24/09/2021 09:40

I think the law is correct here. I don’t think anyone should be forced to raise a disabled child. Also think it’s lovely Heidi is independent but many with DS just aren’t. I don’t think the fact it isn’t fatal is the only consideration to make, it’s quality of life for both the parents and child as well as any existing children.

ThanksIGotItInMorrisons · 24/09/2021 09:39

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Jas1985 · 24/09/2021 09:36

I was recently diagnosed as autistic so this case has become more emotive for me in recent months. There are researchers who would like to find a pre natal test for autism, and fear what the implications of that would be. However, I’ve been pro choice since I was able to understand what that meant. I think there’s better ways to tackle ableism in society than rolling back already precarious reproductive rights.

The specifics of this particular proposal cemented my opinion. BPAS have come out against it as it would be the first law to recognise a fetus as having human rights independent of the person carrying it. That sets a dangerous precedent in my opinion

UsedUpUsername · 24/09/2021 09:33

As early as possibly, as late as necessary

Ah here comes the sloganeering.

BreatheAndFocus · 24/09/2021 09:32

This is the problem with both sides of the argument, the ridiculous absolutes that some people want to put in place

Exactly that, MatildaIThink! This isn’t a black or white situation (abortion in general not DS) and people at the extremes digging their heels in and making absolutist statements does nothing to help.

We have to have some guidelines/rules/restrictions. The discussion is where they should be and in what circumstances. The idea that if you’re pro-choice you have to be ok with every circumstance of abortion is simply stupid.

DifficultBloodyWoman · 24/09/2021 09:25

@Pikaboo
How do you think late term abortion happens? Its not just take a pill and the baby disappears. It's essentially giving birth but your baby is not alive. Pretty much always due to tragic circumstances.

My post was addressing all abortions, not specifically late term.

With regards to late term abortions, I stand by the words ‘forced birth’ because it is incredibly traumatic for a woman to be forced to carry to term a child she doesn’t want for any reason (medical, social, economic, whatever). Refusing to allow a woman to have a termination means that she faces much greater risk to her mental health and physical health. There are also economic consequences for her, and social. Women deserve agency over their own bodies. This shouldn’t be a radical thought.

As early as possibly, as late as necessary.

Lockdownbear · 24/09/2021 09:24

@moofolk good for her if she finds it disgusting that people will abort for DS. But she can not take choice away from other people.
Her DD is maybe on end of the spectrum, she may also still be quite young, she may think differently in the future when she's struggling with old age, fighting for support and struggling to support her DD.

And don't underestimate the fight for support, SW don't always have a sense of urgency.

My DGF felt carering for a disabled son put his brother & SIL in a early graves. The son is now in his 60s, in a home, his sister was convinced he was being abused in one home but couldn't prove it.

It has to be pro-choice, women have a right to decide what is right for them. Some late termination may be due to something happening while the mum was pregnant maybe she's picked up an infection which has harmed the baby.

anon12345678901 · 24/09/2021 09:20

@RosyPoesy

What if this was picked up on tests done in first week could euthenasia be used then? Or at any point in life that the severity became aparent? FYI, in the Netherlands euthanasia is legal until a child is 1 year old. So babies born with profound disabilities can be killed.
I believe that to be kinder than subjecting a child to multiple operations and procedures knowing they will still be suffering after. I think it's quite cruel and selfish to bring children into this world with profound disabilities. It's being done for the parents, not what's best for the child.
UsedUpUsername · 24/09/2021 09:19

@FuckingFlumps

I just have to add again that if you're pro choice you cannot add caveats to that statement.

Anyone who says they are pro choice and follows it up with the word but is deluding themselves that they are pro choice.

What if I’m satisfied with current limits but don’t want to change it to broadened it further? Does this make me anti-choice?

Odd POV that

NoYOUbekind · 24/09/2021 09:16

@Sirzy

Apparently it was said in the ruling yesterday that their where no recorded cases in the last 10 years which if true does make the whole thing even more pointless. There are only just over 200 post 24 week abortions each year for medical reasons
This thread being the first time I've read that stat, I'm more and more coming to the conclusion that this campaign was a Trojan Horse.
Staryflight445 · 24/09/2021 09:13

It’s not horrible @godmum56 it’s true. It’s probably why many couples choose to not get the screening during pregnancy too, cause you know… happy, bubbly independent outcome.

It’s incredibly sad.

MatildaIThink · 24/09/2021 09:12

@FuckingFlumps

I just have to add again that if you're pro choice you cannot add caveats to that statement.

Anyone who says they are pro choice and follows it up with the word but is deluding themselves that they are pro choice.

This is the problem with both sides of the argument, the ridiculous absolutes that some people want to put in place.

I only know one person who is absolutely against abortion (claims to be Christian, but would rather kick a poor person than help them, fairly typical pro-lifers), everyone else has either never expressed a view or believes that abortion should be allowed, but also within limits.

Most people who are pro-choice are find with abortion up until 24ish weeks, as well as after that where medical issues arise. After 24 weeks hat foetus could be delivered and survive on it's own, so I understand why people hold a somewhat different viewpoint after that stage of development. I doubt you will find many other than some hardcore idealogues who believe in entirely elective abortion for no reason other than personal choice, up until birth.

Just because someone does not agree with you entirely, does not mean that you are not both on the same side, they are not your enemy.

Everydayimhuffling · 24/09/2021 09:10

I was 21 weeks when the anomaly scan picked up a heart defect. I was past 24 weeks when we got back the detailed chromosomal analysis that told us that our DC would not have the life-limiting syndrome suggested by their heart defect. If the 24 week limit had been in place for medical issues, I would have been forced to have an abortion that turned out to be unnecessary. People need time to make these decisions with all the information and consideration necessary.

Staryflight445 · 24/09/2021 09:10

People with down syndrome who are like that are few and far between @HarrisMcCoo they’re not likely to show an aggressive, non verbal person with DS on CBeebies are they?
You wouldn’t see anyone hired in a supermarket like that either would you?

godmum56 · 24/09/2021 09:00

@HarrisMcCoo

Just watched Cbeebies this morning - a presenter was on who just happens to have Down's syndrome. He is holding down a job and more than likely leadinga fairly independent life.

We have a supermarket worker who has Down's syndrome in our local town. He does a great job.

I feel Heidi is right to keep up with her fight to change the law.

I had a child diagnosed with a rare condition I didn't know about until after the birth. Did I decide to abandon him because of it? No. He is mine and always will be.

I appreciate years ago lack of knowledge on Down's syndrome meant people didn't want to carry on with the pregnancy but as we learn more with education on learning disabilities it's clear that people who happen to have Down's syndrome can lead fairly independent lives. Often more successful than those who are NT but abuse drugs/alcohol and are costing taxpayers a fortune.

This is going to sound horrible but, as with many disabilities, the general public only see the "acceptable" ones on the media.
FuckingFlumps · 24/09/2021 08:55

I just have to add again that if you're pro choice you cannot add caveats to that statement.

Anyone who says they are pro choice and follows it up with the word but is deluding themselves that they are pro choice.

Itsanewdah · 24/09/2021 08:54

This law has no place in the 21st Century.I suppose it is just another example of how selfish and self-centred the human race has become.
i assume you are not the one cleaning poo of the walls several times a day, having bruises from over enthusiastic hugs, and having slept no more than 3 hours in one go over the last 15 or so years? and are on universal credit etc because working is not possible with no social life?

RosyPoesy · 24/09/2021 08:54

What if this was picked up on tests done in first week could euthenasia be used then? Or at any point in life that the severity became aparent?
FYI, in the Netherlands euthanasia is legal until a child is 1 year old. So babies born with profound disabilities can be killed.

Sirzy · 24/09/2021 08:54

I agree about Katie Price having done a lot of good in that sense, the documentary she did last year gave a small insight into the realities of parenting a young adult with disabilities - both in terms of day to day and in terms of the battles to get what they need to help them develop as much independence as possible.

sashh · 24/09/2021 08:52

@VestaTilley

I’m pro choice, but I agree with Heidi.

“Terminating a pregnancy” three days before your due date isn’t a termination: it’s child destruction.

These incidents are, thankfully, incredibly rare, and I do not underestimate the torturous position mothers in these circumstances go through, but termination at 40 weeks etc should not be legal.

A termination at 40 weeks might be what you refer to as 'child destruction' but if you are terminating at that stage it is because termination is you delivering a dead baby or delivering a baby that will have a short painful life.

I did write a description of a possible outcome but decided to delete it.

Brefugee · 24/09/2021 08:51

I have a Grandson with DS,diagnosed before birth and there was NEVER any thought given to termination.
Am I supposed to believe his life is not as important as others?
This law has no place in the 21st Century.I suppose it is just another example of how selfish and self-centred the human race has become.

He's here now so yes, his life is important. Are you providing day-to-day care? realistically what is that like? is he one of the "lucky" ones who has few health issues and is high-functioning with a family who can afford to buy in help?

or when they are 80 are his parents going to be like the couple above who have lost all their friends and have nothing in their lives except caring for a daughter who can't live independently and are petrified what will happen to her when they die. They have, on the face of it ZERO quality of life.

So shove that in your pipe and smoke it. Women have, and still have (and hopefully will always have) the right to abortion. And as so many have said "as early as possible as late as necessary".

As for PP who mentioned sex-selective abortion. There are many many reasons that happens and they mostly boil down to coercion. And in countries where women aren't valued girl-babies who actually make it as far as birth are killed immediately. I don't think there is a person in the world who actually wants that.

Agree with PP that what we really need are much better support systems for people with disabilities, and their carers (so much support needed there) and it would be lovely to have a few more activitists talking about the harsh reality of life for families in this position.

FWIW when i had DC1 i blitely did the first test but refused an amnio on the grounds that while i am pro-choice it's not my choice. As it happens i could barely cope with a child, let alone a child with additional needs and if i were in that position again i would have the test and make an informed decision. And if termination was that decision, i would have to live with that.

Flowers to the brave pp who have written about their TFMR. It must be extremely difficult for you, but thank you because we really do need to hear about the reality of this.