Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Today's ruling re Down's Syndrome

693 replies

Shirazboobaloo · 23/09/2021 21:09

Sorry to hijack AIBU for this but can someone explain this ruling to me please?

What I can't understand (from press reports) is how this has "come to this".

Who is Heidi Crowther and who are those supporting her?

I am genuinely confused but don't know where to ask

OP posts:
BoredZelda · 24/09/2021 10:30

This is going to sound horrible but, as with many disabilities, the general public only see the "acceptable" ones on the media.

This. I’m all for representation, we need much, much more of it, but it is important to understand the whole picture.

Left without medical care the child would likely die at this stage. With care they could survive but need ongoing support throught life, they could have to be peg fed, deaf, blind, behavioural issues etc etc all due to the premature birth.

There are babies born full term who would not survive without medical care. There are children and adults who become ill or have accidents, who wouldn’t survive without medical care. We treat them regardless of what kind of value other people put on the life of disabled people.

Are all premature births given life saving care or can a parent decide they want to medical team to do nothing?

Treatment is a medical decision. A parent cannot decide.

A baby born at 23.6 weeks is left i understand ?

Incorrect there is no actual cut off date for when medical care is given. All babies, premature or not are assessed after birth and given an APGAR score, most will score highly. Premature babies are more fully assessed and if the APGAR score is zero, no medical intervention is not given. If the score is low, some medical intervention will happen to see if the score can be raised quickly. The higher the score, the longer intervention will take place.

We were at risk of premature labour and was told we needed to get to 24 weeks for medical care.

Told by whom? If it was the consultant team at your hospital and they actually said they would do nothing before 24 weeks, they were not only going against all medical guidance, but possibly acting unlawfully and could lose their medical licences. Maybe you were given the “advice” by a midwife who was actually trying to say most babies before 24 weeks don’t survive.

Being involved in Bliss Charity, I know hundreds of women who had premature babies. I’ve seen 23-26 weekers who have survived and thrived and have no long term problems. I’ve seen more who have not been so fortunate. My own 29 weeker is disabled due to her prematurity, but the vast majority born at that stage come through Ok. It is really important we don’t conflate abortion limits and premature birth. Every pregnancy is individual and should be treated as such.

ManifestDestinee · 24/09/2021 10:29

Ground E is the abortion criteria which covers fetal abnormality. There were 229 abortions under this grounds is 2020 post 24 weeks

And not one of them was for Downs syndrome.

UsedUpUsername · 24/09/2021 10:28

Generally murder only applies to people once they are born anyway. So whatever someone does to an unborn child, legal or otherwise, it isn't murder. Think about it, if you could be prosecuted for that, then lots of mothers who drink/smoke during pregnancy would be prosecuted for child abuse. That doesn't happen, because a person isn't a person until

Some legal systems they do charge people for murder if you intentionally kill a woman’s fetus.

Lockdownbear · 24/09/2021 10:26

To all the mums who've had a tfmr I'm sending my love to you and your sweet babys. Flowers

Thankyou for being brave enough to share your stories must be heartbreaking to try and decide what is best for your baby.

Innocenta · 24/09/2021 10:26

I'm severely physically disabled, with conditions that affect my whole body. So I don't take ableism / disablism lightly. But I think it's simply naive to claim Heidi Crowter isn't being influenced in this battle - of course she has her own opinions and her own agency, but many, many abled people are also manipulated by the religious right, so I'm not sure why anyone thinks Crowter somehow couldn't be.

For what it's worth, I fully support the right to choose. While it's a strange thought to imagine someone having a TFMR motivated by feeling unable to raise a child with my disabilities, that's all it is - a thought. Not a reason to renege on my commitment to that fundamental right.

If anything I think disabled people should be more understanding of the importance of bodily autonomy.

goinggently · 24/09/2021 10:22

@ShushShushShush

There are so, so many people on this thread with opinions about something they know absolutely nothing about, and they should be grateful they know nothing about the experience of TFMR and the horrific distressing, traumatic experience that it is.

I am so sorry to all of the other TFMR mums on this thread and others like it, where the hugely painful loss of our beautiful, precious babies, has been reduced to us being "killers" and "murderers". Where we are judged by those who have no idea at all if the hell we have been through.

This with bells on x Thanks
MobyDicksTinyCanoe · 24/09/2021 10:22

Samcro a lot end up in the care system, the lucky ones are placed with long term forster carers or are adopted. But a lot arent. And a lot of families struggle on and end up needing residential care at some point.

If we had an outright ban on later term abortions we'd be condemming babies to short, painful lives and probably have to go back to the days of having instituions because a lot of families just cant do it.

In fact it would be interesting to know how many of these campaigners have put their money where their mouth is and adopted a profoundly disabled child Hmm

EdgeOfTheSky · 24/09/2021 10:22

P.S and in reality the number of very late terminations would be tiny. As it is now.

saraclara · 24/09/2021 10:21

@Staryflight445

I sadly sense that a lot of posters in this comment sections don’t understand how bad DS can actually be.
Yes.

The Downs people we see around us and who are promoted in the media whenever there's this discussion, are the lucky ones.

I taught children with severe learning difficulties for my entire career (now retired) and I taught the ones you don't see. The ones whose quality of life is poor, and whose families suffer greatly.

I'm glad for those parents of the smiling happy DS children, but I do wish they'd have some empathy and understanding for those who battle their own children's huge behavioural, care, and health needs.

EdgeOfTheSky · 24/09/2021 10:21

So many heart wrenching stories.
Flowers to all women, whatever your circumstances and outcomes.

For me, the principle is absolute. A woman has the right to decide whether her body supports the development of an embryo / foetus / baby whatever the circumstances.

Then there is no discrimination or perceived value judgement about any of it. ‘Should’ the embryo of a rape victim be preserved over conception due to contraception failure? Do some women ‘deserve’ an abortion while others are forced to continue a pregnancy they do not want?

A woman’s right to choose, as early as possible, as late as necessary.

Based on her decision about her body, not society’s judgement about the status of the foetus.

And all stand together to support services for disability, and fight discrimination against (born) disabled people.

Treaclepie19 · 24/09/2021 10:19

ShushShushShush Well said.

@ThanksIGotItInMorrisons you have absolutely no clue what you're talking about.
I, and others on this thread have lived it. Ignorance is no excuse for calling us murderers.
My baby was wanted. I never wanted to give birth to him dead or plan his funeral.
None of us do this for fun you know.

Clymene · 24/09/2021 10:18

@Tigger85 and @ShushShushShush ThanksThanksThanks

I'm so sorry for your losses

Mreggsworth · 24/09/2021 10:16

I know of someone who had to have a late term abortion, how late I'm not sure.

On the early scans they noticed some abnormalities, the head seemed to be growing too fast. She was monitored as a high risk pregnancy, at a later scan it appeared as if the babies head was bent to the side, as if the neck was broke and the head was still developing at a faster speed. She was advised that if she was going to go ahead with birth, it would be a high risk cesarean and even picking the baby up in the slightest wrong way could lead to instant death, and if they could get the baby out, baby would likely die shortly after anyway, and if somehow the baby survived it would be severely disabled.

She chose not to look at the baby when aborted, but she was advised it was apparent the baby was not compatible with life.

I know that's a rare story, but it's just one example of why it is necessary to give parents the opportunity to abort and in this case more humanely kill rather than allow for a traumatic birth with suffering on all parts.

Down syndrome is the same, later scans can show further complications and abnormalities that weren't present when people initially decided to go ahead with their pregnancy.

HarrietsChariot · 24/09/2021 10:15

@ThanksIGotItInMorrisons

Excuse my ignorance, but just how the fuck would one terminate an almost/full term pregnancy? Surely that’s fucking murder not the morning after pill/8 weeks abortion?
Murder is illegal. If the termination is performed legally, then it is not murder, by fact of it being legal.

Generally murder only applies to people once they are born anyway. So whatever someone does to an unborn child, legal or otherwise, it isn't murder. Think about it, if you could be prosecuted for that, then lots of mothers who drink/smoke during pregnancy would be prosecuted for child abuse. That doesn't happen, because a person isn't a person until they're born.

Lockdownbear · 24/09/2021 10:14

so what do they do if the baby becomes disabled a birth, or later ?

Put up with it, love their baby, support it the best they can, cry when it dies, and if it lives a long time accept it may put them in an early grave. And greive for the child they should have had and cry for the life they should have had. And pray that SW will support it in the future. Even if they have been let down before with SW being over stretched.

What do you think people do when a child becomes disabled at birth, go that's fine?

Charliechoosecarefully · 24/09/2021 10:14

@ShushShushShush

Sending love, I'm so sorry you had to go through that, I'm glad your son knew love from the womb and beyond Thanks

ShushShushShush · 24/09/2021 10:11

@ThanksIGotItInMorrisons

Excuse my ignorance, but just how the fuck would one terminate an almost/full term pregnancy? Surely that’s fucking murder not the morning after pill/8 weeks abortion?
You are aware that being ignorant is no excuse to call a grieving mother a murderer?

After 22 weeks gestation, an injection is given into the baby's heart, to stop it, then labour is induced.

Then the mother gives birth to her precious, wanted and loved baby, takes the time to take their hand and foot prints, sing to them, bathe them, dress them, read to them. I had my son baptised shortly after he passed, whilst he was still warm.

Then you start to plan a funeral, and you prepare yourself to hand your darling baby over to a mortuary in a children's hospital and then a funeral director. And then you Bury them, or cremate them. And then you begin making sense of the hell that has been thrust upon you and how you are going to live, and survive going forward.

Ignorance is no excuse for cruelty

Whinge · 24/09/2021 10:09

Tigger85

I cried reading your post, thank you so much for sharing your story. 💐💐

goinggently · 24/09/2021 10:07

@Treaclepie19 Thanks

Sirzy · 24/09/2021 10:05

tigger I can’t even begin to imagine how hard that must have been for you and your family. Thank you for being strong enough to share your story Flowers

goinggently · 24/09/2021 10:03

@Suzy39 ThanksI'm so sorry you had to face that x

Samcro · 24/09/2021 10:03

@Ginger1982

Some women could cope with the challenges a child with DS may bring and some couldn't. It has to be their choice.
so what do they do if the baby becomes disabled a birth, or later ?
Tigger85 · 24/09/2021 10:01

I had a late termination for medical reasons last year. My 12 week scan was normal, nothing was found until the 20 week scan, then they found more and more problems every single week, I was also becoming sick due to too much amniotic fluid. My son had two very rare conditions heterotaxy syndrome (1 in 40 000 occurance) and vacter association ( estimated to be somewhere in the 1 in 10 000-1 in 40 000 occurance) both of these conditions have highly variable outcomes, most people with right sided heterotaxy die within 2 years, most people with left sided (what my son had) die by the age of 5, there are a few that survive childhood, virtually none who make it to adulthood. The majority of people who have vacter are able to live good quality if slightly limited lives once they have had their surgeries, the first 3-4 years are the most dangerous and incredibly tough. Some people are much more seriously affected by vacter and will not survive or will have very short lives filled with pain, others will die due to complications from their multiple surgeries. My son was very severely affected with major severe defects in all his organs except his brain and lungs. His spine was also deformed in the lumbar region. We had genetic screening done and did not have a firm diagnosis or a prognosis until 25+3, I had the first part of the tfmr at 25+6 and he was born at 26+3. You cannot have a termination after 24 weeks unless the fetus has a condition that is either incompatible with life or would cause major physical or mental disability, or the mother's life or physical and mental well being is at risk. Two doctors must agree that a termination is justified, there are no named conditions.

My living son was also found to have congenital abnormalities at 20 weeks in his case it was ventriculomegaly and an absent csp both of which are brain abnormalities with an occurance of 1 in 100 000. I had to make a choice for him too, one of his conditions got better during the pregnancy, in a second MRI at 27 weeks the ventriculomegaly had resolved and was at the very upper limits of normal. At this point we were told that termination would no longer be an option for us, we had already decided to continue anyway and it was a huge relief to learn that termination was no longer an option, it meant our son had much better odds of a good outcome. Both his conditions also had a large variation of outcomes. He could have completely normal development, mild developmental delays and learning difficulties or severe disabilities, unable to ever sit, eat or breath on his own, unable to ever have cognition beyond that of a newborn baby. It was impossible to say for sure where he would fall in that spectrum until sometime after he was born, we would not know the full extent until he became school age but the doctors were very optimistic. He is now 4 with normal development.

I am in several support groups for tfmr, the latest I have heard of anyone having a tfmr was 34 weeks, the lady was American and one of the reasons she had it so late was difficulty financing it as well as finding a clinic and a doctor who would allow it. She did not know her baby was severely sick with multiple severe brain abnormalities caused by strokes in the womb until almost 30 weeks. Almost everyone I know who has had a tfmr for t21 has done so between 12 and 18 weeks. I know one person who has had a tfmr for t21 at 23 weeks after previously deciding to continue with the pregnancy despite knowing the baby had down syndrome. The reason she then changed her mind us because she then found out her baby had several major heart defects as well as ds. It is common for ds and heart defects to go hand in hand, around 50% of people with ds have some form of heart defect, in the general population only 1% of people have a congenital heart defect.

I have followed Heidi's campaign although it has made me very upset, I can understand her viewpoint but she doesn't get to decide for other people. She was campaigning for all terminations for medical reasons to be banned after 24 weeks, not just ds. She is also against screening for ds fullstop and has been involved in the anti NIPT campaign. I am relieved by the outcome. I did not want my son to die, o never wanted a termination, it was a heartbreaking decision, the worst thing I have ever gone through in my life. Ultimately I made the choice to tfmr my wanted and loved son so that he would never suffer.

Making a specific ruling to ban terminations for one named condition is a slippery slope to banning tfmr for other conditions and potentially all terminations for medical reasons. If that happens you are condeming many babies to short painful lives and causing huge amounts of trauma to parents, especially mothers who will be forced to undergo labour only to then watch their child suffer and die.

Charliechoosecarefully · 24/09/2021 09:52

@ThanksIGotItInMorrisons

Excuse my ignorance, but just how the fuck would one terminate an almost/full term pregnancy? Surely that’s fucking murder not the morning after pill/8 weeks abortion?
They usually give the fetus an injection that stops the heart so it dies painlessly in the womb and then the women will need to birth it - about 0.1% of abortions are performed 24+ and it's usually because of medical issues, the women gives birth to a dead baby so I doubt any woman is taking the choice lightly, it must be horrendous.
UsedUpUsername · 24/09/2021 09:50

Not the same as Autism. The vast majority cases of Autism are on the low to moderate end of the spectrum

She has a point. I’ve seen the stress autism can put on families. They are working on diagnostic tests and I’m sure I’m not alone in saying that I’d absolutely abort if I received such a diagnosis.

We should all be fighting for earlier diagnosis

Definitely agree with you there