Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Today's ruling re Down's Syndrome

693 replies

Shirazboobaloo · 23/09/2021 21:09

Sorry to hijack AIBU for this but can someone explain this ruling to me please?

What I can't understand (from press reports) is how this has "come to this".

Who is Heidi Crowther and who are those supporting her?

I am genuinely confused but don't know where to ask

OP posts:
purpleneon · 24/09/2021 13:09

[quote Shmithecat2]@purpleneon

You can be pro choice but not agree with abortion after 24 weeks (I.e. the point that a foetus can survive on its own due to modern medicine).

No, you can't. You are not pro choice. Because you think at some point, the choice should be taken away. That is not pro choice.

Are pro-choice people fine with aborting a 37 month old foetus??

Well, there's not such thing as 37mo foetus, so probably not.Confused[/quote]

*37 weeks

Obviously a typo rolls eyes

lockdownmadnessdotcom · 24/09/2021 13:07

@Carboncheque

Those who are having abortions solely because the foetus has Down syndrome will most probably have done so well before 24 weeks.
I agree. You find out early on, you don't find out at 35 weeks or whatever.
Shmithecat2 · 24/09/2021 13:07

@purpleneon

You can be pro choice but not agree with abortion after 24 weeks (I.e. the point that a foetus can survive on its own due to modern medicine).

No, you can't. You are not pro choice. Because you think at some point, the choice should be taken away. That is not pro choice.

Are pro-choice people fine with aborting a 37 month old foetus??

Well, there's not such thing as 37mo foetus, so probably not.Confused

lockdownmadnessdotcom · 24/09/2021 13:07

People who happen to have Down’s syndrome are usually capable of living full and happy lives

They really aren't. They *sometimes" are. Most have significant problems.

Carboncheque · 24/09/2021 13:07

Those who are having abortions solely because the foetus has Down syndrome will most probably have done so well before 24 weeks.

lockdownmadnessdotcom · 24/09/2021 13:06

My cousin had a baby who was very disabled - she was born close to term and died/allowed to die within hours. That is not abortion.

lockdownmadnessdotcom · 24/09/2021 13:04

It makes me a bit queasy that abortion is allowed up until 40 weeks in some cases, but I also don't think it ever happens in the UK, or if it does, it's not really abortion but a very disabled child will be born and allowed to die.

I don't think anyone has a right to force a woman to carry a baby to term that she does not want, and does not feel equipped to look after.

purpleneon · 24/09/2021 13:01

@ISpyCobraKai

Pro choice BUT isn't pro choice.

You can be pro choice but not agree with abortion after 24 weeks (I.e. the point that a foetus can survive on its own due to modern medicine).

Same way I'm pro choice but would agree that a mother that leaves her 1 day old baby outside in the cold resulting in death should be charged.

Pro-choice doesn't mean that you are fine with abortion up until the hour before a baby is born.

Are pro-choice people fine with aborting a 37 month old foetus??

Anyway I don't mind what others choose to do to be honest, but do feel very sad for the downs girl (and others like her).

RufustheBadgeringReindeer · 24/09/2021 13:01

It's incredibly common in the UK. We have really good cleft services and repairs are done really quite early so you probably see quite a few children who had clefts - you just won't immediately notice

The poster wants facts and evidence that women are aborting babies just because they have a cleft lip and no other issues

No one is arguing that there are children with cleft lips they are arguing that women aren’t aborting purely for that reason

CuriousaboutSamphire · 24/09/2021 12:51

It's hard to see through the emotional res[ponse to this but again this is an issue here 2 sets of protected characteristics, 2 cohorts of people, have equal rights and absolutely opposite ideas on a single subject.

Tighten up the issues around late term abortion by all means but do nto step up and stand alongside a group of people who wish to remove the rights of women to control their own bodies, to make decisions for themselves.

I too think this young woman has been taken up by people whose priorities are NOT disabled people.

It isn't suggesting that she isn't articulate and capable of careful thought and self expression but it is pointing out that, like any other young person, vulnerable or not, finding people who will support your cause can be easily confused by those who see your cause as a good bandwagon, who have other motives, who will use you to their own ends.

Like many posters I empathise with Heidi but her request wouldn't make a good law!

ShushShushShush · 24/09/2021 12:47

I agree, Covidworries. It's perverse that a baby with learning difficulties can be terminated at such a late stage. I too am pro-choice, I completely agree that there should be some extension to the 24 week limit for certain catastrophic conditions. DS should not be included in these exemptions from the 24 week rule.

You realise that it's not "learning difficulties". Babies born to TFMR after 22 weeks, especially the late stage, second and third trimester, often have no brain function at all. That their brain has deteriorated or disintegrated to the point where there is no activity. That's why they have got to 24+ weeks, because their parents were desperately hoping that it would be as simple as having "learning difficulties."

Its not because they might not be able to add up as quickly as others, or have trouble walking. It's complete loss of function where they will never breathe, see, swallow, hear, move, or be without pain.

ISpyCobraKai · 24/09/2021 12:47

Pro choice BUT isn't pro choice.

Lockdownbear · 24/09/2021 12:44

That is many people's reality: dying old, worn out and petrified for your child's future. I wouldn't wish that on anyone

The other reality is dying young because of the strain on the parents. Leaving the child in care.
We don't see the people hidden away in homes. Big fight for properly equipped "changing places" so carers can get out with children / adults in nappies. But reality is many are hidden away out of sight, out of mind.

SpeedRunParent · 24/09/2021 12:40

@Covidworries

Im pro choice too BUT a pregnancy can not be terminated after 24 weeks in most cases. After 24 weeks if the fetus isnt viable is different BUT DS shouldnt be a reason to terminate. Currently a DS baby can be terminated up to term and that isnt right as DS doesnt mean the child isnt viable or would be unable to servive outside of the womb. Plus DS isnt the only thing a child can be born with that causes learning difficulties but most learning disabilities cant be checked in the womb so the ruling has been a kick in the face for the DS community by stating their life isnt as important as a non DS life regardless of any oyher disabilities or not.
I agree, Covidworries. It's perverse that a baby with learning difficulties can be terminated at such a late stage. I too am pro-choice, I completely agree that there should be some extension to the 24 week limit for certain catastrophic conditions. DS should not be included in these exemptions from the 24 week rule.
Lockdownbear · 24/09/2021 12:39

I've google cleft palate in the 36 deaths per 1000. Fairly low but still. It's a risk and probably at the more severe end of the scale.

Brefugee · 24/09/2021 12:35

My beautiful granddaughter has congenital, bilateral talipes and the thought that she could have been killed until birth makes me sick and very fearful.

fearful of what? that someone will come and take her away and kill her? Fearful that other mothers may abort a pregnancy with the same condition and ... how will that affect you?

How is your granddaughter looked after? do her parents have enough money? resources? what about when they die? will a sibling take over? willingly? What is the actual plan for her life?

When we talk about abortion, for whatever reason but especially TFMR, we have to separate the personal from the poplulation. Sure we have all seen happy smiling DS people, and it is absolutely bloody fantastic to see them with more profile on CBBC and acting. I am absolutely for that. But as pp said: they are the "acceptable" ones. For the hard of thinking: they are "acceptable" to the general public as cute, manageable, lovely, not having a tantrum aged 24 and nobody can help.

The fact is we need more visibility of disabilities - not just so that people with disabilities can enjoy life with the rest of us, and so the rest of us learn to accept that everyone is not like us. But so that we can see the struggles they and their carers have. And we need to put way way more resources into helping carers.

The Instamoms may have cute photogenic babies now. But will they be posting later. As PP said about her mother When all her friends were dealing with children becoming independent adults, she was essentially still parenting a toddler, well into her 80s. She died terrified for his future care, which I have taken over.

That is many people's reality: dying old, worn out and petrified for your child's future. I wouldn't wish that on anyone.

Cbtb · 24/09/2021 12:29

And on TFMR till term if you ban this then you get all sorts of awful side effects like that poor lady in Ireland who died before the law change there because they couldn’t/wouldn’t terminate the pregnancy. Or making women continue with pregnancies in situations like anencephaly. What about twin pregnancies when there is twin to twin transfusion or they are conjoined and one won’t survive outside the womb but the other that could maybe survive needs delivery now to save them but you can’t as that would be a tfmr of the other twin

purpleneon · 24/09/2021 12:28

@BoredZelda

Lots and lots of babies have cleft palate without any other conditions - I know this as it is far more common outside the U.K. & yes I'm the U.K. many do abort cleft palate babies.

Again with the “lots” and “many” If you want to assert women are choosing to abort their babies because they won’t have a smiley baby, you need to back that up with actual facts and figures.

www.google.co.uk/amp/s/aleteia.org/2021/06/16/abortion-rates-jump-significantly-in-england-wales/amp

It's a commonly known fact - if you Google so many stats and papers discussing it...

ditalini · 24/09/2021 12:27

@BoredZelda

Lots and lots of babies have cleft palate without any other conditions - I know this as it is far more common outside the U.K. & yes I'm the U.K. many do abort cleft palate babies.

Again with the “lots” and “many” If you want to assert women are choosing to abort their babies because they won’t have a smiley baby, you need to back that up with actual facts and figures.

It's incredibly common in the UK. We have really good cleft services and repairs are done really quite early so you probably see quite a few children who had clefts - you just won't immediately notice.

I notice sometimes because of personal experience, but mostly in adults who were repaired with older techniques that are slightly more visible (obviously the extent of the cleft makes a difference as well).

Cleft babies are gorgeous, both before and after their repairs, and my experience is that clinical staff are hugely positive about eventual outcome (again, depending on extent of cleft) and families get a lot of support.

Lockdownbear · 24/09/2021 12:20

I don't know much about cleft lip and palate, but in some cases does it not mean the brain is at the top of the mouth so actually a really serious and dangerous condition?

BoredZelda · 24/09/2021 12:19

Can't help feeling that Heidi has been manipulated by pro lifers into taking this action.

And perhaps DS charity organisations?

Teapiggies · 24/09/2021 12:18

It’s also very difficult to counter some of the hugely misinformed posts about ‘lazy women waiting 6 months to terminate a baby because it’s a little bit different’, because most of them are underneath a photo or post about a person’s lovely child who has special needs.

I want to debunk the myths and stick up for women who have had a TFMR, but I just know I would be called a heartless monster, and to be honest writing underneath such a photo would feel all kinds of wrong to me.

I noticed Sarah Roberts posted a photo of her son as a baby, not his current age of I think around 9? I love reading about his adventures and I think she’s a lovely lady who writes well.

But it just seems a bit Hmm like a way of shutting debate down by making it so personal that you can’t disagree without making it look like a direct attack on their child. Which is very unfair as what they’re trying to do is introduce a law that wouldn’t even affect their child directly, but it could affect all of us.

Cbtb · 24/09/2021 12:18

I would happily parent a child with Down’s syndrome - (ignoring the higher risk of heart issues for the moment) but I wouldn’t want to care for an adult with downs with the early early dementia and the common issues around weight management and capacity and relationships and capacity and the rest , watching ones parents succumb to dementia is hard enough but to watch ones child- I am not strong enough

ShushShushShush · 24/09/2021 12:18

@BoredZelda

She would have FELT AS IF SHE WAS FORCED. Yes, she would have been forced to make a decision, as you say. That is the point.

Which is what she should have said.

Nobody is saying she would have been held down and forcibly had the pregnancy terminated, so stop arguing against that. Get a clue and have some bloody compassion.

That is how it reads. Language around this is very important. Have some bloody compassion for the women in her situation who read that thinking someone could force them to have an abortion. Get a clue that goes beyond your narrow view and actually involves reason my responses.

I agree with this. It is how I read it too. I apologise to that poster if that was not what she meant.
BoredZelda · 24/09/2021 12:18

Lots and lots of babies have cleft palate without any other conditions - I know this as it is far more common outside the U.K. & yes I'm the U.K. many do abort cleft palate babies.

Again with the “lots” and “many” If you want to assert women are choosing to abort their babies because they won’t have a smiley baby, you need to back that up with actual facts and figures.