Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Today's ruling re Down's Syndrome

693 replies

Shirazboobaloo · 23/09/2021 21:09

Sorry to hijack AIBU for this but can someone explain this ruling to me please?

What I can't understand (from press reports) is how this has "come to this".

Who is Heidi Crowther and who are those supporting her?

I am genuinely confused but don't know where to ask

OP posts:
cloudacious · 24/09/2021 13:57

don't mind what others choose to do to be honest, but do feel very sad for the downs girl (and others like her).

Please don't call Heidi the downs girl.

The disablism on this thread is a powerful demonstration of why our society gets away with removing legal protections on the basis of disability.

IveGotASongThatllGetOnYNerves · 24/09/2021 13:53

Do you know how many women have aborted after 24 weeks and of those how many aborted for anything other than severe disabilities incompatible with life or severe disability abortion delayed by a week or two due to circumstances beyond their control? Almost none.

Anti abortionists like to focus on abortions of viable foetuses because it suits their agenda. Women murder their babies days before they are due to be born. Evil evil women. It is intended to put a very upsetting image on people's minds which can then be used to further restrict and eventually remove the right to abortion.

It is intended to provoke strong emotions against something that actually very rarely happens.

Wanting to force women to give birth to babies they do not want and do not feel able to raise would not be the victory they think it will. It will result in an increase in babies born severely disabled being given up and growing up in an overwhelmed and barely fit for purpose care system.

So let's say they win their appeal. Do they later go to court to ban people giving up severely disabled babies on the grounds that doing so when they would not surrender a non disabled child is discriminatory?

Instead of forcing women to give birth against their will they should focus on improving resources for disabled people. You can barely get respite. You have to fight for every penny of help. Social services fob you off until you reach breaking point then act like you're a terrible person.

Sort THAT out. That will make people with disabilities feel equal and valued. Not bringing unwanted babies into the world.

ThePriceIsNotRight · 24/09/2021 13:51

Correct ruling. The point is that women should have choice. What is the right decision for one person may not be the right one for another, and that needs to be respected.

ShushShushShush · 24/09/2021 13:46

@Aberteifi

I am so angry at posters who think of me and others like me who are called murderers for tfmr after 24 weeks. You have no idea what pain we have been through we did not terminate our pregnancies for fun. I wanted my son it wasn't a case of not wanting to raise him it was that i didn't want to see him suffer and struggle until he died from the condition he had. Until you have walked in our shoes i actually don't give a damn on your opinion but there are families who do care and they don't need to be hurt by mindless people who actually don't give a damn who they hurt.
Well said. It's sick. And shows a complete lack of compassion, understanding or even just basic human kindness. They have no idea of the hell that is TFMR. They should be grateful they have no idea of the hell that is TFMR.

Flowers to you and all the other mums who have shared their experiences here.

Carboncheque · 24/09/2021 13:44

I’m so sorry for your loss Flowers

FuckingFlumps · 24/09/2021 13:44

@pointythings

aberteifi Flowers

We hear you.

Some of us absolutely do hear you and will absolutely continue to hear you and ensure your voices are heard no matter how loudly those who think they know your situation better than you may protest and shout. Flowers
pointythings · 24/09/2021 13:42

aberteifi Flowers

We hear you.

Aberteifi · 24/09/2021 13:40

I am so angry at posters who think of me and others like me who are called murderers for tfmr after 24 weeks.
You have no idea what pain we have been through we did not terminate our pregnancies for fun.
I wanted my son it wasn't a case of not wanting to raise him it was that i didn't want to see him suffer and struggle until he died from the condition he had.
Until you have walked in our shoes i actually don't give a damn on your opinion but there are families who do care and they don't need to be hurt by mindless people who actually don't give a damn who they hurt.

Carboncheque · 24/09/2021 13:35

The law as it stands gives doctors and women the time and space to decide how to progress when the foetus has serious medical issues.

279 abortions were carried out after 24 weeks in the U.K. in 2019. Most of them will have been due to issues picked up on the 20 week scan where, after further testing and the opinions of consultants, the women made the decision to terminate. By the time an appointment was available they were past 24 weeks. Sometimes the consultant might say that allowing more time for the foetus to grow would allow them to give a more accurate picture of how severe a defect will be and how much would impact the future health of the foetus.

The law has worked. It’s allowed the decisions to be made by medical professionals and the women concerned, not banner waving members of the public. The majority of these women are having to terminate much wanted pregnancies because of severe and complex health issues with the foetus.

pointythings · 24/09/2021 13:30

I agree. You find out early on, you don't find out at 35 weeks or whatever.

Well, there have been no post 24 week terminations in the UK for DS for the past 10 years. So in that sense you are correct (and that clearly makes Heidi Crowter's case a proxy for eroding abortion rights).

But sometimes medical investigations for potentially very serious things do run very very late - because of delays, because of the complexity of the situation. And when in the end the woman is confronted with devastating news, in rare cases she can be very far along in her pregnancy.

Which is why the law needs to stand as it is. When it comes to abortion, I'm with Barack Obama: safe, legal and rare. I would add to that: but always an option.

Teapiggies · 24/09/2021 13:28

If there was better information about downs syndrome and more support, I bet the abortion rate would be lower.

I know what you’re getting at, but it’s also important to note that it might not be and that is just as valid. There’s no ‘acceptable rate’ of termination, only what women choose.

Brefugee · 24/09/2021 13:28

I think 24 weeks in a perfectly reasonably time frame and within that I am prochoice. For life limiting disabilities that only come to light after 24 weeks I am prochoice that abortion should be available. Down syndrome can be screened from 10 - 14 weeks so there is just no need for a termination at 30 or 40 weeks imo. It is also not life limiting. I would assume it's an extremely rare thing to happen anyway but I think it should not be possible to terminate for at this stage.

tell me you haven't read the thread without telling me you haven't read the thread...

UsedUpUsername · 24/09/2021 13:27

The suggestion that women willingly choose a late term abortion for cos they can’t be bothered to have a baby isn’t born out by the figures, or by the powerful accounts on this thread

Ok but it’s not legal to terminate a healthy fetus that far into pregnancy. You can’t do it past 24 weeks (and in practice, most places wouldn’t do it past 18-20 weeks unless something was very wrong with the baby.)

ChaToilLeam · 24/09/2021 13:26

I trust women to make the right decisions for themselves and their families.

I also wish that politicians would make better decisions regarding support for disabled people and their carers.

But even if all of that were ideal, I would still wish for women to have the right to terminate. The courts made the correct decision.

Tal45 · 24/09/2021 13:24

'Prochoice but not prochoice' is just ridiculous. It means unless you think women should be able to get an abortion at any stage for any reason, then you are not prochoice. This is bullshit.

I think 24 weeks in a perfectly reasonably time frame and within that I am prochoice. For life limiting disabilities that only come to light after 24 weeks I am prochoice that abortion should be available. Down syndrome can be screened from 10 - 14 weeks so there is just no need for a termination at 30 or 40 weeks imo. It is also not life limiting. I would assume it's an extremely rare thing to happen anyway but I think it should not be possible to terminate for at this stage.

The suggestion that Heidi must be being manipulated by prolifers because she doesn't like the thought that she could have been terminated days before she was born is so offensive. Just because people have different views from you doesn't mean they're being manipulated - or perhaps you think it's because she has a disability so she can't think for herself? Disgusting.

EnidFrighten · 24/09/2021 13:21

Funny how there's always money to fund chipping away at abortion rights, but the same people don't want to fund the support people need to raise children with disabilities.

No one waits to have a late abortion for the fun of it. I suspect any late abortion with DS involved would have another factor like relationship breakdown, another disability being detected etc. The law should allow maximum flexibility so people can choose based on their own specific circumstances.

If there was better information about downs syndrome and more support, I bet the abortion rate would be lower. People are wary of having a highly dependent child with no support, having caring responsibilities right into old age. I don't blame them.

Motorina · 24/09/2021 13:17

I don’t think a 38 week abortion is “fine”. I think it a tragedy. It’s incredibly, vanishingly rare for terminations to be undertaken that late, as the statistics given earlier in this thread show.

Late terminations happen in the context of wanted pregnancies. They are both a tragedy and the least awful of all the awful outcomes on offer.

I trust women to make these incredibly difficult decisions in consort with their medical teams and any loved ones they choose to involve.

The suggestion that women willingly choose a late term abortion for cos they can’t be bothered to have a baby isn’t born out by the figures, or by the powerful accounts on this thread.

enjoyingscience · 24/09/2021 13:16

It’s excellent that some people with downs go on to have happy and almost independent lives, and undoubtedly downs children being their families great joy. However, the story of boys like my next door neighbour, who is almost 20, non verbal, doubly incontinent, violent and completely unable to even have a short walk unassisted don’t get told. The times his mother had to take him to have multiple teeth extracted when he didn’t know what was happening, with all the pain and aftercare that involved don’t get told. Of course she loves him, but it’s a dangerous false narrative to present high functioning cases like Heidi as the norm.

Shmithecat2 · 24/09/2021 13:15

@purpleneon

Are pro-choice people fine with aborting a 37 month old foetus??

Fine isn't the right word. Because abortions are never 'fine'. But they are necessary and should be accessible. Because at 37w, there will be devastating issues that would lead to an abortion at such a late stage. I feel nothing but sadness for anyone who has to go through it. Do you think it's a glib choice some women make just because they can?

ManifestDestinee · 24/09/2021 13:15

Are pro-choice people fine with aborting a 37 month old foetus??

Are we "fine" with it? No. Do we like the idea? No. Do we think it actually happens or would happen in practice...also no.
But do we know that it is not our decision to make for others? YES.

londonrach · 24/09/2021 13:14

The ruling was correct...the lady has the choice re the pregnancy...no one else. I do see alot of patients with Ds and know I never could have a baby with Ds...not due to the LD but the horrible early demantia that often comes with Ds. My choice due to what I see at work. But everyone is different so I'm very pro choice

CatJumperTwat · 24/09/2021 13:13

Those who think women should be forced to give birth to babies they don't want - who do you propose looks after these children? Should the woman have to look after the child she doesn't want? Should they go into care, with its associated (terrible) outcomes? Are you under the illusion there are thousands of couples lined up to adopt disabled children?

Lockdownbear · 24/09/2021 13:11

Are pro-choice people fine with aborting a 37 month old foetus??

I assume you mean weeks.
Nobody would leave it that late through choice. However if the baby has had multiple strokes or something in the womb then yes I think she should be supported to make the right choice for her baby.
God love any mum given that knowledge so late that her baby is so badly damaged 💔

purpleneon · 24/09/2021 13:11

[quote Shmithecat2]@purpleneon

You can be pro choice but not agree with abortion after 24 weeks (I.e. the point that a foetus can survive on its own due to modern medicine).

No, you can't. You are not pro choice. Because you think at some point, the choice should be taken away. That is not pro choice.

Are pro-choice people fine with aborting a 37 month old foetus??

Well, there's not such thing as 37mo foetus, so probably not.Confused[/quote]
Genuine question so that I understand the parameters of what it means to be pro choice apparently LOL

Do pro choice people have to be fine with a requested abortion at 38 weeks then??

You have to think it's fine anytime before the baby gets pulled out or given birth to??

ISpyCobraKai · 24/09/2021 13:10

It doesn't matter what I would or wouldn't do, it's not up to me to decide another woman's choice, it's hers.