Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The economy has shafted millennials: now it wants their offspring too

435 replies

CarryOnNurse20 · 23/09/2021 18:44

AIBU to ask your opinion on this article?

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/sep/23/economy-millennials-children-low-birthrate?CMP=fb_cif&fbclid=IwAR1C57OgCdGCGhSr5uVLI5tRVeMCq-eNtyyxEuUiYOjYgSn5P2w3yMHQeTM

As a dreaded millennial and a mother I find it very sad and very true for a lot of people I know.

OP posts:
Oldandcobwebbed · 24/09/2021 07:10

@Pixxie7 I'm not saying that it might not have been a really good option for you, just that it might not be as much of a good option for people now.

I recognise that for different areas of the country its very different, and that in general good quality second hand stuff will last longer than cheap new stuff but that only helps if you have the money to invest in quality stuff in the first place

There certainly isn't much for free on my local area pages, there's only 3 bed frames (that aren't broken or a divan that I couldn't move without also hiring a van) in 5 miles for sale under the price of what I can get one from IKEA for. That's without figuring out how to get it in my car, and they look about ikea quality too.

Pixxie7 · 24/09/2021 07:03

Flat pack wasn’t available then so yes second hand was a lot cheaper as normally it was free.

Oldandcobwebbed · 24/09/2021 06:53

@Pixxie7
Second hand isn't always better though. I'm in a deprived area and our local Facebook market places aren't any cheaper then argos furniture etc due to the high demand for second hand

My parents that live in a wealthy area, there are some bargains to be had, but not unless I drive out of area (and incurr petrol costs) in general buying second hand doesn't save much here

chocolateorangeinhaler · 24/09/2021 06:51

I really do think we've done this for ourselves over time without realizing.

It used to be that you usually lived in the same town/ city you worked in. You could walk/cycle to work or school. So we're not reliant on having to have an extra car.
As we love having the next new thing as cheap as possible manufacturers solved this by outsourcing to cheap Far East countries where there is scant regard for wages or safety of employees. But who cares if you can get a 60" tv from tesco for £199. The same thing if made in the UK would be a much higher price due to minimum wages and other mandatory requirements employers have to do to protect employees. Would you pay £800 for a TV from a supermarket that might only last until the new must have TV arrives? No me neither. So factories have closed. Housing estates built on top of them. People have to travel further afield for jobs. Areas that do have jobs become victim to supply/demand and property prices soar. Other areas fall into decline and people can't get out.

We need to stop consuming utter junk we don't need and start paying a realistic price for things made locally, to create local jobs and level out the housing market.

Everyone's greed has caused this. It can never be blamed on one generation. But on a personal level who is prepared to shop local and only use a bike and get items repaired rather than replace or only replace when it fails totally rather than you want a bigger one or one in a different colour.

Oldandcobwebbed · 24/09/2021 06:50

As a millennial the biggest debate I have about the whole thing is that most people are out of touch with how much things cost. I'll use my Mil as a "in my day we just saved example"

People talk about 80k flats, I live in one of the most deprived areas of the South East and there's 50 things on rightmove under that within a 40 min car travel distance. Every single one is either a retirement flat, something that's not housing(eg a garage), a caravan or something that's not mortgagable eg auction properties or cash buyers only. I'm not sure why people always insist that people need to move, I could understand if we were talking a swanky area but this is a deprived area, it needs nhs staff, teachers, and people on regular wages to live here

Like most people I'm bound by a mortgage, the cheap houses without heating, kitchens etc or incredibly mouldy that people are talking about buying are either sold by auction or cash buyers as not mortgagable . Unless you can buy the whole thing out right then you don't have a chance. Mil says they bought a flat by saving and we need to lower our standards

MIL says find a doer upper. If we found a mortgagable house where the mortgage value allowed us to buy it, we would then need the money to do it up. Mil says central heating, electrics doesn't cost much her friend did hers. She was amazed at how much the estimate for those things are now. Don't get me started on how much she thinks a kitchen or bathroom might cost.

If we had lots of cash then yes we would find a rip out job but ultimately you often need large chunks of cash for it, or to buy those properties. If like me you need a 90% mortgage then its not doable

My Mil is also a fan of the "why such fancy weddings" just use a village hall type of thinking. We planned out a wedding not dissimilar to hers, and she called the venue herself because she wouldn't believe the cost and thought we must have it wrong.

I agree with previous poster that said its not about blaming other generations, it's just about asking other generations to not insist that it's because everyone under 35 is lazy, vain, buying too many avocados. Everyone's options changes I'm each generations, just like some of the options available to our grand parents werent offered to their children, and whats offered to us won't be the same offered to the generation below. Just let's not pretend that the circumstances are the same and everyone should just try harder?

Pixxie7 · 24/09/2021 06:30

The economy has shafted most people at some stage in their lives I remember when mine were young worrying about the atom bomb. We had to scrimp and save to buy somewhere to live and as pp said secondhand furniture etc.

Mummypigisalwaysright · 24/09/2021 06:10

There are many reasons why the birth rate is falling. Baby boomers were named this for a reason. My DM was one of seven children, many other families had a similar amount. Those seven children each had only two/three children each, my Second cousins are now having two/ three children each. The economy is based on population maintaining at a steady rate, with births and deaths cancelling each other out. Baby boomers had quite a few children and due to better medicine are living longer. We now have a swell in population that isn't going to decrease at the rate it should as people are living longer. Unfortunately society and the economy has had to swell to accommodate all these extra people. It makes sense that we're going to have to shrink at some point.

gofg · 24/09/2021 02:26

@Samuraisammy - just give it a rest will you! What makes you think everyone (or even anyone) wants to read dozens of your increasingly irrational posts.

OddSockReunion · 24/09/2021 01:43

[quote Samuraisammy]@OddSockReunion
Not sure what else I can say other than handbags and cuppa soup?[/quote]
Well, indeed. We'd figured that out already.

Thanks for your.... contribution 🤷🏻‍♀️🤷🏻‍♀️🙄🥱 to the conversation. 🤣

RtHonNicolaMurray · 24/09/2021 01:30

The first section of this is just your opinion stated as fact. I was lucky enough to buy my first house (my partner’s second) at 24. We had no central heating for a year, no TV for 6 months, all our furniture was second-hand from family/gifted.
One of our salaries today was equivalent to our joint earnings then, and we took a 40 year mortgage.

Millenial housing insecurity is the result of decades of piss-poor housing policy, a largely unregulated rental market, economic instability and wealth inequality. It is not a result of under-30’s not being able to live without a fucking tv.

Samuraisammy · 24/09/2021 01:25

@OddSockReunion
Not sure what else I can say other than handbags and cuppa soup?

OddSockReunion · 24/09/2021 01:15

Also we're not American. It is called mathS.

OddSockReunion · 24/09/2021 01:13

@Samuraisammy

You’re all convinced I’m a boomer when I’ve just used references of a millennial growing up. Do the math.
Lol. I suspect you just have a millenial child, given that some of the references and your language is totally off. So no, not buying it, sorry.

You even posted - as another poster pointed out - how you and your DH think young people these days should just move in with their parents and save for a house deposit or something along those lines. 😂😂

If you were of of our generation you'd be aware why that's impossible for many, even if you personally happen to be rich/ lucky/ academically able so you could dig yourself put of the hole despite the odds against it etc; unless you are just so obtuse that you cannot comprehend that many people have more challenging life circumstances than you happen to have had, and have no true friends outside of the socio-economic group that you - by chance - were born into.

Either way I feel sorry for you.

Samuraisammy · 24/09/2021 00:39

You’re all convinced I’m a boomer when I’ve just used references of a millennial growing up. Do the math.

OddSockReunion · 24/09/2021 00:37

@Samuraisammy

Not sure how many boomers would know what being a mosher/townie/scene kid/emo/chav/scallie when you watched jackass, pop world,South Park to family guy whilst playing guitar hero?? Get over yourselves!
Again, not sure what that means at all. I make many typos but this is completely unintelligible.
OddSockReunion · 24/09/2021 00:36

Well indeed. Which is why is was probably unwise to reject highly skilled, highly qualified Europeans moving here who have common cultural values with us and were also young and net taxpayers: using social housing less than British people, paying more tax than British people, using the NHS etc less than British people, and consistently making a net economic, social and industrial contribution to our economy throughout the period where we were involved in free movement in Europe. Without even going into the opportunities, rights and protections that young British people have now lost.

Those that voted for Brexit should hang their heads in shame. All of what was branded "project fear" 😂😂😂😂😂 is predictably coming to pass now.

Samuraisammy · 24/09/2021 00:33

Not sure how many boomers would know what being a mosher/townie/scene kid/emo/chav/scallie when you watched jackass, pop world,South Park to family guy whilst playing guitar hero?? Get over yourselves!

IsEveryUserNameBloodyTaken · 24/09/2021 00:31

@Nat6999

I bought my first home in 2001 & paid £34,000 for it, that house is now worth £125,000 but salaries haven't kept pace with house prices. Ds is 17, I can't ever see a time where he will be able to buy a home of his own. We are getting to a stage where we have an elderly heavy population, as elderly people are retiring there aren't young people starting work to replace them, lots of my generation have only had one child because we either chose to have children much older or because we couldn't afford to have more than one child. Until the economy is in a better state I can't see this changing. We need more young people to fill jobs & to pay taxes or the economy will eventually grind to a halt.
Exactly this re more young people to fill jobs.But sadly unless it’s a bloody good paying job,there is still too much financial pressure to house yourself.
OddSockReunion · 24/09/2021 00:30

@OddSockReunion I’m talking about you because you said you were off to bed. I meant you were off to bed with your handbag

This has to be the weirdest one of the night. Why would anybody go to bed with their handbag? The mind boggles.

imnotdrunk · 24/09/2021 00:29

@MintJulia

I have 17 millennial nephews & nieces. Only two have children (one each).

The others are working abroad, in the forces, not married, doing post-grad research, not interested in children. Five have their own homes so they have the space but mostly they are focussed on having a good time. The two who have children are the oldest. The others seem to regard children as something to do, late 30s or 40s.

None is pining for the chance to have a baby as far as I can see.

The Guardian article seems to have been written by someone from an older generation with different expectations.

This is so true! My 3 children are all late twenties and in long term relationships. They all say they want to travel, and get their houses done up first. That people don't think about babies these days until they're in their early 30s.

Two of them are home owners and saved for years while living at home. My son freely admits he'd have had loads more saved if he hadn't bought a new car and gone out most weekends with his friends. He's not bothered about his student loan he knows he wouldn't have got his job without his degree.

I told our family WhatsApp group someone on here said this generation had been f...ed over. They said no one wants to start off in a rubbish flat in a bad area, they want a nice place with nice things straightaway, and a lot of their friends blow all their salary each month and then moan they can't afford to move out.

wellards · 24/09/2021 00:29

yes it has been amusing, but i'm off to bed too now, very sleepy.

OddSockReunion · 24/09/2021 00:27

[quote wellards]@OddSockReunion the language is a bit of a giveaway [/quote]
Yep!!! Never heard a millenial say "codswallop" in my life. Hilariously bad attempt at lying. Has made me laugh a lot. 😁

OddSockReunion · 24/09/2021 00:26

[quote Samuraisammy]**@OddSockReunion* I’m talking about you because you said you were off to bed. I meant you* were off to bed with your handbag after dancing around with it for the last half an hour getting offended left right and centre :0)[/quote]
I am off to bed. Did you think that would mean I'd fall asleep instantly like a small child? Bless. I think you may have got your dates confused but millenials aren't 3 year olds. Maybe your boomer brain is getting decrepit and can't do maths anymore. 😬

wellards · 24/09/2021 00:26

Place is brimming with handbags and cuppa soups.

What does brimming with cuppa soups even mean?

Samuraisammy · 24/09/2021 00:25

@OddSockReunion some other poster rolled up their sleeves and said ‘how dare you’ and it was actually very funny to even bother to say that. Like victor Mildrew on acid.