Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The economy has shafted millennials: now it wants their offspring too

435 replies

CarryOnNurse20 · 23/09/2021 18:44

AIBU to ask your opinion on this article?

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/sep/23/economy-millennials-children-low-birthrate?CMP=fb_cif&fbclid=IwAR1C57OgCdGCGhSr5uVLI5tRVeMCq-eNtyyxEuUiYOjYgSn5P2w3yMHQeTM

As a dreaded millennial and a mother I find it very sad and very true for a lot of people I know.

OP posts:
Oldandcobwebbed · 24/09/2021 08:42

@Thisbastardcomputer
Even if you don't sell, your percentage wage going on mortgage is likely to be much less than a non boomer.

Inherited wealth just keeps money and house owning only within the reaches of certain people. Its also not a given considering the massive likely hood of care costs etc.

Oldandcobwebbed · 24/09/2021 08:40

@toconclude

It's not about blame. It's about acknowledging that each generation faces different challenges and the solution that worked for you won't always work for people now.

No one is saying you should move out of your house, just that telling people they could afford to buy your house if only they didn't have a phone, or buy Costa isn't realistic nor is telling them to try harder.

We need to be finding solutions rather than assuming other should try harder or having an "alright jack" attitude just because you housing is secure and presumably benefit from increased house prices should you sell

Thisbastardcomputer · 24/09/2021 08:39

@blubberyboo

Every generation has had its own problems

My mothers generation had to give up work when they married and didn’t get any decisions in finances. Many of them didnt know how to operate a bank account.

I was one of the first years to encounter student loans rather than grants and we were given very scant information about what it would mean.

For my first baby I was only allowed 18 weeks paid maternity and yet this article complains about the paternity leave. Paternity leave was unheard of 20+ years ago and childcare options weren’t very plentiful. We’d only started letting men into labour wards really.

Our generation had the boom and bust credit crunch on the housing market causing many of our age to spiral into debt and unemployment and losing their homes.

Earlier generations had much less quality of life but perhaps simpler times.

Every generation has had its ups and downs

This post sums it up brilliantly.

I'm of the much maligned Baby Boomer generation and yes we have done alright regarding house prices.

But whatever you sell your house for, goes into the next one, you don't get to keep the rise unless you're downsizing massively.

My accrued wealth will pass to my millennial children

Thecurliestwurly · 24/09/2021 08:37

Oh god, I see this thread has already descended into 'well when I was younger I lived in a shed and I was ok'. Many people live in damp overcrowded flats now and I'm sure when many people were in their damp flat years ago they would have expected some progress and this to be a thing of the past. I certainly would want things to change for my children.

Can we please stop blaming each other? These threads are often derailed by these sorts of comments to draw attention away from the fact that this GOVERNMENT IS SHIT. They have seen these problems coming and have done nothing and they were there way before COVID came along.

Thecurliestwurly · 24/09/2021 08:30

@chocolateorangeinhaler

Hmmm well I have my theory that this has slowly been ticking away like a time bomb since the mid 70's. Obsession over house price increases has got to the point where nobody can afford a house until in their 30s. My parents bought their first house in 72 when they were 19 & 21. That's unheard of now. Every stick of furniture was second hand and they didn't have a TV for the first six months. People nowadays wouldn't accept living like that. We've been brainwashed into being consumers with the fear that your not 'normal' unless you have the latest must have thing. The amount of people in debt because of keeping up with the Jones's is scary. Childcare is extortionate in the uk compared to other countries. Schools are over subscribed and there is the constant underlying whispers that the environment is shot and any future generations won't make it. No wonder people don't want to bring more humans into this mess.
This is pretty much it, although I love second hand furniture and clothes and don't choose to get into debt over owning new clothes. Even our TV was second hand and our first one was free and donated.

I think it is seeing older generations (not everyone) have more wealth than them. If you feel poor, you don't have kids in individualistic countries (may be different in third world countries). Birth rates have fallen in many countries and it is probably to do with declining wages, high housing and childcare costs and political uncertainty (this morning we are told fuel could be rationed now). We both have to work FT to get by and save some money for our future. We buy second hand, rarely eat out, don't go abroad, have second hand cars. We have no debt. Our household income is over 70k. If we had the same jobs and equivalent salaries 30 years ago, we would most likely have bought our property and one of us would be able to give up work and we would still be comfortable. Instead we are paying stupid money on someone else's mortgage and childcare which would be hugely subsidized in the rest of Europe. We don't even rent a massive house, So it's not because of extravagance - it's a two bed flat for a family of 4. It's shit.

toconclude · 24/09/2021 08:28

@iago

No, you don't understand. You're a boomer. Everything is your fault and because your house now has a label on it with a lot of noughts you are stinking rich, selfish and greedy even though it's the same house as when you bought it and you can't realise its value without selling.
This is now The Truth and you are not allowed to point out why it doesn't universally apply without the stunning, argument-winning riposte ' ok boomer' which instantly nixes you and your inconvenient facts.
Witness all the replies to this comment...

Annoyedanddissapointed · 24/09/2021 08:22

@JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon none shouls. I uncklicke them

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 24/09/2021 08:21

@Annoyedanddissapointed

226 of 1+ bedroom for under 80k around me.
How many are shared ownership though?
Annoyedanddissapointed · 24/09/2021 08:21

I thought you were having a conversion with yourself ffs😂 @jesus

User135644 · 24/09/2021 08:20

@Pixxie7

The economy has shafted most people at some stage in their lives I remember when mine were young worrying about the atom bomb. We had to scrimp and save to buy somewhere to live and as pp said secondhand furniture etc.
Also the 80s. Depending on your circumstances or where you grew up it was either easy money and get rich, under Thatcher, or rot away in decaying communities that have lost their industries. That's where the massive divide between rich and poor really started in modern times.
JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 24/09/2021 08:18

@jesusmaryjosephandtheweedonkey

I bought my house in "92" for 16k . It has rotting windows, no central heating, no inside bathroom, no fitted kitchen and woodchip on every wall. We sat on my aunts conservatory furniture for 2years and the first winter in the house was bloody freezing. We didn't care though as we owned our home. Very few people would live like that now days
Plenty would but there aren't the opportunities because all of those houses have been "property developed".

Most would rather own a place like yours than carry on with the insecurity of renting.

Annoyedanddissapointed · 24/09/2021 08:17

I think being childfree more is also because the pitfalls of parenting are less of a taboo. Not just work or money. It's the relentlessness, people talk about the negative sides now openly, we understand pnd better, more open about disabilities and risks, and so on and and on. We can now make informed decision. And we (well still work to be done there) aren't shamed for it as much as before. Still shamed, but it's getting better.
My mum loves us but even she admitted if she waa that age now, she probably would choose not to have kids. Or at least wait until 30s.

VestaTilley · 24/09/2021 08:10

“I wonder why women are having fewer children?” Said no woman ever.

The point about pensions is correct, but no way should women be encouraged to have more children to fix this. We’re not brood mares. The climate can’t cope with bigger populations anyway; the global population needs to shrink.

wellards · 24/09/2021 08:09

@PickUpAPepper yes I don't understand the need to deny facts. Saying that people younger than me have it harder than me or I couldn't have bought without family help doesn't mean I've had a life of luxury whilst being fed bon-bons!

Why is the default to ignore the truth & blame feckless youths?

I suppose it's like those who vote Tory thinking it will make them richer, who then realise they have less in their pocket but instead of blaming the government policies it's "them in the dinghies".

Annoyedanddissapointed · 24/09/2021 08:09

While i quite agree withoat og the post, just want to add to this that
something that's not mortgagable eg auction properties
You can get mortgage on auction properties.

CMZ2018 · 24/09/2021 08:07

What a load of nonsense

whenwillthemadnessend · 24/09/2021 08:06

I'm only 50 but got my first house at 23. It cost 35k and I earnt 11k.

No way those percentage can work now. At least not in the south east.

Average one bed 180-200k
Average salary 24-35 k

The
Math just do t work.

User135644 · 24/09/2021 08:06

They said no one wants to start off in a rubbish flat in a bad area, they want a nice place with nice things straightaway, and a lot of their friends blow all their salary each month and then moan they can't afford to move out.

A lot of people struggle to budget nowadays. Perhaps home working has shown them how to budget better. I.e. don't spend a fiver in Pret every day for lunch, don't buy a 4 pound coffee and a 2 pound cookie from Costa every morning.

But everything is more expensive now. Even a night out. Compare the relative price of a pint 40 years ago to now, or even your cab fare home. If you went to a festival like Glastonbury it wouldn't cost you the then equivalent of hundreds of pounds back in the day. Even in the early 80s you could get into any football ground for a pound or two.

And the extras needed for modern life such as smart phones. The fact things don't last nowadays. Even the smart phone starts to wear out once that two year contract ends. I remember having an old Nokia for about 5 years that cost me about 20 quid and i'd just pop a tenner in it every month or 2. That was before apps.

Anyone not earning huge money who can afford all these things is probably in unsustainable credit card debt, but that's neoliberalism. Cheap credit, spend spend spend.

PickUpAPepper · 24/09/2021 08:02

This thread is depressing in that just when you start to think that the older generations are starting to get it you read the same old bullshite on here. I thought the problem of house prices and entrenched generational inequality was pretty much accepted, as the failing economy bites further and further up the hierarchy. Unless it’s just morons trolling for sad kicks. Pixxie7 this is not just another economic downturn, there has not been a serious economic upturn for the vast majority of people in over 20 years, and that small one in the late 90s only benefitted those who were already homeowners then. I really don’t understand why people pretend not to see that tenants have to scrimp and save and do without posh furniture - and avocados - and dry unmouldy walls in order to rent. House prices have gone up exponentially for decades while wages have not.

2orangey · 24/09/2021 07:54

I feel like the media has us trapped in thinking of Millennials as young and foolish. The oldest Millenials are 40. Way past the stage of living with parents to save money. Also mature enough to (usually) make fairly sensible financial decisions.

The idea that Millennials spend all their money on going out (as a previous poster suggested) just can't be true. Surveys have shows Millennials spend less on alcohol than previous generations.

Consumer goods are also cheap now - just look at the cheapest flat screen TVs and smartphones. So cheap as to be almost disposable. Not great in terms of our throwaway culture but also not what's stopping anyone from saving a deposit.

When previous generations tell us they bought the cheapest place in their area and scrimped and saved to do it up, it's admirable but a lot of the time they aren't seeing how the world has changed. The cheapest place in many areas now is still hugely expensive compared to our stagnant wages.

Pixxie7 · 24/09/2021 07:49

Olda it was an option because it wasn’t available generally speaking it is probably comparatively speaking cheaper to furnish a house these days with essentials, shame about the same can’t be said about the house for it to go.

EatYourVegetables · 24/09/2021 07:41

This generation is the first one in ages who will have a lower life quality than their parents.

The “luxury” goods we have, eg instagramable furniture, are relatively cheap. IKEA furniture plus a can of gold contact paper is much cheaper than furniture the previous generation bought, but getting it gets the boomers going “omg you have golden furniture no wonder you can’t afford a house”.

The price of houses has gone up ridiculously (much faster than inflation) and the salaries have stayed the same (or gone down compared to inflation). It is objectively harder to buy a house because the cost-to-salary ratio.

containsnuts · 24/09/2021 07:40

[quote doublemonkey]@monkeytennis9, that doesn't surprise me but there are plenty of areas in the country with cheap housing. It's absolutey possible to get on the property ladder with a small deposit and wage.[/quote]
But getting on the property ladder means you need to be able re-sell at an increase and many 'cheap' houses are priced that way because they need expensive work or are in less desirable locations which makes that difficult. I know people trapped in 'cheap' houses, unable to renovate, unable to sell and for quality of life would have been better renting in an area they like living in, near to work, transport, good schools etc.

Pixxie7 · 24/09/2021 07:36

A lot of things that even a few years ago was considered a luxury is really now essential. An example of this is an I phone or equivalent so a family of 4 needs 4 phones, the same with computers and broadband is essential with most correspondence sent on line. These are all extra expenses before you start on luxuries.

PRsecrets · 24/09/2021 07:22

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.