Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The economy has shafted millennials: now it wants their offspring too

435 replies

CarryOnNurse20 · 23/09/2021 18:44

AIBU to ask your opinion on this article?

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/sep/23/economy-millennials-children-low-birthrate?CMP=fb_cif&fbclid=IwAR1C57OgCdGCGhSr5uVLI5tRVeMCq-eNtyyxEuUiYOjYgSn5P2w3yMHQeTM

As a dreaded millennial and a mother I find it very sad and very true for a lot of people I know.

OP posts:
wellards · 26/09/2021 07:37

I think we need to build more houses that are suitable for the ageing population eg a 1/2 bed with off street parking & garden. My mum wants to downsize but anything small is a flat.

containsnuts · 26/09/2021 06:54

Stevie77
"One of the major issues affecting the cost of housing is hoarding of housing by the older generations. Older people, and not just the very elderly, continue to live in big family homes decades after their kids have flown the nest. It stops the traffic up and down the property ladder and is a major bottle neck of property availability.

Until British people will let go of the notion that they need to hold on to houses for as long as possible to hand something down, and until younger people let go of the notion that they deserve to inherit, like it’s a right and not a privilege, nothing will change. Even the recent NI tax rise plays to this notion but the fact is that if you have an asset and need to pay for something e.g. care home fees, that asset should be used to pay for that. Alternatively, people could down size sooner, release equity and gift money earlier to their heirs."

For those who would like to downsize where are they supposed to go? Many areas do not have enough one bedroom homes (I remember this issue from the bedroom tax debacle). One bedroom homes that do exist tend to be flats, many with no parking, no lift access etc which is surely not appealing to those planning their later years.

allfurcoatnoknickers · 26/09/2021 03:16

I'm 34 and DH is 35. We bought a 2 bed 2 bath garden flat for 1.25m our next door neighbour bought his identical flat in 1989 for 80k. That's a pretty hefty price rise that's far outstripped wage growth and inflation.

I'm also baffled by this whole "millennials don't buy second hand furniture" thing. In my first flat, all my furniture was hand me downs or bought off FB marketplace. Half my furniture in my overpriced flat is second hand - we only got a new sofa because we don't have a car so couldn't go and pick up a second hand one.

JaninaDuszejko · 26/09/2021 02:08

That's ridiculous, people aren't hoarding their houses, they're just living out their years in a home they've bought and why shouldn't they??

How big a house are we allowed to have in retirement do you think? My parents build a 3 bed house with a study and 3 reception rooms (sitting room, dining room and sun room) as their retirement home, it is half the size of the old sprawling farmhouse we grew up in. But their retirement home is still larger than the average house.

imnotdrunk · 25/09/2021 20:05

@Stevie77

One of the major issues affecting the cost of housing is hoarding of housing by the older generations. Older people, and not just the very elderly, continue to live in big family homes decades after their kids have flown the nest. It stops the traffic up and down the property ladder and is a major bottle neck of property availability.

Until British people will let go of the notion that they need to hold on to houses for as long as possible to hand something down, and until younger people let go of the notion that they deserve to inherit, like it’s a right and not a privilege, nothing will change. Even the recent NI tax rise plays to this notion but the fact is that if you have an asset and need to pay for something e.g. care home fees, that asset should be used to pay for that. Alternatively, people could down size sooner, release equity and gift money earlier to their heirs.

That's ridiculous, people aren't hoarding their houses, they're just living out their years in a home they've bought and why shouldn't they??
XingMing · 25/09/2021 16:37

We like our spacious family home and have been happy here for 24 years. Now that we are planning for retirement and a move is part of that to be closer to family and friends, I've spent hours on Rightmove combing several counties for property that might suit us that we would like to live in. And frankly, there is damned little out there that appeals, and what there is will cost nearly as much as the house we're selling by the time we've paid stamp duty and done any work necessary. "Retirement" properties all seem to have teeny rooms and cottages have low ceilings, tiny rooms and smaller windows (DH is 6'5") so while there's not much on the market, we shall stay put.

ColorMagicBarbie · 25/09/2021 12:25

@Stevie77

One of the major issues affecting the cost of housing is hoarding of housing by the older generations. Older people, and not just the very elderly, continue to live in big family homes decades after their kids have flown the nest. It stops the traffic up and down the property ladder and is a major bottle neck of property availability.

Until British people will let go of the notion that they need to hold on to houses for as long as possible to hand something down, and until younger people let go of the notion that they deserve to inherit, like it’s a right and not a privilege, nothing will change. Even the recent NI tax rise plays to this notion but the fact is that if you have an asset and need to pay for something e.g. care home fees, that asset should be used to pay for that. Alternatively, people could down size sooner, release equity and gift money earlier to their heirs.

Tbh, I can understand why people don't want to move back into a semi or similar with all the associated noise etc once they've spent decades working hard to buy a bigger house. That and that fact that they've for decades worth of memories. I also understand people's frustrations, but recent generations have defo become a bit entitled in their demands of what other people should do for them. Nobody is obliged to share their wealth or move houses to help you out.
Stevie77 · 25/09/2021 12:21

One of the major issues affecting the cost of housing is hoarding of housing by the older generations. Older people, and not just the very elderly, continue to live in big family homes decades after their kids have flown the nest. It stops the traffic up and down the property ladder and is a major bottle neck of property availability.

Until British people will let go of the notion that they need to hold on to houses for as long as possible to hand something down, and until younger people let go of the notion that they deserve to inherit, like it’s a right and not a privilege, nothing will change. Even the recent NI tax rise plays to this notion but the fact is that if you have an asset and need to pay for something e.g. care home fees, that asset should be used to pay for that. Alternatively, people could down size sooner, release equity and gift money earlier to their heirs.

ColorMagicBarbie · 25/09/2021 11:34

I thought rising house prices were also a reflection of household income doubling - basic supply and demand. If so, gender equality is as much a reason as anything caused by the boomers.

Buttercup1954 · 25/09/2021 11:30

Every generation has had the same problems since the seventies. We rented when we got married in the seventies. We had no car, no phone, and had second hand furniture despite being in well paid jobs. We were told then not to have too many children because in the future the population explosion will cause mass starvation and basically the world will come to an end. We were very happy. As far as I can see today people are much better off to start with and we are still being told about not having children and how we are destroying the planet. In my opinion you should have children, save up and buy a house if that's what you want although do realise that nothing is ever easy and if you really want something you have to work really hard to get it.

CreepingDeath · 25/09/2021 11:19

@wellards

If young people want us to save the planet then they have to stop having children and buying crap. Otherwise they can shut up and let us live the lives we want to live without the "save the planet" earworm

Did you miss the part in the OP how young people aren't having children. I'm not sure they have the monopoly on buying crap either.

Agreed about the buying crap thing. I know it's only anecdotal, but my pension aged mother buys more crap than most people. Because she has the funds to do so, house paid off, a large pension that they don't ever spend all of...so she buys lot's of shopping channel crap that she doesn't even use. My parents house is filled with stuff I wouldn't dream of buying (not that I can afford it). Interestingly they grew up in an era or reusing and mending stuff, but that seems to have gone out the window!

Also, out of my aunts and uncles, my parents are the only ones not to own multiple properties. And none of them would have been considered middle class. They all had public service jobs, two of my uncles were postmen, the others worked in the civil service. But they managed to buy investment properties which are now worth a fortune.
My parents bought their house in the early 80's on one wage (my dad was not a high earner or management level, just an average worker), and supported three kids, we had several holidays abroad. That's just not possible now on an average wage, only if you are a CEO or something.

I think the thing is, while they never intended to pull up the ladder behind them, there was always an assumption that things get better for each generation. And it's a hard adjustment to realise that's not the case anymore. I guess it's always easier to level up than level down.

Things like clothes and gadgets are cheaper, but more important things like education and housing are out of more expensive or out of reach for many.

It is depressing to think that me and most of my friends may never own a home of our own, even a small one. Or if we do it will be when our parents die and we inherit, what a depressing thought. And yes, there are places for sale in various parts of the country, but there are no jobs there, certainly no career jobs, little or no public transport, terrible broadband or none at all.

usernamealreadytaken · 25/09/2021 08:48

@EatYourVegetables

www.bankofengland.co.uk/monetary-policy/inflation/inflation-calculator

According to this, £7000 in 1974 would be about £74 600 in 2020.

I don’t think there are many houses or flats you can buy today for £74 600, avocado or no avocado.

There are, if you don't live in the south east bubble. Within five miles of me, there are 40 2 bed houses or apartments for less than £80k, more if you include 1 bed or studio. Three beds start at around £70k for a fixer upper. Salaries don't get London weighting, but people can afford to buy homes here. Northwest.
gofg · 25/09/2021 04:37

Then they bought up all the houses and became landlords, charged extortionate rents, and completely wrecked the housing market for future generations. As the predominant policy makers, they allowed rents to rise extortionately, and failed to build more houses as they were benefitting from all the rental income

Bloody hell, I wish someone had told me I’d done all that. I thought I just owned the house I live in.

I wish someone had told me I'd done all that too. Why have I been renting for the past 20 years when I actually "bought up all the houses and became landlords"?

ArblemarchTFruitbat · 25/09/2021 01:25

@Peoniesandpeaches

ArblemarchTFruitbat You perhaps missed the part where I said coveted senior roles (although if you want to talk pensions we could go into how millennials have been more shafted by that too.) I’m not talking about the near minimum wage worker but higher earning senior posts like head of department, chief executive, director type posts. It’s why there are so many jokes about “entry level job only 3-5 years of experience needed.”
Yes, sorry, I wasn't talking about the coveted senior roles.

I don't disagree that millennials have it worse than gen x on the whole.

Peoniesandpeaches · 25/09/2021 01:07

ArblemarchTFruitbat You perhaps missed the part where I said coveted senior roles (although if you want to talk pensions we could go into how millennials have been more shafted by that too.) I’m not talking about the near minimum wage worker but higher earning senior posts like head of department, chief executive, director type posts. It’s why there are so many jokes about “entry level job only 3-5 years of experience needed.”

Mamanyt · 25/09/2021 00:32

Personally, I think that unless drastic changes are made NOW, world-wide, by the mid-2050s we will have lost most of our ability to grow food, our air and water quality will be abysmal, and it won't much matter.

ColorMagicBarbie · 25/09/2021 00:27

@Gingerandlemont

To be fair its the boomers in charge of policy that attract most of the anger. And the ones with the vile "everyone is just jealous of our money" attitude that *@ColorMagicBarbie* has.

Yes, most would choose to get ahead given the chance but there are plenty of ways to get rich without trampling over the basic human rights (ie somewhere to live) of others.

Boomers as a generation do seem to show a staggering lack of empathy towards younger generations (eg "if you cant afford a house just don't buy a new iphone" kind of comments). And many do seem ridiculously entitled (But I'm entitled to multiple properties because I WANT THEM FOR MY OWN FINANCIAL WELLBEING!!) Although realise not all are like this.

I'm actually a millennial lol.

I just recognise that boomers grew up in a much tougher world where you had to stand on your own two feet and couldn't call the police if somebody offends you online. Testosterone levels in men have been dropping for decades too. I seem to remember that there was a double figure % decrease from '60s to '80s, and then almost 20% again from '80s to early '00s. Highly likely it's dropped again in last 20 years.

This could well have an impact as it affects men's drive, which is why CEOs are repeatedly shown in studies to have high testosterone levels.

Nogardenersworld · 24/09/2021 23:10

Boomers had free education, cheap housing, jobs and benefits galore
Now all we hear is that ‘interest rates on mortgages were high though’
So what?! There have been countless studies showing that financially millennials are and will continue to be worse off than boomers.

We don’t care that you had it easier than us, we care that you had so much privilege and now you’re completely ignorant to it and think you got where you are completely because of your own excellence.
…all whilst confusing us with generation Z
And blaming us owning a phone and a tv on the fact we don’t have 25k (the deposit needed for an average Uk house)
which shows some truly terrible maths skills

Gingerandlemont · 24/09/2021 22:33

To be fair its the boomers in charge of policy that attract most of the anger. And the ones with the vile "everyone is just jealous of our money" attitude that @ColorMagicBarbie has.

Yes, most would choose to get ahead given the chance but there are plenty of ways to get rich without trampling over the basic human rights (ie somewhere to live) of others.

Boomers as a generation do seem to show a staggering lack of empathy towards younger generations (eg "if you cant afford a house just don't buy a new iphone" kind of comments). And many do seem ridiculously entitled (But I'm entitled to multiple properties because I WANT THEM FOR MY OWN FINANCIAL WELLBEING!!) Although realise not all are like this.

Blossomtoes · 24/09/2021 22:19

Then they bought up all the houses and became landlords, charged extortionate rents, and completely wrecked the housing market for future generations. As the predominant policy makers, they allowed rents to rise extortionately, and failed to build more houses as they were benefitting from all the rental income

Bloody hell, I wish someone had told me I’d done all that. I thought I just owned the house I live in.

XingMing · 24/09/2021 22:19

There are very hard decisions to be made in every generation. But they are different for every generation.

XingMing · 24/09/2021 22:14

I'm a tail end boomer. I didn't come from a wealthy family and my divorced parents are still alive. I have inherited £400 from one grandparent and £3000 from the other grandparents. Everything I see around me I have earned from my own work and my partner's. When I bought a tiny one bed flat at 31, with the deposit I commuted from a pension fund accrued in overseas employment, I paid 9% or more for 15 years on the mortgage. I have one child, born when I was 42.

No sympathy asked or expected, simply some recognition that every generation endures and lives through different difficulties. Boomer generation has not intended to make life tough, but if you want to be microscopically analytical, the generation that were born just before 1935 have missed a lot of the tempests.

ColorMagicBarbie · 24/09/2021 22:07

Tbf, isn't it due to the commonplace situation of both partners now working that people can no longer buy a house on one salary? I'm sure this has changed since the boomers days.

ColorMagicBarbie · 24/09/2021 22:04

@Gingerandlemont

This article is so true.

It’s really hard not to hate the boomers sometimes. They bought their own houses cheaply and had a free uni education. Then they bought up all the houses and became landlords, charged extortionate rents, and completely wrecked the housing market for future generations. As the predominant policy makers, they allowed rents to rise extortionately, and failed to build more houses as they were benefitting from all the rental income.

But if millennials dare complain about working the longest hours in Europe just to pay extortionate rents to live in a tiny flat share, they call us snowflakes and tell us to stop wasting our money on avocado toast.

You’re basically screwed in this country unless you have rich parents or a very high paid job. I’m sure there are many out there who would love a baby but just don’t think they can afford one - it’s heartbreaking.

Bastards! How dare they put their financial wellbeing above that of strangers! You know loads of people would still do it of they could. They're just annoyed they can't.
Gingerandlemont · 24/09/2021 21:47

@XingMing actually she couldn't be more right about Boomers. (I disagree about the war generation).

I doubt the boomers will ever pay for the damage they have caused though. That will be for the younger generations to do.

Swipe left for the next trending thread