Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The economy has shafted millennials: now it wants their offspring too

435 replies

CarryOnNurse20 · 23/09/2021 18:44

AIBU to ask your opinion on this article?

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/sep/23/economy-millennials-children-low-birthrate?CMP=fb_cif&fbclid=IwAR1C57OgCdGCGhSr5uVLI5tRVeMCq-eNtyyxEuUiYOjYgSn5P2w3yMHQeTM

As a dreaded millennial and a mother I find it very sad and very true for a lot of people I know.

OP posts:
PickUpAPepper · 23/09/2021 22:21

Im not quite sure what the aim of that barb is. Part of it is local increase, part is immigration. There will be more as lands become unlivable due to climate change. Lots of good reasons for humans to not render more land uninhabitable via war, but conflicts increase as pressure grows.

User135644 · 23/09/2021 22:18

[quote blubberyboo]@chocolateorangeinhaler

I agree with the furniture thing. People used to scrimp a deposit and then begged and took donations of everything from second hand crockery to big furniture. Nothing matched and it was just the way to start out.
You moved in and decorated a room at a time or not!

Now everyone wants an Instagramable house Mrs Hinch style. And weddings in the tens of thousands.[/quote]
It's Thatcher's Britain.

A consumer society built on cheap credit, only without the social housing (they were sold off along with everything else)

Lanique · 23/09/2021 22:15

@PickUpAPepper good point, yes there's definitely a difference from one end of a generation to the other. I was born five years before the end of Gen X and admittedly just just got onto the property ladder months before the boom really hit houses in our area. Many of my older friends who are now in their early to mid fifties have second homes because they were able to buy a flat or a house, often in now highly desirable parts of London, on a single salary, and then met their partner who also owned a London property on a single salary.

Student loans existed when I was a student but only for living, tuition fees were introduced soon after. Grants were just being phased out but until then had allowed our older friends even greater privileges.

My dsil and our niece are at opposite ends of the Millenial generation and because dsil married someone with a house (a Gen-Xer Smile) and a good job she lives a far different life to our niece who is really struggling to get on the housing ladder but likes her avocados.

So in conclusion I guess we shouldn't make sweeping generalisations!

wellards · 23/09/2021 22:13

@PickUpAPepper but you understand why the UKs population has increased don't you?

wellards · 23/09/2021 22:11

So I am not entirely convinced that Generation x and Millenials are much worse off.

Well you could just read up on the stats. Why is the benchmark not dying in the war?

Agadorsparticus · 23/09/2021 22:10

The generation blame game is unhelpful and just causes resentment.

We just have to deal with what we are given and make the most of what we can.

PickUpAPepper · 23/09/2021 22:09

And yet the world population (and the UK’s) rises, seemingly unstoppable. In 1976 U.K. was 56 million.

XingMing · 23/09/2021 22:08

I bought a one-bed flat in 1987 that was a cheapo conversion from a large terraced house in Kilburn, which was still IRA fundraiser territory I didn't dare venture near a pub but the Jubilee Line was extended there and so it became a cheap option to live centrally while working in the centre of The City. And now, you'd be spending £350k to live there.

wellards · 23/09/2021 22:08

@DukeOfEarlGrey I was confusing X with Y

AutistGoth · 23/09/2021 22:08

I'm a Millennial. For me, it isn't so much that I begrudge earlier generations for having it easier (and several other people are correct when they say that earlier generations had their own problems too), it's the fact that it is fashionable in the media to blame Millennials for not being able to afford their own house, be in a worse position than their parents etc. If earlier generations would admit that most people born post 1980s simply won't be able to afford things that they could because of rising prices and lack of job stability, I wouldn't mind. But instead, we're simply portrayed as selfish, childish and lazy. That attitude (which doesn't come from all previous generations, I agree) is what really upsets and angers me.

We can't afford a mortgage and children because rising house prices, lack of employment, low wages and the fact that jobs for life aren't really a thing any more. Not because of avocados and smartphones!

Speaking of smartphones, when they first were introduced, nobody needed them. Then, for better or worse, society changed so they became necessary. Look at how many apps we had to download to get out of lockdown. We couldn't enter a building without scanning a code, and you can't scan a code without a smartphone. That's just one example of course, but it is indicative of how society changes to create a demand: that is, the demand fir consumers to buy smartphones and make money for the tech industry.

As for me, my smartphone was a freebie to say thank you to my DH for staying with his mobile company since 2001. I got it in 2017 and I'll be keeping it until it dies. I can't afford to replace it, so I'll probably have to go back to a "dumb phone." Though I can't say I'd mind all that much.

wellards · 23/09/2021 22:07

@PickUpAPepper birth rates are reducing in lots of countries but it does need to be managed.

SusanBAnthony999 · 23/09/2021 22:06

If I were a millennial I would definitely feel hard done by compared to the earlier generations. I'm so lucky I had a free university education

I was chatting to a woman born in 1928 today. She is currently in a care home costing her £5000+ per month. She and her family lived in a small house near Manchester when she was born. She saw three of her siblings die of childhood diseases pre penicillin, NHS etc. Her father had been injured in WW1 and her oldest brother was killed in WW2. Their home was destroyed by bombing in WW2 and they spent several years living in one room together. It was almost impossible to access further and higher education if you were a woman however clever you were. She did benefit from the foundation of the NHS and she has benefited from house price growth over the years. But since she has been in care for 4 years now almost all of that money is gone.

So I am not entirely convinced that Generation x and Millenials are much worse off.

DukeOfEarlGrey · 23/09/2021 22:04

@wellards

Gen X are the ones before millennials? I think they still did ok, or perhaps it's just the ones I know as they managed to buy a house in time.
The Gen X / Millennial cusp is approx. 1980.

I was born in 1980 and was hit by student debt and sky rocketing house prices after graduation, followed by the global financial crash and a shocking job market. My brother is only 2 years older and university fees were nothing like the same for him - I'm not sure he even had to pay tuition fees! My sister is 5 years older and house prices were nothing like the same for her.

Having said that, I do find the later-born Millennials that I meet in the workplace to live up to the precious stereotype. I buckled down, accented the grim economy and worked my ass off to scrape together a deposit and buy a small flat in my early 30s. The younger colleagues in my workplace have a massive sense of entitlement that I find really hard to swallow. I was a great protestor against the precious Millennial stereotype until I worked with them!

PickUpAPepper · 23/09/2021 22:03

It’s generally estimated that the feeding capacity of the land is round abput 40-50 million. That might be a reasonable aim for us. Two provisos are that as land gets flooded by the sea that will drop a little, and I’m not sure how quickly we should aim to drop it. The ageing population is going to have it a lot tougher than the baby boomers did.

It really doesn’t matter how we manage it, as it’s not a matter for choice. Populations will be reducing either way. Political decisions should have been made with that in mind for the last 40 years as that is how long we have known. The globalist madness should never have happened. Blame the fools in power then, not me.

katnyps · 23/09/2021 22:03

It's also not all by choice - fertility rates have been steadily declining since the 70s - interesting article about that recently to do with phthalates showing that if sperm counts reduce at the same rate going forward (and nothing to indicate that the trend is slowing) then the majority of conceptions in the 2040s will have to be by IVF - that's frightening

JaninaDuszejko · 23/09/2021 22:02

There's about 100 properties in my town under £80K, including 3 bedroomed houses. Most people at work buy a house within a couple of years of graduating. Prices in the SE are overinflated but that doesn't mean the whole country is the same.

wellards · 23/09/2021 22:02

@worrybutterfly it's unsavoury but it's true. Why would you want older, ill people who are retired over young workers? It's not sustainable.

CaribouCarafe · 23/09/2021 22:01

I broadly agree with the article OP. I'm a late millenial (born 1994) so have been hit with the £9k per year university tuition fees as well, which has been a lovely extra bonus to the whole shitshow.

Throughout the entirety of my schooling I was taught about the damage we do to the environment and one teacher in particular used to tell us with glee that "In 20 years time you'll all be walking around in gas masks because the world will be uninhabitable." I've wrestled with the ethics of having a baby as a consequence ever since I was a kid myself, but ultimately have decided to try. But...turns out my DH and I aren't the most fertile couple in the world either (and there's been studies showing that infertility has increased for both men and women over the past couple of generations - seemingly also related to damage we've done to the environment).

On top of that, my DH and I couldn't even bring ourselves to thinking about having a baby earlier due to issues such as the job market, high rent costs relative to income (even though we were flat sharing), and student debt. It's only since we emigrated that it became an option for us.

Raising a deposit in the UK if you live in the South or in a city such as Edinburgh is really difficult without getting help from family. Certain jobs are clustered around places where the living costs are higher - even with a 1 hour commute the rent can be eating up a healthy portion of your income.

People like to assume we're all the same Insta hyper-consumerists, but the reality is that the majority of us probably have spent a large portion of our 20s in mould-infested, dodgy apartments, spending at least 25% of our pre-tax income on rent. Gadgets are relatively cheap compared to that, can be inherited/bought second hand for a reasonable price, and provide a respite from what seems like an otherwise pretty depressing predicament.

I have absolutely no hope of there being an NHS, pensions, or adequate social care by the time I hit retirement. It does get grating to hear older generations try and offer 'helpful advice' when their own situations seemed much less bleak. It's completely irritating for them to fixate on the few luxuries we do enjoy, whilst also overlooking all the challenges we have that they did not.

worrybutterfly · 23/09/2021 21:59

@PickUpAPepper

We need the birth rate to decline because there are too many humans on the planet. The sector of the population that like cheap immigrants don’t like that as it might lead to pressure to return rights and wages to decent living levels. The ecological limits just kinda might possibly take priority over their insane levels of ego and greed by just a teeny-tiny little bit.
From a very western point of view....

Environmentally we need global population to decrease. Economically we need the younger working population to increase.

To put it bluntly the only solution that suits both is for life expectancy to drop or stagnate.

Disclaimer: I'm not saying we should kill anyone off, I'm just pointing out an unpleasant truth.

Moneysavvymam · 23/09/2021 21:57

@chocolateorangeinhaler

Hmmm well I have my theory that this has slowly been ticking away like a time bomb since the mid 70's. Obsession over house price increases has got to the point where nobody can afford a house until in their 30s. My parents bought their first house in 72 when they were 19 & 21. That's unheard of now. Every stick of furniture was second hand and they didn't have a TV for the first six months. People nowadays wouldn't accept living like that. We've been brainwashed into being consumers with the fear that your not 'normal' unless you have the latest must have thing. The amount of people in debt because of keeping up with the Jones's is scary. Childcare is extortionate in the uk compared to other countries. Schools are over subscribed and there is the constant underlying whispers that the environment is shot and any future generations won't make it. No wonder people don't want to bring more humans into this mess.
Hey! we lived like that for longer. Years and years longer. Except we were doing it to rent rather than own Hmm
wellards · 23/09/2021 21:57

so not do.

wellards · 23/09/2021 21:57

@Samuraisammy do it's got nothing to do with wage stagnation & increased house prices 🤔

wellards · 23/09/2021 21:56

@PickUpAPepper what do you think it should decline to in the UK?

How do you suggest we manage the ageing population?

"In 50 years there are projected to be an additional 8.6 million people aged 65 years and over – a population roughly equivalent to the size of London"
"By 2030, one in five people in the UK (21.8%) will be aged 65 or over"

Samuraisammy · 23/09/2021 21:55

@wellards but why are people FTB at 34? I know far more people that don’t stay at home and save for a deposit, they move out and rent or move in together and rent. Then no wonder there’s not much money left at the end of each month as rent is so high. I understand not everyone is in a position to stay at their parents home and save but most take the initiative not to unless they’ve had to boomerang back.

SandraGreen · 23/09/2021 21:55

No @WatchMyChops,

Gen Z people will have been born between 1997 and 2012
Before them are Millenials born between 1981 and 1996.
Before them Gen X born 1965 and 1980
Before them, Baby Boomers

The youngest Generation, born since 2013 are known as Generation Alpha.