Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The economy has shafted millennials: now it wants their offspring too

435 replies

CarryOnNurse20 · 23/09/2021 18:44

AIBU to ask your opinion on this article?

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/sep/23/economy-millennials-children-low-birthrate?CMP=fb_cif&fbclid=IwAR1C57OgCdGCGhSr5uVLI5tRVeMCq-eNtyyxEuUiYOjYgSn5P2w3yMHQeTM

As a dreaded millennial and a mother I find it very sad and very true for a lot of people I know.

OP posts:
Flyingantday · 23/09/2021 22:51

@ColorMagicBarbie

Surely an exponentially rising birth rate can't be a good thing. A couple has two kids, who each have two kids, who also have kids. Where does it end?

People usually answer that we need people to care for the elderly, but we will continue need more and more and more.

What you describe isn’t exponential as people don’t live forever. Replacement is just over 2 live births per woman. Currently in the U.K. birth rate is around 1.7 births per woman which would put population in decline. Our population is however growing due to increased life expectancy and immigration.
LobsterNapkin · 23/09/2021 22:49

Higher education is another element. There are loans that need to be paid back, but even apart from that there is the fact that while you are in higher education, you are not working in a way that does much more than pay for basics. You can't save. And more and more people are getting degrees, and multiple ones, so they are putting off working productivity later and later.

We sold our house about a year ago and one of the things I noticed that was really interesting was that all of the younger people looking to buy were in trades. There were a few younger men, under 25, who had been working for five years or so and had managed to save enough for a deposit. Most of my university friends at that age were finishing up masters degrees or just getting their legs in a professional job.

If we stopped the requirement for degrees in a lot of jobs where it really isn't necessary, it might make a significant difference to the number of people who could be buying homes in their 20s.

User135644 · 23/09/2021 22:48

@wellards

I don't disagree about those points. The population issue will likely lead to a big decline in our living standards and the west losing dominance with younger countries becoming more powerful. The rich will be fine though, there will just be less for the rest of us.
It's telling that many of the countries that have been worst hit by Covid (such as our own) are the one with ageing populations. Compared to, say, Africa.
Speakuptomakeyourselfheard · 23/09/2021 22:48

We actually moved out of the area where our parents lived, in order to be able to afford to buy, and that was back in 1977. Our first place was a semi detached 2 bed bungalow, in Northamptonshire, cost £7,700. I have 3 grandkids, and they wouldn't DREAM of moving out of the area to buy a home. I can't help wondering how many youngsters would be prepared to do that to get started on the ladder??

wellards · 23/09/2021 22:47

I don't disagree about those points. The population issue will likely lead to a big decline in our living standards and the west losing dominance with younger countries becoming more powerful. The rich will be fine though, there will just be less for the rest of us.

AutistGoth · 23/09/2021 22:47

That’d take a couple around 2 years to hard save a 10% deposit of their wages whilst living at parents but no.

Parents are within their rights to tell their adult children to leave. Not every parent is prepared to have their adult child living at home. I know that we'd like to think that no loving parent would ever do that, but the reality is, that's not true. And the law is on their side. Once a child reaches their 18th birthday, their parents have no obligation to provide them with a roof over their heads any more.

SirSamuelVimes · 23/09/2021 22:45

[quote blubberyboo]@chocolateorangeinhaler

I agree with the furniture thing. People used to scrimp a deposit and then begged and took donations of everything from second hand crockery to big furniture. Nothing matched and it was just the way to start out.
You moved in and decorated a room at a time or not!

Now everyone wants an Instagramable house Mrs Hinch style. And weddings in the tens of thousands.[/quote]
Well, this is basically what dh and I have done. We rented for years but unfurnished, all our furniture was second hand from eBay or charity shops or donated from family. Never had anything but an old car, bought in cash for about 2k.

We could still only buy because I inherited enough money for a deposit.

Four years into house ownership, most of our furniture is still the second hand stuff we bought years ago. Did buy ourselves new sofas with an unexpected tax rebate, and have bought the kids' beds new (but cheap - Argos and IKEA). Decorating is probably averaging 1 room a couple of years.

PickUpAPepper · 23/09/2021 22:45

@wellards, my apologies then. It can be an emotive subject. To be perfectly honest at this point I am suggesting nothing about the fact that people are living longer. As I said, the decisions should have been taken 40 years ago. I am tired of the way the greed and ego of the rich - the seriously rich, who bought up dozens of homes in a nation with an acknowledged shortfall of a million - has been allowed to shaft all of us.

MarieKlepto · 23/09/2021 22:44

It's a really complicated situation in some ways. Of 1026 properties for sale, there are 10, yep, just 10, properties in my city (top 5 most expensive UK - and it's not London) sub £80k. Five are garages, one is a 25% share, and four are retirement flats. The two newest neighbours bought in their 30s (for a few times over that £80k), neither with parental help, both single, but they have really good jobs (yes, we're friendly neighbours, they offered this information!). No way could the backbone of the city (admins, various operating roles, etc) be able to afford this on their own without help. Even ex-council "right to buy" 1 beds in really crime ridden areas are pushing £200k. Those areas should be safe and affordable (as some were not so many years ago).

Samuraisammy · 23/09/2021 22:43

@wellards Did you not read the first part where I said I understand it’s difficult for those already renting???

Lightisnotwhite · 23/09/2021 22:43

@wellards

I worry about the ageing population, the NI hike is just not going to cut it & that's now. In 30 yrs there will be fewer young people.

I think it's ridiculous that a 20 something has to pay ££££ for university & yes they don't have to go but employers need to stop making degrees pre requisites. Then pay ££££ whilst they save ££££ for a house with a 30 yr mortgage. They also should pay ££££ into a pension scheme which is less favourable to them & look forward to a state pension at 70? Plus the NHS won't be free at the point of care or free prescriptions over 60 in 20 years time.

I'm lucky mine are European so they have some chance of making a better future & I would encourage any young person to look abroad but than that compounds the issue with an ageing population.

They don’t pay ££££ though. They ( and I) pay a small bit a month towards it. Why should someone whose job doesn’t gave a degree as a prerequisite such as a care worker or retail staff use their taxes to fund my job. Less humans are no bad thing. They’ll cope.
wellards · 23/09/2021 22:41

For young couples today, firstly no one gets engaged until they’ve had a dog together for 5 bloody years, then they decide it’s okay to pool wages to save. So yes it’s got a lot to do with people’s commitment to want to knuckle down together and save for a purpose.

But what are you basing this on? anecdotal evidence about people you know? I don't doubt some don't save or live lavishly but the majority? If I was paying rent I'd have no money for such luxuries as it's about 3x my mortgage.

User135644 · 23/09/2021 22:40

It's called Planned Obsolescence - a policy of planning or designing a product with an artificially limited useful life or a purposely frail design

It's called Capitalism.

wellards · 23/09/2021 22:38

Birth rates for Europe and Asia are below replacement rate, at this time of writing, so (in theory), the global population is set to stabilise or even shrink. A lot depends on what happens on the African continent.

Yes

"And 23 nations - including Spain and Japan - are expected to see their populations halve by 2100."

Also China reversing their policy & pushing for 3 children will have a big impact.

Samuraisammy · 23/09/2021 22:37

@wellards absolutely not, for those that have found themselves renting to save for a deposit I completely understand how that’s tough.
For young couples today, firstly no one gets engaged until they’ve had a dog together for 5 bloody years, then they decide it’s okay to pool wages to save. So yes it’s got a lot to do with people’s commitment to want to knuckle down together and save for a purpose.
There literally over ten flats/terraces in my good area from 130-140 grand. And there’s even more for less than that in slightly sh!tter but still okay areas nearby.
That’d take a couple around 2 years to hard save a 10% deposit of their wages whilst living at parents but no. Let’s take an instagram holiday to Singapore, attend 2 hen dos, 3 stag dos, a wedding in Greece, and a sh!ting holiday to Disneyland.

PattyPan · 23/09/2021 22:36

I am on the young end of millennial, born in 1995. I was talking to a friend recently who went to private school and is now a very high earner and he was saying the fees for his alma mater have gone up enormously even since the time he was there and he doesn’t know who can afford it now. I think it’s definitely harder to provide our children with the standard of living our parents provided for us, which makes me nervous as my parents had a lot of debt to finance their lifestyle. I would never have more than two children on environmental grounds, but I’ll probably only have one on financial grounds, despite DP and I both being highly educated professionals. I have no idea how people on low incomes can afford to have multiple children.

User135644 · 23/09/2021 22:36

@ColorMagicBarbie

Surely an exponentially rising birth rate can't be a good thing. A couple has two kids, who each have two kids, who also have kids. Where does it end?

People usually answer that we need people to care for the elderly, but we will continue need more and more and more.

The real problem is higher life expectancy (in terms of these logistics). The average person lives too long now.

Therefore, we need a bigger working age population, which will either come from high birth rates or mass immigration. The problem at that point is overpopulation.

LobsterNapkin · 23/09/2021 22:35

@Hollyhead

The 1970s flat price is irrelevant without considering interest rates, so if the equivalent price of a flat would now be 74000, assuming interest of 8% the repayment equivalent on a 25 year mortgage would be 540 per month - which is very similar to if you had a £150000 mortgage now which would be typical for a starter flat outside the SE. It’s the deposit which is crippling for people now, not so much the actual repayments once you’ve got enough together. I would bring back 100% mortgages but for a lower multiple of salary - maybe minimum wage (because you can always pick up minimum wage) * 3 or something. It would really help people in very poor areas.
My in-laws in the early 80s had a 21% interest rate on their mortgage!

The switch to the two-income family has also had an impact both on salaries and housing prices, unfortunately. It seems like a nasty trick, you thought you'd double your income and instead you give your employer twice the productivity but retain the same purchasing power. Which is hardest, of course, on the people who are in jobs that don't pay enough to get by alone.

MondieBee · 23/09/2021 22:35

@AutistGoth

I'm a Millennial. For me, it isn't so much that I begrudge earlier generations for having it easier (and several other people are correct when they say that earlier generations had their own problems too), it's the fact that it is fashionable in the media to blame Millennials for not being able to afford their own house, be in a worse position than their parents etc. If earlier generations would admit that most people born post 1980s simply won't be able to afford things that they could because of rising prices and lack of job stability, I wouldn't mind. But instead, we're simply portrayed as selfish, childish and lazy. That attitude (which doesn't come from all previous generations, I agree) is what really upsets and angers me.

We can't afford a mortgage and children because rising house prices, lack of employment, low wages and the fact that jobs for life aren't really a thing any more. Not because of avocados and smartphones!

Speaking of smartphones, when they first were introduced, nobody needed them. Then, for better or worse, society changed so they became necessary. Look at how many apps we had to download to get out of lockdown. We couldn't enter a building without scanning a code, and you can't scan a code without a smartphone. That's just one example of course, but it is indicative of how society changes to create a demand: that is, the demand fir consumers to buy smartphones and make money for the tech industry.

As for me, my smartphone was a freebie to say thank you to my DH for staying with his mobile company since 2001. I got it in 2017 and I'll be keeping it until it dies. I can't afford to replace it, so I'll probably have to go back to a "dumb phone." Though I can't say I'd mind all that much.

Exactly this. Of course other generations had it worse in some areas too. But don't insist you could afford a house in 1970 when you were 18 because you worked hard and we didn't.

And all this bullshit that the reason young people struggle is because they buy brand new furniture and tech is just so much rubbish. Yeah, it's buying a new sofa on credit that stopped them getting a house on one wage at 21 Hmm seriously though I know no one like that. I am not unusual among my friends. I am 33, still renting. We have had secondhand furniture since we lived together. Our TV was given to us in 2013 by a friend who was emigrating. Our phones are old, off contract on sim only plans. We each need a car for work, his is 21 years old and mine is 13 years old. We have (God forbid us going for luxuries) broadband and Netflix. Our dishwasher is secondhand, our washing machine is financed after our secondhand one died, our fridge freezer is second hand. I switch for the cheapest of everything all the time. Our bloody bathroom sink was bought off Facebook marketplace. Yet our rent, bills and essential outgoings (groceries, fuel) are about 75% of our income, before buying kids clothes or trying to save. And that's only because our landlord is an acquaintance who hasn't raised rent in 5 years. If he was charging us what he could it would be about £250 a month more. Tell me again how I'm just feckless and if I worked hard I'd bloody be able to afford stuff. We both work hard in professional/skilled jobs.

User135644 · 23/09/2021 22:34

My DC are Gen Z - 24 and 21, and both plan to have children. How they will afford it I just don't know

For years we've heard it said "don't have kids if you can't afford them".
People stop having kids. "The birthrate is too low".

Or "we're going to need more immigration for labour shortages". "We voted to leave the EU to cut down on immigration, we can't be having more."

TheABC · 23/09/2021 22:33

@PickUpAPepper

And yet the world population (and the UK’s) rises, seemingly unstoppable. In 1976 U.K. was 56 million.
"Unstoppable", mostly because we are all living longer which is (mostly) good thing. However, the traditional retirement plan simply isn't going to happen for my generation (millennial).

Birth rates for Europe and Asia are below replacement rate, at this time of writing, so (in theory), the global population is set to stabilise or even shrink. A lot depends on what happens on the African continent.

wellards · 23/09/2021 22:30

@PickUpAPepper it's not a barb

I said birth rates are reducing in lots of countries & you replied And yet the world population (and the UK’s) rises, seemingly unstoppable

Birth rates have reduced dramatically in many countries, that doesn't necessarily equal a reduction in population growth because much is driven by people living longer. I'm not sure what you are saying we should do about the fact people are living longer?

ColorMagicBarbie · 23/09/2021 22:29

Surely an exponentially rising birth rate can't be a good thing. A couple has two kids, who each have two kids, who also have kids. Where does it end?

People usually answer that we need people to care for the elderly, but we will continue need more and more and more.

AutistGoth · 23/09/2021 22:28

I'm lucky mine are European so they have some chance of making a better future & I would encourage any young person to look abroad but than that compounds the issue with an ageing population.

Well, I for one would love to leave the UK and live and work elsewhere but that route has been largely closed off to English and Welsh Millennials/Gen Z too because of Brexit.

wellards · 23/09/2021 22:24

I have quite a few colleagues & school mum friends who are in there mid 40s upwards who have quite a few properties despite not earning mega bucks. There was also the fact lending criteria changed after 08 which tightened things up & BTLs were more profitable in the past plus SD tax changes. My neighbour has 11 BTLs!