Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The economy has shafted millennials: now it wants their offspring too

435 replies

CarryOnNurse20 · 23/09/2021 18:44

AIBU to ask your opinion on this article?

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2021/sep/23/economy-millennials-children-low-birthrate?CMP=fb_cif&fbclid=IwAR1C57OgCdGCGhSr5uVLI5tRVeMCq-eNtyyxEuUiYOjYgSn5P2w3yMHQeTM

As a dreaded millennial and a mother I find it very sad and very true for a lot of people I know.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
OddSockReunion · 01/10/2021 12:56

[quote Samuraisammy]@Annoyedanddissapointed it’s not people I hate, it’s people are more showy or lavish in really daft ways these days and are too selfish to see how much it costs others to partake with or too blind/self absorbed in their online image to see how tiring it’s made you on the day/occasion. It’s a circus for the cameras, a big fancy competitive circus.[/quote]
If you feel like this about them, why do you remain in contact with them?

OddSockReunion · 01/10/2021 12:55

@Samuraisammy

No perhaps Melissa needs to not pull a face because I won’t dance to snow patrol because I’m shattered after having to drive across and stay over at a hotel for a badly ventilated reception space with bad chairs but ooooh the lighting and oooh it’s a fairytale barn and ooooh hash tag be11 end.
Wow. You sound like so much fun. I hope your friends are equally enthusiastic about celebrating/ supporting you through big life events.
dualteaching · 01/10/2021 12:39

@Speakuptomakeyourselfheard

We actually moved out of the area where our parents lived, in order to be able to afford to buy, and that was back in 1977. Our first place was a semi detached 2 bed bungalow, in Northamptonshire, cost £7,700. I have 3 grandkids, and they wouldn't DREAM of moving out of the area to buy a home. I can't help wondering how many youngsters would be prepared to do that to get started on the ladder??
@Speakuptomakeyourselfheard, it depends on whether there are jobs available elsewhere. Often the areas with the cheapest houses have the worst economies. And with so many people requiring two incomes to afford a mortgage, it may become impossible for both to find a new job there.
OddSockReunion · 01/10/2021 11:55

@Annoyedanddissapointed

I don't know why "abroad" is painted in bad light. It's actually a saving in most cases, compared to holiday in UK.🤷🏻
Indeed. With much better food, landscapes, hotels and service for a lower price, including travel.
OddSockReunion · 01/10/2021 11:53

@Samuraisammy

And I’m talking about those that don’t rent. Of course if you already rent it’s almost impossible to save but that’s obvious. Which is why it comes back to the idea that if you can move back into your parents and you can turn down Isabelles garish hen do, wedding weekend, Carl’s 30th around Edinburgh, Daves stag do to Hamburg, quit your girls hols to Tenerife and just look at the beauty on your doorstep, get a train more, stop with brunches at El Crappos, buy somewhere that isn’t in London if you can, in a house which isn’t a 3-4 bed semi but an ok flat or terrace which you can do up to sell, then yes it CAN be done.
But clearly it's obvious that many people can't move back in with their parents. Hmm What do you suggest that these people do? You recognise it's almost impossible to save a deposit while renting so do such people - simply as a result of the bad luck of not having a supportive family - deserve to be excluded from any chance of home ownership?
OddSockReunion · 01/10/2021 11:51

flipping London!

What? Do you not realise that many people grow up in the largest city in our country and that's where their family and friends are?

What is "flipping" about it??

OddSockReunion · 01/10/2021 11:47

[quote Samuraisammy]@PattyPan that’s great but you must be the exception because my social media has been flooded with this Tom foolery for over a decade and you only need to look at Mumsnet trending threads.. peeved off bridesmaid robe buying.. brothers destination wedding.. to see it’s a thing.. my 12 year old has already got 32 consoles what else can I get him for Christmas this year? My grandparents went on U.K. holidays, family holidays to Butlins, think they had reception in a pub and married just the pair of them. Birthday celebrated at home. Non of this bar crawling, or long weekends in Prague. Everyone wants to be someone and the problem is at the end of the day and there’s nothing to show for it put a daft photo, and even that isn’t ‘real’ because it’s on a bloody phone!! I can assure you that is it wasn’t for social media, all of these lavish or expected ways of celebrating, holidaying and the like would be drastically cut down.[/quote]
Your comments are absurd and offensive, but aside from that, the "what is there to show for it?" shows such materialism. Partly due to having been denied access to the material benefits of home ownership etc, and partly simply because of a shift in values, many millenials value experiences over physical property.

Given you have one life, if you have to live a miserable life for 15+ years anyway to save enough to get a deposit together for a really run down house, many have understandably decided that a few hundred pounds on a holiday with friends that they will really enjoy for a special occasion such as a friend getting married is a good use of money that will have a negligible impact on their ability or not to save for house ownership because of the sheer scale of deposits now required for that. It's not like normal people are off abroad every other weekend (even pre-Covid).

Your comments are either very ill considered or just vindictive.

AngelDelight28 · 01/10/2021 11:15

This seems to be a London/SE thing. The media talks about it as though it's a universal thing across the Uk, but most people I know in Scotland who are my age ("millennial" 30 somethings) have bought houses and have had children no problem. Same with friends in northern England and Northern Ireland. Lots of people are now on their second and third "forever" houses and on their second and third child.

The only people I know who fit the skint/ renting/no children/avocado eating millennial stereotype are those who sneered at the idea of living in "uncool" locations like small towns, or in the "boring suburbs" and insist on living in the trendy, hipster-y areas of Edinburgh, London, Sheffield, Manchester etc, paying extortionate rent. They also only want to do "cool" jobs rather than be a teacher, nurse, accountant, sales person or work in regional offices. Which is fine, but if you want to live in an expensive trendy area and have an extended adolescence, you can't then complain that you can't afford children or a house.

OddSockReunion · 01/10/2021 01:58

This is such a cliche. I cringe at this 'snowflake' narrative which is what you're alluding too.

I also cringe at the entitlement in generations who feel they've 'earned' their second homes, property portfolios and 2, 3 or 4 times a year holidays and don't realise the impact this has on others.

Meanwhile millennials get shafted from both sides - repaying student loans, ridiculous childcare costs, saving for deposits, crazy rents and now higher NI to pay for your social care (or Brexit lets be honest - which older generations voted for more than most)

Yep. And also not much mentioned, the fact that one of the main reason companies have supressed salaries for current staff in recent decades is that they are still syphoning off company profits to pay for defined benefit pension schemes for boomers who have retired, that they europe never have committed to if they were running companies in a responsible manner and which the staff who are paying for it will not receive themselves.

They took tax cuts from North Sea oil rather than asking the Government to invest it in a sovereign wealth fund like Norway. They knew about climate change but did nothing. They took free educationa then decided young people now should pay. They got generous benefits if out of work. They had grammar schools to attend if they were poor but bright. They had decent apprenticeship programmes and jobs for life. They could hitch hike around Europe with an expectation of not ending up dead in a ditch. They've had the triple lock and the entire country shut down and lose jobs etc to protect them.

Yet we are the snowflakes, Just a tiny bit of empathy for how our situations are not as favourable - despite inside loos and smartphones and better availability of avocados - would not go amiss.

HappyTimeTunnelDinosaur · 01/10/2021 00:41

As a millennial I resent the ongoing accusation that I would ever allow avocado to pass my lips.

DeepaBeesKit · 01/10/2021 00:25

I'm a millennial

More of my peers than I expected are choosing to remain childless. There's a sort of endemic selfishness I see in many people.... lots of not wanting to make any lifestyle sacrifices. In my twenties everyone rented in cool flats in trendy areas, took ages to buy because they wanted 2 beds in Brixton not a dump wherever they could afford. Then they dont want to stop travelling or living somewhere fun in order to accommodate kids.

OddSockReunion · 30/09/2021 23:48

[quote Oldandcobwebbed]@Pixxie7
Second hand isn't always better though. I'm in a deprived area and our local Facebook market places aren't any cheaper then argos furniture etc due to the high demand for second hand

My parents that live in a wealthy area, there are some bargains to be had, but not unless I drive out of area (and incurr petrol costs) in general buying second hand doesn't save much here[/quote]
That's really interesting because here, you struggle to get anybody wanting to buy things second hand. I don't understand it.

XingMing · 27/09/2021 15:53

Several years ago, Grand Designs reviewed several projects and the eventual winner was the retirement home that Sir Evelyn de Rothschild and his wife had built for themselves. Clearly their budget was considerably higher than ours, but I remember thinking at the time that it was extremely well thought through for all the likely issues associated with ageing.

We'd like two generous-sized bedrooms and bathrooms, plus a large kitchen-dining room and a large sitting room. DH likes the idea of a conservatory. One floor of our current house would do nicely. Apparently we are hunting for a unicorn!

Lightisnotwhite · 26/09/2021 20:52

@containsnuts

Stevie77 "One of the major issues affecting the cost of housing is hoarding of housing by the older generations. Older people, and not just the very elderly, continue to live in big family homes decades after their kids have flown the nest. It stops the traffic up and down the property ladder and is a major bottle neck of property availability.

Until British people will let go of the notion that they need to hold on to houses for as long as possible to hand something down, and until younger people let go of the notion that they deserve to inherit, like it’s a right and not a privilege, nothing will change. Even the recent NI tax rise plays to this notion but the fact is that if you have an asset and need to pay for something e.g. care home fees, that asset should be used to pay for that. Alternatively, people could down size sooner, release equity and gift money earlier to their heirs."

For those who would like to downsize where are they supposed to go? Many areas do not have enough one bedroom homes (I remember this issue from the bedroom tax debacle). One bedroom homes that do exist tend to be flats, many with no parking, no lift access etc which is surely not appealing to those planning their later years.

People have ALWAYS held on to houses, It’s not new. Moving a massive expense, a pain to organise and involves a lot of decision making. You moved when one of you went into a home or died.
Lightisnotwhite · 26/09/2021 19:25

@Stevie77

One of the major issues affecting the cost of housing is hoarding of housing by the older generations. Older people, and not just the very elderly, continue to live in big family homes decades after their kids have flown the nest. It stops the traffic up and down the property ladder and is a major bottle neck of property availability.

Until British people will let go of the notion that they need to hold on to houses for as long as possible to hand something down, and until younger people let go of the notion that they deserve to inherit, like it’s a right and not a privilege, nothing will change. Even the recent NI tax rise plays to this notion but the fact is that if you have an asset and need to pay for something e.g. care home fees, that asset should be used to pay for that. Alternatively, people could down size sooner, release equity and gift money earlier to their heirs.

I disagree.Mostly it’s the first and second rung homes being bought up as investment properties. It’s caused a shortage of homes to buy at the bottom end and pushed up prices generally.
MintJulia · 26/09/2021 19:20

Interesting isn't it. I have two older sisters. One had retired with her husband, to a 3 bed detached house in a less costly area and the other has stayed in her 4 bed family house despite being widowed.

Both started out looking for two bed bungalows with dining rooms, and small gardens and couldn't find any.

Blossomtoes · 26/09/2021 11:36

Our house is too big for us but it’s perfectly located for us as we age. We could easily continue to live here without a car if we became unable to drive. We want to stay where we are but would happily down size. We want a bungalow ideally with two beds, two receptions and a garden. Essentially we want a unicorn so we’ll continue to rattle around here.

OhamIreally · 26/09/2021 10:07

The Bank of England has an inflation calculator on its website.
I put in what I paid for my flat and the year I paid it and it calculated what that amount would be in 2020 - £285,000. Actual value is more like £700,000.

Oldandcobwebbed · 26/09/2021 10:07

I realise that sounds ungrateful/ snobby but my point is housing stock doesn't encourage people to smaller properties

I dont believe my 2 bed, or the hundred of other identical ones on just my estate is made for family life or even to a certain extent permanent living. The new 2 beds being built by the big builders have somewhat similar issues, houses where there is no space for a dining table and zero storage. The lack of storage means should you actually use the second bedroom shock horror as a bedroom you wouldn't be able to store things like hoovers or even stupid stuff like coats and gift wrap.

The last new build 3 bed we saw (around 300k). The master bedroom had an en-suite but with a double bed in it, wouldn't be able to have a waldrobe that opened. The second bedroom was the same. The third was a single. They suggested we used the third room as a "dressing room".

The two beds were the same

Oldandcobwebbed · 26/09/2021 09:05

I think there is a problem about budget housing wether that's retirement or homes for first time buyers.

All of the 2 beds here are very tight on living space. For us we want enough room for a dining room table somewhere in our house, and space is incredibly limited.

I dread to think if you needed to have space for aids etc, if you needed clear space to walk through etc

We are looking for a 3 bed, but don't really need the 3rd room. We just find all of the 2 beds here are incredibly cramped. We currently live in a 2 bed, and the living space is snug. In order to have a table (even though its up against a wall) we can only have a 2 seater sofa and one visitor chair. What we would like from our future home is simply the ability to have guests round and seat them. Currently our second room is pretty essential because the house has zero cupboards built in and the hall isn't wide enough for storing the hoover in, there's no space for an ironing board, clothes horse (no outside space to dry or space for a drier) to be stored for instance, . We use it essentially as a dumping room. If new builds were planned better and had suitable storage like an airing cupboard, wider halls etc we probably wouldn't need the second room

MintJulia · 26/09/2021 08:52

@downthespidersweb

It's a good point. I'm 58. When ds goes to uni, I will retire and want to downsize. We currently have a 4 bed house (one spare bed and an office) and I won't need that much space.

I've looked for two bed homes and can choose between Victorian two up, two downs, but finding one that hasn't been extended is difficult, or two bed retirement flats. No chance, I'd rather stay where I am.

Neighbourhood plans need to require a mix of housing. The govt must turn down developers who build 'executive homes'. Where are the homes for people who aren't executives?

wellards · 26/09/2021 08:20

yes hence why my previous point said we need to build different style housing.

Downthespidersweb · 26/09/2021 08:03

@wellards

And we do have a situation where the bigger family homes often have an older, single person in & then you have a family in a flat. Of course people should be allowed to stay but house prices shouldn't be so prohibitive that people can't move up the ladder or decide they won't have dc.
I live in a small village (about 1000) i can think of several single older people living in large houses. If they wanted to downsize but stay in the village they couldnt because there is only about 2 bungalows.
wellards · 26/09/2021 07:44

Until British people will let go of the notion that they need to hold on to houses for as long as possible to hand something down, and until younger people let go of the notion that they deserve to inherit, like it’s a right and not a privilege, nothing will change. Even the recent NI tax rise plays to this notion but the fact is that if you have an asset and need to pay for something e.g. care home fees, that asset should be used to pay for that.

That notion is not going away as it's now a given that younger people should be helped onto the ladder by family instead of a market readjustment. It's why you have all those family backed mortgage schemes & why as pp NI has increased. Basically the best way of a person getting on the ladder is whether their parents can help them.
I also think the gov were aware that home ownership is shrinking & more people will be in rented homes when they are pensioners. So they won't actually have the asset to fund care hence NI hikes.

wellards · 26/09/2021 07:40

And we do have a situation where the bigger family homes often have an older, single person in & then you have a family in a flat. Of course people should be allowed to stay but house prices shouldn't be so prohibitive that people can't move up the ladder or decide they won't have dc.