Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Our society just doesn’t work for women

169 replies

Ozanj · 23/09/2021 10:40

Not really an aibu but I am horrified by the Sabina Nessa murder. She was killed by a random stranger during a 5 min walk to meet a friend at 8 fucking 30 in the evening. What the fuck is this? Do we as women now need to hide ourselves away from 5pm to be safe?

OP posts:
WeRTheOnesWeHaveBeenWaitingFor · 23/09/2021 15:08

Imagine a world without male criminality and violence. Think how different it would be. When I’m outside my home almost everything I do is filtered through a fear of male criminal behaviour. For many women that fear doesn’t stop when they are home either. Something needs to change.

DearFrutti · 23/09/2021 15:01

@NewIdeasToday

This case is incredibly sad. But I’m afraid your post is a complete over reaction and that is the last thing that women should do.
Overreaction? Hmm What a stupid thing to say.
FOJN · 23/09/2021 14:54

There was a thread here a few days ago about two 11 years olds having an argument about nerf guns, the 11 year old boy told the girl if she didn't shut up he would shoot her (with a nerf hun presumably), he later apologised.

There were a handful of responses by the time I saw it and all posters thought it was a non issue, it struck me that an 11 year old boy had resorted to a threat of violence to silence a girl disagreeing with him, where did he learn that? And why did posters not see the dynamic at play in that situation?

Women seem to be conditioned accept male aggression and threats of violence as normal, probably because it's so common, so when it happens it's considered a non issue unless you actually get hurt.

CBroads · 23/09/2021 14:43

Sorry but any women that disagree with this are socially blind. Misogyny and sexism towards women in the UK in this day and age is "normal" sexual harassment is passed off as "boys being boys" it's literally not safe for a woman to be out alone after dark because of these preditors, yet people think that men get "too much hate" men just don't like being called out for their disgusting behaviour and their ego gets but hurt when they're upstaged by women. Tragic really.

TheBillboardsAreLeering · 23/09/2021 14:38

Basically it’s not what us being discussed. I see this a lot on threads talking about violence against women, you get all the ‘what about the mens?!’ but I never see these posters caring enough to make a new thread about violence against men just happy to derail threads for women so

To be honest these threads always follow EXACTLY the same script and don't really serve any purpose, other than to vent, I guess.

Seen one, seen them all. Must as well just let people rant rather than expecting anything to actually change by saying "let's make all men stay home at night!"

brokenbiscuitsx · 23/09/2021 14:29

Then go start a thread about men murdering men. Why do people feel the need to make threads like this about men?!?!

Because it affect's men too. Teenage boys stabbed to death. A lone man leaving a pub and looks at another man by mistake etc. Most deaths in city centres at night are against men.

Yes male on male violence does exist and is an issue and female on male violence exists too but this a thread about male on female violence it doesn’t need this whataboutery derailing it.

If I started a thread about what are your favourite breakfasts you wouldn’t barge in and say what about lunches? Can we discuss favourite lunches. Or if we were discussing an environmental issues in say, Europe, you wouldn’t say what about Africa? It may be you would who knows.

Basically it’s not what us being discussed. I see this a lot on threads talking about violence against women, you get all the ‘what about the mens?!’ but I never see these posters caring enough to make a new thread about violence against men just happy to derail threads for women so 🤷🏻‍♀️

BarbaraofSeville · 23/09/2021 14:27

@beguilingeyes

Cressida Dick said after Sarah Everard that it was 'vanishingly rare'. It's not though is it...it's happening every day.

I was really upset by the murder of the woman and the three children...one of whom was a friend. Can you imaging sending your child off to a sleepover and them not coming home? Those poor parents.

Soon after Sarah Everard was murdered, there was also the lady who was killed while walking her dog, the Plymouth shootings and I'm sure there was another family killing before the Derbyshire one this week, plus probably countless others.

I don't know if rates are increasing, but these sorts of events seem quite common at the moment Sad.

DoesHePlayTheFiddle · 23/09/2021 14:24

I suggest writing to your MP today.
I suggest that every time you are present with men you state clearly what is not acceptable, so that they hear it every way they turn.

LuaDipa · 23/09/2021 14:19

@Movingsoon21

Not extreme at all. We urgently need to look at ways to curb male violence (against both men and women).
Wholeheartedly agree.

This week has seen the murder of Sabina Nessa and the murder of a woman and three children. They all deserved better and something needs to be done.

mbosnz · 23/09/2021 14:19

I don't know why anyone would accept anything Cressida Dick said as being at all representative of the truth. A bit like pretty much every representative in the whole bloody government.

beguilingeyes · 23/09/2021 14:16

Cressida Dick said after Sarah Everard that it was 'vanishingly rare'. It's not though is it...it's happening every day.

I was really upset by the murder of the woman and the three children...one of whom was a friend. Can you imaging sending your child off to a sleepover and them not coming home? Those poor parents.

LukeEvansWife · 23/09/2021 14:05

Not rousing each other to terror, but to fury! To the anger that won't be calmed down, to the outrage that burns like fires of hell until women can walk freely, unmolested; until we know that any oppression will be met with the full force of the law. Until the law is fair and there is genuine justice for women snd girls. Don't lay there and accept it - fight!

What do you suggest?

LukeEvansWife · 23/09/2021 14:04

Its great people are getting worked up. But after all the outrage about Sarah's murder, everything just went back to how it was. People did the appropriate amount of virtue signalling and then went back to their lives.

And that is what will happen after this too. Its depressingly predictable.

TiredButDancing · 23/09/2021 13:46

I think what annoys me most about these situations at the moment is how they are positioned as bad luck or whatever. The woman and three children from earlier in the week - the news reports are all being coy but it's clear that he was a current and/or ex boyfriend. But it's framed as "an isolated and tragic" incident. Bollocks. I bet you what you like he'd been involved in all kinds of things prior to this.

Blossomtoes · 23/09/2021 13:41

Don't lay there and accept it - fight!

I’ve been fighting all my adult life and after 50 years of fighting I’m bloody tired. And I’ve done my share. If anyone wants to organise a Reclaim the Night march I’ll join in.

BarbaraofSeville · 23/09/2021 13:41

[quote Shmithecat2]@x2boys

What about shift workers,men picking their kids up etc

I believe that @TonyThreePies was being facetious to make a point. And your response confirmed that. Women will be told to alter their behaviour because of male violence, and somehow that's acceptable, but if men were, all the whataboutery/reasons why they possibly can't kicks in. Can you not see how wrong that is?[/quote]
What about shift workers,men picking their kids up etc

What about women who are shift workers or picking their kids up etc?

Shouldn't they be allowed to be safely out and about?

Sabina Nessa might well have been going to meet a friend, but she could well have been on her way home from work, like Sarah Everard was, or taking her DC to the park, like Rachel Nickel or home from school like Lin Russell, or doing constituency work like Jo Cox or going to work like Claudia Lawrence.

Every single one of those women should have been able to safely go about their business, we all should. And sadly it seems that, yet again, it's not the case.

DoesHePlayTheFiddle · 23/09/2021 13:36

Not possible? Not possible? Open your mouth and scream! Rage! Find your righteous indignation, instead of accepting 'That's just the way it is!'

Not rousing each other to terror, but to fury! To the anger that won't be calmed down, to the outrage that burns like fires of hell until women can walk freely, unmolested; until we know that any oppression will be met with the full force of the law. Until the law is fair and there is genuine justice for women snd girls. Don't lay there and accept it - fight!

Blossomtoes · 23/09/2021 13:28

@LukeEvansWife

So the choices are

Do something about it (not possible)

Get on the internet and wind each other up into a state of terror

Accept that risk is there and live your life the best way you can

I'm not seeing either of these to be honest

If you don’t have anything to add to the discussion, why bother to engage with it? Nobody needs to be wound up to a state of terror by the Internet, the world we live in does the job quite well enough.
LukeEvansWife · 23/09/2021 13:25

So the choices are

Do something about it (not possible)

Get on the internet and wind each other up into a state of terror

Accept that risk is there and live your life the best way you can

I'm not seeing either of these to be honest

Blossomtoes · 23/09/2021 13:19

@Coyoacan

The other week I walked the dog alone in some isolated woods and suddenly thought what a stupid idea it was. I was painting a target on my back. I won’t be doing it again. The responsibility for keeping women safe lies with all of us

Ay, there's the rub. Despite all the comments about men being the more likely victims of random strangers, women are supposed to stay at home to avoid trouble, whereas that is never expected of men.

Well, not exactly stay at home but I’ll be walking her in less isolated spots when I’m alone. We’ve always walked in those woods with my adult son before and it felt fine. But, yes, you’re right.
Ozanj · 23/09/2021 13:19

@Coyoacan

The other week I walked the dog alone in some isolated woods and suddenly thought what a stupid idea it was. I was painting a target on my back. I won’t be doing it again. The responsibility for keeping women safe lies with all of us

Ay, there's the rub. Despite all the comments about men being the more likely victims of random strangers, women are supposed to stay at home to avoid trouble, whereas that is never expected of men.

This is what frustrates me. So we what finish before 5pm? But no, women get murdered during the daylight too. So what, do we now not work? But wait SAHM are most likely to face dv and guess what? Also get murdered. So what do I do to protect myself short of buying a desert island? But wait…why do I even have to protect myself? Why can’t the police do it?

I am so angry right now because this young girl looks just like my neice, and I really don’t want her to end up as yet another statistic / DM story but there is nothing I can do to protect her while society encourages men to become the worst toxic versions of themselves.

OP posts:
Coyoacan · 23/09/2021 13:15

The other week I walked the dog alone in some isolated woods and suddenly thought what a stupid idea it was. I was painting a target on my back. I won’t be doing it again. The responsibility for keeping women safe lies with all of us

Ay, there's the rub. Despite all the comments about men being the more likely victims of random strangers, women are supposed to stay at home to avoid trouble, whereas that is never expected of men.

Ozanj · 23/09/2021 13:14

@DoesHePlayTheFiddle

I think the point of the post is to rage, as every woman should, against the murder of yet another of our kind.

We all need to let our anger and grief, our outrage, be heard.

As long as women are snidely picking at each other instead of focusing on the actual problem, we will continue to be victims.

Men are killing us. Men are raping us. Men are terrorising us, oppressing us, making household slaves of us, intruding on our private spaces, financially abusing us (even at government level), mocking us. And laughing amongst themselves because it's all such a good joke.

Mothers, sisters, daughters, girlfriends, wives, colleagues, friends ... rage! Rage now! Make it known to every man and boy that abuse of women and girls will not be tolerated. Make it known to politicians, lawyers and especially judges that we intend to see prosecutions, convictions and sentences that are enough to deter others from committing future offences.

If you're not angry, you should be. Every woman who thinks 'My man/son/brother wouldn't do that only means 'He hasn't done it yet.'

Every woman matters. Every girl matters. Stop carping at each other and join the howl of indignation that once again, a woman has been harmed by a man.

Yes, this
OP posts:
Islamorada · 23/09/2021 13:09

There are so many murders lately. All sorts children, families, women, man. This is horrible.

mbosnz · 23/09/2021 13:08

@DoesHePlayTheFiddle

I think the point of the post is to rage, as every woman should, against the murder of yet another of our kind.

We all need to let our anger and grief, our outrage, be heard.

As long as women are snidely picking at each other instead of focusing on the actual problem, we will continue to be victims.

Men are killing us. Men are raping us. Men are terrorising us, oppressing us, making household slaves of us, intruding on our private spaces, financially abusing us (even at government level), mocking us. And laughing amongst themselves because it's all such a good joke.

Mothers, sisters, daughters, girlfriends, wives, colleagues, friends ... rage! Rage now! Make it known to every man and boy that abuse of women and girls will not be tolerated. Make it known to politicians, lawyers and especially judges that we intend to see prosecutions, convictions and sentences that are enough to deter others from committing future offences.

If you're not angry, you should be. Every woman who thinks 'My man/son/brother wouldn't do that only means 'He hasn't done it yet.'

Every woman matters. Every girl matters. Stop carping at each other and join the howl of indignation that once again, a woman has been harmed by a man.

Sing it, sister.
Swipe left for the next trending thread