Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Near drowning

146 replies

aibuprofile · 23/09/2021 09:13

My daughter was taking part in a swim lesson with school last week. During this lesson she panicked in 2m deep water and the swim teacher tried to throw life saving aids to her but she was going under and could not grab them. The lifeguard sounded the alarm and dived in and pulled her out. She was ok.
But... I was not told about this until the end of the school day. When I was told it was in a very casual way and a brief version of events given. This version does NOT match those of several other children there or indeed my own daughters (who is very sensible and not dramatic).

I am angry that I was not at least called. I'm angry that when I phoned the school to discuss (took a few moments for it to sink in when I was told in person, by which time the teacher had walked off) I was fobbed off and told she did not nearly drown and that her head only went under water for a brief moment.

AIBU to be angry with the school for the lack of communication and would I be unreasonable to go over to the swimming pool and ask for their version of events?

OP posts:
SD1978 · 23/09/2021 10:10

I'm sorry- taking the word of excitable 8 year olds and one scared 8 year old (your daughter) over the school and lifeguards, I probably wouldn't. She was supervised and fine all day at school. She has been fine since. If there was a need for medical intervention at the time, there would have been some offered. I understand it's scary, but she was helped and is safe.

Cissyandflora · 23/09/2021 10:08

@Macncheeseballs

I'd be thankful she'd been saved
Do you think op is not thankful? Does being thankful mean being obsequious and compliant?

I’d most certainly be going to the pool for an incident report and having a meeting at the school about the incident too.

CounsellorTroi · 23/09/2021 10:06

@aibuprofile

Yes I am of course very grateful that the lifeguard did his job.

What I'm not happy about is her being in water that is 2m deep when she can't swim, that there was no swim teacher actually in the pool and that schools version of events literally makes no sense at all and the school did not phone me straight away.

She absolutely should not have been out of her depth when she couldn’t swim. I don’t think you are being unreasonable.
PlonkyWillyWonky · 23/09/2021 10:05

You should have been told straight away, your poor child, never underestimate a child's distress, it's very real to them
I'd like to see how the school recorded it and how the pool did
I hope this doesn't put her off

Saladovercrispsanyday · 23/09/2021 10:04

@GoodbyePorpoiseSpit

I think secondary drowning is a risk only if you have breathed in water ie asphyxiated rather than swallowed water. It seems as though you feel they have downplayed it but the bottom line is you don’t trust them. If you don’t trust what they have told you and don’t like when they told you then that leads to loss of trust. Tell them that then take your kid out of swimming if you’re not satisfied. Doesn’t sound like they took it seriously but perhaps they did and it’s a communication issues. I would say that an incident that required the intervention of a life guard would be treated as a BIG DEAL at my kids school. In fact I saw a similar incident play out at a swimming lesson and the kid was shaken up but totally fine. His mum was there to witness it though - the lifeguards did everything right, it was just one of those things as the kid got cramp. No rush if secondary drowning. Just scary.
But how you one be sure she didn’t breathe In water? Confused
GoodbyePorpoiseSpit · 23/09/2021 10:03

No RISK OF secondary drowning sorry!

GoodbyePorpoiseSpit · 23/09/2021 10:02

I think secondary drowning is a risk only if you have breathed in water ie asphyxiated rather than swallowed water.
It seems as though you feel they have downplayed it but the bottom line is you don’t trust them. If you don’t trust what they have told you and don’t like when they told you then that leads to loss of trust. Tell them that then take your kid out of swimming if you’re not satisfied. Doesn’t sound like they took it seriously but perhaps they did and it’s a communication issues. I would say that an incident that required the intervention of a life guard would be treated as a BIG DEAL at my kids school. In fact I saw a similar incident play out at a swimming lesson and the kid was shaken up but totally fine. His mum was there to witness it though - the lifeguards did everything right, it was just one of those things as the kid got cramp. No rush if secondary drowning. Just scary.

Lorw · 23/09/2021 10:00

I don’t understand why schools do swimming lessons tbh, literally one teacher to a whole class of students at all mixed abilities is a recipe for disaster, especially since it doesn’t seem many children actually learn how to swim at school 🤷🏻‍♀️

Should just phone and ask why a non swimmer was allowed in a deep pool, that is the main issue here and hopefully some safeguards can be put in place.

Saladovercrispsanyday · 23/09/2021 09:54

@Doveyouknow

What would you have done differently if they had rung you during the school day? I am not sure the issue is when they told you. The issue is surely that your daughter cannot swim but was in a pool out of her depth. That shouldn't have happened and that is what I would raise with the teacher.
Me?

I would have ensured they were aware of risk of secondary drowning

And given her age. I probably would have said I’ll come and collect her

probsouting · 23/09/2021 09:53

@Saladovercrispsanyday

You absolutely should have been told

Risk of delayed drowning death

Exactly this. Secondary drowning (possibly an old term from when I studied it) is scary, luckily it's not common, but definitely needs to be known about.
soapboxqueen · 23/09/2021 09:45

Tbh I'd contact the pool and ask them what happened. You don't have to be drowning for the lifeguard to jump in but it would at least give another perspective of what happened.

I wouldn't expect a call immediately from the school in such circumstances as they were at the pool unless an ambulance was called. However, since swimming was in the morning, they had plenty of time to call if deemed necessary.

The biggest question is 'why was she in such deep water if she can't swim?' a question for the swimming instructors at the pool.

Also Why did the school not make the decision to call you? Did they believe she was fine so no need? Did the pool staff not communicate correctly what had happened so school staff were working on false info?

Doveyouknow · 23/09/2021 09:44

What would you have done differently if they had rung you during the school day? I am not sure the issue is when they told you. The issue is surely that your daughter cannot swim but was in a pool out of her depth. That shouldn't have happened and that is what I would raise with the teacher.

thelastgoldeneagle · 23/09/2021 09:44

@HarrietsChariot - I can understand you being upset but to be fair I'd trust the official version of events over those of other children.

Really? Like teachers and people in positions of authority never lie to get themselves out of trouble??

I'd trust your dd.

It doesn't sound like too big of a deal, she got into trouble and the lifeguards got her out of it. Assuming she didn't need mouth-to-mouth or anything, it sounds like the system worked?

Really?? A lifeguard had to dive in to save a child during a supervised school swimmng lesson, and that's 'the system working'? I hope you're not in charge of anything risky like swimming or mountain climbing...

A non-swimming child was in 2m deep water??

FFS, the school are lucky nothing worse happened. Absolutely bonkers. I'd contact them in writing, ask for their risk assessment, asky why your dd was out of her depth.
Then I'd contact the leisure centre and ask to see the lifeguard's report. Then I'd think hard about whteher I wanted dd to swim with school again.

HunkyPunk · 23/09/2021 09:43

@FlibbertyGibbitt

If this was last week why didn’t you call the school the next day ?
The op stated that she did phone the school, and was fobbed off. If people in authority keep telling you ‘nothing to see here’ it can take a while for you to gather your thoughts and decide to act on your gut instinct that there is more to an incident than is being revealed.
viques · 23/09/2021 09:41

@aibuprofile

Yes I am of course very grateful that the lifeguard did his job.

What I'm not happy about is her being in water that is 2m deep when she can't swim, that there was no swim teacher actually in the pool and that schools version of events literally makes no sense at all and the school did not phone me straight away.

Swimming teachers don’t get in the pool. They coach /teach from the side.

I am glad your daughter is OK.

I think the issue to focus on is why non swimmers were in water out of their depth.

Sightlinesandsolutions · 23/09/2021 09:39

Something very similar happened to us. It is horrific, and in our case it was also treated very dismissively. I'm so sorry that this has happened to you too, but I'm glad your daughter is ok. If it's any consolation at all, my child has gone on to become a very confident swimmer and absolutely loves the water.

As for next steps, I would contact both the school and the pool and formally complain and request that they review the incident. They should have a health and safety policy in place for reporting and reviewing never events like this. There should be CCTV footage too, which you can ask to view. I would also ask what steps they took to assess her medically, as with incidents like this, there is always a risk of secondary drowning.

Good luck, I hope you get the answers you're looking for.

FlibbertyGibbitt · 23/09/2021 09:36

If this was last week why didn’t you call the school the next day ?

PlantyPotts · 23/09/2021 09:35

"I can understand you being upset but to be fair I'd trust the official version of events over those of other children. "

For Christ sake will we learn nothing from the past about heinous lies told by adults and children not been listened to until the truth finally comes out years later.

Yes children can over dramatise but you look at the whole picture not ignore them.

OP even if not a near drowning you should have been told. Our school has to phone the parents for any head bump at all. You'd think a water incident would have to be reported too.

discombobulatedonion · 23/09/2021 09:35

@discombobulatedonion

To continue from this, I did a 3 week programme called NCS when I was 16. For one activity on the first week, we were required to do some water sport type thing then at the end, we were required to run and jump into this massive, deep lake. Now I can’t swim very well, so I refused - but yet the team leaders of that particular activity literally threw me into the water. Despite having a life jacket on, I went underwater and someone had to jump in to save me because I couldn’t, and still can’t, swim very well.

But according to the “officials”, it wasn’t that bad because I didn’t actually drown.

SaltySeaAir · 23/09/2021 09:34

I would want it followed up on. She should not have been in the deep water in the first place if she can't swim. There is a possibility these are the first swimming lessons the school has done since covid, and maybe they need to re-check the procedures they have in place to ensure children are in the correct group.

I hope she is ok and this does not effect her confidence in the water.

Brollywasntneededafterall · 23/09/2021 09:34

Don't underestimate your dd's experience. At 32 my dd still remembers being fished out also. She only learned to swim 2 years ago. So put off by the incident - really affected her. School never told me either.
Until the end of day also.

HunkyPunk · 23/09/2021 09:31

Could it be that seeing a lifeguard go in has made the whole incident seem more dramatic to your dd and the children?

Tbf, having to be saved by a lifeguard during a ‘supervised’ school swimming lesson is pretty dramatic. And somewhat concerning…

discombobulatedonion · 23/09/2021 09:30

@HarrietsChariot

I can understand you being upset but to be fair I'd trust the official version of events over those of other children.

It doesn't sound like too big of a deal, she got into trouble and the lifeguards got her out of it. Assuming she didn't need mouth-to-mouth or anything, it sounds like the system worked?

@HarrietsChariot

I certainly wouldn’t trust the word of “officials” over my child and other children. With all due respect, sometimes “officials” do downplay things to cover their own back.

OngoingTrauma · 23/09/2021 09:30

Don't make a big deal of this in front of your daughter though. Don't put her off swimming for life.

Justyouwaitandseeagain · 23/09/2021 09:29

I don’t think you are being unreasonable. Swallowing a lot of water can still be dangerous and even if she is ok physically it still sounds like a very distressing experience.

Why did the swim teacher not go in? The fact there was a failed attempt to throw life aids before the lifeguard rescue indicates how long this must have felt to your daughter in the water.

I was swimming in a hotel pool with a friend in our late teens (around 17) she couldn’t swim as well as the rest of us so stayed in the shallow end. Accidentally - and unbeknown to us - she got out of her depth and began to panic. She was so scared she couldn’t shout for help or show her distress. Eventually we realised something was wrong, swam across and got her out. To anyone else it seemed relatively minor but she was absolutely petrified and that experience has stayed with her.

Yes these things happen but I think the school are unreasonable for down playing what happened.

How is your daughter feeling about going back to lessons? Do you feel more support will be needed?