Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is Sabina Nessa murder not all over the media?

462 replies

postingfortraffichere · 22/09/2021 23:45

Such a tragic killing and sad, truly awful to hear about this murder.

Though I can't understand why, it doesn't get the same media/public attention as Sarah Everard who died in similarly tragic circumstances not long ago.

Both are equally tragic, two young women attacked in similar circumstances - the only difference I can see in these cases is the colour of their skin. Sarah's murder was everywhere - before we knew it was a police officer responsible.

Women had lined the streets in protest to make the country a safer place for women.

I can't help but notice where are these women protesting for Sabina? Or for the Killmarsh murders, or other women of colour?

The media treats women of colour - even to this day - very differently to white women.

It feels like the media are sending a clear message that black lives STILL 'don't matter' quite as much as their white counterparts.

OP posts:
LizzieW1969 · 23/09/2021 16:23

**EnidSpyton
What really matters here is that another woman has been murdered by a man. Male violence is an epidemic, it is killing women every single day, of every skin colour, every social class, etc. Rather than infighting over 'privilege' when it comes to media reporting of female victims of male violence, perhaps we could direct our energies to working together to publicise, protest about and push for change when it comes to male violence?

Last week we had the poor woman, her two children and her daughter's friend murdered in their beds by her boyfriend in the news.

This week it's Sabina.

A month or so ago the incel bloke on a rampage in Portsmouth, killing his mother before murdering bystanders.

In between these cases have been hundreds more that have gone totally unreported.

Why? Because they're often classed as 'isolated domestic violence' incidents.

Calling this violence 'domestic' minimises it and enables it to be brushed under the carpet. Anything to do with the domestic is automatically classed as to do with women and therefore of lesser importance.

Anything 'domestic' is also automatically labelled as 'isolated' - i.e. nothing to see here, move on, won't affect you. Absolute bollocks. All domestic violence cases are linked - linked to a wider societal acceptance of male violence which exists due to patriarchy and a sense of male entitlement which makes all women, everywhere, all the time, vulnerable to abuse and injury. If the same number of men were murdered by female partners as the other way around, there would be legislation, there would be task forces, there would be education, there would be outcry. But because it's 'just' women being obliterated off the face of the earth on a regular basis, no one in power does anything about it.

This is made even worse by the pathetic women who join the #notallmen chorus every time a woman is murdered. No, it's not all men. But it's ALWAYS MEN. Isn't it? Men kill men, men kill women. Male violence is a thing. It's statistically proven, in every society, all over the world, since time immemorial - in general, men are violent and women aren't. Just because your husband or son is lovely, doesn't mean you can ignore the fact that men in general are violent towards women. And if you include harrassment, heckling, groping, sexist comments, sex discrimination, etc within the terminology of 'violence' - then we're all experiencing this, every single day, and denial that we are is the greatest victory of the patriarchy, I'm afraid.

On the topic of the thread, yes, there is of course racial bias in the media, when it comes to everything. There is also class bias, location bias, etc. A poor white woman's murder, or a white prostitute's murder, is not going to get reported in the national news in the same way a middle or upper class white woman's murder will be. The murder of someone in London will undoubtedly get more attention than in Northumberland. A university educated black or Asian woman with a high flying career being murdered will generate much higher volumes of interest in the media than a benefit-collecting white woman's murder. Any murder related to suspected gang violence will be brushed under the carpet. This isn't just about race, and is just as much about class, actually - notice how Sabina's image in the press has been of her with her university degree - emphasising that this was an educated, professional woman. Had she been a single mum on a council estate, the press coverage would have been very different.However, comparing Sabina and Sarah is like comparing apples with oranges. Sarah Everard was missing for several days with the hope she would be found alive - much of the press coverage was appealing for witnesses to try and find her. Sabina was found already murdered and a suspect already arrested. There's no real 'hook' for the media to hang a story on there. Nonetheless, I disagree that she hasn't had plenty of media coverage. She has. As she should. I hope that the perpetrator is swiftly caught and rots in hell for all eternity. I grew up nearby and know where she was murdered well - it's a space I've always thought of as very safe and quiet, and again, just emphasises that male violence can happen to any of us, anywhere, any time. This is what we need to be uniting to fight. In order to protect all women, everywhere.**

^I agree with this totally. There has been a lot of coverage, and rightly so. But there have been so many other murdered women who have barely been mentioned at all, 180 between last year’s and this year’s International Women’s Day, as Sadiq Kahn reminded us today.

Cadent · 23/09/2021 16:06

@nyktipolos

Her name was also misspelt by people denying her race is factor in the low coverage, but you don't seem concerned by those people.

In regards to getting her name and/or race right I haven't mentioned wether those posters are of one opinion of another.

I am talking about all posters who are posting that she is black or getting her name wrong.

Regardless of their opinion, if they give a shit enough to post they should know the basics about her. Especially the op.

Don't presume to know what I am or am not concerned about.

When you post 'Doesn't scream 'we really care about this individual womans death and how her race is impacting reporting' to me' it's pretty obvious where your concerns lie.

You're presuming an awful lot about people's intentions. All I see is lots of people disheartened by yet another forgotten about woman of colour.

NautaOcts · 23/09/2021 16:06

I thought this too
I really really hope it’s not because of the colour of their skin.
Maybe it’s as a pp poster said that there was a high profile missing persons thing first for Sarah then people were shocked at the turn of events when it was a serving police officer

LimitIsUp · 23/09/2021 16:03

I've read about this poor young woman in the Times. There have been at least two articles. Awful, heinous murder

nyktipolos · 23/09/2021 15:00

@Itsbeen84yearss

I don’t like the way they’ve used that pic of her pouting with a filter on and the repeated mentioning of her going on a date. Is it me?
I don't see anything wrong with the photo. It's likely one the family have released. If not then I may have an issue with it. It's shows a young women.

The main picture they have been using is her graduation photo.

Also the only time I have seen a date being mentioned is when a friend was quoted as saying it was date.

The rest have said going to meet a friend.

Itsbeen84yearss · 23/09/2021 14:47

I don’t like the way they’ve used that pic of her pouting with a filter on and the repeated mentioning of her going on a date. Is it me?

nyktipolos · 23/09/2021 14:45

Her name was also misspelt by people denying her race is factor in the low coverage, but you don't seem concerned by those people.

In regards to getting her name and/or race right I haven't mentioned wether those posters are of one opinion of another.

I am talking about all posters who are posting that she is black or getting her name wrong.

Regardless of their opinion, if they give a shit enough to post they should know the basics about her. Especially the op.

Don't presume to know what I am or am not concerned about.

DrSbaitso · 23/09/2021 14:44

Sorry, @AGameOfCrones, I missed it. Thank you.

What the fuck.

AGameOfCrones · 23/09/2021 14:39

@DrSbaitso

On the point of older women: after a certain age, rapes of older women are not even included in UK rape statistics. What the f^k is that about?!*

What? Is there a link for this?

I posted a link and screenshot above showing the cut off has been raised to 74
Cadent · 23/09/2021 14:22

[quote RussianSpy101]@WishingYouAMerryChristmasToo the man they’ve arrested is her new partner. She was pregnant with his child at the time of her death.
He has only recently gotten out of prison for another violent offence.[/quote]
Who are you talking about? You really need to quote.

Cadent · 23/09/2021 14:18

@nyktipolos

I agree if people are erasing Sabina's culture then that's not acceptable, but I didn't really see that intention.

You don't see the irony of talking about race, in regards to a specific woman and just using an incorrect catch all term for her race.

Her name is wrong AND people are incorrectly referring to her ethnicity.

Doesn't scream 'we really care about this individual womans death and how her race is impacting reporting' to me.

Yes, I know her name has been spelt wrong, I've been correcting people.

Her name was also misspelt by people denying her race is factor in the low coverage, but you don't seem concerned by those people.

RussianSpy101 · 23/09/2021 14:16

@WishingYouAMerryChristmasToo the man they’ve arrested is her new partner. She was pregnant with his child at the time of her death.
He has only recently gotten out of prison for another violent offence.

DrSbaitso · 23/09/2021 14:14

Ithink we shoiuld all be treated equally.

That would include acknowledging that some people are not being treated equally now....

nyktipolos · 23/09/2021 14:12

I agree if people are erasing Sabina's culture then that's not acceptable, but I didn't really see that intention.

You don't see the irony of talking about race, in regards to a specific woman and just using an incorrect catch all term for her race.

Her name is wrong AND people are incorrectly referring to her ethnicity.

Doesn't scream 'we really care about this individual womans death and how her race is impacting reporting' to me.

JudgeJ · 23/09/2021 14:11

@Mothersister

Because she’s not white. It’s disgraceful and disappointing.
Anyone's murder is 'disappointing' and I mean irrespective of race, gender etc etc, unlike many on here I think we shoiuld all be treated equally.
BoredZelda · 23/09/2021 14:11

Why do people pretend they don’t know the answer to this? Then post wide eyed, faux innocence about it?

JudgeJ · 23/09/2021 14:08

@LampLighter414

We all know why, no need to pretend here
Oh do shed some light LampLighter dear. or are you merely being predicable? D0 some of the posters on this site ever read any other news outlets?
DrSbaitso · 23/09/2021 14:00

On the point of older women: after a certain age, rapes of older women are not even included in UK rape statistics. What the f^k is that about?!*

What? Is there a link for this?

Charley50 · 23/09/2021 13:53

@CoffeeWithCheese

A schoolfriend (white - just because race is being discussed here) was murdered in a domestic violence related incident a few years ago now - very very brutal killing. She was, like Sabina, a primary teacher, and the media I think stayed back from the saturation coverage there in order to protect the school kids in her class. The only one who really went to town on it was the Daily Mail.

Just throwing it in as another factor out there.

I think that's a good point.

OverByYer · 23/09/2021 13:34

@EnidSpyton

What really matters here is that another woman has been murdered by a man. Male violence is an epidemic, it is killing women every single day, of every skin colour, every social class, etc. Rather than infighting over 'privilege' when it comes to media reporting of female victims of male violence, perhaps we could direct our energies to working together to publicise, protest about and push for change when it comes to male violence?

Last week we had the poor woman, her two children and her daughter's friend murdered in their beds by her boyfriend in the news.

This week it's Sabina.

A month or so ago the incel bloke on a rampage in Portsmouth, killing his mother before murdering bystanders.

In between these cases have been hundreds more that have gone totally unreported.

Why? Because they're often classed as 'isolated domestic violence' incidents.

Calling this violence 'domestic' minimises it and enables it to be brushed under the carpet. Anything to do with the domestic is automatically classed as to do with women and therefore of lesser importance.

Anything 'domestic' is also automatically labelled as 'isolated' - i.e. nothing to see here, move on, won't affect you. Absolute bollocks. All domestic violence cases are linked - linked to a wider societal acceptance of male violence which exists due to patriarchy and a sense of male entitlement which makes all women, everywhere, all the time, vulnerable to abuse and injury. If the same number of men were murdered by female partners as the other way around, there would be legislation, there would be task forces, there would be education, there would be outcry. But because it's 'just' women being obliterated off the face of the earth on a regular basis, no one in power does anything about it.

This is made even worse by the pathetic women who join the #notallmen chorus every time a woman is murdered. No, it's not all men. But it's ALWAYS MEN. Isn't it? Men kill men, men kill women. Male violence is a thing. It's statistically proven, in every society, all over the world, since time immemorial - in general, men are violent and women aren't. Just because your husband or son is lovely, doesn't mean you can ignore the fact that men in general are violent towards women. And if you include harrassment, heckling, groping, sexist comments, sex discrimination, etc within the terminology of 'violence' - then we're all experiencing this, every single day, and denial that we are is the greatest victory of the patriarchy, I'm afraid.

On the topic of the thread, yes, there is of course racial bias in the media, when it comes to everything. There is also class bias, location bias, etc. A poor white woman's murder, or a white prostitute's murder, is not going to get reported in the national news in the same way a middle or upper class white woman's murder will be. The murder of someone in London will undoubtedly get more attention than in Northumberland. A university educated black or Asian woman with a high flying career being murdered will generate much higher volumes of interest in the media than a benefit-collecting white woman's murder. Any murder related to suspected gang violence will be brushed under the carpet. This isn't just about race, and is just as much about class, actually - notice how Sabina's image in the press has been of her with her university degree - emphasising that this was an educated, professional woman. Had she been a single mum on a council estate, the press coverage would have been very different.However, comparing Sabina and Sarah is like comparing apples with oranges. Sarah Everard was missing for several days with the hope she would be found alive - much of the press coverage was appealing for witnesses to try and find her. Sabina was found already murdered and a suspect already arrested. There's no real 'hook' for the media to hang a story on there. Nonetheless, I disagree that she hasn't had plenty of media coverage. She has. As she should. I hope that the perpetrator is swiftly caught and rots in hell for all eternity. I grew up nearby and know where she was murdered well - it's a space I've always thought of as very safe and quiet, and again, just emphasises that male violence can happen to any of us, anywhere, any time. This is what we need to be uniting to fight. In order to protect all women, everywhere.

Excellent post. Well said.
ithinkilikeit · 23/09/2021 13:23

@GCAcademic I have no accused anyone of lying. I do not know how many times I must reiterate it but I do not care what your race is. I was not accusing you of lying about it simply telling you that claiming you are a certain race does not being validity to your point. I think the only person engaging in bad faith arguments is you as you continue to deliberately mais the point of what people are saying to make yourself look better.

Cadent · 23/09/2021 12:51

@nyktipolos

Which posts are you referring to? Some black and ethnic minorities do use 'black' to refer to women for colour.

The ones that refer to Sabina as an individual as black. Completely, erasing her actual heritage.

Not sure what Southall sister have to do with anything? We can all dig out an incorrect usage somewhere or other. Just because they use it, doesn't mean its correct? Or are you suggesting that because they use that, everyone else should just comply?

I know no Asian women who refer to themselves as black. Or that would be referred to as black.

Its definitely erasure and is definitely poor behaviour from those trying their best to be woke. Talking about Sabina and how her 'race' (inverted because race isn't the correct word at all) or rather ethnicity is playing the biggest part in her murder being under reported and people can't even be arsed being accurate about the victim.

I'm South Asian but don't have an issue with Southall Black Sister sisters including Asian women in their definition of 'black'. That's why I mentioned it, that black can be sometimes used as shorthand for black/Asian women.

I agree if people are erasing Sabina's culture then that's not acceptable, but I didn't really see that intention.

CoffeeWithCheese · 23/09/2021 12:34

A schoolfriend (white - just because race is being discussed here) was murdered in a domestic violence related incident a few years ago now - very very brutal killing. She was, like Sabina, a primary teacher, and the media I think stayed back from the saturation coverage there in order to protect the school kids in her class. The only one who really went to town on it was the Daily Mail.

Just throwing it in as another factor out there.

andyoldlabour · 23/09/2021 12:26

Sorry, cross posted and with less up to date information.