Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is Sabina Nessa murder not all over the media?

462 replies

postingfortraffichere · 22/09/2021 23:45

Such a tragic killing and sad, truly awful to hear about this murder.

Though I can't understand why, it doesn't get the same media/public attention as Sarah Everard who died in similarly tragic circumstances not long ago.

Both are equally tragic, two young women attacked in similar circumstances - the only difference I can see in these cases is the colour of their skin. Sarah's murder was everywhere - before we knew it was a police officer responsible.

Women had lined the streets in protest to make the country a safer place for women.

I can't help but notice where are these women protesting for Sabina? Or for the Killmarsh murders, or other women of colour?

The media treats women of colour - even to this day - very differently to white women.

It feels like the media are sending a clear message that black lives STILL 'don't matter' quite as much as their white counterparts.

OP posts:
Plumtree391 · 23/09/2021 19:27

I think the poster said somethng like, "If Madeline came from a council house there wouldn't have been.....".

Plumtree391 · 23/09/2021 19:24

Are we forgetting them? I wouldn't have thought so.

The poor girl's murder was on the news again this evening. Oh I do hope the murderer is found, it's so horrible.

Chicchicchicchiclana · 23/09/2021 19:22

How disappointing that this thread has been tainted by in-fighting amongst the people on it.

There are many interesting points to raise about the under-reporting of murders of women generally (most of whom are killed by men they are or have been in a relationship with) and why some make the news headlines and some don't. Sabina's killer is still at large so people feel it is more scary. All the time we are forgetting the women and children who live with violent men day in day out.

SueSaid · 23/09/2021 19:09

'Please don't tell me you are resentful of Madeline McCann, JanlieJones. Poor little girl has been missing for over ten years and probably dead'

What?! Why would I be 'resentful'? It is tragic. A pp said the case would not have got the same coverage if they were from a council house I corrected them and said of course it would have, Shannon Matthew's abduction did.

superplumb · 23/09/2021 18:56

@Plumtree391

Please don't tell me you are resentful of Madeline McCann, JanlieJones. Poor little girl has been missing for over ten years and probably dead. No amount of publicity and searching has found her.

The McCanns are fairly ordinary middle class people, not fabulously wealthy or privileged but they and friends knew how to go about keeping Madeline in the public eye, and raise funds. It hasn't worked though, has it.

The same with Ben Needham.

I can't bear to think of what those children went through and wish their parents could at least have closure.

Another highly publicised kidnapping in America was of Elizabeth Smart; there is a dramatised film about her called, "The Elizabeth Smart Story". It's worth watching.

Thank goodness, she was found alive and keeping her face in the public eye helped immensely. She went through Hell though, she was fourteen.

Ermmmm who exactly is resentful of Madeleine?
TSSDNCOP · 23/09/2021 18:55

I'm trying to write this carefully, as I am anxious not to offend anyone, but I think the investigation reporting and the despicably unchecked violence against women reporting should possibly be decoupled.

I saw the early reports of Sabina's murder and reflected on the relatively low coverage. Having read subsequently that the police had a suspect I wonder if there was initially an attempt to mute coverage in case the investigation was impeded. Now that suspect has been released, coverage is increasing (rightly) as the process of the investigation comes back under scrutiny as this very dangerous person is still at large.

The reporting of male violence against women, on the other hand, must and should be a focus of media and political attention. It is evident that this is not getting the attention it deserves, it is evident that there is race bias in the attention it does get. It is evident that women are at risk from and their freedoms curtailed by men and it's evident to women that nowhere near enough is being done to stop it in its tracks.

superplumb · 23/09/2021 18:55

@JaniieJones

'If Madeline McCann was from a benefit reliant council homes child, would she have got the same amount of coverage?'

Yes. Shannon Matthews did.

Nope. ...she got media appeal because the bloke her mum lived with was weird and there were lots of whispers tgatbher mum had something to do with it.
Plumtree391 · 23/09/2021 18:40

Please don't tell me you are resentful of Madeline McCann, JanlieJones. Poor little girl has been missing for over ten years and probably dead. No amount of publicity and searching has found her.

The McCanns are fairly ordinary middle class people, not fabulously wealthy or privileged but they and friends knew how to go about keeping Madeline in the public eye, and raise funds. It hasn't worked though, has it.

The same with Ben Needham.

I can't bear to think of what those children went through and wish their parents could at least have closure.

Another highly publicised kidnapping in America was of Elizabeth Smart; there is a dramatised film about her called, "The Elizabeth Smart Story". It's worth watching.

Thank goodness, she was found alive and keeping her face in the public eye helped immensely. She went through Hell though, she was fourteen.

Curerofsouls · 23/09/2021 18:40

It has been on the Beeb several times?

Annoyedanddissapointed · 23/09/2021 18:39

Plenty of them don't, it's an opportunity to play the 'I am so virtuous' card. Like the op on another thread who decided that it wasn't being reported outside London until some point today which again, is bollocks.

Unfortunately I agree there.

nyktipolos · 23/09/2021 18:32

The point is you’re trying to imply people who are saying her race is a factor in low coverage don’t care about her. When that’s not the case.

Plenty of them don't, it's an opportunity to play the 'I am so virtuous' card. Like the op on another thread who decided that it wasn't being reported outside London until some point today which again, is bollocks.

And no, if you don't even bother to get details right about her, whatever side of the debate you are on, whilst claiming to understand the issue around those details. No I don't believe you care. If someone is insisting race isn't an issue and can't be arsed actually knowing what her race is, I would say they don't really care either.

Whilst not every case gets media attention, the cases that have got attention in the past are of white females.

Its a really specific type of white woman that gets coverage. I haven't denied that. I have denied race is part of it at all. But I don't think it's a main part of it. There's loads of factors that has meant less coverage, early on.

The only time the media cares when a black or brown woman or girl is killed is if it’s an honour killing (Banaz Mahmoud, Shafiliea Ahmed), because they can blame it on Asian culture.

I disagree. I think society and the press don't care about most women's deaths. I think honour killings in the UK are quite unusual, so therefore, they make big news. Personally, I would prefer to scrap the term 'honour killing. To me the term should be banned entirely though.

She is not being forgotten aboutnowbecause of the people saying she needs to be remembered. If we left to you, she would be forgotten. See attached example of how little people cared until people spoke out about the lack of fucks given.

You are actually vile. If it was up to me she would be forgotten?

I know more about her than the majority on this thread, including you because I cared enough to read and watch things about the case and Sabina, as a person. Not just a victim. Where exactly, have you got and evidence for the accusation, that I would allow her to be forgotten?

You don't. You just come up with something that's attention grabbing to try and silence other posters.

Again, you just need to make up shit to pretend you are just more virtuous than others and have to be right.

Paddingtonthebear · 23/09/2021 18:07

*violence.

Paddingtonthebear · 23/09/2021 18:07

I’m hours from London and I’ve heard at least 5 news reports about Sabina, it’s all over the news outlets online too. I’m in a hair salon right now and there’s just been a news report about it on radio 1 too. I don’t think it’s lacking coverage. Sarah Everard went missing at first and had friends doing a huge amount of campaigning from the start and it built from there. What has happened to Sabina, and all of these women is just horrific. I agree the focus needs to be on male violence’s

Cadent · 23/09/2021 17:59

@nyktipolos

When you post 'Doesn't scream 'we really care about this individual womans death and how her race is impacting reporting' to me' it's pretty obvious where your concerns lie.

Yes, it's doesn't scream that people care. Any side of the debate. I can't say that there's been any posts from people who claim not to care? So it would apply to all on the thread. The only reason you would think its aimed at only one side, is if only one side is saying these things. If that's the case why? What do they gain out of of it?

You're presuming an awful lot about people's intentions. All I see is lots of people disheartened by yet another forgotten about woman of colour.

I see a lot of people completely ignoring the massive differences between this case and others.

Ignoring the fact its actually a small amount of women that actually get alot of coverage, even when white. I mentioned several cases that barely made the national news, outside London concerning white women. Why didn't their cases are bug news?

This case has been compared by people on here to 2 cases that are completely different to this one. Anyone who cares to look at the detail can see the differences

Sabina has not and was not forgotten. Anyone who thinks she has is causing their own upset.

Yes, it's doesn't scream that people care. Any side of the debate. I can't say that there's been any posts from people who claim not to care? So it would apply to all on the thread. The only reason you would think its aimed at only one side, is if only one side is saying these things. If that's the case why? What do they gain out of of it?

The point is you’re trying to imply people who are saying her race is a factor in low coverage don’t care about her. When that’s not the case.

Whilst not every case gets media attention, the cases that have got attention in the past are of white females.

The only time the media cares when a black or brown woman or girl is killed is if it’s an honour killing (Banaz Mahmoud, Shafiliea Ahmed), because they can blame it on Asian culture.

Sabina has not and was not forgotten. Anyone who thinks she has is causing their own upset.

She is not being forgotten about now because of the people saying she needs to be remembered. If we left to you, she would be forgotten. See attached example of how little people cared until people spoke out about the lack of fucks given.

Why is Sabina Nessa murder not all over the media?
Annoyedanddissapointed · 23/09/2021 17:43

@JaniieJones

'If Madeline McCann was from a benefit reliant council homes child, would she have got the same amount of coverage?'

Yes. Shannon Matthews did.

Coverage. Yes. Continuous funding. Doubt it
Nuffaluff · 23/09/2021 17:41

Sabina’s murder is the third story down on my BBC news headlines page.
This is a new update from a couple of hours ago. I read another story about her yesterday, also on the front page. Her murder is being covered, prominently.

SueSaid · 23/09/2021 17:34

'If Madeline McCann was from a benefit reliant council homes child, would she have got the same amount of coverage?'

Yes. Shannon Matthews did.

HeadPain · 23/09/2021 17:25

If you look into it lots of women of all ethnicities are missing and/or murdered up and down the country and its not covered in main media. It was unusual that Sarah everard case was covered to the extent it was and generated such a movement.

Btw there have been 2 or 3 Asian women found dead and burned quite recently in the UK and nobody talking about it at all, except right wingers.

nyktipolos · 23/09/2021 17:24

When you post 'Doesn't scream 'we really care about this individual womans death and how her race is impacting reporting' to me' it's pretty obvious where your concerns lie.

Yes, it's doesn't scream that people care. Any side of the debate. I can't say that there's been any posts from people who claim not to care? So it would apply to all on the thread. The only reason you would think its aimed at only one side, is if only one side is saying these things. If that's the case why? What do they gain out of of it?

You're presuming an awful lot about people's intentions. All I see is lots of people disheartened by yet another forgotten about woman of colour.

I see a lot of people completely ignoring the massive differences between this case and others.

Ignoring the fact its actually a small amount of women that actually get alot of coverage, even when white. I mentioned several cases that barely made the national news, outside London concerning white women. Why didn't their cases are bug news?

This case has been compared by people on here to 2 cases that are completely different to this one. Anyone who cares to look at the detail can see the differences

Sabina has not and was not forgotten. Anyone who thinks she has is causing their own upset.

WoodburnersRUs · 23/09/2021 17:22

Smallman. Sorry, autocorrect. Nicole Smallman.

superplumb · 23/09/2021 17:22

@LizzieW1969

**EnidSpyton What really matters here is that another woman has been murdered by a man. Male violence is an epidemic, it is killing women every single day, of every skin colour, every social class, etc. Rather than infighting over 'privilege' when it comes to media reporting of female victims of male violence, perhaps we could direct our energies to working together to publicise, protest about and push for change when it comes to male violence?

Last week we had the poor woman, her two children and her daughter's friend murdered in their beds by her boyfriend in the news.

This week it's Sabina.

A month or so ago the incel bloke on a rampage in Portsmouth, killing his mother before murdering bystanders.

In between these cases have been hundreds more that have gone totally unreported.

Why? Because they're often classed as 'isolated domestic violence' incidents.

Calling this violence 'domestic' minimises it and enables it to be brushed under the carpet. Anything to do with the domestic is automatically classed as to do with women and therefore of lesser importance.

Anything 'domestic' is also automatically labelled as 'isolated' - i.e. nothing to see here, move on, won't affect you. Absolute bollocks. All domestic violence cases are linked - linked to a wider societal acceptance of male violence which exists due to patriarchy and a sense of male entitlement which makes all women, everywhere, all the time, vulnerable to abuse and injury. If the same number of men were murdered by female partners as the other way around, there would be legislation, there would be task forces, there would be education, there would be outcry. But because it's 'just' women being obliterated off the face of the earth on a regular basis, no one in power does anything about it.

This is made even worse by the pathetic women who join the #notallmen chorus every time a woman is murdered. No, it's not all men. But it's ALWAYS MEN. Isn't it? Men kill men, men kill women. Male violence is a thing. It's statistically proven, in every society, all over the world, since time immemorial - in general, men are violent and women aren't. Just because your husband or son is lovely, doesn't mean you can ignore the fact that men in general are violent towards women. And if you include harrassment, heckling, groping, sexist comments, sex discrimination, etc within the terminology of 'violence' - then we're all experiencing this, every single day, and denial that we are is the greatest victory of the patriarchy, I'm afraid.

On the topic of the thread, yes, there is of course racial bias in the media, when it comes to everything. There is also class bias, location bias, etc. A poor white woman's murder, or a white prostitute's murder, is not going to get reported in the national news in the same way a middle or upper class white woman's murder will be. The murder of someone in London will undoubtedly get more attention than in Northumberland. A university educated black or Asian woman with a high flying career being murdered will generate much higher volumes of interest in the media than a benefit-collecting white woman's murder. Any murder related to suspected gang violence will be brushed under the carpet. This isn't just about race, and is just as much about class, actually - notice how Sabina's image in the press has been of her with her university degree - emphasising that this was an educated, professional woman. Had she been a single mum on a council estate, the press coverage would have been very different.However, comparing Sabina and Sarah is like comparing apples with oranges. Sarah Everard was missing for several days with the hope she would be found alive - much of the press coverage was appealing for witnesses to try and find her. Sabina was found already murdered and a suspect already arrested. There's no real 'hook' for the media to hang a story on there. Nonetheless, I disagree that she hasn't had plenty of media coverage. She has. As she should. I hope that the perpetrator is swiftly caught and rots in hell for all eternity. I grew up nearby and know where she was murdered well - it's a space I've always thought of as very safe and quiet, and again, just emphasises that male violence can happen to any of us, anywhere, any time. This is what we need to be uniting to fight. In order to protect all women, everywhere.**

^I agree with this totally. There has been a lot of coverage, and rightly so. But there have been so many other murdered women who have barely been mentioned at all, 180 between last year’s and this year’s International Women’s Day, as Sadiq Kahn reminded us today.

Agree. Sadly the same when children go missing. If Madeline McCann was from a benefit reliant council homes child, would she have got the same amount of coverage? I suspect not. Child is a child and a murder is a murder regardless of who the victim is
WoodburnersRUs · 23/09/2021 17:21

GB News just did a segment on her - the man being interviewed referred to Sarah Everard and the sisters Bibaa Henry and Nicole Small as comparators saying that the link between them all and the reason that these murdered women are high profile is that they were murdered by strangers which is more unusual than women being murdered by partners. I was a) surprised GB news would devote coverage to it and b) pleased that he didn’t only refer to the murders of white women.

superplumb · 23/09/2021 17:19

Slightly misunderstood
Police do ( and I have) crimed rapes and sexual assaults on older ladies (sometimes well over 74). This report is about respondent surveys in order to understand stats on victims...it forsnt mean the police wont record it if you are over an age. Legally we must record all crimes unless police have evidence to the contrary a crime hasnt happened which rarely happens.

superplumb · 23/09/2021 17:12

Sadly, I expect it's because she wasnt white. That poor pcos was murdered quite soon after sarah and there were no vigils for her...because she was older perhaps, not quite so photogenic.

OverByYer · 23/09/2021 17:08

@DrSbaitso

On the point of older women: after a certain age, rapes of older women are not even included in UK rape statistics. What the f^k is that about?!*

What? Is there a link for this?

Bollocks