Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is Sabina Nessa murder not all over the media?

462 replies

postingfortraffichere · 22/09/2021 23:45

Such a tragic killing and sad, truly awful to hear about this murder.

Though I can't understand why, it doesn't get the same media/public attention as Sarah Everard who died in similarly tragic circumstances not long ago.

Both are equally tragic, two young women attacked in similar circumstances - the only difference I can see in these cases is the colour of their skin. Sarah's murder was everywhere - before we knew it was a police officer responsible.

Women had lined the streets in protest to make the country a safer place for women.

I can't help but notice where are these women protesting for Sabina? Or for the Killmarsh murders, or other women of colour?

The media treats women of colour - even to this day - very differently to white women.

It feels like the media are sending a clear message that black lives STILL 'don't matter' quite as much as their white counterparts.

OP posts:
Suzi888 · 23/09/2021 04:52

I knew nothing about it, still can’t see anything unless I go looking.

TheFairPrincess · 23/09/2021 04:47

I don't know why people are pearl clutching so hard right now, is it guilt/defensiveness?

This is an absolutely well known social phenomenon with decades of evidence behind it.

I am a white woman, there are lots of connotations to that which I am aware of. People seem to be personally offended by this OP which is very strange. You are not the victim here. Literal murder victims are.

elkiedee · 23/09/2021 03:53

I agree that some cases get far more coverage of a different type than others.

The police's shortcomings in investigating the horrible murders of Nicole Smallman and Bibaa Henry, two black sisters killed after celebrating a birthday with a picnic in the park, finally got more coverage this year, presumably thanks to the efforts of their brave mother, but that took some time too.

GoIntoTheLight · 23/09/2021 03:42

@UsedUpUsername it's not "ridiculous" at all - it's a well-known phenomenon called missing white women syndrome.

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Missing_white_woman_syndrome

GreenUp · 23/09/2021 03:06

If I recall rightly, there was a mass twitter storm and collective fury over police telling women in the area of Everad's murder to stay indoors. The police advice led to there being calls for a "curfew for men" and then lots of debate around whether men should be the ones to stay in. I think the police advice in some part galvanised the angry response from women who showed up to the vigil..

Also the longer time frame between Sarah going missing and being found and all the CCTV footage being shown on the news.

There's no doubt that there is a "missing white woman" factor going on as well but it seems more complicated i.e. the white female who gets big media attention is often blonde and middle class like Everard or Madeleine McCann.

Colouringaddict · 23/09/2021 02:25

I live less than a minute away from the crime scene. I don’t understand how she could have lain there for as long as is commented. It is a space that is always in use, youngsters on skateboards, footballers using the pitch. It’s a very busy road too.

My heart breaks for her poor family.

UsedUpUsername · 23/09/2021 02:22

@GammyLeg

You are right, OP. I remember on MN the boards were flooded with posts about Sarah. And rightly so - every time a woman is murdered by a man, we should be in uproar.

But BAME women are not afforded the same outcry.

This is ridiculous. Sarah did not get a lot of coverage as a missing person case, it was persistence by her loved ones that saw the case being bigger in the press. If you go missing, you better hope you have friends and family that can go to the press and not be easily discouraged if it doesn’t get immediately picked up.

Sabina’s case got huge attention the moment her body was found.

The reason BOTH cases eventually got huge attention was that they were murdered by a stranger.

If they were murdered by a partner, no one would care and we’d never hear about them.

Awful but true.

GatoradeMeBitch · 23/09/2021 02:18

It's probably too late at night to try and formulate this thought so I apologize if it comes across badly, not my intention, but in most cases the murderer is usually the same race as the victim, and I wonder if the media want to be careful to not add to negative/hateful stereotypes.

White men are really the only demographic in existence who can run around murdering and whatever else and it only reflects on them personally. In literally every other group the person will be held up as making everyone in their demographic look bad, and "see, this is why they can't be trusted/shouldn't have rights", so it becomes a more loaded issue.

Sorry if that sounded bollocks. But I agree that women of colour need as much representation in the media as white women, and as much assistance.

MumsTheWordFact · 23/09/2021 02:09

When I started reading this I knew you were going to ignore the obvious reason about the murderer being a police officer and go straight to blaming it on racism. You didn't disappoint did you?

Gimlisaxe · 23/09/2021 01:50

I wondered whether the police for some reason where trying to keep it quiet. Not sure if it works like that, but it was on Crimewatch a couple of days ago, and rather than this is what we know, this is the last time she was spotted, it was literally if you were in the park at such a time, please contact the police if you know anything. Not exactly that but hopefully you get my drift.

Plumtree391 · 23/09/2021 01:44

I think the fact that Sarah Everard was murdered by a police officer is what caused the large media coverage.

"Your post is a disgrace and an insult to Sarah Everard. And so is the whole thread. I am hiding this repugnant thread now. I am sure it won't last long. The OP @postingfortraffichere knows it's a stinker, and that is why she has posted it at almost midnight when there is little moderation."

Why is it a disgrace, an insult and repugnant? The op is entitled to express how she feels and what she has said is not unreasonable.

Plumtree391 · 23/09/2021 01:39

I've seen quite a bit about her and the case was on the news tonight (I mean last night, Wednesday).

ilovesooty · 23/09/2021 01:29

[quote MyPatronusIsACat]@MsHedgehog

Your post is a disgrace and an insult to Sarah Everard. And so is the whole thread. I am hiding this repugnant thread now. I am sure it won't last long. The OP @postingfortraffichere knows it's a stinker, and that is why she has posted it at almost midnight when there is little moderation.[/quote]
That's really uncalled for.

Eesha · 23/09/2021 01:26

I felt exactly the same Op. It was much lower on the DM yesterday, towards the bottom, then this morning it's at the top.c I only really started thinking about this when Maddeline Mccann went missing and remains a huge news story. Then when those two sisters were murdered reasonably near me, it should have been one of the biggest stories. I just wondered whether people thought they were two black girls out late and somehow 'paid the price for that'. I can imagine if they were white, their names would gave been plastered over the media. I assume this story is not being given much press because she might have known her perpetrator. There's definitely a strong element of race issues here.

Charley50 · 23/09/2021 01:24

RIP Sabina and Sarah and all the other murdered women. Agree with PPs saying there are big differences between the two cases; major one being Sarah being missing for days before the suspect being found to be a policeman with a history of sex offending, then her body being found.

Sabina wasn't reported missing so there was no search. There has been no details about if the attack was sexually motivated, and I think police initially suspected someone known to her. As we all know, a woman is murdered every three days by a partner or ex, and most don't get days of coverage, whatever their skin colour.

Let's hope they put enough resources into finding the killer so that women in that area can feel safer again.

Thatoneoverthere · 23/09/2021 01:19

I agree @KittyWindbag, 14 other women have died since August, at least 106 this year by men (stats care of Karen Ingala Smith) we won't know most their names either.
Also I'm in New Zealand and have seen and read about Sabina.

Theoldprospector · 23/09/2021 01:11

It may be that the level of disclosure is because there are other victims.

Diverseopinions · 23/09/2021 01:10

The murder took place on Friday and was discovered, I believe, on Saturday. It is only five days later now. I don't think there has been much information about this crime coming out. The local news shopper, within the last couple of days, had a short interview with one of Sabina's relatives, but locally , not a lot has been known, until, maybe yesterday.

genericuserneeded · 23/09/2021 01:05

Yes I agree with @Diverseopinions though I don’t necessarily believe the killer was known to her.

The police are being selective with the information divulged to the public about Sabina Nessa. It could be that they don’t want to tip the killer off. It could be that there’s v unique details that only the killer would know so they don’t want to compromise an investigation by making it public knowledge too early etc.

Eg they purposely haven’t released the cause of death, or details of a potential suspect or what clothing Sabina wore that day/where she was travelling from in case anyone saw them earlier that day.

Theoldprospector · 23/09/2021 01:05

‘Other posters are being deliberately obtuse because if you google Sabina Messa, of course you're going to find articles from reputable papers to link here.’

Well no, because that isn’t her name.

OP, you can ask MNHQ to edit the thread title to the correct name. It seems respectful to do so.

KittyWindbag · 23/09/2021 01:05

This post is disingenuous.

Yes it’s true that non-white victims are not historically known for gaining visibility and momentum in the way that white victims are.

However two things. It’s not comparable as Sarah was a missing person so there was a campaign to find her.

But second and really most importantly, people go missing and are murdered every day. The media don’t even scrape the surface of the reality of what goes on. If they did people would quickly turn the news off because it’s overwhelming and disgusting and terrifying. So to say ‘why isn’t Sabina getting the same energy as x’ is disingenuous, you might as well say ‘why isn’t (unknown) getting the same energy as Sabina’. There are too many murders, too many missing people, too many children and women being failed. Yes there is a wider problem of racism when it comes to representation, the justice system And societal response to victims and crime, but this simplification does no one any good, I think.

TangledUp789 · 23/09/2021 00:56

I followed the Sarah Everard disappearance from when I first read about her online, and it wasn’t actually a big story until the police officer was arrested for her murder. She wasn’t on the front pages of the newspapers when she went missing or when she was found dead.

I watched the BBC news at six tonight and Sabina featured on the main news and was the top story on the London news - roughly the same coverage as Sarah received before the arrest. I think Sabina is getting quite a lot of coverage actually - it helps that she’s young, female and pretty.

Diverseopinions · 23/09/2021 00:55

It's the fact that this talented and inspirational person wasn't missing. In the Sarah Everard case, the focus was on working out what had happened to her. I think this is the difference.

I suppose there is a careful police operation being carried out, currently. Presumably, the police don't feel that publicity will improve the effectiveness of their investigations.

The people in Sabina's community or area are shocked and in tears. They will be devastated at the school where she teaches.

I think it's important to talk about the press, and what they do, and any perceived bias. It isn't a case that ordinary people care less. The Sarah Everard case appeared to be a random attack, a stranger on a stranger, and massive publicity was launched to apprehend a dangerous criminal. Perhaps, the police don't think that the circumstances in this recent crime were the same. If there wasn't much publicity earlier, as a previous poster has said, perhaps the police, for whatever good reason, didn't want that publicity, for certain reasons.

MrsMaizel · 23/09/2021 00:51

@smallandimperfectlyformed

It's been trending on Twitter today and I'm from the Borough, my Facebook is full of reposts about it today and the council have also released a statement on Instagram but it is weird that her body was found last week and there wasn't so much press then. I do agree that women of colour are not given the same level of attention or concern when they go missing. Another woman has gone missing within the Borough but there was very little press about her, she is white but in her 50s so I think age is also a factor as to how much publicity a person's disappearance gets.
Don't you think that the initial attention and concern would come from her own community action ? Where is that ?
User5490453456 · 23/09/2021 00:50

YANBU OP, I'm online a lot and haven't seen anything about this case. Now that there's a thread about it, I do recall scrolling past one article low down on the DM a few days ago but there hasn't been enough coverage for me to remember the name. This is in stark contrast to the Gabby Petito case which is so prominent that virtually nobody can forget the name.

Other posters are being deliberately obtuse because if you google Sabina Messa, of course you're going to find articles from reputable papers to link here, but the huge difference is how long it was online and how many consecutive days were dedicated to the headline. I'm fairly certain that most newspapers do A/B testing on their headlines and if they notice certain stories losing traction then those get more hidden in favour of articles that pull in more views. It's a chicken or the egg scenario because once a story starts losing exposure then it's even less likely that people will know or care about it.

Interestingly the unsolved murder of two women in the USA from mid-August was also in a similar vein. They were white but in a same sex relationship and had an "alternative" type lifestyle that made them less relatable and the story disappeared from the news. However it only resurfaced again after Brian Laundrie (alleged murderer of Gabby Petito) was in the exact same area during his trip. It might all be a coincidence but it's proof how much power some cases have over others.