Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is Sabina Nessa murder not all over the media?

462 replies

postingfortraffichere · 22/09/2021 23:45

Such a tragic killing and sad, truly awful to hear about this murder.

Though I can't understand why, it doesn't get the same media/public attention as Sarah Everard who died in similarly tragic circumstances not long ago.

Both are equally tragic, two young women attacked in similar circumstances - the only difference I can see in these cases is the colour of their skin. Sarah's murder was everywhere - before we knew it was a police officer responsible.

Women had lined the streets in protest to make the country a safer place for women.

I can't help but notice where are these women protesting for Sabina? Or for the Killmarsh murders, or other women of colour?

The media treats women of colour - even to this day - very differently to white women.

It feels like the media are sending a clear message that black lives STILL 'don't matter' quite as much as their white counterparts.

OP posts:
SD1978 · 23/09/2021 06:46

One was missing, the other found dead. Sounds crass, but there is a difference in those two scenarios. I don't really think the situations can be compared although I also agree that crimes against certain people don't receive the same media coverage.

GCAcademic · 23/09/2021 06:46

Nobody is denigrating poor Sarah Everard here, if you cannot understand that then you are ridiculously stupid. You should be ashamed of yourself.

Unfortunately (and I say this as a brown person) there is a definite undertone of Sarah Everard being somehow privileged to have been kidnapped, raped and murdered while being white. Comments like “typical missing white woman syndrome” certainly convey that, especially when Sabina Nessa was not a missing person, but was discovered murdered (as indeed dozens of women are every year without much media interest at all, particularly older women) and the circumstances of the two cases are very different.

Nuffaluff · 23/09/2021 06:43

I do actually find it really offensive that the horrific murders of Nicole Henry, Bibaa Smallman, Sarah Everard and now Sabina Nessa are being played off against each other, in a strange kind of Top Trumps, when the actual issue is male violence. Sarah Everard was kidnapped and brutally sexually assaulted, for days maybe, before being murdered, and yet there is this strange focus on her being white and somehow lucky and privileged. She is dead, they are all dead.

Yes.

Booknooks · 23/09/2021 06:42

Interesting how some people refer to anyone who isn't white as black. Also it's possible to discuss the bias without referencing SE specifically, why not just say the coverage white women get?

Plumtree391 · 23/09/2021 06:42

Charlie50, you are right there, all that you said.

I read that Sarah Everard's family campaigned to keep her in the news before her body was found, otherwise we may have heard little about her going missing. Of course, once it was known that a police officer had kidnapped, raped and killed her, it became huge news, especially when it came out that fellow officers had been suspicious of him.

The police are generally rubbish when it comes to violent crimes on women, always have been.

wannabeamummysobad · 23/09/2021 06:40

It's because Sabina is not white. If the media and society were honest there is a hierarchy to the "importance/care" assigned to the public. It goes;

White women>white children>white men> non black people of colour>black men >black women.

History and current cases sadly show us this every day.

adrianmolesmole · 23/09/2021 06:39

My last 2 paras are aimed at @MyPatronusIsACat, not to the Mods!

adrianmolesmole · 23/09/2021 06:37

[quote MyPatronusIsACat]@MsHedgehog

Your post is a disgrace and an insult to Sarah Everard. And so is the whole thread. I am hiding this repugnant thread now. I am sure it won't last long. The OP @postingfortraffichere knows it's a stinker, and that is why she has posted it at almost midnight when there is little moderation.[/quote]
Your post is disgusting, over the top and ridiculous. Angry

How dare you call a thread trying to highlight the murder of a woman "repugnant" and a "stinker"?? Angry How dare you try to get it deleted.Hmm

Mods please don't delete this thread.

Nobody is denigrating poor Sarah Everard here, if you cannot understand that then you are ridiculously stupid. You should be ashamed of yourself.

Missing white woman syndrome is a real thing as we can all see. And so is Typical White Person's Knee Jerk Response to Anything Remotely Relating to POC, of which you are a clear example.

AGameOfCrones · 23/09/2021 06:34

@AtlasPine

Why are some people so defensive about the pointing out of institutional racism? It won’t change until we call it.
white fragility
UsedUpUsername · 23/09/2021 06:30

[quote GoIntoTheLight]@UsedUpUsername it's not "ridiculous" at all - it's a well-known phenomenon called missing white women syndrome.

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Missing_white_woman_syndrome[/quote]
Just because it has a Wikipedia entry doesn’t make it true.

The reality is, if you go missing, you need people to push the case to both the police and the media. With the latter, it’s an easier ‘sell’ if it’s an attractive woman killed by a stranger, sure.

But dubbing this phenomenon ‘missing white woman’ syndrome leaves out unattractive white women, old white women, poor white women, white women who were drug addicts or prostitutes.

Best example of this is the Cleveland kidnappings. There was just as much local coverage about Michelle Berry as there was about Gina DeJesus, who was not white. But Michelle Knight didn’t get any coverage as a poor white single mom from a broken home. No one was interested in her case, and her kidnapper taunted her with the fact no one was looking for her.

Someone tried to use the Cleveland case as an example of this phenomenon, btw, but you’ll see an interesting correction at the end of this article: www.bbc.com/news/magazine-22441124.amp

It seems the media is only interested in the ones when the murderer didn't know the victim

This is what drives a lot of it. If it’s a woman missing from domestic violence or via her work as a prostitute, then viewers feel safer (it won’t happen to me!)

But a stranger? Could happen to anyone then, and viewers feel unsafe. Drives interest in a case. Even if from an overall risk perspective, domestic violence is the far greater risk …

Pixxie7 · 23/09/2021 06:29

I think the OP makes a valid point a couple of years ago there had been a number of black boys stabbed and then a white girl which was widely reported with purple ribbons tied around the park. I remember thinking at the time.
Although the cases are different both involve 2 young women who have been killed.

AtlasPine · 23/09/2021 06:27

Why are some people so defensive about the pointing out of institutional racism? It won’t change until we call it.

smallandimperfectlyformed · 23/09/2021 06:27

@MrsMaizel I am sorry I don't understand your question. Are you asking me about the friends creating a campaign for Sabina or the other missing woman? For Sabina I don't really understand what they could have done as she wasn't missing for long at all, it sounds like she was just on her way home and was attacked. For the other woman (who I am not naming as the police deleted their tweet asking for help finding her so maybe she's been found) I saw some tweets but nothing on Facebook, no idea why.

Simonjt · 23/09/2021 06:16

Typical missing white woman syndrome, people claiming Sarahs awful murder was in the news more as she was killed by an officer, care to explain why coverage was so heavy before anyone knew it was an officer?

Blessing Olusegun is a classic case, police action wasn’t taken until her family complained.

adrianmolesmole · 23/09/2021 06:16

I agree with you Op.

The mainstream media are only just now starting to push Sabina's story mainly because of pressure from twitter and SM. they weren't doing it before.

Those posters trying to justify the difference in coverage between sarah snd sabina was because sarah went missing first are totally (wilfully?) missing the point. Many, many women of colour also go missing every day yet they don't get the same attention. At all.

Charley50 · 23/09/2021 06:12

@nyktipolos and @Balonzette - exactly!
I do actually find it really offensive that the horrific murders of Nicole Henry, Bibaa Smallman, Sarah Everard and now Sabina Nessa are being played off against each other, in a strange kind of Top Trumps, when the actual issue is male violence. Sarah Everard was kidnapped and brutally sexually assaulted, for days maybe, before being murdered, and yet there is this strange focus on her being white and somehow lucky and privileged. She is dead, they are all dead.

It's well known the police are generally shit for all women. Look at the rape conviction stats. Look at the response to domestic violence. Research the Yorkshire Ripper in the 70s and 80s. The police allowed him to kill dozens of working class white women and didn't care because they worked as prostitutes, before stepping up when a 'better class' of woman for murdered. Look at the hundreds of white girls all over northern England raped and trafficked and stalked for years, police couldn't give a shit.

Yes we all know the media love a pretty face. We know there is racism. We also know there is classism too. We also know there is misogyny. Do we have to play brutally murdered women off against each other all the time? I find it quite sick.

Briony123 · 23/09/2021 06:07

Sadly, a main reason for Sarah Everard's murder being huge news was that we were in lockdown, a lot of people needing an outlet for their anger (also with spare time). People are almost back to normal now, and the nation can't stop and protest every time someone is murdered.

Balonzette · 23/09/2021 05:49

Top story Daily Mail, and headline in the Sun, it's pretty low down on the BBC website but they have more intl news, and it's also a main story on the Mirror. I don't live in the UK so can't think of any other papers to check.

My social media is literally flooded with the story.

It's mentioned juat as much as the Sarah Everard case (and more so on my social media).

And of course, like posters said, the cases are not the same.

Sarah Everard was missing under mysterious and worrying circumstances for a long time. Hence appeal to find her. And then it turned out she was murdered by a POLICEMAN! That's a huge and terrifying story - a policeman (who carried a weapon as part of his job).

I don't see why a tragedy affecting another woman needs to be made into an argument about race when the cases seem to be moreorless reported exactly the same.

And there are women killed all the time, of every ethnicity, whose deaths go entirely unreported. It seems the media is only interested in the ones when the murderer didn't know the victim.

FreeBritnee · 23/09/2021 05:45

First story in the Mail Confused

nyktipolos · 23/09/2021 05:39

As a mixed race woman, it is known that white women as victims of crime get more coverage.

But I still think op is being disingenuous. There are other things to be taken into account. They are not 2 exact cases.

Such as Sarah's story was pushed in the press as she was missing. It was pushed by the police in the hope to find her. They were certain she had not gone missing of her own accord and were trying to find her in the hope she was still alive. In this case there wasn't chance to push it as she wasn't ever missing.

Also the fact that Sarah's killer was a serving police officer made it much bigger news.

I saw on TV yesterday there is infact a vigil/protest being organised. Just because one hasn't happened immediately doesn't mean its not happening. Sarah's case was big news because the police had to police the protestors while one of their own was responsible. The protest made news, in part, because of covid and the rules around gatherings.

People seem to ignore one fairly massive point which is really hypocritical. That had both these murders happened outside London, there would be barely any fuss at all. Sarah's case would probably have gone on to become a bigger news story, once the person arrested turned out to be a policeman.

But had he just been a shopkeeper or traffic warden etc, neither would have got big news.

Women go missing and are murdered all the time. Most don't make the news. Especially, outside London.

Eileen Barrot wasn't a big news story. Even though they didn't have the killer in custody.

The 5 women all murdered in South Yorkshire between March and June 2020, didn't make much of a news story either. All white women.

Op is also ignoring status. Had Sarah not been a 'professional' and Sabina not been a primary teacher, I think there would have been even less interest. Had they have been a sex workers or a cleaner, the papers and news channels and society in general would have cares less too.

I do think race plays a part. But there's tons of other factors that the OP is ignoring and placing it all on race. Which I find frustrating because its muddying the waters when tackling race issues.

The focus here, should be on finally doing something about male violence. Not on how much air time 2 different murders in different situations, get.

MsHedgehog · 23/09/2021 05:36

@Balonzette

It's literally all over the news.
Now it is. It wasn’t at first and even when it was creeping into the news, it wasn’t that big a story.
feesh · 23/09/2021 05:36

I’m not in the U.K., but I have BBC news 24 on a lot, and it’s been a running story since the weekend. An update is appearing on the news ticker this morning, although they haven’t discussed it in the studio yet.

MsHedgehog · 23/09/2021 05:35

@Orangejuicemarathoner

most murders are not reported. If they were, then there would be no room in the news for anything else. This terrible murder has had a surprising amount of coverage for a crime where someone has already been arrested and charged.

But the vast majority of murders are never never mentioned in the media at all, and most victims are men

This is plainly wrong. No one has been arrested and charged. They haven’t even found the culprit.
Balonzette · 23/09/2021 05:35

It's literally all over the news.

Orangejuicemarathoner · 23/09/2021 05:27

most murders are not reported. If they were, then there would be no room in the news for anything else. This terrible murder has had a surprising amount of coverage for a crime where someone has already been arrested and charged.

But the vast majority of murders are never never mentioned in the media at all, and most victims are men