Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is Sabina Nessa murder not all over the media?

462 replies

postingfortraffichere · 22/09/2021 23:45

Such a tragic killing and sad, truly awful to hear about this murder.

Though I can't understand why, it doesn't get the same media/public attention as Sarah Everard who died in similarly tragic circumstances not long ago.

Both are equally tragic, two young women attacked in similar circumstances - the only difference I can see in these cases is the colour of their skin. Sarah's murder was everywhere - before we knew it was a police officer responsible.

Women had lined the streets in protest to make the country a safer place for women.

I can't help but notice where are these women protesting for Sabina? Or for the Killmarsh murders, or other women of colour?

The media treats women of colour - even to this day - very differently to white women.

It feels like the media are sending a clear message that black lives STILL 'don't matter' quite as much as their white counterparts.

OP posts:
GammyLeg · 23/09/2021 07:34

"The reality is, if you go missing, you need people to push the case to both the police and the media. With the latter, it’s an easier ‘sell’ if it’s an attractive woman killed by a stranger, sure."

Having someone influential to make a noise on your behalf speaks to privilege. Look at all the indigenous women who have gone missing in Canada. Indigenous communities have been telling us about this for years, how many of us know any of the names of these women, compared to, say, Gabby Petito? It's because they are marginalised. They don't have the resources, or the influential friends, to make themselves heard.

Cadent · 23/09/2021 07:34

@WishingYouAMerryChristmasToo

The two women in the park - I think came across like they were having a party or something so assumptions were drug overdose or something, but yes colour has a part to play.

Are you serious?! There was not even a hint of drugs in coverage.

These attempts to find black women as less deserving of sympathy is truly disgusting.

Rainbow0821 · 23/09/2021 07:33

YABU It's all over the news.

YouJustDoYou · 23/09/2021 07:30

Society has lived with females being murdered for all of history. Sadly, it's yet another murder, yet another day.

Cadent · 23/09/2021 07:27

[quote Auroreforet]@GCAcademic
Meanwhile, the narrative that a woman was privileged to have been kidnapped, raped and murdered while white continues and we have a man on here whose first thought is how privileged white female murder victims are rather than looking to the issue of male violence, though he is not alone on MN in being oblivious to that. A thread that was started on that topic is languishing well down the boards with no one interested in discussing the apparently irrelevant topic of male violence.

This^^

I don't think Sarah Everard's family will feel privileged.

Surely the discussion can be had in general terms without referencing a soecific murdered white woman's privilege to be in the press. It feels very off to me.[/quote]
I think you and that poster have deliberately missed the point. No one is saying the murdered white woman is privileged. Is that really what you understand?

But the lack of reporting of assaults and murder of BAME women is linked to lack of police action over the these crimes against BAME women.

Calling this out does not detract from the memory of Sarah Everard at all. Saying the memory of a white woman is more important than calling out the disparity in reporting between murders of white women vs black women is tacit acceptance of the lack of media coverage.

RussianSpy101 · 23/09/2021 07:25

I live near Killamarsh. Terri wasn’t a woman of colour and there has been lots of coverage.

Runforthehillocks · 23/09/2021 07:23

Also worth remembering that sometimes the police tell the papers what to print/what they can't print, as part of the investigations. We don't see the whole picture. Hope they find whoever did this.

WishingYouAMerryChristmasToo · 23/09/2021 07:22

I think because it was presented, as female white professional vanishes and search and then the resulting horror that it was a police officer.

The two women in the park - I think came across like they were having a party or something so assumptions were drug overdose or something, but yes colour has a part to play.

For this one it was very quiet. Professional woman found dead in a park - I don’t understand the lack of media coverage - it should be all over every page - is there someone or something being held back - I don’t understand the lack of coverage.

The woman who died with the children the other day - killed by it appears a man she knew. But it did pop out at me that the father of the children said a statement which included something along the lines of ‘ex wives shouldn’t stop their husbands from seeing the children’ can’t remember the exact wording - and I thought now is not the time when she is dead - to say they- I read it as the implication that he hadn’t seen the kids as much as he wanted and she had stopped him - she isn’t here to say or what the reason was that he wasn’t involved as much as he wanted. Then a headline saying she was ‘pregnant’ like that might have been a reason for murder. And then victim blaming on here - why don’t women ask for Claire’s law disclosures against new partners - so if we don’t and have they have history of assault - that’s our fault too. We shouldn’t have to do Claire’s law on any potential new partner as men shouldn’t have been violent towards their previous partner. Even then we look at how they are raised - women get blamed for that too - we apparently make these monsters - again our fault. It’s all men killing their wives, girlfriends, strangers - it seems like they are out of control but no one wants to acknowledge the huge problem - which remains violence towards women and victim blaming. Men need to put their own house in order. It needs to come from within. Joking about giving ‘the ones with the big tits a good one’ as office banter needs to involve the other men going - you know what that could be my wife, daughter, mother - that’s disgusting I’m reporting you & we don’t want to work with men that treat women like meat.

Everything from women in high heels - designed to make the leg look longer and more attractive, skirts (easy access), make up - to look more attractive to a mate (sometimes women say …, but I like high heels!) etc men at work are comfy, practical and spend far less then us….. just realised I’m completed off topic, so back to the issue

Women were in a park having a party - breaking Covid rules? Victim blame on both counts. But yes two whites women would have had a different coverage.

I remember someone saying to me about Sarah E - what was she doing out at a friends house during Covid - and actually saying ‘she has no one to blame but herself’ and I’m thinking wtf right back to if you wear a short skirt - asking for it, out alone in the dusk - asking for it etc

Everything just seems to be directed at pointing all blame away from these men.

Auroreforet · 23/09/2021 07:21

specific

Cadent · 23/09/2021 07:20

@FreeBritnee

First story in the Mail Confused
Why are you confused? Funny how you and others like you post and run. Ashamed? Nothing else to say?

I agree OP, media coverage started very slow, the focus was on an AMERICAN white woman, rather than a BRITISH Asian woman. The sad thing is, I wasn’t even surprised.

Auroreforet · 23/09/2021 07:20

@GCAcademic
Meanwhile, the narrative that a woman was privileged to have been kidnapped, raped and murdered while white continues and we have a man on here whose first thought is how privileged white female murder victims are rather than looking to the issue of male violence, though he is not alone on MN in being oblivious to that. A thread that was started on that topic is languishing well down the boards with no one interested in discussing the apparently irrelevant topic of male violence.

This^^

I don't think Sarah Everard's family will feel privileged.

Surely the discussion can be had in general terms without referencing a soecific murdered white woman's privilege to be in the press. It feels very off to me.

DarceyDashwood · 23/09/2021 07:20

I really don’t get why people are so keen/quick to try to prove there’s no difference in media reporting when it comes to the murder of women of colour compared to white women. I don’t think it’s up for debate! Yes cases do get more momentum when someone is missing for a while before they are discovered, but there’s no denying there’s a disparity of coverage/outrage in certain cases.

I remember at the time of the Soham murders there was similar comparisons made to coverage of a murder of a young black boy that happened at the same time.

KittyMcKitty · 23/09/2021 07:19

@postingfortraffichere

Yes I appreciate there are news articles about it, but it hasn't dominated the news anywhere near Sarah ever area murder IMO
Because Sarah was white. Look at the coverage of Bibaa Henry and Nicole Smallman’s murders.
iloveeverykindofcat · 23/09/2021 07:16

@UsedUpUsername

Oh my God, I'm a sociologist Grin. I work for a major UK research university. I've read a lot more than a Wikipedia page. But yeah, I totally got my Russell Group PhD but copy and pasting, that's how it works.

UsedUpUsername · 23/09/2021 07:11

@iloveeverykindofcat

Just because it has a Wikipedia entry doesn’t make it true.

(Wikipedia page literally links to large bodies of statistical evidence)

I read through it (recommend ppl do, in fact) and it wasn’t actually very conclusive, which you would have noted if you’d read carefully through it.

But I suppose you’ll just copy and paste the evidence that supports your thesis, won’t you?

gerispringer · 23/09/2021 07:11

I live a few miles from this case and that of Sarah Everard, the Nessa story is all over the local news. It’s on the radio this morning - she was going out to meet a friend, so new evidence is coming out all the time. There is a vigil planned for tomorrow evening. so this idea that it isn’t being reported or no one cares is simply wrong.

OverByYer · 23/09/2021 07:09

It is all over the media.
Sarah Everard had a lot of coverage because she was missing before she was found murdered.
Sadly Sabina was found murdered. It’s another awful crime.

OnlyFoolsnMothers · 23/09/2021 07:08

Sarah was missing hence the media attention- equally though I don’t think non-white victims get as much press.
Also in the case of Sabina, the police had arrested someone before releasing so they didn’t take everything to the press straight away

wannabeamummysobad · 23/09/2021 07:04

@Nuffaluff you being offended doesn't change the discussion nor does it change what we are seeing in the press and society.

Yes, these women are all dead however, some of them had a better chance of being found alive due to the extra attention their cases received. God rest the soul of Blessing Olusegun who's family and bf told the police where and when she went missing (they were on the phone) yet the police did nothing for days until her body was found washed up in the sea. Rest the soul of the two sisters found murdered in the park- police officers had time to take selfie's with their bodies, send them on group chats etc but no time to investigate their murders.
Then we go to the west London case of the teen with sickle cell who's parents explained he was CEV yet the police did nothing for days until the black community and media started organising. His body was found on the other side of london in Epping forest despite leaving the house with no money or phone.
Finally (because I have to get ready for work), Stephen Lawrence; the police spent year's "investigating" how Stephen's friend contributed to his murder instead of arresting and prosecuting his racist murderers (people came forward with evidence that the racists did this). 20yrs later and Cresssida still won't admit there is institutionalised racism in the met police.

Spare your offence for their lives not the fact some people on this thread are highlighting a truth we sadly all see.

iloveeverykindofcat · 23/09/2021 07:02

Just because it has a Wikipedia entry doesn’t make it true.

(Wikipedia page literally links to large bodies of statistical evidence)

GCAcademic · 23/09/2021 07:01

Everyone points out all of the differences in the cases. No one had mentioned the glaringly obvious difference though, have they? One was white and one was not.

Surely that is the entire basis of this thread and the difference in their skin colour has been discussed by multiple posters? Very disingenuous to deny this.

Meanwhile, the narrative that a woman was privileged to have been kidnapped, raped and murdered while white continues and we have a man on here whose first thought is how privileged white female murder victims are rather than looking to the issue of male violence, though he is not alone on MN in being oblivious to that. A thread that was started on that topic is languishing well down the boards with no one interested in discussing the apparently irrelevant topic of male violence.

Jobseeker19 · 23/09/2021 07:00

Its everywhere what you talking about

nyktipolos · 23/09/2021 06:57

The people who are deny race ever has anything to do with it AND the ones sayings it just about race seem in capable of critical thinking and/or seeing detail and/or nuance.

There's a shit of ton of reasons there's reporting differences. Race very well play a small part. But its not the only or main part.

Charley50 · 23/09/2021 06:53

Yes @adrianmolesmole - and many white women and girls go missing everyday in the UK, and don't get any media attention at all. There are hundreds of runaways and trafficked girls not getting media attention, of all ethnicities.

Do not forget class in this. Even at the time of Bibaa and Nicole's murder, their mum mentioned colour AND perceived class (due to their address) in lack of police response to take their going missing seriously.

Think of Natalie Connolly; brutally killed (murdered IMO) and left to die by her millionaire partner. Both white. He got two years I think for manslaughter.

Lasttimeneveragain · 23/09/2021 06:49

@TheFairPrincess

I don't know why people are pearl clutching so hard right now, is it guilt/defensiveness?

This is an absolutely well known social phenomenon with decades of evidence behind it.

I am a white woman, there are lots of connotations to that which I am aware of. People seem to be personally offended by this OP which is very strange. You are not the victim here. Literal murder victims are.

It stinks very much of "I'm not a racist but........"

Everyone points out all of the differences in the cases. No one had mentioned the glaringly obvious difference though, have they? One was white and one was not.

There has already been a suggestion up thread that it was honour based. Why do we make this assumption? Hmm