Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why is Sabina Nessa murder not all over the media?

462 replies

postingfortraffichere · 22/09/2021 23:45

Such a tragic killing and sad, truly awful to hear about this murder.

Though I can't understand why, it doesn't get the same media/public attention as Sarah Everard who died in similarly tragic circumstances not long ago.

Both are equally tragic, two young women attacked in similar circumstances - the only difference I can see in these cases is the colour of their skin. Sarah's murder was everywhere - before we knew it was a police officer responsible.

Women had lined the streets in protest to make the country a safer place for women.

I can't help but notice where are these women protesting for Sabina? Or for the Killmarsh murders, or other women of colour?

The media treats women of colour - even to this day - very differently to white women.

It feels like the media are sending a clear message that black lives STILL 'don't matter' quite as much as their white counterparts.

OP posts:
VestaTilley · 23/09/2021 08:39

It’s been high up on bbc news and the papers. I’ve had it all over my Twitter feed for days. It’s absolutely awful what has happened to Sabina.

Some stories run and run in the press more than others, some are a slower burn. I expect most people assumed Sabina was killed by someone she knew, which is no less awful, but as a more frequently committed crime that would also be less unusual. If that turns out not to be the case then I expect it will get much bigger as a story by next week as people realise there’s a killer on the loose.

The Sarah Everard case isn’t comparable, because at first she was missing, which was out of character, then it emerged she’d been snatched off the street, driven miles away, raped and murdered. That’s not the same profile of crime as in this case- though that does not reduce in any way the tragedy of it.

bellabasset · 23/09/2021 08:37

There was a lot of news about Sarah as she had disappeared on her walk home and the awful circumstances of her death by a serving police officer.

It seems possible that Sabina's body was found before anyone realised she was missing. Her poor family, I can't imagine anything worse than knowing your lovely dd or sister has been killed by a stranger. She was such a pretty girl

Cadent · 23/09/2021 08:36

@Innocenta

Also, the title of the thread itself was misspelt, and Sabina's name has been repeatedly erroneously written in various people's posts. I really think those claiming she is receiving no attention from the media could at least take the time to check their own spelling, as a matter of respect.
I agree. I said to @Onyernelly that she spelt Sabina’s name wrong, and instead of saying she’ll ask MNHQ to fix it, she told me to fuck off. BAME woken are definitely lesser in the eyes of people.
Annoyedanddissapointed · 23/09/2021 08:36

@UsedUpUsername

However those of us who are white are privileged regardless of our status, we often don't realise and just take it for granted. We have to step outside of our box to see it objectively

If you are a woman over 40, good luck getting anyone to care about your being missing or murdered, especially if you also happen to be poor or ‘doing something’ (ie on drugs or sex work) to be seen as related somehow.

This is far more relevant than skin colour.

There is white and there is not white enough just an fyi. The "missing white woman syndrome" should be "missing local white woman syndrome".

Re this vs previous case. They are completely different. Shouldn't be compared when it comes to coverage. Sad to say that of course missing person case will gain more traction than body dound case. However it is and have been in media a lot. I've seen it on my feeds on SM as well.

Fredstheteds · 23/09/2021 08:36

So sad- only picked it up in the NEU - teaching union .

GCAcademic · 23/09/2021 08:36

[quote ithinkilikeit]@GCAcademic you are particularly missing the pint and trying to use the fact that you are apparently a women of colour (which none of us can verify and is frankly irrelevant ) to support your point. Why do you think that people can only talk about one thing at a time. Why don’t you start a thread about male violence instead of insisting that people talking about a specific issue in disparity of media reporting are missing the point about male violence.[/quote]
Oh here we go. I must be lying about my skin colour because I don't think in the way that brown people presumably do (because we are all the same , right?).

I have been on loads of threads on here about male violence. They always go the same way. They end up being derailed by the NAMALT and "not my Nigel" brigade. I even attracted a creepy stalker on here as a result of pointing out male violence. There is a thread in Feminism about this case in relation to male violence. It's not received much attention other than from the usual FWR posters.

SueSaid · 23/09/2021 08:35

As pp have said Julia James, a white woman walking her dog murdered a short time after Sarah did not get vigils or massive press coverage either.

It has nothing to do with skin colour.

Chicchicchicchiclana · 23/09/2021 08:35

There was a similar thread on Mumsnet after the murder of Julia James. It was thought that her story didn't get as much attention because she wasn't young and beautiful as Sarah.

I have noticed some odd things in the reporting of Sabina's murder. The police have mentioned that there was "a delay" in finding her body and apologised. Apparently she was murdered at 8.30 in the evening and her body found after 5pm the following day. So had she been reported missing and were people looking for her, or was her body found in passing?

The lack of details about any suspect is disconcerting. But there could well be a valid police reason for that.

RIP Sabina and I hope the evil bastard who snatched your life away is charged soon.

Cadent · 23/09/2021 08:34

[quote Clarefromwork]I always thought the murders of sisters Nicole Smallman and Bibaa Henry didn’t get a lot of media attention. I only realised now from reading this article that the family didn’t receive a lot of support from the police and found the bodies themselves. Awful

www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-london-57679755[/quote]
Not only that, but the police actually took selfies with their mutilated bodies.

Cadent · 23/09/2021 08:34

@GCAcademic

Saying it’s a privilege to have friends speak for you is not the same as saying Sarah Everard was privileged. The former is a truth, the latter would be cruel and tasteless. Do you really not see the difference?

The discussion was about Sarah Everard. Therefore it's not unreasonable to think that while the general can be extrapolated from the specific, a general point can also be taken to apply to the specific case that was being discussed on the thread.

I did think it was cruel and tasteless, yes.

More obfuscation from you. The poster made a general point. No one has said Sarah Everard was privileged.
Clarefromwork · 23/09/2021 08:33

I always thought the murders of sisters Nicole Smallman and Bibaa Henry didn’t get a lot of media attention. I only realised now from reading this article that the family didn’t receive a lot of support from the police and found the bodies themselves. Awful

www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-london-57679755

Innocenta · 23/09/2021 08:33

Also, the title of the thread itself was misspelt, and Sabina's name has been repeatedly erroneously written in various people's posts. I really think those claiming she is receiving no attention from the media could at least take the time to check their own spelling, as a matter of respect.

ithinkilikeit · 23/09/2021 08:33

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

Cadent · 23/09/2021 08:32

@UsedUpUsername

However those of us who are white are privileged regardless of our status, we often don't realise and just take it for granted. We have to step outside of our box to see it objectively

If you are a woman over 40, good luck getting anyone to care about your being missing or murdered, especially if you also happen to be poor or ‘doing something’ (ie on drugs or sex work) to be seen as related somehow.

This is far more relevant than skin colour.

Skin colour is very relevant unfortunately.

The Office of National Statistics said:

For the year ending March 2018 to year ending March 2020 combined, the Crime Survey for England and Wales (CSEW) showed that those in the Black or Black British and Mixed ethnic groups were significantly more likely than those in the White, Asian or Other ethnic groups to experience sexual assault within the last year (Figure 5)

www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/crimeandjustice/articles/sexualoffencesvictimcharacteristicsenglandandwales/march2020

EnidSpyton · 23/09/2021 08:32

What really matters here is that another woman has been murdered by a man. Male violence is an epidemic, it is killing women every single day, of every skin colour, every social class, etc. Rather than infighting over 'privilege' when it comes to media reporting of female victims of male violence, perhaps we could direct our energies to working together to publicise, protest about and push for change when it comes to male violence?

Last week we had the poor woman, her two children and her daughter's friend murdered in their beds by her boyfriend in the news.

This week it's Sabina.

A month or so ago the incel bloke on a rampage in Portsmouth, killing his mother before murdering bystanders.

In between these cases have been hundreds more that have gone totally unreported.

Why? Because they're often classed as 'isolated domestic violence' incidents.

Calling this violence 'domestic' minimises it and enables it to be brushed under the carpet. Anything to do with the domestic is automatically classed as to do with women and therefore of lesser importance.

Anything 'domestic' is also automatically labelled as 'isolated' - i.e. nothing to see here, move on, won't affect you. Absolute bollocks. All domestic violence cases are linked - linked to a wider societal acceptance of male violence which exists due to patriarchy and a sense of male entitlement which makes all women, everywhere, all the time, vulnerable to abuse and injury. If the same number of men were murdered by female partners as the other way around, there would be legislation, there would be task forces, there would be education, there would be outcry. But because it's 'just' women being obliterated off the face of the earth on a regular basis, no one in power does anything about it.

This is made even worse by the pathetic women who join the #notallmen chorus every time a woman is murdered. No, it's not all men. But it's ALWAYS MEN. Isn't it? Men kill men, men kill women. Male violence is a thing. It's statistically proven, in every society, all over the world, since time immemorial - in general, men are violent and women aren't. Just because your husband or son is lovely, doesn't mean you can ignore the fact that men in general are violent towards women. And if you include harrassment, heckling, groping, sexist comments, sex discrimination, etc within the terminology of 'violence' - then we're all experiencing this, every single day, and denial that we are is the greatest victory of the patriarchy, I'm afraid.

On the topic of the thread, yes, there is of course racial bias in the media, when it comes to everything. There is also class bias, location bias, etc. A poor white woman's murder, or a white prostitute's murder, is not going to get reported in the national news in the same way a middle or upper class white woman's murder will be. The murder of someone in London will undoubtedly get more attention than in Northumberland. A university educated black or Asian woman with a high flying career being murdered will generate much higher volumes of interest in the media than a benefit-collecting white woman's murder. Any murder related to suspected gang violence will be brushed under the carpet. This isn't just about race, and is just as much about class, actually - notice how Sabina's image in the press has been of her with her university degree - emphasising that this was an educated, professional woman. Had she been a single mum on a council estate, the press coverage would have been very different.However, comparing Sabina and Sarah is like comparing apples with oranges. Sarah Everard was missing for several days with the hope she would be found alive - much of the press coverage was appealing for witnesses to try and find her. Sabina was found already murdered and a suspect already arrested. There's no real 'hook' for the media to hang a story on there. Nonetheless, I disagree that she hasn't had plenty of media coverage. She has. As she should. I hope that the perpetrator is swiftly caught and rots in hell for all eternity. I grew up nearby and know where she was murdered well - it's a space I've always thought of as very safe and quiet, and again, just emphasises that male violence can happen to any of us, anywhere, any time. This is what we need to be uniting to fight. In order to protect all women, everywhere.

IReallyCantThinkOfAnything · 23/09/2021 08:31

Sarah was kidnapped and murdered by a police officer who is supposed to protect us. I think that contributed to the level of news coverage.

However, Sabina is the first story on everything I’ve seen this morning. Rightly so, the level of violence towards women in society is at epidemic proportions.

Innocenta · 23/09/2021 08:31

It can simultaneously be true that (1) missing white woman syndrome is real, and BAME victims are less-covered by the media, AND (2) Sarah and Sabina's cases have key differences that make it fairly unhelpful to compare them.

I think it's important to note that where it's possible to draw direct factual comparisons - e.g. the details of the vigil - Sabina is not being neglected or unrecognised. Ignoring that makes the dialogue about this issue feel counterfactual, whereas it should be possible to acknowledge the realities of how her case is (rightly) being accorded public attention, and yet still to discuss the wider systemic neglect of BAME victims.

Watercoloursky · 23/09/2021 08:30

@OnwardsAndSideways1

I'd forgotten about Julia James, and that was also a very random murder in a very ordinary setting, I think she was taking her dog for a walk, like millions of women do every evening.

Women were told to avoid woods, to lower their risk, just like they now need to avoid parks, police, and indeed probably going outside at all if they don't want to get murdered...

I remember there were threads on Mumsnet at the time asking why her case wasn't getting more publicity (eg www.mumsnet.com/Talk/_chat/4233918-The-Murder-of-Julia-James)
GCAcademic · 23/09/2021 08:30

Saying it’s a privilege to have friends speak for you is not the same as saying Sarah Everard was privileged. The former is a truth, the latter would be cruel and tasteless. Do you really not see the difference?

The discussion was about Sarah Everard. Therefore it's not unreasonable to think that while the general can be extrapolated from the specific, a general point can also be taken to apply to the specific case that was being discussed on the thread.

I did think it was cruel and tasteless, yes.

wellards · 23/09/2021 08:29

I think Sarah's case was actually the anomaly in terms of press attention. For one "disappearing" of the street & going missing is more of a story then finding a body & arresting someone. It's unpalatable but it's true plus the police officer as the suspect is also a big deal.

I also think there is a tendency to "other" victims & this does happen to ethnic minorities more than white but does also apply generally. You see a murder victim in the paper & see someone is arrested & assume the suspect is known to the victim because that's what we are always told & you feel "safer" because it wasn't a stranger attack. Sabina's case is getting more attention now because I don't think they have a suspect. All these cases need more attention.

DukeOfEarlGrey · 23/09/2021 08:29

@Simonjt

Typical missing white woman syndrome, people claiming Sarahs awful murder was in the news more as she was killed by an officer, care to explain why coverage was so heavy before anyone knew it was an officer?

Blessing Olusegun is a classic case, police action wasn’t taken until her family complained.

Without wanting to diminish any of the other factors in discussion here, I’m pretty sure that things are known well before we see them in the press and that what we then receive as the public is an attempt at control / management of these women’s stories.
Dontgetyerknicksinatwist · 23/09/2021 08:29

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Shoxfordian · 23/09/2021 08:28

There have been several women murdered since Sarah Everard; majority of which are not reported to the same level as her death

Cadent · 23/09/2021 08:27

@GCAcademic

What’s weak is asserting a statement was made ‘Sarah Everard was priviliged’ and then not being able to back it up and quoting someone out of context. No one has said Sarah Everard was priviliged.

Yes, they did. I literally posted the comment that said that having friends to advocate "on your behalf speaks to privilege". You're the one taking that comment out of context, because it was said within the specific context of a discussion on the thread about Sarah Everard's friends advocating "on her behalf" (as if she fucking benefitted from it, ffs). It's not me who is taking posts out of context.

Saying it’s a privilege to have friends speak for you is not the same as saying Sarah Everard was privileged. The former is a truth, the latter would be cruel and tasteless. Do you really not see the difference?
Dontgetyerknicksinatwist · 23/09/2021 08:27

It is the top story on the Mail online.

Swipe left for the next trending thread