Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Dog lovers please help

36 replies

Thefieldofdreams · 22/09/2021 22:12

Hello.
I am really very upset as my old dog is in her twilight year. We are recently bereaved and am carrying so much grief.
We have been offered another dog.and I really feel that it wd be wrom
G for our elderly dog. However i also kmow that the presence of another dog would help me massively when.my okd dog passes. I wanr ro put my old dog first alomgside kmowing that i.really am struggling amd i honstely fear another loss.
Am.i bu ro put my fears and sadness first.
Mt mates say our dog will.adapt. she sleeps most of rhw day and the dog we have seen seems chilled.
Am so upset.

OP posts:
Yarboosucks · 22/09/2021 22:21

You would need to see how the two dogs get along. Let you old dog decide. BUT the younger dog will not ease the pain of your older dog passing

chequeredinlove · 22/09/2021 22:21

My parents thought my old dog who is 15 would suffer being around my young and energetic rescues. Instead she plays with them and it’s like seeing a young dog again.

It won’t hurt your old dog, I would get the new dog. The grief is too much, it isn’t bearable and I’d do anything to not feel the pain quite so much.

Frequency · 22/09/2021 22:19

It really depends on the dogs involved. For the odd few an older dog and a puppy can work out. For most it doesn't.

I have a five month old pup with a 14yo senior but I worked for a rescue when the senior was younger so he was used to random dogs coming and going and very good at exerting his boundaries and claiming his space without aggression. The pup came from a rescue where he was very heavily socialised with dogs of all ages and learned from day one to respect the boundaries of other dogs.

It's actually benefitted the senior as he now "plays" instead of sleeping all day. His play involves standing in the middle of the room barking in order to encourage the pup to run zoomies around him rather than actual physical play but they both seem to enjoy it.

Is there any way you could trial it for a week?

Houseonahill · 22/09/2021 22:19

It depends if your current dog literally is on her last legs as in weeks to live, then I would say no as your current dog needs your attention but if she's just old and the new dog is a puppy I think it might be good for all, anecdotally we got a puppy when our dog was 11 and he loved her, and my friend got a puppy earlier this year and her older dog was quite poorly and she says the older dog has almost got a new lease of life, she's much more playful and lively than she was. So long as the old dog has somewhere quiet to escape to if they need it I don't see the harm Smile

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 22/09/2021 22:18

I wouldn’t bring a new dog in now. Your old one is settled in their ways and a new dog will be disruptive.

Sorry.

Thefieldofdreams · 22/09/2021 22:18

No he is 6 and settled

OP posts:
ArcherDog · 22/09/2021 22:18

I think it would be pretty distressing for your elderly dog to bring a new dog into the house.

Raffles1981 · 22/09/2021 22:17

I'm not sure I could do it. If we had two dogs and one died, it would be a different matter. But for me, another dog in the house would just link it to the grief of losing my boy. But this is what works for you so if you honestly feel another dog would help and you are sure the atmosphere would be right, then do what works for you. Sorry about your dog OP, heres to lots of fun over the rainbow when it comes Flowers

AlCalavicci · 22/09/2021 22:17

I would not get another dog while your old one is still alive , it could be to much for her , esp if it is a boisterous dog.

Wait for a while , allow yourself to grieve , then consider rescuing another dog

NiceTwin · 22/09/2021 22:15

Is the potentially new dog a puppy?

Thefieldofdreams · 22/09/2021 22:14

Am so struggle with this and have not slept.for 2 nights.

OP posts: