Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Drinking in pregnancy

463 replies

PurplePizzaCake · 22/09/2021 21:24

AIBU in thinking it's OK to have the odd glass of wine while pregnant? Maybe 2 very small glasses a week?

Yes = YABU and shouldn't drink that much/anything at all

No= it's fine to have the odd glass

OP posts:
Drumgley · 24/09/2021 13:51

@TheKeatingFive

I can see how my child is affected

I am so sorry for your situation, but your child wasn’t affected by minimal levels of drinking.

You know literally nothing about this.

Drumgley · 24/09/2021 13:48

@TheKeatingFive

there's a diagnosis that states otherwise!

Presumably based on self reported usage, which doesn’t actually get us anywhere,

Eh no. Birth mum is dead. This relates to the clear physical facial features related to FASD.

Drumgley · 24/09/2021 13:47

[quote YourFinestPantaloons]@Drumgley

No - it states any levels of drinking could be harmful.

Where?
You're wrong - it states we don't know what levels are harmful. That's not the same as 'any levels are harmful'

With the greatest of respect I think you're situation is colouring your view, which is understandable but it doesn't make it ok to lie to women.

@nameisnotimportant none of those links provide evidence that just one drink harms a baby. That's what I'm looking for because SO many people here have said it.[/quote]

If you can't actually read a full article and see what's in it, I'm not wasting more time assisting you in spelling it out.

One drink at any time in pregnancy can cause FASD. Ask a GP or midwife, should I drink alcohol in pregnancy? and they will advise you not to, for this reason. Are they lying to you?

Alcohol is a drug. If you would not feed alcohol to your newborn, being aware of the risks that carries, why would you do it in the womb? Your argument makes no sense.

TheKeatingFive · 24/09/2021 13:43

I didn't say she couldn't make the choice herself

I personally wouldn't take the risk.

I am certainly cool with these points anyway

Kdubs1981 · 24/09/2021 13:39

@PurplePizzaCake

Sometimes I think it's easier to accept a drink at a social occasion than basically telling people you are pregnant by not drinking
You absolutely should not be drinking if you are so early in your pregnancy that you do not want to tell people yet.

This is the time it has its greatest (neurotoxic) effect. It has its biggest impact on a baby's central nervous system int he early developmental stage

SylvanasWindrunner · 24/09/2021 13:38

Yes, even NOFAS say:

'Myth: A single drink containing one ounce of alcohol during pregnancy, or occasionally during pregnancy, has been scientifically linked to affects that can be diagnosed as an FASD.

While only abstention from alcohol during pregnancy completely eliminates any risk to the embryo or fetus, there is no published research of a diagnosis of an FASD from prenatal exposure to an ounce of alcohol. It is possible that a drink could have a subtle harmful effect, but it has not been scientifically shown that such an effect would reach the criteria necessary for a diagnosis under the FASD umbrella.'

nameisnotimportant · 24/09/2021 13:38

@TheKeatingFive
I didn't say she couldn't make the choice herself. I gave my opinion that I thought drinking twice a week was too much and I personally wouldn't take the risk.

nameisnotimportant · 24/09/2021 13:36

@YourFinestPantaloons
I didn't say that the links to the research provided evidence that one drink causes FASD. I said I thought two drinks a week for the whole pregnancy was drinking quite regularly, which the research shows does have an affect. I also stated that I personally don't think the occasional drink has too much of an affect but by occasional, I mean 2-3 drinks for the whole pregnancy.

TheKeatingFive · 24/09/2021 13:36

their regular alcohol consumption caused FASD

And we can’t use this to decide that minimal drinking levels cause fasd, especially as there is absolutely no evidence at a macro level to back that up. Of course we can’t have double bind trials, but where are the shifts in levels we’d expect to see as guidelines change?

Therefore, most health officials and governing bodies air on the side of caution.

Well sure. It doesn’t mean a well informed woman shouldn’t make that choice for herself.

YourFinestPantaloons · 24/09/2021 13:35

[quote nameisnotimportant]@YourFinestPantaloons
I have also nursed babies with FAS, where the mother has just had a daily drink during pregnancy. It's not just the junkie, alcoholic mums that have FAS babies. Once you see a baby suffering like that, it changes your perception on it being worth the risk. [/quote]
That's what they tell you. This is why it's a notoriously difficult area to study, because women aren't going to be truthful when they hear there's repercussions

LaundryForever · 24/09/2021 13:34

I'm guessing you declared your drinking to your midwife and then listened to their advice?

ohfook · 24/09/2021 13:33

@arield

Ugh I hate this obtuse passive aggression of the faux-dippy "I just don't undy-stand" that women do. Fucking grow up, and say what you mean

I'm not being PA, I think anyone who can't go without alcohol for 9 months needs to look at their relationship with alcohol in general

And I think anyone who judges women for making a completely rational decision based on actual science not fudged generalisations needs to look at their attitude to women.

I cannot stand this one size fits all treating of pregnant women like imbeciles. Give us the actual data and let us make our own informed decisions like the responsible adults we are. Then if one person chooses to or not to drink alcohol, eat bagged salad or runny eggs or anything else they're doing it from a place of knowledge not just because or some imagined risk.

YourFinestPantaloons · 24/09/2021 13:33

@Drumgley

No - it states any levels of drinking could be harmful.

Where?
You're wrong - it states we don't know what levels are harmful. That's not the same as 'any levels are harmful'

With the greatest of respect I think you're situation is colouring your view, which is understandable but it doesn't make it ok to lie to women.

@nameisnotimportant none of those links provide evidence that just one drink harms a baby. That's what I'm looking for because SO many people here have said it.

nameisnotimportant · 24/09/2021 13:32

@TheKeatingFive
Yes unfortunately self reporting is not very accurate and usually the amount they say they have drunk is less than it probably is in reality but that doesn't negate the fact that their regular alcohol consumption caused FASD in their baby. I don't think there will ever be concrete evidence because it would be unethical to conduct a proper double blind trial to really measure the effects per drink. Therefore, most health officials and governing bodies air on the side of caution.

YourFinestPantaloons · 24/09/2021 13:31

@TheKeatingFive

No one has yet addressed the question of why, if minimal levels drinking can lead to FASD do we not see clear drops in levels after guidelines change or clear differences across levels in countries with different guidelines.
Yep, I wonder why that is
YourFinestPantaloons · 24/09/2021 13:31

@Newpuppymummy

This makes me so sad. That you need to ask snd the results of the poll. If you’d been around children with FASD you wouldn’t ask. No amount is safe
@Newpuppymummy link to the source that backs up your claim please?
Glssr195726113493 · 24/09/2021 13:29

Drumgley you said in your first post, “I'm an adopted mum to a child exposed to drugs and alcohol in the womb”

Your post doesn’t sound like the child was exposed to minimal levels of alcohol does it? Especially as the child was subsequently put up for adoption.

So it sounds like while you’re obviously emotionally affected by your adopted child’s situation and that is understandable, you’re really not qualified to be haranguing women about the odd drink in pregnancy and making claims that even one exposure is enough to damage the child. Because the evidence says otherwise.

TheKeatingFive · 24/09/2021 13:26

there's a diagnosis that states otherwise!

Presumably based on self reported usage, which doesn’t actually get us anywhere,

TheKeatingFive · 24/09/2021 13:25

I have also nursed babies with FAS, where the mother has just had a daily drink during pregnancy.

Self reported usage which is inaccurate sadly.

TheKeatingFive · 24/09/2021 13:24

No - it states any levels of drinking could be harmful

I know why the policy decision has been taken to say that and I’m capable of interpreting the data myself. I understand the cultural context that leads to decisions like this being taken without any data to merit them.

So I’m all good thanks,

nameisnotimportant · 24/09/2021 13:22

@YourFinestPantaloons
I have also nursed babies with FAS, where the mother has just had a daily drink during pregnancy. It's not just the junkie, alcoholic mums that have FAS babies. Once you see a baby suffering like that, it changes your perception on it being worth the risk.

Iris2020 · 24/09/2021 13:22

.
I personally don't drink at all when pregnant but would understand someone having say, 2 glasses over the course of the whole pregnancy to celebrate an anniversary and wedding for example.

I definitely wouldn't feel it was reasonable to consume alcohol with any level of regularity.

YourFinestPantaloons · 24/09/2021 13:20

@Drumgley so you can say for sure that your child is affected because of ONE incident of exposure to alcohol?

Drumgley · 24/09/2021 13:20

@TheKeatingFive

I can see how my child is affected

I am so sorry for your situation, but your child wasn’t affected by minimal levels of drinking.

There's a diagnosis that states otherwise! Shall I tell our paediatric team that Mumsnet states they are liars?!

Glssr195726113493 · 24/09/2021 13:20

[quote Drumgley]Please, please don't. I'm an adopted mum to a child exposed to drugs and alcohol in the womb - the effects of even one exposure incident to alcohol in the womb can be lifelong and leave a child with challenges that could otherwise be avoided. It's not always recognised as Foetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorder which is why people are unaware of the risks. It's as dangerous as smoking during pregnancy would be. So I'm begging you - please wait until your child is born.
www.nhs.uk/conditions/foetal-alcohol-syndrome/[/quote]
Your situation is shit and I’m sorry. But what you’re saying is inherently wrong and fear-mongering.

Also that’s not evidence, that’s a link to blanket advice given by the NHS as they cannot say that any level is safe, because some pregnant women would take one drink to mean one bottle of vodka, so instead they advise against anything to cover themselves.