Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Drinking in pregnancy

463 replies

PurplePizzaCake · 22/09/2021 21:24

AIBU in thinking it's OK to have the odd glass of wine while pregnant? Maybe 2 very small glasses a week?

Yes = YABU and shouldn't drink that much/anything at all

No= it's fine to have the odd glass

OP posts:
Shieldmaiden00 · 23/09/2021 16:20

I had one sip of champagne while pregnant to toast a marriage celebration. It wasn't difficult for me not to drink and I'm thankful I didn't have more. My DC has as an intellectual disability and ASD, I wrongly already have a lot of guilt and worry that something I did caused this. I'd do anything to take their struggles away, thankfully there's no worry that alcohol played a part.

ManifestDestinee · 23/09/2021 16:17

But we're talking about regular drinking here, 2-3 times a week, pregnant or not, isn't a small amount of drinking. There absolutely have been women who say they drink a a small regular amount throughout their pregnancy and it's resulted in FAS

One small glass twice a week IS a small amount of drinking. Very small. And the key word there is SAY they drink a small amount. In reality the data shows us that even in women who we know are drinking huge amounts of alcohol, full on binge drinking alcoholics, only a small percentage of their babies have FAS. Most are fine, even with massive amounts of alcohol.

Every bit of science we know about alcohol points to small amounts being perfectly safe. No, we can't guarantee it as thats not how science work, but we can't guarantee anything is safe, and we don't expect to.

CecilyP · 23/09/2021 16:13

How about we look at all the healthy living adults who didn't use seatbelts smile (myself included!!) while we forget about all the ones who HAD problems

No that doesn't work. Those of us who were around know about people who died in RTAs for want of wearing a seatbelt. We can compare road accident fatalities today with the level of fatalities from 40 years ago. We would also know about the ones with serious life limiting injuries. We can see the scars of people who were badly injured.

However, are any of us aware of the supposed effects of alcohol in pregnancy amongst the over 30s compared to those of younger generations?

YourFinestPantaloons · 23/09/2021 16:13

@ManifestDestinee

Very defensive for someone who must think it's OK. If you're so sure you're right and I'm wrong, you wouldn't be this bothered surely?

I'm not defensive, my fertile days are long behind me. I'm bothered by all the sanctimonious women lying about the subject. What's that about? Is it some kind of weird boasting or is it just that you swallowed the lies of others and feels the need to pass it on...as realising how readily you absorbed their nonsense and how gullible you were would make you feel very silly?

Judge away, and I'll do the same.

I actually think it's mummy martyrs who feel uncomfortable at the women who didn't spend their pregnancies martyring themselves for absolutely nobody to notice or care.
LaikO · 23/09/2021 16:12

I wouldn't, and haven't, had a drink during pregnancy. There isn't definitive research to show a "safe" amount, so I wouldn't take the risk. I figure it's 9 months, I can go without, although I'm not a big drinker anyway.

YourFinestPantaloons · 23/09/2021 16:10

@TheKeatingFive

But if you do the research you will learn that even a teeny tiny amount of alcohol can cause permanent brain damage to the foetus.

🙄

What research?

How come we didn’t have sky high FASD rates when guidelines included small levels of consumption.

I really wish someone would answer this. My mum had low iron and drank Guineas regularly throughout all her 4 pregnancies. How come none of us have FASD and how come all of us have done well academically and in our careers?
YourFinestPantaloons · 23/09/2021 16:09

Much depends on how old the foetus is, as at some stages of development, even a glass of wine can cause damage.

Source for this please @Skysblue

Cuddlyrottweiler · 23/09/2021 16:09

The odd drink most likely won't affect the baby. But we're talking about regular drinking here, 2-3 times a week, pregnant or not, isn't a small amount of drinking. There absolutely have been women who say they drink a a small regular amount throughout their pregnancy and it's resulted in FAS.
Why would you even risk it? Alcohol doesn't taste that nice, neither does coffee, roller coasters aren't that fun. Nothing is surely worth risking, not only your baby's health, but also that you'll spend the rest of your life looking after a disabled baby/child/adult. It's only a few months, just do the best you can by your baby.

shrunkenhead · 23/09/2021 16:07

Of course it's fine. Like a previous poster said, you have to at least pretend to be drinking otherwise it's obvious - I mean in the first 12 weeks before you're allowed to tell people. I remember in the early stages going to a comedy night with some friends and I really didn't even fancy a wine but knew that to not have one would arouse suspicions so nursed one all night long - doubt I even finished it but to anyone watching it all looked totally normal - shrunkenhead with a glass in hand as per!
Also, if you do your research, there is a critical time during pregnancy when the brain is developing and it's important to restrict your intake to just the small one then. I think in the mid to latter stages when baby is pretty much fully formed it's not such a big deal to have a drink.
I think it's interesting that for the first 12 weeks you're unlikely to want to go anywhere near alcohol as it knocks you sick - your body's way of saying it's not a good idea!

YourFinestPantaloons · 23/09/2021 15:59

@GertietheGherkin

The way I've always looked at it is I would never fill my babies bottle with wine and make them drink it, so I wouldn't give them wine via my umbilical cord either. Whatever I eat/ drink ultimately ends up in my babies system. It makes no difference how small.

For the sake of your babies health and well being can you just skip alcohol. During pregnancy and breastfeeding?

@GertietheGherkin I'm assuming you only drank breastmilk or formula during pregnancy then? Going by your logic of only feeding yourself what you'd feed a baby

YourFinestPantaloons · 23/09/2021 15:57

@Brokensunflower

Alcohol is more dangerous to an unborn baby than heroin in terms of long term effects yet we all look down our noses at addicts but not at mother's who are willing to drink when pregnant. One glass of champagne at a wedding might not be awful but every week is a terrible thing to do. Perhaps this baby will escape unharmed from it but why risk it? Why do something with no benefit but a potential for harm?
Source for this claim?
YourFinestPantaloons · 23/09/2021 15:56

@KarmaStar

Yanbu there is an innocent baby who didn't ask to be there,it was your choice. Then to pour toxins into your body ,the baby may not have serious damage but could feel ill,I don't know,but it ,to me,is extremely selfish to drink whilst pregnant,even if you self justify by saying it's a small drink.surely you don't need to drink.
@KarmaStar how do you feel about women drinking coffee in pregnancy?
YourFinestPantaloons · 23/09/2021 15:55

@Maggie178

Alcohol foetal syndrome doesn't just happen to babies born to alcoholics and women who binge drink. Any woman who drinks during pregnancy can have a child with it. Why take the risk?
Source for this?
YourFinestPantaloons · 23/09/2021 15:55

@shouldistop

2-3 glasses in one week is too much. Occasional drink is fine but to me that means one every couple of months because of a special occasion.
6 times a year is not occasional
Ponoka7 · 23/09/2021 15:49

@FreedomFaith

"If women choose to drink alcohol, they are advised to have no more than 1-2 units of alcohol no more than 1-2 times a week, as there is no evidence of harm at this level." Taken from a BMA/NICE/RCOG clinical paper.

Different bodies of research have shown that between 40-78% of pregnant women drink alcohol. If it was any amount of alcohol we'd be seeing more FAS and considerably more during other decades.

"The sole risk factor is maternal consumption of alcohol during pregnancy. Not all women who drink heavily during pregnancy have babies with FAS and it is clear that other factors affect the vulnerability of the fetus. These include the stage of pregnancy affected, the pattern of drinking, the health, age, stress levels and nutritional status of the mother and the use of other toxic substances, including tobacco."

However feel free to present your peer reviewed research paper to the BMA, to say otherwise.

sineadteh · 23/09/2021 15:42

Those children have issues through a choice made by their mother. I do find that sad.

FAS is very sad. Babies aren't getting FAS from their mother having a wine at Christmas. Just seems another stick to beat people with rather than genuine concern

LittleGwyneth · 23/09/2021 15:40

@ManifestDestinee a fair point!

ManifestDestinee · 23/09/2021 15:38

If you know those things are potentially dangerous too, then why add another? Roughly 7000 babies each year in the UK are born with FAS, is that worth it to you?

Because it ISN'T adding another. The odd glass of wine does not cause FAS, I know that and I think you do to. The fact that it is only 7,000 out of about 750,000 per year shows that. If occasional drinking caused FAS there would be many multiples of it, and almost everyone of my generation in my home country would have it, as all of our mothers regularly drank wine in pregnancy.

You thinking something is a risk doesn't make it a risk, but in all honesty I don't beleive you think it is a risk.

TheKeatingFive · 23/09/2021 15:27

Those children have issues through a choice made by their mother.

The choice to get into a car for a non essential trip is also made by the mother.

The choice to eat salad also made by the mother.

The choice to not get a handle on weight also made by the mother,

Virtually everything we do carries tiny risk. No one has yet provided any data to suggest that drinking small amounts is anything more than a minuscule risk.

PurplePizzaCake · 23/09/2021 15:26

Wow, there are some very opinionated people here.

I am in no way dependent on alcohol. I love wine and savour the small glasses I've had (and I do mean small, 75-100ml) I definitely don't drink to get drunk and don't miss the drunk feeling, there just isn't a non alcoholic wine as a substitute so I think I will continue to treat myself to the odd drink, perhaps every 2-3 week. Or just have a taste of my husband's drink.

I don't drink caffeine, never smoked and I'm healthy and not overweight. My mum drank in moderation while pregnant with me and I've turned out OK. Although I imagine some people on here might disagree as I am a selfish, unreasonable mother.

I had the odd drink while pregnant with my now 2 year old who seems to be thriving. So I think I managed to care for a newborn, even though I breastfed and also had the odd glass of wine then too Shock

OP posts:
FreedomFaith · 23/09/2021 15:18

@TheKeatingFive @ManifestDestinee

If you know those things are potentially dangerous too, then why add another? Roughly 7000 babies each year in the UK are born with FAS, is that worth it to you?

I feel a bit sorry for those children to be honest. It could have been stopped by simply not drinking alcohol. A car crash can happen through no fault of the pregnant driver. Women (unless you both have some sort of brilliant vision I don't have) can't see bacteria on food, so again they can't know it's happening. Caffiene is already another product pregnant women are advised not to have, but this thread is about alcohol.

Those children have issues through a choice made by their mother. I do find that sad.

ManifestDestinee · 23/09/2021 15:01

So can you guarantee to me that every single child in the world born with the mother having drunk a glass of wine a week, or any amount of alcohol during pregnancy, will be safe from FAS? Can you guarantee that

Can you guarantee that every single child in the world whose mother had a cup of coffee once a week will be safe from the terrible effects of caffiene?
No, of course you can't.

Everything you eat and drink in pregnancy can theoretically harm your foetus. A salad sandwich could give you listeria that kills the foetus, or leads to it being born blind and brain damaged. Do you harangue every pregnant woman who eats salad? Do you tell her "it's only 9 months, how can you be so selfish?"
Of course you don't. The risks of a glass of wine a week while pregnant are lower than eating salad, are lower than driving in a car, are lower than flying, are lower than crossing the road.
But you choose just this infinitisemal risk that you think there is. Why? Because you did all the other things and wouldn't care to be criticised for them?

TheKeatingFive · 23/09/2021 14:56

So can you guarantee to me that every single child in the world born with the mother having drunk a glass of wine a week, or any amount of alcohol during pregnancy, will be safe from FAS? Can you guarantee that?

I can’t guarantee that no unborn baby will be harmed by their mother being in an RTA while taking a non essential car trip, but we don’t endlessly harangue woman for that.

Life is a balance of risks. Getting out of bed in the morning is a risk. Staying there is also a risk.

The data available on the subject tells us that the risk of occasional drinking in pregnancy is minimal. The focus on this compared to much more significant risk factors (obesity) is ridiculous.

FreedomFaith · 23/09/2021 14:51

@ManifestDestinee

Very defensive for someone who must think it's OK. If you're so sure you're right and I'm wrong, you wouldn't be this bothered surely?

I'm not defensive, my fertile days are long behind me. I'm bothered by all the sanctimonious women lying about the subject. What's that about? Is it some kind of weird boasting or is it just that you swallowed the lies of others and feels the need to pass it on...as realising how readily you absorbed their nonsense and how gullible you were would make you feel very silly?

Judge away, and I'll do the same.

So can you guarantee to me that every single child in the world born with the mother having drunk a glass of wine a week, or any amount of alcohol during pregnancy, will be safe from FAS? Can you guarantee that?

Really, considering the uk is amongst the highest for the amount of children born with FAS, that would suggest you couldn't possibly guarantee that even one glass would definitely not cause it. Less risk, perhaps, but guarantee nothing will happen? Do you know exactly how much alcohol is safe and can prove that?

PartyPotato · 23/09/2021 14:47

I had one drink a couple of times a month when pregnant. I think it’s fine. But twice a week sounds a bit much.