Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Being refused a company car as I'm part time

87 replies

Blahdyblahbla · 22/09/2021 19:32

AIBU to think this is some sort of sex discrimination?
It's an NHS lease car, so I believe minimal expense to the employer other than administrating the scheme. Manager told me today he doesn't think I'll be entitled to apply as I'm part time.
Is this a done thing?

OP posts:
gavisconismyfriend · 22/09/2021 23:00

The lease is dependent on your doing sufficient business miles to qualify. As a part-time member of staff you simply may not do enough miles at work. It isn’t discrimination, it’s the criterion set by the lease company to make the contract financially viable

KrisAkabusi · 22/09/2021 22:53

@Bluntness100

You really don’t want an electric car, the safety risks are huge, Google it. If you do get one, you need two things, a way to charge it away from your home and an escape plan when you have the misfortune to drive it.
Nonsense, electric cars are no more dangerous than any other type of car.
HalzTangz · 22/09/2021 22:30

Check the T&C, staff at our company are only entitled to a company car if they will drive 10000 miles per year for business trips. Commutes to the regular office place are not included in the milage. Full time/part time doesn't factor in.

Anyone travelling less than 10000 use a department pool car

TaraR2020 · 22/09/2021 22:25

@Cheshirewife

Why should a PT employee get the same benefits as a FT employee? Hardly discrimination.
Except it is.
surreygirl1987 · 22/09/2021 22:23

@SpamIAm ah I was confused actually. Thank you for clarifying.

idontlikealdi · 22/09/2021 22:04

I'm private sector but you need to earn above a threshold to get a car allowance or salary sacrifice with company benefit. You'd have to be a pretty high earner to do that p/t.

SpamIAm · 22/09/2021 21:59

I think some people are confused about what the OP actually wants here - she wants to lease a car, via the salary sacrifice scheme offered by her employer. She doesn't want use of a car that her employer is leasing for staff to use.

TractorAndHeadphones · 22/09/2021 21:41

@Iamthewombat

It's an NHS lease car, so I believe minimal expense to the employer other than administrating the scheme.

Wrong! The expense to the NHS is not “minimal”. The lease will be subsidised, for a start. Who is paying for the servicing? Oh yes, the NHS. What about repairs, when you damage it? Insurance? The cost of the employees to administer the scheme is not inconsiderable either.

You’ll either qualify on business mileage grounds or you won’t, but please don’t pretend that leased cars provided to NHS employees, or other public sector employees, come at minimal cost. They really don’t.

The OP probably means that it doesn’t cost them any more to give her one, seeing as she does more miles than some full timers even.

Also sorry OP didn’t read that you were on 3 days a week!

SecretSpAD · 22/09/2021 21:24

I've been in and out of the NHS for years and I've never heard of a part timer ring banned for having a lease car. It's nit sex discrimination though. Not even sure it's discrimination, more an arse of a boss, but I might be wrong.

Bluntness100 · 22/09/2021 21:18

You really don’t want an electric car, the safety risks are huge, Google it. If you do get one, you need two things, a way to charge it away from your home and an escape plan when you have the misfortune to drive it.

Iamthewombat · 22/09/2021 21:16

It's an NHS lease car, so I believe minimal expense to the employer other than administrating the scheme.

Wrong! The expense to the NHS is not “minimal”. The lease will be subsidised, for a start. Who is paying for the servicing? Oh yes, the NHS. What about repairs, when you damage it? Insurance? The cost of the employees to administer the scheme is not inconsiderable either.

You’ll either qualify on business mileage grounds or you won’t, but please don’t pretend that leased cars provided to NHS employees, or other public sector employees, come at minimal cost. They really don’t.

DoNotGetADog · 22/09/2021 21:15

Part time employees are not allowed to be treated less favourably than their full time colleagues, but they don’t have to be given the exact same benefits.
Like the salary, benefits can be given pro rata ie you would get 3/5 of the benefits of a full time employee. Not all things can be divided up though, and some are all of nothing.
I used to work somewhere where employees doing my job were routinely given a company car, or paid a car allowance in lieu of the car. I worked 4 days and was not allowed the car option, but was paid 4/5 of the car allowance a full time person would get.

Randomactofkindness · 22/09/2021 21:08

I work for the NHS part time and I’m getting my lease car in November!

Sparklybanana · 22/09/2021 20:56

A read of "Invisible women' would do a lot of women on here a lot of good.
More women work part time because of childcare requirements and the fact that average wage is lower for women so it makes sense that they are the ones that do childcare. The man can continue his career progression, increasing the wage gap and also be entitled to better pensions and perks like the one op is talking about.

But no one bats an eyelid because the woman has the 'choice' to be part time. It is indirect sex discrimination and there is so much about that it is imperceptible to most people unless they really think about it.

Blahdyblahbla · 22/09/2021 20:47

@Zeal, in order to provide health care to individuals there must be staff. Those staff must be renumeration for their work, unless you are suggesting we return to the days of slavery or bonded labour. Part of that renumeration can be made up of benefits other than salary.
I'm assuming you are a troll so will just hope you find your bridge again soon. Ta-ra

OP posts:
melissasummerfield · 22/09/2021 20:46

[quote Cheshirewife]@icedcoffees

I’m an employment lawyer.

That certainly isn’t the law!

Maybe leave the “idiot-splaining” for those who know less than you... (probably no one!)[/quote]
you might want to check that LOL

Zeal · 22/09/2021 20:42

@Blahdyblahbla

AIBU to think this is some sort of sex discrimination? It's an NHS lease car, so I believe minimal expense to the employer other than administrating the scheme. Manager told me today he doesn't think I'll be entitled to apply as I'm part time. Is this a done thing?
Manager told me today he doesn't think

To be honest, I think that is probably correct.

Anyway, I thought the NHS was about the healthcare of individuals, not car finance and leasing. Just throw that one out there.

NameChangeforMoneyThings · 22/09/2021 20:39

[quote Cheshirewife]@icedcoffees

I’m an employment lawyer.

That certainly isn’t the law!

Maybe leave the “idiot-splaining” for those who know less than you... (probably no one!)[/quote]
Treating part time workers less favourably than a full time equivalent definitely isn't permitted.

E.g. www.crosslandsolicitors.com/site/cases/BA-v-Pinaud-part-timers-less-favourable-treatment-justification

Blahdyblahbla · 22/09/2021 20:38

@DancingDog it's absolutely not for everyone you're right, I'm using it as a risk free way to try an electric car, and I believe BIK is only 1% at present so its worth a punt.
I'm reluctant to buy an EV as I don't think the batteries are there yet, and it could be an expensive outlay for a new one in a few years.

OP posts:
DancingDog · 22/09/2021 20:34

On the nhs scheme the lease cost gets deducted from your salary so if it takes you below NMW they probably won’t be able to do it. You pay the BIK in addition to the lease cost.
Don’t forget it affects your pension amount because you have sacrificed some of your salary.
We looked into it for DH but decided against it because it’s not as generous as you think once you’ve paid the lease,BIK and lost some pension. Also if you leave you have the rest of the lease to pay.

Ashitaka · 22/09/2021 20:23

@katie2812

It's because your wage will take you below minimum wage.... E.g. I couldn't join my Christmas savings scheme because k was part time but the full time could You can't do anything which means you'll get paid less than minimum wage Check that's the reason first
Surely that is linked to your hourly rate, more than full time/part time
NavigatingAdolescence · 22/09/2021 20:22

@clolo

Is it something you would pay for out of your salary? If so due to being part time the payments might take you under national minimum wage which they can't do
It’s this.

(NHS HR Director)

BrilliantBetty · 22/09/2021 20:22

Speak to HR and CC him in. He should have found out himself rather than leaving you to investigate.

MojoJojo71 · 22/09/2021 20:21

Sounds like he doesn’t know what he’s talking about then @Blahdyblahbla. I’d speak to someone in HR who deals with the lease cars and ask them. Do you know which lease firm your trust uses? You can usually put your details into their website for a quote and speak to them for advice too

TractorAndHeadphones · 22/09/2021 20:18

He says he doesn’t ‘think’ you’ll be entitled to apply. Can you get him to confirm this in writing or send over the exact wording of the policy?

If not can you ask HR/car admin?

Also how ‘part-time’ are you? Is it at least 3 days a week?