Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Being refused a company car as I'm part time

87 replies

Blahdyblahbla · 22/09/2021 19:32

AIBU to think this is some sort of sex discrimination?
It's an NHS lease car, so I believe minimal expense to the employer other than administrating the scheme. Manager told me today he doesn't think I'll be entitled to apply as I'm part time.
Is this a done thing?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MiddlesexGirl · 23/09/2021 19:49

[quote ithinkilikeit]@MiddlesexGirl wrong. Most of the people who are part time are female.[/quote]
I think you are @ -ing the wrong person!

RockingMyFiftiesNot · 23/09/2021 09:09

@NavigatingAdolescence the link suggests otherwise ?

NavigatingAdolescence · 23/09/2021 08:38

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

RockingMyFiftiesNot · 23/09/2021 08:11

I worked part-time for many years. My understanding is that there are some areas where an employer must treat part-timers equally with full timers (eg rate of pay) and other areas where they don't have to.
So it's not as simple as 'it's against the law to treat part-timers differently'

link

IveGotASongThatllGetOnYNerves · 23/09/2021 08:07

If he says he doesn't THINK you'll be eligible then that means he doesn't know
Perfect.
Go directly to those who manage the scheme and get the facts.
Present him with the facts.

Briarshollow · 23/09/2021 08:03

[quote Cheshirewife]@icedcoffees

I’m an employment lawyer.

That certainly isn’t the law!

Maybe leave the “idiot-splaining” for those who know less than you... (probably no one!)[/quote]
Oh my god, you can’t be serious. I didn’t even see this when I posted my last comment. You have to be lying.

Briarshollow · 23/09/2021 08:01

@Cheshirewife

Why should a PT employee get the same benefits as a FT employee? Hardly discrimination.
Living up to your name there, a bit. Why pitch up on a thread you know absolutely nothing about?! Embarrassing. 😂
TractorAndHeadphones · 23/09/2021 07:52

@NavigatingAdolescence

The OP said her manager “didn’t think” she could apply as a part timer.

It’s possible that they have this impression because others have been caught by the NMW issues and mistakenly thinks that’s due to the part time aspect, not the actual earnings. Simple human error is the most likely explanation here.

This He should have checked but still je didn’t say she couldn’t - just that he ‘think’s she can’t. Seems like if she proves she can he’ll be quite happy to approve or whatever it is.

Useless thread IMO until OP finds out more.

Getyourarseofffthequattro · 23/09/2021 07:50

I couldn't get a car through the NHS scheme because I didn't earn enough as a band 3. I felt like replying and saying well isn't that a big red flag that your wages are shit when you're own employer tells you that you can't have a £120 a month Citroen c1.

Whataroyalannoyance · 23/09/2021 07:47

@NavigatingAdolescence

The OP said her manager “didn’t think” she could apply as a part timer.

It’s possible that they have this impression because others have been caught by the NMW issues and mistakenly thinks that’s due to the part time aspect, not the actual earnings. Simple human error is the most likely explanation here.

Unfortunately that wouldn't make as impressive a thread as a sex discrimination in the NHS would. And it wouldn't have led to calls to report the manager to hr or put in issues with the union. Why look for a horse when a t rex is a better name!!
PooWillyNameChange · 23/09/2021 07:46

Don't know why everyone is speculating. Organisations will have different schemes with different rules.

OP, is there a number on the portal where you can order the cars so you can confirm details of the scheme? My manager wouldn't have a clue about this so I would check and then let them know if you think you're entitled.

icedcoffees · 23/09/2021 07:42

[quote Cheshirewife]@icedcoffees

I’m an employment lawyer.

That certainly isn’t the law!

Maybe leave the “idiot-splaining” for those who know less than you... (probably no one!)[/quote]
You may want to report the university who allowed you to qualify if that's the case Grin

Moraxella · 23/09/2021 07:30

There are some pension implications if you get a salary sacrifice car via the NHS. Search MSE

ithinkilikeit · 22/09/2021 23:53

@MiddlesexGirl wrong. Most of the people who are part time are female.

ClareBlue · 22/09/2021 23:37

It's because it is a salary sacrifice and not a deduction. Though it can be a deduction but you don't get the tax break if it is a deduction. You can't sacrifice your salary to below the NMW but you can have as many deductions as you authorise. In theory you can end up with no pay if you authorise enough deductions for different things.
So you need to divide the 330 a month sacrifice into your hours and take that reduction in hourly rate from your 24 per hour. As long as this is above the NMW you qualify. The 330 will only take you below if you do less than 25 hours a month, which seems unlikely. Your figures look like you do around 80 hours, so you do qualifying.

NavigatingAdolescence · 22/09/2021 23:33

The OP said her manager “didn’t think” she could apply as a part timer.

It’s possible that they have this impression because others have been caught by the NMW issues and mistakenly thinks that’s due to the part time aspect, not the actual earnings. Simple human error is the most likely explanation here.

atomicnotsoblonde · 22/09/2021 23:25

Find your trust policy and go from there. I doubt very much that this is in the policy. If you can't find it, ask HR and copy him in. There's a cost saving if it's salary sacrifice, so they are generally supportive.

Iamthewombat · 22/09/2021 23:20

@HahaAreyouSerious

"please don’t pretend that leased cars provided to NHS employees, or other public sector employees, come at minimal cost. They really don’t."

Maybe of they were paid better for the work they did they could afford their own car that didn't have to be tied to their employment.
Maybe there wouldn't be as many needing to" leech" benefits like others usually suggest in these threads.

Fuck it, let's all work for free!

Are you quite well? Your post comes off as rather an incoherent rant. Although slightly less so than your earlier post, aimed at a different poster, in which you talk about darning socks and sending children up chimneys!
DixonD · 22/09/2021 23:16

[quote Cheshirewife]@icedcoffees

I’m an employment lawyer.

That certainly isn’t the law!

Maybe leave the “idiot-splaining” for those who know less than you... (probably no one!)[/quote]
Er, if you were an employment lawyer you would know the legislation. I’ve been doing huge research on this very subject this week.

You are not an employment lawyer. If you are, you’re a very bad one.

HahaAreyouSerious · 22/09/2021 23:12

"please don’t pretend that leased cars provided to NHS employees, or other public sector employees, come at minimal cost. They really don’t."

Maybe of they were paid better for the work they did they could afford their own car that didn't have to be tied to their employment.
Maybe there wouldn't be as many needing to" leech" benefits like others usually suggest in these threads.

Fuck it, let's all work for free!

DixonD · 22/09/2021 23:12

@Cheshirewife

Why should a PT employee get the same benefits as a FT employee? Hardly discrimination.
Why should they? It’s against the law to treat part time workers less favourably than full time workers.

There’s a whole piece of legislation on it.

Apparently, if a benefit cannot easily be given to a part time worker for whatever reason, you cannot give it to a full time worker. Such benefits would usually be completely withdrawn.

Zeal · 22/09/2021 23:10

Or that she says 'deductible' when 'sacrifice' has a completely different meaning and outcome under ITEPA 2003. Wink

HalzTangz · 22/09/2021 23:09

@SpamIAm

I think some people are confused about what the OP actually wants here - she wants to lease a car, via the salary sacrifice scheme offered by her employer. She doesn't want use of a car that her employer is leasing for staff to use.
It doesn't help that her title says company car
HahaAreyouSerious · 22/09/2021 23:08

"Anyway, I thought the NHS was about the healthcare of individuals, not car finance and leasing. Just throw that one out there."

See, those things called jobs often have things attached them, like not having to work 24 hours a day 7 days a week.

I hear in some places they even let people have holidays for free!
Some of them don't even have to lose their livelihood if they have a baby or become disabled while on the job.
Sometimes they're even allowed to be paid a percentage to be able to get to work in order to take care of sick people???

I agree with you, get them all back darning socks I say, and while we're at it, get the kids back up the chimneys.

If they get hungry they can eat the birds that nest in the chimney pot.

Zeal · 22/09/2021 23:05

[quote Blahdyblahbla]@Zeal, in order to provide health care to individuals there must be staff. Those staff must be renumeration for their work, unless you are suggesting we return to the days of slavery or bonded labour. Part of that renumeration can be made up of benefits other than salary.
I'm assuming you are a troll so will just hope you find your bridge again soon. Ta-ra[/quote]
Calm down. All those are your words, not mine. You really do have the wrong end of the stick and have misinterpreted my post. Smile