Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can I wear this if I'm a SAHM ?

263 replies

baggingareaunattended · 22/09/2021 18:47

There's a few tees I like, not so keen on the girl slogan ones as I'm a women, but I like this one and the WOMAN one .. but would I be a bit of a contradiction? As it goes I'm not married, but I'm technically engaged 😬

thespark.company/collections/feminist-t-shirts/products/on-wednesdays-we-smash-the-patriarchy-fitted-v-neck-t-shirt

Can I wear this if I'm a SAHM ?
OP posts:
Saladovercrispsanyday · 24/09/2021 13:10

Emily Pankhurst

Married
5 children
Didn’t work
Supported her husband campaign to become an MP

Today, she’d be regarded by somehow less of a feminist by a number on this thread

FloconDeNeige · 24/09/2021 13:09

@BelleOfTheProvince

I think that families with special needs are in a different situation. If parental support is the only suitable, then it would be great it more Dads were willing to take on this responsibility and not always leave it to women. But regardless of which parent has to stop working to do this, they should be fully supported by the state.

BelleOfTheProvince · 24/09/2021 13:01

So is married sahm are ok then?🙄
Raising children is a partnership and a team effort. Especially for those of us with higher needs children who can't thrive in outside provision.

FloconDeNeige · 24/09/2021 12:56

How many women could have got the mortgage for the house they live in purely in their own salary, for instance?

How many men could, either? Both the male and female partners benefit from 2 incomes, it’s not only a gain for women. The fact that their salaries (probably) aren’t exactly the same, doesn’t matter.

I can’t believe you’re seriously trying to say that a because a women may earn less than her male partner, she’s therefore no different to a woman who earns nothing and is totally dependent upon him. Wow. Mind-boggling.

FloconDeNeige · 24/09/2021 12:50

Because in doing that, you are taking economic responsibility for yourself (and your offspring) and not making yourself dependent on a man/men, which is hardly feminist.

It only makes sense if the lower-earning partner has their own independent source of income, has future pension provision, is married or has other comprehensive legal protection in case of split/death/ill-health and/or is otherwise not financially dependent on the earner. In reality that is very rarely the case and as we know from this very site, there are innumerable threads from women who end up trapped or shafted.

moch11 · 24/09/2021 12:48

‘It’s irrelevant, you earn, are socially active, have a voice in the workplace and are financially self suffienct as to be able to provide for yourself.’

No it’s very relevant Bluntness, unless you believe that married couples should exist as totally separate financial entities (maybe you do actually believe this)?

Most families lifestyles are based on two incomes. Over time your finances become one and the same, regardless of who earns what. Yes, for some couples, their incomes may be comparable, but for many this is never going to be the case. It is what it is. So your lifestyle becomes defined by the higher income (in the main) regardless. How many women could have got the mortgage for the house they live in purely in their own salary, for instance?

Surely you can see it’s not always as simple as working v not working? It’s all about context.

BelleOfTheProvince · 24/09/2021 12:38

Why is it deemed more feminist to earn money to pay someone else to look after your own children?
Someone has to look after the children. In most households the male partner earns more due to various sexist factors. So it makes sense for the lower earning partner to stay at home and raise your children with your shared values and not farmed out to someone who has different values.

moch11 · 24/09/2021 12:38

Why did you not post an informed, relevant article from one of your global associations for women’s rights? Surely that would be more effective than some bitter rant from a random on the internet? Hmm

Bluntness100 · 24/09/2021 12:33

@moch11

‘a man to work to pay for you.’

Here we go..,.

If I was working Bluntness, my husband would still be ‘paying for me’ by virtue of the fact he earns many multiples of what I earn.

How should we get around that? Separate finances? Live in different houses? Go on different holidays?

I’m just wondering how the real feminists do it. Do they only get into relationships with men in the same salary as them?

It’s irrelevant, you earn, are socially active, have a voice in the workplace and are financially self suffienct as to be able to provide for yourself.
FloconDeNeige · 24/09/2021 12:30

It doesn’t matter to me whether you think my POV comes from a place of concern or not. I know that it does and I’m a member of multiple global associations and bodies that actively campaign for equality of women, particularly in the workplace. This takes time and effort on top of my regular job.

I also go to work every day in a male-dominated environment and fight against the inherent systematic sexism of the workplace, on a micro-agression level and more widely.

So I must say that it rankles a bit to hear women who don’t do this, who stay at home and outsource responsibility for themselves to men, trying to claim that they are also ‘smashing the patriarchy’ in doing this. It’s patently untrue - if all women went about challenging male domination by not working and being economically dependent on men, how far do you think we’d be/get?

If someone wants to make this choice, and it’s a valid one (although unwise IMO), then as I said before, they need to own it and not try to pretend it’s an equally valid one for advancing female equality, because it isn’t.

moch11 · 24/09/2021 12:16

‘a man to work to pay for you.’

Here we go..,.

If I was working Bluntness, my husband would still be ‘paying for me’ by virtue of the fact he earns many multiples of what I earn.

How should we get around that? Separate finances? Live in different houses? Go on different holidays?

I’m just wondering how the real feminists do it. Do they only get into relationships with men in the same salary as them?

BelleOfTheProvince · 24/09/2021 12:11

The main issue with it is it's like weekday socks and you have to time your washing so you wear it on Wednesday.

moch11 · 24/09/2021 12:09

Flocon - I’m at all not sure your posts do come purely from a place of concern, to be honest. If you are genuinely posting from concern, I have to tell you that’s definitely not how it comes across.

Not just you by any means, but so many posters claim to be posting out of concern on these threads. It’s astonishing that they have no awareness of how their tone and choice of words betray them. I mean, when you post a stupid, bitter article like the one above, it says it all,

By the way, I never claimed to be ‘smashing the patriarchy’ or anything of the sort.

BelleOfTheProvince · 24/09/2021 12:08

Raising children is a job. It's not as valid as it should be but that's a sign of the patriarchy.

I have this t shirt in pink. I use it for slobbing as it's not a very flattering fit. If I was thinner I could tie the bottom in a knot and that would look cute.

Saladovercrispsanyday · 24/09/2021 12:08

And it’s adding nothing to the debate and indeed actually “smash the patriarch” (heave) to argue differently

Saladovercrispsanyday · 24/09/2021 12:07

I work
I don’t see the op as less of a feminist than me because of that one fact of our current existence

Saladovercrispsanyday · 24/09/2021 12:06

You mentioned the tax payer

You think the op isn’t “smashing the patriarchy” (heave) because she isn’t working.

You pay tax if you work.

Bluntness100 · 24/09/2021 11:56

@Saladovercrispsanyday

So now feminism is inextricably linked with whether or not you are a tax payer? Grin
It’s not, who said it was?

It was intrinsically linked to whether you are reliant on a man to work to pay for you.

Saladovercrispsanyday · 24/09/2021 11:54

So now feminism is inextricably linked with whether or not you are a tax payer? Grin

Bluntness100 · 24/09/2021 11:42

@Saladovercrispsanyday..but it’s not about winning or loosing or who is happier.

Feminism is about gaining female equality in economic, social and political arenas.

Female empowerment is about supporting women in the choices they make.

They are both valuable , both linked, but both different. That’s the point. The op wishes to wear a tacky slogan mean girls t shirt that says she smashes the patriarchy on a wed. In reality no one gives a shit what she wears. And I’m sure everyone supports her life style choice decisions.

The discussion was is she smashing the patriarchy by being a stay at home mum snd having ger husband or the taxpayer pay for her choices.. Not whether her decision to be one is valid. It is, it’s her choice and it’s not about if she’s happier than her husband.

But Is it one that positions her as the woman who is out there smashing the patriarchy? As a stand alone decision, without wider it’s hard to see how she’s doing that.

FloconDeNeige · 24/09/2021 11:38

@moch11

Why do you feel the need to trail me around the site?

It’s an important issue for women’s rights and something I feel strongly about as I’ve seen women shafted after getting themselves into these positions. I also live in a country that is finally starting to realise that the trad set-up of women at home, economically inactive & dependent upon men, isn’t the best one for most stakeholders.

I also don’t understand the frothing over feminism. If you, as an adult woman, don’t want to work and want a man to support you and your offspring, then own that. Don’t expect to be able to to claim you’re ’smashing the patriarchy’ by doing that though and then whine when it’s pointed out that you’re not. You can’t have it both ways.

Saladovercrispsanyday · 24/09/2021 10:14

You are seeing the competing very narrow minded
Simply earning money versus not

Saladovercrispsanyday · 24/09/2021 10:13

@Bluntness100

They don’t want to compete with men on men’s terms. This is no longer enough. Why the hell should they when they can define their own terms

Your argument is confused, women don’t need to compete with men on their own terms, but you’d be hard pressed to argue that being a stay at home mum or house wife and living off your husbands wages is in any way shape or form competing with men at all.

What if man hates very dull boring factory job Woman loves being a sahm and childcare and cooking

Seems to me like woman winning
Man losing

Bluntness100 · 24/09/2021 09:23

They don’t want to compete with men on men’s terms. This is no longer enough. Why the hell should they when they can define their own terms

Your argument is confused, women don’t need to compete with men on their own terms, but you’d be hard pressed to argue that being a stay at home mum or house wife and living off your husbands wages is in any way shape or form competing with men at all.

fiveinfulham · 24/09/2021 09:13

“The whole point of feminism is equal rights for women to men. It’s equality in pay, politics and social rights. You cannot redefine it.”

Times change and feminism needs to adapt. Otherwise it’s a blunt instrument. Maybe once it was all about beating men in their own workplaces; proving you could work as long hours as them etc. But times are changing. Women know they have different choices now than they did in the 60s or the 80s. They don’t want to compete with men on men’s terms. This is no longer enough. Why the hell should they when they can define their own terms? Having children and instinctively wanting to be around for them should not be sidelined as some kind of inconvenience or ‘lesser.’ Let women be the judge of what works for them and stop trying to stuff everyone into some outdated capitalist box.

In the future women (and men) will increasingly work from home. The concept of 9-5 is becoming outdated. People will demand flexibility. There will be no such thing as ‘a job for life’ and it will be common for people to take career breaks for children, retrain and change direction completely in many cases. Far more people will be self-employed. You won’t need to be locked into a given career path, terrified to take more than 6 moths off because that’s professional suicide. Pandering to that mentality is not feminism for the future. Feminism for the future is women defining their own reality, whatever that may be, and men confirming to that. If equality just means suppressing differences, it will never be achieved. And if it is, it’s just replacing one form of oppression with another.

Swipe left for the next trending thread