Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can I wear this if I'm a SAHM ?

263 replies

baggingareaunattended · 22/09/2021 18:47

There's a few tees I like, not so keen on the girl slogan ones as I'm a women, but I like this one and the WOMAN one .. but would I be a bit of a contradiction? As it goes I'm not married, but I'm technically engaged 😬

thespark.company/collections/feminist-t-shirts/products/on-wednesdays-we-smash-the-patriarchy-fitted-v-neck-t-shirt

Can I wear this if I'm a SAHM ?
OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
FirewomanSam · 25/09/2021 11:24

Well said Blahglah.

Being a feminist or not isn’t as simple as whether you work or not. As long as people are having children, they are going to need to find ways of taking care of those children. Rather than damning SAHMs for choosing to provide that care themselves, we should be viewing traditionally ‘woman’s’ work as a vital and essential part of our economy instead of expecting it to just happen behind the scenes.

Why is it that if you look after someone else’s children as a nanny or childminder or a nursery nurse that’s seen as a career, worthy of payment, but if you look after your own children it’s ‘staying at home’ and letting the side down?

Added to that, as Blahglah says, a lot of the SAHMs I know didn’t entirely choose that life, but were essentially forced out of their jobs or passed over for promotion after they returned from maternity leave, having their ‘commitment’ to the role questioned because they had to leave on time for school pickup, or because the cost of childcare plus commuting made it prohibitively expensive for them to continue working. It makes me so sad but I see those women as victims of the patriarchy, not traitors who are upholding it.

I would like to see couples be able to make a meaningful choice about how to care for their children that doesn’t inevitably mean the career of one partner (almost always the woman) going down the toilet against their wishes. There are a lot of factors involved in making that happen but properly valuing the unpaid labour that millions of people, mainly women, are doing every day and seeing it as essential to our economy, instead of a cop-out, would be a good start.

RickOShay · 25/09/2021 00:05

But I don’t feel dependant on dh. Honestly. If anything he’s more dependant on me. Emotions are deeper than money.

Blahglah · 25/09/2021 00:04

Wear it if you like it.

As for women doubting the ability of being a SAHM and smashing the patriarchy, it's worth remembering that 54,000 women a year are pushed out of the workplace and childcare is more than £14,000 year for one child. Sure you can maybe work for free or a couple of hundred quid a month, but that ain't smashing the patriarchy either, it's just playing their game.

Financial independence isn't doing your bit, it's doing your bit for yourself and your family. Nothing wrong with it but feminism isn't just about paying the bills, it about wanting better for all women and recognising that few of us have the choices we'd really want to have.

Recessed · 25/09/2021 00:01

A fundamental component of being an adult is supporting yourself.

And a fundamental component of parenting is supporting your children. Most women chose to be at home to do so. In my case working full time with a baby meant a child in childcare from dawn to dusk - such a feminista I was though Hmm smashing that patriarchy all the way.

readwhatiactuallysay · 25/09/2021 00:00

A fundamental component of being an adult is supporting yourself

Did you stop being an adult when your DH supported you?

women who work are not ‘acting like men’ because working is not a inherently male activity

Im not sure anyone suggested otherwise 🙄

The patriarchy have succeeded in blocking women’s access to employment and financial emancipation until relatively recently

Yes, So find a way to aim your frustation and bitterness their way, not at a woman who just wants a little more time with their kids FGS.

readwhatiactuallysay · 24/09/2021 23:53

@FloconDeNeige no the crux of it now, is that you are judging others on here and dragging them down because you dont deem their choices feminist enough, that is not on and should not still be happening, its ludicrous.

Asking you to clarify your many points is not dragging you down, making assumptions isnt dragging you down, if as you claim they are incorrect , but to group a whole load of woman together based on one choice in common and pass judgment on them negatively, is dragging them down.

But don't be pointing your bitterness towards the women who just want to spend a little more time with their kids, its a valid choice and not the root of the problem.

FloconDeNeige · 24/09/2021 23:50

A fundamental component of being an adult is supporting yourself. That is neither patriarchal, feminist nor capitalist. Women who work are not ‘acting like men’ because working is not a inherently male activity. The patriarchy have succeeded in blocking women’s access to employment and financial emancipation until relatively recently.

And with that, I’m going to bed 🛌

FloconDeNeige · 24/09/2021 23:35

@readwhatiactuallysay

The crux of the matter is that staying at home long-term and choosing not to work is not ‘smashing the patriarchy’. And it’s disingenuous to suggest that doing so advances female equality in an equal way to women working and supporting themselves.

That’s it. And it’s quite rich to suggest that I’m trying to drag people down when others have trawled my posting history and attempted to throw it at me, have tried to paint my husband as unsupportive and me and jealous/obsessed/ashamed/whatever.

moch11 · 24/09/2021 23:35

more like - not ‘nuts’ sorry.

moch11 · 24/09/2021 23:34

How was I not a SAHM? I left work at 31. My husband and I are a team. Yes he generates the money but, over the years, we’ve decided on investments etc and the renovations were a part of that. I never thought of myself as a property developers it was nuts like I kept an eye out and it was just something on the side when I had the energy to do it. I also did a mini running club at one point, but I was hardly a ‘fitness instructor.’ It was more a hobby really. You don’t literally have to stay indoors to be a SAHM.

Recessed · 24/09/2021 23:34

I do think that there’s something in the idea of being a SAHM to support a husband’s career progression though. That’s upholding the patriarchy and is inherently un-feminist.

Eh?! I can't imagine many SAHMs decide to do so solely to support a husband's career progression Confused it's to be home with their DC. There's nothing "unfeminist" about wanting to spend your days with your children - that's patriarchal talk. It says the only valuable contribution to society is traditional male patterns of work and the idea that women need to act like men to be proper feminists is laughable and often does a disservice to women and children and serves only to pit women against each other (SAHM vs WOHM) instead of joining forces for the advancement of ALL women.

OP wear the damn t-shirt if you like it!

FloconDeNeige · 24/09/2021 23:23

But you weren’t really a SAHM though, so I’m not surprised you didn’t consider yourself vulnerable in the same way.

If that’s how you defined yourself and you felt secure, then that’s good for you, but many SAHMs do risk their own and their children’s financial security unfortunately.

readwhatiactuallysay · 24/09/2021 23:22

I just personally disliked the vulnerability of not being able to rely on myself

Which is respected as a personal preference and everyone is entitled to that
But you didnt you come on and try to drag other women down because you dont deem them feminist enough because of their choices and that itself is just plain wrong.

moch11 · 24/09/2021 23:15

‘I just personally disliked the vulnerability of not being able to rely on myself.’

Fair enough and I respect that.

But also, do you think I would have been a SAHM for all these years if it was a risk my own and (more to the point) my children’s financial security?

readwhatiactuallysay · 24/09/2021 23:13

[quote stilltiredinthemorning]**@FloconDeNeige do you really think that being a feminist means judging and condemning the choices of other women?
I find it so sad that you seem to be experiencing feelings of shame because your husband helped you through a tough spot.
It's not about 'relying on a man' it's about relying on a partner, on someone you love who you've chosen to spend your life with. When we had our first child my husband took a year off and I went back to work. With our second I took a year off. I am not currently working because our eldest needs a bit of extra support and I want to be there for her. I expect my husband would also like to be at home to support her, but he is a kind and loving man and he is making the sacrifice of going out to work, so that I can have this opportunity.
I understand that I am a very privileged, well-educated person with a professional career that I can pick up and put down when needed. Lots of families may not have the options that we have and I respect their choices as being the best for them in their own unique circumstances.
I do have daughter. I want her to grow up in a society where she genuinely has a choice and in a relationship based on mutual respect, trust and compromise. I don't ever want her to feel shamed because she hasn't got a PhD or a 'calling' or because she might want to stay at home and look after her children. I thought that was feminism?[/quote]
Absolutely this !!! 👏👏🙌🙌

It's about mutual respect and support in a relationship. If you cant rely on your partner to support you where they can for a while, whats the point in the relationship.

Its about a woman having the right to choose and not being or feeling forced to make a choice either way but respected for either.

I do despair that this is still being discussed in such a way on here to drag other women down, still 🙄

FloconDeNeige · 24/09/2021 23:10

@moch11

I’ve never said that that we don’t share finances; you’ve decided that yourself. My husband is a wonderful man who is ready and willing to support me, as I am him. There’s no issue there whatsoever.

I just personally disliked the vulnerability of not being able to rely on myself.

FloconDeNeige · 24/09/2021 23:05

you said you struggled to look at yourself in the mirror, that sounds like shame to me.

No I didn’t say that, someone else did in a facetious attempt at a gotcha, and I replied to say that I indeed did find it a difficult time.
But not because I felt ashamed.

moch11 · 24/09/2021 23:01

I can’t imagine being able to share your DNA with someone to bring children into this world, yet you can’t manage to share finances.

You shouldn’t need to be ill to justify your own husband supporting you, Flocon. Really, he should want to do that all the time. You’re his wife and the mother if his children. There is no more that needs to be said.

thinkbiglittleone · 24/09/2021 23:00

@FloconDeNeige

I didn’t feel shame because my husband helped me through a tough spot. I was ill, there was no shame that. His love and encouragement throughout that period helped me to get through it. I just didn’t like the vulnerability of not being able to rely on myself.
Were you less of a feminist at that point ? Because you were dependant on a man

So again what if a woman going back to work isn't financially viable for the family, so she is realistically unable to work, as you were, does she pass as a feminist then or is she not ?

stilltiredinthemorning · 24/09/2021 22:55

@FloconDeNeige you said you struggled to look at yourself in the mirror, that sounds like shame to me.
Isn't feminism about freedom? Freedom from shame and the judgement of others about what we 'should' and 'shouldn't' be doing?

FloconDeNeige · 24/09/2021 22:45

I didn’t feel shame because my husband helped me through a tough spot. I was ill, there was no shame that. His love and encouragement throughout that period helped me to get through it. I just didn’t like the vulnerability of not being able to rely on myself.

moch11 · 24/09/2021 22:43

I might tell people they are henceforth to be known as ‘SAHMs’ and are a hot topic on MN.

Until I came on here it never occurred to me that anyone would give a hoot about how my husband and I organise our family.

I can’t recall anyone in real life asking me if I work or not. I never meet people and start weighing them up based on their job or ‘are you a SAHM?’ I find MN so very strange.

thinkbiglittleone · 24/09/2021 22:38

@FloconDeNeige

There are loads of things that are discussed on here more extensively than in real life. Owning a toilet brush, breastfeeding, changing bedsheets etc etc. It is a discussion forum, after all.
It wasn't how extensively they are discussed, it was the views and comments of people I refer to.
stilltiredinthemorning · 24/09/2021 22:37

@FloconDeNeige do you really think that being a feminist means judging and condemning the choices of other women?
I find it so sad that you seem to be experiencing feelings of shame because your husband helped you through a tough spot.
It's not about 'relying on a man' it's about relying on a partner, on someone you love who you've chosen to spend your life with. When we had our first child my husband took a year off and I went back to work. With our second I took a year off. I am not currently working because our eldest needs a bit of extra support and I want to be there for her. I expect my husband would also like to be at home to support her, but he is a kind and loving man and he is making the sacrifice of going out to work, so that I can have this opportunity.
I understand that I am a very privileged, well-educated person with a professional career that I can pick up and put down when needed. Lots of families may not have the options that we have and I respect their choices as being the best for them in their own unique circumstances.
I do have daughter. I want her to grow up in a society where she genuinely has a choice and in a relationship based on mutual respect, trust and compromise. I don't ever want her to feel shamed because she hasn't got a PhD or a 'calling' or because she might want to stay at home and look after her children. I thought that was feminism?

FloconDeNeige · 24/09/2021 22:29

There are loads of things that are discussed on here more extensively than in real life. Owning a toilet brush, breastfeeding, changing bedsheets etc etc. It is a discussion forum, after all.