Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People who claim to be empaths are narcissists

239 replies

Justreadingtheforum3 · 22/09/2021 11:00

I know a couple of people who claim to be empaths. They say things like "I was crying I feel their pain so deeply". This is normally in response to someone telling them their problem. Everything has to be about them and their feelings.

I'm pretty sure everyone is empathetic bar a few sociopaths, but other people don't have to make other peoples trauma about them?! In fact I think its insulting to the person experiencing the trauma to have person who believes they feel their problems deeper than them.

I'm assuming we all know at least one of these "empaths".

Are people claiming to empaths narcissist?

Yabu no they're not

Yanbu they are

OP posts:
cravingthelook · 22/09/2021 13:17

Everyone has the capability for empathy. When someone is described as an empath it's usually to say they are tuned into others feelings more than usual.
Learning to be this tuned in is often a trauma response and it is a subconsciously learned defence mechanism.
The same trauma can also cause the response to be to think about me me me.
This I'm sure there's a link between 'empath's' and 'narcissists' but I'd be more interested in a study of the link with childhood trauma.

IHateCoronavirus · 22/09/2021 13:17

I think ‘empath’ is a term used by people with a low sense of self, and poor appreciation for how different someone else’s frame of reference can be.

They think they feel what the other person is feeling when in reality they are reacting to their own feelings and experiences, triggered by something in the other’s situation.

We can empathise when we hear someone has lost their mum, for example. We can listen to them and acknowledge the emotions they express. We can give them space to explore their thoughts and feelings and wish healing thoughts for them.
We can never pretend to know how they are feeling because we never experienced the specific bond and dynamics that they had. Even siblings, born and raised by the same parents, will have very different experiences based on birth order etc.

SorryMyFault · 22/09/2021 13:15

NC as - even on Mumsnet - I don't want to claim anything. I am an empath. I feel the emotions of other people as does my mother. I don't tell them or talk about it, it isn't a badge of an type and is rarely a benefit or a useful skill. It also isn't telepathy or psychic powers. I feel the emotion and can't tell anything other than I suddenly feel a certainty, most times it is hard to distinguish from my own emotions so I have to try and figure out if it is my emotion or not.
If it's clear who it is coming from I still don't know the reasons for the emotion or anything else, just the feeling.
That said, people who go around telling everyone they are an empath is a twat. I would assume that most are, like me, rarely on FB or etc. as the more you avoid the general duckers of drama the less it will affect you. You also learnt to close it off to a degree and ignore it or it will make you crazy - or at least exhausted! I assume anyone that goes around saying it or even better talking about it all the time is a liar.
Empathy is a scale like most things. I am always a bit secretly impressed with the arrogance of people that say, "it doesn't exist" about something they cannot measure or prove. The emphatic "but we know there is no such thing as ghosts" or "but there is no God". No one else has ever proved something they cannot measure and haven't experienced but there you are "knowing" it anyway. Love it.
NC-ing back now so not going to reply to any comments, doesn't matter does it!?! Just saying my two cents. Each to their own views, etc. Smile

donquixotedelamancha · 22/09/2021 13:15

I don't think you can tar everyone with the same brush. Some people are empaths, some narcissists

Except only one of those terms is from Science Fiction.

thecatsthecats · 22/09/2021 13:15

Empath must surely perpetually be annoyed or irritated though, as most people find such behaviour irritating?

However it doesn't seem to rank highly on the emotions they claim to feel...

CatJumperTwat · 22/09/2021 13:11

@bruffin

There were a few threads on here the other week where people claimed to be empathic. To me it sounded like the new "anxiety" on here.
Piss off with that. Anxiety is a real disorder. Empaths don't exist.
TheFoundations · 22/09/2021 13:11

@Alconleigh

I just don't understand this increasingly prevalent trend for labelling oneself. Empath / pansexual / non binary / seer of unicorns; this ravening hunger to be more, to be special, to be "this particular thing and everyone must know and acknowledge it". Often becoming a different thing the following week.....I sort of get teenagers doing it, as navel gazing is part and parcel of that age, but it seems wider. Is it purely social media driven? Do we actually have a population who is so devoid of sense of self that they must endlessly articulate it externally? One of the lovely thing about getting older (I am mid forties) is the realisation that no one cares. Which doesn't mean no one cares ABOUT you (hopefully), but we're all dealing with our own lives. Don't be a dick, be a decent friend and family member, and crack on. Stop identifying and just be.

Which was somewhat off topic. Re empaths, I don't know anyone who describes themselves as such but I'd lean to the emotional vampire or trauma explanations.

I think that labelling is quite useful inwardly. It's helpful to know what you are so that you can find others like you. There's nothing unusual in that; we all seek people like us, whether it's fellow gay people or fellow knitters or fellow cooks. It's quite interesting and helpful in understanding those you're close to, too. My friend's autism diagnosis led me to quite a lot of reading, and understanding him better.

That's quite different from saying 'I'm an empath, so that thing that's hurting you right now? Your hurt hurts me, so pay attention to/comfort me.'

Whatever labels you have, you can be a dick about them, or not be a dick about them. It's not the label's fault if you're a dick. It's not the label's fault if you use it as an excuse.

Actually, that captures the issue, I think: Label all you like, but don't use your chosen labels as an excuse to be a dick or treat people badly.

bigbaggyeyes · 22/09/2021 13:10

I don't think you can tar everyone with the same brush. Some people are empaths, some narcissists, some are simply good at reading people and situations and use that information to be kind and caring, or manipulate the person/situation for their own personal gain

donquixotedelamancha · 22/09/2021 13:09

There are many empaths who go about being empathic, and deal with their own sensitivities quietly.

Presumably they are all on Betazed so we won't meet them until at least 2063.

VelvetChairGirl · 22/09/2021 13:08

"I think you actually have a very shallow understanding of ASD, based on this evidence. ASD in women is often a very different ball game."

my son is ASD

strawberrydonuts · 22/09/2021 13:08

@Redcrayons

Empath = drama llama who hoovers up all the attention. If you have to tell everyone how nice, kind, thoughtful, feeling etc you are then you probably aren’t.
I think "Empath" and "drama llama who hoovers up all the attention" are pretty much mutually exclusive actually.

Some people are very empathetic but they are not usually the people going around shouting about it.

QueenoftheKarens · 22/09/2021 13:08

Yes!

I knew one clearly a narc.
I had stillborn triplets and they made it out all about them. Phoned me on the day of their funeral demanding I go help them as they were overwhelmed with emotion and couldn't pick their kids up from school... on my children's FUNERAL DAY. AngryConfused
Then after that the real narcissist traits kept coming out. Gone no contact now.. life is much better! Hopefully the karma bus will hit them soon.

alloalloallo · 22/09/2021 13:08

Every time I was upset about something, he would be "feeling it too" so I would somehow end up comforting him

Yes! My MiL is like this.

She claims to “feel other peoples trauma so deeply” when in reality, somehow, you end up comforting her as she’s in tears as she’s so worried/upset/anxious

My SiL went through a horrible divorce a few years ago, but everything became about how worried and upset MiL was.

Again, recently my younger daughter has had some health issues and we just can’t talk to her as she end up in tears and always manages to turn any conversation into how worried and upset she is about DD, so you end up comforting and reassuring her. Of course, she’s worried about her grandchild, but I always find it odd that if DH phones for a chat with his mum, he’s the one that ends up comforting her.

onelittlefrog · 22/09/2021 13:07

Strange question and kind of unanswerable because everyone is different.

Some people are very empathetic, some people aren't. Some people are in between.

Some people feel things very deeply and intensely and may be trying to support someone but it then becomes about them, and they can no longer help that person.

It's not really their fault but just how they are built. People with BPD are often like this.

Some people just don't have the ability to have true insight into their behaviour and the impact of it.

donquixotedelamancha · 22/09/2021 13:06

It always surprises me how much loads of posters on MN are convinced they know other's inner thoughts from small actions and facial expressions. These people invariable assign bad faith to others but excuse themselves.

I think it shows a deep lack of empathy and wisdom to be so sure you are right about others without listening first.

I've never met an 'empath' but I imagine them as just one step worse than that.

TheFoundations · 22/09/2021 13:03

@chocolateorangeinhaler

I agree with you OP. They are like vultures waiting to latch on to someone else's misfortune. There is being nice and helping someone in need. And then there are the virtue signaling brigade that like to help just to get the likes on whatever social media platforms they use.

Very insecure shallow people is what they are.

That's not the case. That's like saying 'It's always obvious when somebody's wearing a wig'

There are many empaths who go about being empathic, and deal with their own sensitivities quietly. Just because you don't know them, doesn't mean they are not there.

WeeMadArthur · 22/09/2021 13:00

I’m fairly sure my ex MIL was a narcissist. When they sent their kids to military boarding school ( which they all hated ) she cried so much about them being unhappy that they comforted her, and then made a pact not to complain anymore as it upset her so much. When she went to her step fathers funeral she was crying like the rest of the family but made the point to her kids that she was crying because she was upset that she didn’t feel anything about him dying. Putting them in the position of having to comfort her because she didn’t care their grandfather was dead. She was a real piece of work.

Yogsgirl · 22/09/2021 12:59

Oh Yes!

I have a 'friend' like this- she's always claiming she was crying- she even cried when Prince Phillip died!

Rosycheeks21 · 22/09/2021 12:59

I do consider myself an empath. I don’t go round telling people this though because I don’t necessarily think it’s a good thing. It causes me so much anxiety.

Narcissistic people call themselves empaths because they think it’s a good thing or makes them a better person.

rhonddacynontaf · 22/09/2021 12:58

@VelvetChairGirl

As someone who studies psychology in her spare time and did a few courses on child psychology and dealing with ASD kids.

the entire idea of empaths is BS to me you can have sympathy and understanding but unless you have lived in someone elses shoes you cant feel anything also crying is BS and achieves nothing except maybe making the person feel bad for opening up to you because now you are upset, unless thats your intent to shame them into shutting up about their problems. but narcissism is a big word which has a very exact criteria, those whom you think are making it about them are very likely not narcs but could be all many of things from ASD to depressives to nothing at all, ASD for example will tend to use personally experience to impart solidarity (i.e they say about their experience to show they understand). narcs are not stupid when it matters in terms of manipulation they tend to let you speak and fake concern rather then as you put it make it all about them, they know when to turn on the charm etc thats why they tend to be highly successful in jobs.

I think you actually have a very shallow understanding of ASD, based on this evidence. ASD in women is often a very different ball game.
Angrymum22 · 22/09/2021 12:57

You can put yourself in the position of someone who has just lost their mother, but if your mother is still alive you cannot possible empathise. Your reaction will be totally different to someone whose mother has died.
Experience gives us the ability to empathise not some perceived gift.
I would not know how it feels to lose a child but I can be supportive. However if someone has lost mother/father/had a miscarriage I can empathise.

KittenKong · 22/09/2021 12:57

Emotional tourists...

rhonddacynontaf · 22/09/2021 12:57

@Alconleigh

I just don't understand this increasingly prevalent trend for labelling oneself. Empath / pansexual / non binary / seer of unicorns; this ravening hunger to be more, to be special, to be "this particular thing and everyone must know and acknowledge it". Often becoming a different thing the following week.....I sort of get teenagers doing it, as navel gazing is part and parcel of that age, but it seems wider. Is it purely social media driven? Do we actually have a population who is so devoid of sense of self that they must endlessly articulate it externally? One of the lovely thing about getting older (I am mid forties) is the realisation that no one cares. Which doesn't mean no one cares ABOUT you (hopefully), but we're all dealing with our own lives. Don't be a dick, be a decent friend and family member, and crack on. Stop identifying and just be.

Which was somewhat off topic. Re empaths, I don't know anyone who describes themselves as such but I'd lean to the emotional vampire or trauma explanations.

This is my line of thinking too. Nobody gives a shit.
KittenKong · 22/09/2021 12:56

@ClumpingBambooIsALie

"Captain, he's hiding something"
Fnarr fnarr
Alconleigh · 22/09/2021 12:54

I just don't understand this increasingly prevalent trend for labelling oneself. Empath / pansexual / non binary / seer of unicorns; this ravening hunger to be more, to be special, to be "this particular thing and everyone must know and acknowledge it". Often becoming a different thing the following week.....I sort of get teenagers doing it, as navel gazing is part and parcel of that age, but it seems wider. Is it purely social media driven? Do we actually have a population who is so devoid of sense of self that they must endlessly articulate it externally?
One of the lovely thing about getting older (I am mid forties) is the realisation that no one cares. Which doesn't mean no one cares ABOUT you (hopefully), but we're all dealing with our own lives. Don't be a dick, be a decent friend and family member, and crack on. Stop identifying and just be.

Which was somewhat off topic. Re empaths, I don't know anyone who describes themselves as such but I'd lean to the emotional vampire or trauma explanations.

Swipe left for the next trending thread