Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People who claim to be empaths are narcissists

239 replies

Justreadingtheforum3 · 22/09/2021 11:00

I know a couple of people who claim to be empaths. They say things like "I was crying I feel their pain so deeply". This is normally in response to someone telling them their problem. Everything has to be about them and their feelings.

I'm pretty sure everyone is empathetic bar a few sociopaths, but other people don't have to make other peoples trauma about them?! In fact I think its insulting to the person experiencing the trauma to have person who believes they feel their problems deeper than them.

I'm assuming we all know at least one of these "empaths".

Are people claiming to empaths narcissist?

Yabu no they're not

Yanbu they are

OP posts:
3scape · 22/09/2021 14:46

My very manipulative ex will tell anyone that a lot of things are difficult for him as he is so very sensitive to others pain. So much so that it hurts him for them to bring up their problems as it makes him anything from uncomfortable to suicidal. Yeah. You can't discuss your bad day in front of him as he will then have a bad week Hmm

Fruitinator · 22/09/2021 14:36

From my sample size of the one person I know who claims to be a empath, after 20 years, I am yet to see this demonstrated.....ever.

To the contrary, plenty of examples of self centered, unsympathetic and quite frankly bulling behaviors.

They also talk a lot about their faith and charity work, only examples of this have been when they will be seen and praised externally.

There must be some truly lovely empathetic people. Sadly those self professed, that I have encountered, who proclaim it most loudly haven't been.

Peoniesandpeaches · 22/09/2021 14:24

@Angrymum22

Empathy is an emotional state that most people experience in n day to day life. It is not a personality type.
Absolutely! I tend to find people claiming to be empaths are either very self involved (grief thief types) or lack emotional resilience and expect others to mollycoddle them. There is a reason you don’t find it in the DSM. Those with trauma responses or who are neurodivergent that are being labeled this have just had the misfortune to meet idiots who lack understanding of psychology…
Toffeesprinkles · 22/09/2021 14:04

This is a really interesting thread! I have a friend who claims to be an empath but she is actually very self-centered (I feel mean saying it but it is true - everything becomes about her). She often makes people feel uncomfortable with the questions she asks, she's ever so nosey and doesn't seem to realise that the things she says irl and on social media make people feel judged, embarrassed etc. So I always find it odd that she claims to be an empath but has so little understanding of how her actions and words affect others.

SorryMyFault · 22/09/2021 13:59

Also would add that for me personally I experienced no trauma until being raped in my teens and yet was like this from a very small a child. Didn't know it wasn't something everyone experienced until I was a lot older and didn't know my mother was the same until I was an adult. I have had anxiety and depression my entire life, medicated on and off once I was late teens and I am 40 now. It's misunderstood and mostly due to the bellends that go around telling people they are empaths. It's an oddity and an inconvenience (to put it mildly!), not a super power or special gift. It must be fantastic to only ever have to feel your own emotions. Not everyone wants to be a centre of attention twat that jumps on and exploits the suffering of others. That's why I say no real empath would ever go around telling people! What a cunty thing to do/way live.

PhilCornwall1 · 22/09/2021 13:57

Yes, you are, Deanna, but in fairness you do sometimes say things like ‘I sense anger!’ when the Borg are actually attacking the Enterprise and a toaster would probably say the same…

I thought Talkie Toaster was Red Dwarf. 🤔🤔

QueeniesCroft · 22/09/2021 13:57

I'm not qualified to diagnose anyone, so I don't know about narcissism, but I am generally extremely suspicious of anyone who feels the need to describe themselves.
Usually, it's people telling me how good they are at their jobs (they usually are not), or how trustworthy they are (ditto). But I suppose this fits too. If someone has a quality or particular ability, it's generally obvious. If you have to tell people, there is a fair chance that it isn't true.

YouJustDoYou · 22/09/2021 13:56

Oh, i have a friend like this. She posts constantly, waxing lyrical about what an empath she is, how she is so amazing at understanding other people's feelings, how they always come to her for advice, it goes on and on and on. She is also a raging narcissist and doesn't actually demonstrate true empathy at all. She only ever thinks about herself - her own feelings, what she's going through etc, and doesn't seem to understand at all how her actions affect those around her.

SorryMyFault · 22/09/2021 13:51

Didn't know you could pop between names once you NC and I have been on here years! I'm a dick, sorry.

Thank you @TintinIsBack that is exactly it. You feel so stupid if you cry when it isn't your own emotion. People don't realise that it is just an extension of your own feelings, you don't need to be told someone is sad or angry you just know that YOU weren't sad or angry until a new person came into the room and then you can tell you haven't suddenly become sad or angry at random so it is them not you. That's all it is. A confusing, stressful and distracting thing you learn to cope with by blocking it off as you learn how.
I am no royalist but when I saw the queen at Phillips funeral, so small and defeated and old but unable to raise her head as she isn't supposed to cry... I had tears running down my face the whole time even though I wasn't "crying", it is impossible to avoid. I avoid so many places and situations as a result, there is nothing worse than crying because someone else is, you look a total twat. It is awful with kids, too. A child crying because their dog died does not need a moronic adult crying along with them so you learn to distance yourself and actively avoid these situations. I continually have to hide my face if one of my kids cries about a playground bully or something, to be seen crying with them is confirming to them that they should cry - it does not go hand in hand with the speech I'm trying to give about how the little shit isn't worth crying over and is best ignored, etc. Could give a thousand examples but there is no point!
Sorry for ridiculous amounts of errors in previous message, bloody autocorrect. There should be an edit function! Why after all these years is there no edit function?! Sigh

52andblue · 22/09/2021 13:46

I agree that both are trauma responses though (either end of the spectrum of responses, and often attracted to each other due to that)

mutedrainbows · 22/09/2021 13:46

I think some people cross over into empath & grief thief but obviously that's a big generalisation.

52andblue · 22/09/2021 13:44

@MotherofPoodles

I think empaths are more likely to be hyper vigilant which is usually caused by trauma.
Very few people are diagnostically Narcissistic. Very few people are true Empaths. Lots of people have traits. some self advertise it, some don't.
LouLou789 · 22/09/2021 13:43

I haven’t voted because I think some are and some aren’t. On one hand anyone who is truly empathic doesn’t usually go round telling everyone they are, and on the other hand some may truly be trying to encourage others. Not many in the second category though!

TintinIsBack · 22/09/2021 13:41

@cravingthelook

Everyone has the capability for empathy. When someone is described as an empath it's usually to say they are tuned into others feelings more than usual. Learning to be this tuned in is often a trauma response and it is a subconsciously learned defence mechanism. The same trauma can also cause the response to be to think about me me me. This I'm sure there's a link between 'empath's' and 'narcissists' but I'd be more interested in a study of the link with childhood trauma.
I’ve read that before.

No idea if. it’s true.

But I’m actually not sure I’d wish for people to be empath. Too many struggles associated with it tbh.

TintinIsBack · 22/09/2021 13:38

@SorryMyFault

NC as - even on Mumsnet - I don't want to claim anything. I am an empath. I feel the emotions of other people as does my mother. I don't tell them or talk about it, it isn't a badge of an type and is rarely a benefit or a useful skill. It also isn't telepathy or psychic powers. I feel the emotion and can't tell anything other than I suddenly feel a certainty, most times it is hard to distinguish from my own emotions so I have to try and figure out if it is my emotion or not. If it's clear who it is coming from I still don't know the reasons for the emotion or anything else, just the feeling. That said, people who go around telling everyone they are an empath is a twat. I would assume that most are, like me, rarely on FB or etc. as the more you avoid the general duckers of drama the less it will affect you. You also learnt to close it off to a degree and ignore it or it will make you crazy - or at least exhausted! I assume anyone that goes around saying it or even better talking about it all the time is a liar. Empathy is a scale like most things. I am always a bit secretly impressed with the arrogance of people that say, "it doesn't exist" about something they cannot measure or prove. The emphatic "but we know there is no such thing as ghosts" or "but there is no God". No one else has ever proved something they cannot measure and haven't experienced but there you are "knowing" it anyway. Love it. NC-ing back now so not going to reply to any comments, doesn't matter does it!?! Just saying my two cents. Each to their own views, etc. Smile
I agree.

I am an empath and I can physically feel other people emotions. I feel the hurt and the pain, the anger etc….
I’ve learnt to separate my feelings from other people’s feelings. It’s making me good at my job.
It’s also hard to have to deal with other people’s pain tbh.

However, I don’t go round claiming I can feel what they feel. I just internally acknowledge their pain and concentrate on supporting them.

Someone who goes round saying they can feel the pain of others like that is a twat. Nothing to do with being an empath. I would actually suspect they are nowhere near an empath tbh.

TheHouseIsOnFire · 22/09/2021 13:36

I’m not a narcissist - far from it - but I do get upset at other peoples pain. When my DP talks about his best friend who died I end up welling up more than he does which I think he finds quite distracting but I can’t help myself. I feel so sad for his friend who had a mental breakdown and I feel so sad for him losing a close friend so suddenly. He is uncomfortable with tears. Even at the time he wouldn’t really let go and properly cry about it, so I feel like there’s a lot of pent up sadness in there. When I cry about it he he seems bemused by it.

Similarly my friend’s mum just died. When she was telling me a story about her mum it brought tears to my eyes, even though she was quite matter fact about it.

I don’t think that makes me self centred at all, but I guess that having lost my own mum, some of the upset may be about her as much as on behalf of my friend.

AnotherFruitcake · 22/09/2021 13:35

@CounsellorTroi

I’m definitely an empath!
Yes, you are, Deanna, but in fairness you do sometimes say things like ‘I sense anger!’ when the Borg are actually attacking the Enterprise and a toaster would probably say the same… Grin
woodenbroomer · 22/09/2021 13:33

I absorb the feelings of those around me and I truly wish I didn't. You would never know. I'd never tell you. I'd hide it then retreat

MacNougat · 22/09/2021 13:33

The only time I've ever heard anyone call themselves an empath is on Mumsnet.

yellowcourgette · 22/09/2021 13:31

Excuse the awful grammar there... why is there no edit button?!

yellowcourgette · 22/09/2021 13:30

I am 'one of these people' - well, not in the way you describe - I'm certainly not a narcissist and I'm not a 'grief thief' but I do react in certain ways to other people's grief and emotions. I can see how it can be percieved as selfish and I can see how it can be misunderstood.

I have ADHD and one symptom/related behaviours of that are hypersensitivity. So for example, something like seeing somone cry makes me cry, and I find emotional films quite stressful. If someone shouts at me I find it really stressful and may cry or have a child-like response. I am super aware of other people's emotions, and if someone is in a bad mood it makes me extremely anxious and uncomfortable. Giving me the silent treatment is absolute torture. Because of this I tend to try and fix things and get involved in the cause of other peoples' emotions. I am/was often told I am ovrereacting or being ridiculous or oversensitive.

I also have rejection sensitivity. So if I've upset someone unintentionally, or someone criticises me, my knee-jerk reaction is absolute mortifying anxiety and an emotionally charged scramble to explain/fix it/undo it. My uncontrolled reation could be to cry, or to have a panic attack.

But I am also generally very empathatic and a people pleaser, which I have learnt from my Mum. Again, sometimes not helpful on both sides. But it brings me geniune and great joy to help people. Whether that is selfish or not is up for debate (altruism is an evolutionary trait that is ultimately selfish).

Believe me, I am very aware that my behaviour can be difficult for others. It can come across as selfish and it can be a coping mechanism that I adopt to protect myself from my emotions. It's really, really difficut for me and I wish I was different. It's led to depression an anxiety for my whole life and just coping with these extreme emotions is exhuasting. I try very hard and have been through a lot of therapy to help me override these knee-jerk reactions, and I am a much more balanced individual. As an analogy I would say that I am like someone who has arachnaphobia and is still absolutely terrified of spiders, but has taught themselves to be able to catch one and put it out the window instead of permanently avoid the room it's in!

So. I think lumping everyone into the same category and overgeneralising is really unhelful for both sides. People are wired differently and many people are neuroatypical to some degree. If someone comes across as 'selfishly empathetic' then there is probably a genuine reason for this and highly unlikely that they are actually a narcissist, which seems to be the Mumsnet go-to diagnosis.

Itsnotdeep · 22/09/2021 13:24

@MotherofPoodles

I think empaths are more likely to be hyper vigilant which is usually caused by trauma.
I think this. I'm not an empath, but due to a shitty upbringing, am ridiculously stressed by people's (imagined? Real? Possible?) reactions to things, and my need to people please. It has led me to/kept me in some very abusive relationships and It absolutely is a trauma response.

Anyone I've met who has said they are an empath, or very kind, or a nice guy, is usually an abusive pig.

Wroxie · 22/09/2021 13:23

Someone truly empathetic who would never, ever describe themselves as an "empath", because actually being empathetic means being humble and thoughtful- empathetic people understand and help others without making it about themselves.

GurtBusty · 22/09/2021 13:20

I've only encountered 2 people who claimed to be empaths - they weren't, they were just 2 completely self centred cocks. In my head I called them "MeMeOne" and "MeMeTwo"

Lweji · 22/09/2021 13:19

I won't comment on the narcissism aspect, but, yes I think it's very selfish and self centered of such people.
My mother is like that. Everyone's issues end up being about her.
Hardly any support during my divorce. And some key absences still sting.