Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People who claim to be empaths are narcissists

239 replies

Justreadingtheforum3 · 22/09/2021 11:00

I know a couple of people who claim to be empaths. They say things like "I was crying I feel their pain so deeply". This is normally in response to someone telling them their problem. Everything has to be about them and their feelings.

I'm pretty sure everyone is empathetic bar a few sociopaths, but other people don't have to make other peoples trauma about them?! In fact I think its insulting to the person experiencing the trauma to have person who believes they feel their problems deeper than them.

I'm assuming we all know at least one of these "empaths".

Are people claiming to empaths narcissist?

Yabu no they're not

Yanbu they are

OP posts:
CatJumperTwat · 23/09/2021 09:37

The irony.

Exactly my point. So ironic that "empaths" are the more self-involved people you could ever meet.

Alicenwonderland · 23/09/2021 09:36

I am an empath. Growing up I was extremely over sensitive, I hated upsetting people or making them unhappy so I always put myself last. I really had to re-evaluate myself after my 8 year abusive relationship. My IDVA pointed out that my childhood was rather emotionally abusive. I learnt from a young age to always be good to keep my Mum happy, her needs always came first. As a result I've always been hyper vigilant to the feelings of others. Sadly there are many narcissistic personality types who seek out sensitive, empathic people. My ex would always accuse me of being the very things he was. I agree with a previous poster who suggested it is a result of hypervigilance.

TintinIsBack · 23/09/2021 09:31

I think basically people are talking about different things, comparing apples with oranges really.

Plus, as usual on MN, you have a lot of people who have decided they are right and get very argumentative when someone else says they dint agree 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️

TheFoundations · 23/09/2021 09:20

@CatJumperTwat

If somebody is making somebody else's pain about them, they're not an empath. That's not what it means, and they, and you, have misunderstood the term.

Empaths don't exist so there is no standard definition. Yet you think your view of these unicorns is the only right one and everyone else on the thread (including self-labelled "empaths") is wrong. Bit narcissistic.

The irony.
CatJumperTwat · 23/09/2021 09:13

If somebody is making somebody else's pain about them, they're not an empath. That's not what it means, and they, and you, have misunderstood the term.

Empaths don't exist so there is no standard definition. Yet you think your view of these unicorns is the only right one and everyone else on the thread (including self-labelled "empaths") is wrong. Bit narcissistic.

thepeopleversuswork · 23/09/2021 09:09

I think saying they are all narcissists is a stretch but I am certainly suspicious of a self-described “empath”.

It’s one of those things where I feel that if you have to advertise this quality to others you probably don’t have it.

LemonTT · 23/09/2021 09:01

One of the posts mentioned that we are all self centred. This is true, a natural instinct to meet our own needs. But almost all humans are redeemed by empathy.

The absence of empathy in general or specifically is the basis for psychopathy. True goodness is someone whose empathy extends beyond theirs friends, family and people like them to everyone, even their supposed enemies.

True evil is a lack of empathy for anyone or selected groups. Hitler and many Nazis were out and out psychopaths. Most Nazis just limited their empathy because of rage hatred and anger. After the war they lived apparently normal lives because the focus and basis of hatred was removed. This suggests are empathy can be suspended or limited.

Posts on here by people describing empaths are not describing an empathic response. They are describing an inability to relate to another’s suffering because of their own suffering. They are not putting themselves in another’s shoes. They are staying firmly in their own. Feeling pain caused by other events in their life. Unable to show compassion and provide emotional support. It’s not empathy.

Unfortunately I think it is easier to ascribe a bogus name to a behaviour rather than address MH issues and inability to process or manage their own emotions.

TheFoundations · 23/09/2021 08:09

@jd88123

A narccisist I dated told me he was an empath. He was very demeaning towards me and gas lighting. When we finished he said "everyone's an empath and narcissist as there is no greater sense than self" I disagree as I would say I am an empath and feel other people's emotions but don't use that to get sympathy. It just means I have to ensure I recognise and deal the the emotions so they don't get "stuck".
It would have made more sense if he'd said 'Everyone has some empathic and some narcissistic traits', but he's made the mistake most people on the thread have made, which is to think that having those traits makes you 'a narcissist' or 'an empath'.
TheFoundations · 23/09/2021 08:04

@RicherThanYew

TheFoundations - I'm not angry, I just like to fucking swear. You need to work on your empathy.
OK, will do. You clearly know best.
Brokensunflower · 23/09/2021 06:38

My toes literally curl on hearing someone describe themselves as an empath.

LavenderAskew · 23/09/2021 06:38

😁 @BoobsOnTheMoon, probably something in that too. I mean so far it's all been about knowing someone is angry ot sad. There are other emotions!! Sadness and angry show in people's faces, not sure another person being affected by that (experiencing their physical and psychology reaction to anger or sadness based on past experiences) makes them an "empath".

I mean certainly some people are more aware of the signs of other people's feelings than others, they read body language better. But that's not an empth, might not even be empathetic (depending how the emotions are interpreted)

Underamour · 23/09/2021 06:33

I’ve met people who truly are empaths who can feel your pain, understand it and make it all make sense and those people are worth their weight in gold. There was also a Facebook “trend” of people calling themselves empaths- if it made them even 1% more empathic in real life then it’s a good thing.

The root problem is that Facebook Instagram etc demand that you talk about yourself/ upload pictures of yourself each day. This leads normal people to overthink how they can make themselves seem interesting/relevant etc. I don’t think these people are narcs, many are perfectly normal in real life. It’s that they take the “Tell me what’s on your mind” prompt too seriously.

Either way, making things all about yourself all the time is never a good thing.

BoobsOnTheMoon · 23/09/2021 06:24
Grin
People who claim to be empaths are narcissists
BrickingIt44 · 23/09/2021 06:23

I consider myself to be an empath in that I can easily tell what other people are feeling, rather than feeling it myself. Maybe empath isn't the right word?
It comes from having a mum who would have a hair trigger temper and could fly into a rage at the slightest thing. As a defense mechanism I paid very close attention to any signs that showed how she was feeling. I'm not narcissistic in the least - very much the opposite. Could be the same for other self-proclaimed empaths.

RicherThanYew · 23/09/2021 00:42

TheFoundations - I'm not angry, I just like to fucking swear. You need to work on your empathy.

Gingernaut · 23/09/2021 00:29

I'm empathetic and it's awful. I am definitely not a narcissist.

When strangers are upset or angry in public, it upsets me to the point I have to leave.

If I can't, it leaves a lasting impression and I avoid places.

I couldn't manipulate anyone if I tried - I'd love a Machiavellian streak, but it's beyond me.

I hate it and have been the victim of a narcissist in the workplace.

WhoIsPepeSilva · 23/09/2021 00:24

Had a discussion with someone a few months back about this.

I dislike the term, people that describe themselves this way IME tend to be people who want to be seen as special or different because they have low self esteem. They actually vary in empathy from not very at all to how most people are - sometimes they can be and other times less so.

It seems to be the new fashionable term people use for just old fashioned putting yourself in someone else's shoes or having similar experiences that make you relate to someone.

jd88123 · 23/09/2021 00:23

A narccisist I dated told me he was an empath. He was very demeaning towards me and gas lighting. When we finished he said "everyone's an empath and narcissist as there is no greater sense than self"
I disagree as I would say I am an empath and feel other people's emotions but don't use that to get sympathy. It just means I have to ensure I recognise and deal the the emotions so they don't get "stuck".

AnnieSnap · 23/09/2021 00:23

@Bluntness100

This site is obsessed with narcissists. Apparently every other person is one.
Yep, this ☝️
WeasilyPleased · 23/09/2021 00:15

I am extremely empathetic and would only admit that on an anonymous forum. It's nothing big or clever. It's often a horrible trait to have and not something I'd want to have others know.
People who go round spouting off about it aren't genuine because they would know it makes others feel exasperated or worried. Those people are self centred idiots.

TheFoundations · 22/09/2021 23:53

@RicherThanYew

I've cross posted with many on here but I stand by what I said, hyper vigilance is not some twee romantic identity that people can affix to themselves like a fucking rosette. Moofolk is completely right too.
Hypervigilance isn't the same as being an empath, either. You sound angry, indignant, and like you don't really know what you're talking about.
RicherThanYew · 22/09/2021 23:44

I've cross posted with many on here but I stand by what I said, hyper vigilance is not some twee romantic identity that people can affix to themselves like a fucking rosette.
Moofolk is completely right too.

RicherThanYew · 22/09/2021 23:41

I fully believe that empaths exist and that they are not narcissists. I know this because I've met people from horrifically abusive backgrounds who spent literal decades of their lives walking on eggshells around abusers and needing to know when the abusers moods changed and what would trigger them in order to avoid further abuse so they developed almost an extra sense because they could pick up on micro cues. None of these people blather on about it or spend time navel gazing like it's some ethereal super power because they hate how it feels and they actively try to avoid all social interaction with people they don't know and trust implicitly not to have raging mood swings.

goinggently · 22/09/2021 23:40

@Alconleigh

I just don't understand this increasingly prevalent trend for labelling oneself. Empath / pansexual / non binary / seer of unicorns; this ravening hunger to be more, to be special, to be "this particular thing and everyone must know and acknowledge it". Often becoming a different thing the following week.....I sort of get teenagers doing it, as navel gazing is part and parcel of that age, but it seems wider. Is it purely social media driven? Do we actually have a population who is so devoid of sense of self that they must endlessly articulate it externally? One of the lovely thing about getting older (I am mid forties) is the realisation that no one cares. Which doesn't mean no one cares ABOUT you (hopefully), but we're all dealing with our own lives. Don't be a dick, be a decent friend and family member, and crack on. Stop identifying and just be.

Which was somewhat off topic. Re empaths, I don't know anyone who describes themselves as such but I'd lean to the emotional vampire or trauma explanations.

Completely agree
Griefmonster · 22/09/2021 23:39

@MotherofPoodles

I think empaths are more likely to be hyper vigilant which is usually caused by trauma.
This is such a good point. Like with everything, there will be many different types who fall in to an "empath" description.

I don't think any who use that description to hijack other's experiences have healthy boundaries or emotional maturity.

Many will have the feelings without making a big deal of it though. For those who have developed hyper-vigilance to attempt to keep themselves safe, it will be exhausting .