Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People who claim to be empaths are narcissists

239 replies

Justreadingtheforum3 · 22/09/2021 11:00

I know a couple of people who claim to be empaths. They say things like "I was crying I feel their pain so deeply". This is normally in response to someone telling them their problem. Everything has to be about them and their feelings.

I'm pretty sure everyone is empathetic bar a few sociopaths, but other people don't have to make other peoples trauma about them?! In fact I think its insulting to the person experiencing the trauma to have person who believes they feel their problems deeper than them.

I'm assuming we all know at least one of these "empaths".

Are people claiming to empaths narcissist?

Yabu no they're not

Yanbu they are

OP posts:
grapewine · 23/09/2021 14:01

And this is a key distinction, IMO

"being an empath" and "having empathy" are different things.

grapewine · 23/09/2021 13:59

@MotherofPoodles

I think empaths are more likely to be hyper vigilant which is usually caused by trauma.
Agree with this.
AnotherFruitcake · 23/09/2021 13:56

@ClawedButler

Well I think most of us can agree that people who publicly say they are empaths are not empaths, by definition.

Someone upthread likened "empaths" to "psychics". As in, this ability isn't real, so you can't genuinely believe you are one. To my mind, though, people who claim to be psychic are probably like Derren Brown but don't know it - as in, they are incredibly good at reading people and making things sound true and personal, but as they don't realise that they are using this skill they think it's psychic ability.

I think that being an empath is similar. Hypervigilance and sensitivity to the most subtle cues mean you pick up on every nuance of the mood, and interpret that according to your own (trauma-based, possibly) experience, and that is experienced as taking on the feelings of others. It's not a gift. It's a burden. And anyone using it like a badge of honour has fundamentally misunderstood what it actually means.

I think that’s fair. I also wonder how a self-proclaimed ‘empath’ knows they are more empathic than other people — after all, how would you calculate that, given that there’s no scale against which varying degrees of empathy can be measured? It’s like trying to judge your own pain threshold against your friend who breezed through labour with no pain relief.

If the self-proclaimed empath bases their sense that they’re unusually empathetic on the fact that they burst into tears when someone tells them something sad, or are disabled by other peoples suffering or trauma, or can’t cope with watching news footage of humanitarian disasters, then I would say that another available (less glamorous) explanation is that they’re simply unusually poor at regulating their own emotions against stimuli.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 23/09/2021 13:48

Does being an empath mean that you only feel other people's negative feelings, or do their positive ones too impinge?

LaRobeRouge · 23/09/2021 13:38

In my experience of nearly 60 years, people who feel the need to tell you what they are are generally the opposite. I worked with a woman who liked to remind me that she was "a very spiritual" person, when in reality she was about as spiritual as a wooden spoon. Same goes for those who self proclaim to be; empathic, honest, sensual etc. I always take an interest in anyone who self proclaims and they never let me down.

BrightYellowDaffodil · 23/09/2021 13:30

I can see it's a way of trying to make sense of a world where you're nice and other people aren't, but I hope she doesn't throw herself into the 'I'm bound to be a victim' hole.

I think she's teetering on the edge of that. She's desperate to avoid being a victim again but it just makes her see almost everyone as a 'narc' for the sake of protecting herself, and has made her very angry and bitter. I've stepped back from the friendship because I just can't listen to the rants and the "I'm a victim" stuff any more.

BrightYellowDaffodil · 23/09/2021 13:26

if you're so much in tune with others' feelings, you'd run a mile from any 'narc' you came across, because you'd be able to feel their deceptiveness. That's a part of being very empathic that can be very useful; the more empathic you are, the more you can tell if somebody is untrustworthy.

I meant to quote this bit too, because I completely agree with it. I wouldn't say empathy is something I can do to a notable extent but sometimes it happens and can be exhausting. Interestingly I never liked the guy she's split up with recently because to me he always screamed "Mr Nice Guy", like he was wearing a mask and everything was a "front". Turns out I was right...

TheFoundations · 23/09/2021 13:22

To be fair to her, some of the abuse stems from childhood

Sorry, I hadn't realised that. She might still be putting herself willingly at the mercy of abusers, though, if she's sure that being lovely can make her a victim. I can see it's a way of trying to make sense of a world where you're nice and other people aren't, but I hope she doesn't throw herself into the 'I'm bound to be a victim' hole.

BrightYellowDaffodil · 23/09/2021 13:14

@TheFoundations

To be fair to her, some of the abuse stems from childhood so I don't think it would be right to level an accusation of "allowing" herself to be a victim at that time. In my opinion (and I'm not a psychologist) I'd say she's a very damaged person looking to make sense of what's happened to her in order to be able to cope with her past, and who is frightened of it happening again. I don't think she can separate what's genuinely nice and normal behaviour from behaviour that starts out as being nice and normal but becomes abuse. I'd also say she's got it into her head that "being an empath" is the same as "being a nice person", rather than being someone who is particularly in tune with the emotions of others.

Bluntly, I don't think there's any sense in what she talks about, it's all just a coping mechanism. Sadly she's pretty vulnerable and she's also now been sucked down an anti-vaxxer/covid conspiracy theories rabbit hole.

TheFoundations · 23/09/2021 12:53

@BrightYellowDaffodil

in that she believes that narcissists (or 'narcs' hmm ) target empaths and therefore what happened to her is because she's a lovely person with pure spirit

That's interesting, because really, if you're so much in tune with others' feelings, you'd run a mile from any 'narc' you came across, because you'd be able to feel their deceptiveness. That's a part of being very empathic that can be very useful; the more empathic you are, the more you can tell if somebody is untrustworthy.

What would your friend say if you put that to her? She seems very keen on absolving herself of responsibility for allowing herself to become the victim of a narcissist.

BrightYellowDaffodil · 23/09/2021 12:37

I also agree that "being an empath" and "having empathy" are different things.

I know two people who are self-pronounced 'empaths'. The first is a manipulative bully who is desperately insecure, which drives them to want to be everyone's best and most indispensable friend. When they aren't getting their own way (or even the perception of not getting their own way) they're a nasty piece of work, which becomes "You won't dare stand up to me because I'll cry and then everyone else will hate you because I AM A LOVELY KIND PERSON". Bloody exhausting.

The other one has a very sad history of abuse. I think she's used the whole empath/narcissist thing to come to terms with it, in that she believes that narcissists (or 'narcs' Hmm ) target empaths and therefore what happened to her is because she's a lovely person with pure spirit. She also seems to see the world as divided into empaths/good people and narcissists/bad people, and if she learns how to 'spot a narc' she'll be able to keep herself safe. Equally sadly she's got herself a therapist who seems to be of the "Me too, hun" brigade, rather than any sort of clinical qualification, and who seems to specialise in inspo-crap. Even worse still, my friend has decided she wants to be a therapist too in order to 'help abused women' which is a fucking terrible idea.

I sometimes feel other's pain acutely, I'm sure we all do from time to time in some way and to differing degrees, particularly if it's someone we are close to or whose situation is unfair or hard to cope with. But the difference comes in how we react to it - the self-proclaimed empaths are usually the 'emotional tourists' mentioned above (great phrase!) or those who just want to be involved in other people's problems so they can make it about themselves or look good. These people are to be avoided.

DogFoodPie · 23/09/2021 11:51

I agree with someone upthread who said being empathetic is an ability that exists on a spectrum. Also psychopathy exists on a spectrum, a few psychopathic traits can be a good thing it's said to be a quality of people like brain surgeons and fighter pilots. Having that ability to shut down emotion and laser focus on the task at hand and thriving in risky, stressful situations. Too much psychopathy and you become a danger to society and yourself. I think it's the same with empathy, being a little more empathetic than normal would make you very good in the caring professions, too much and you would be liable to have a lot of problems dealing with everyday life, setting boundaries with others and keeping your mood steady.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 23/09/2021 11:30

The word "empath" had not yet got into dictionaries in 2002; empathic yes, empathetic yes, empathy yes, but not empath. Empathy then meant "empathy: the power of understanding and imaginatively entering into another's feelings".

Claiming to be one (as opposed to having that ability) before that wouldn't have been possible, so what did people who were naturally able to enter into the feelings of others call themselves before this century? or did they just get on with trying to be kind to people they could tell were in distress, having fun with people who were happy and avoiding people who gave them a grue?

(I assume empaths don't only feel the nasty stuff?) (The spellcheck on this machine does not recognise the word "empaths". Oops.)

IveGotASongThatllGetOnYNerves · 23/09/2021 11:30

I think the term you are looking for is 'twat'.

HidingFromDD · 23/09/2021 11:28

I also feel other people’s emotions as if they were my own. Doesn’t happen with everybody and tends to be the ‘strong’ emotions. It means I can go from happy/content to sad/angry very rapidly. It’s taken a while to understand that it’s not my emotion and then just ignore it. It’s def not an asset, just v confusing until you work out where it’s coming from.

I’m also hyper sensitive as a result of early trauma. It’s v v different. Hyper sensitive means I can be v good at reading people to assess whether there is a threat/issue. It’s not feeling their emotions as my own, but picking up on their emotions and sometimes (I manage it better now) feeling anxious until I’ve ‘made things better’.

Neither of these are ‘empathy’ as it’s usually understood, but the first is how I would explain being an empath. Except I wouldn’t because pretty much no-one in the first group would go around proclaiming they are an empath.

I like to think I can show empathy to my friends, but there’s usually an element where you have to rely on personal experiences to truly understand so whilst I can imagine how they feel that’s as far as it goes (unless they’re one of the people I pick up on)

Doyoumind · 23/09/2021 11:12

Of course there are people who are genuinely empathetic so generalisation is not reasonable. I would say I'm very empathetic but not in a loud or showy way as I really do care about people.

I do know someone very well who has no empathy but who exhibits something that people might mistake for empathy along the lines of what you're saying. Sometimes they aren't actually seeing beyond themselves, and others they are feigning empathy to make themselves look good.

TintinIsBack · 23/09/2021 11:02

It's not a gift. It's a burden. And anyone using it like a badge of honour has fundamentally misunderstood what it actually means.

I agree there @ClawedButler

I also think this is why 'empaths' are geting a bad name. Because those who go round shouting the everyone that they are empaths and 'oh Look at me' are not actual 'empaths'
This thread has demonstarted that very well.

ClawedButler · 23/09/2021 10:36

Well I think most of us can agree that people who publicly say they are empaths are not empaths, by definition.

Someone upthread likened "empaths" to "psychics". As in, this ability isn't real, so you can't genuinely believe you are one. To my mind, though, people who claim to be psychic are probably like Derren Brown but don't know it - as in, they are incredibly good at reading people and making things sound true and personal, but as they don't realise that they are using this skill they think it's psychic ability.

I think that being an empath is similar. Hypervigilance and sensitivity to the most subtle cues mean you pick up on every nuance of the mood, and interpret that according to your own (trauma-based, possibly) experience, and that is experienced as taking on the feelings of others. It's not a gift. It's a burden. And anyone using it like a badge of honour has fundamentally misunderstood what it actually means.

LemonTT · 23/09/2021 10:32

There’s nothing special about being able to read people’s emotions. We can all do it because as humans we tend to have excellent and obvious ways to signal feelings. We use our facial expressions, body language and actual language and tone to convey how we feel. People respond with varying degrees of emotional intelligence and boundaries. In reality most people are very good at it. For thousand of years it keep us alive.

I don’t dispute that narcissists or ego driven people will seek out those who lack boundaries and emotional intelligence. But these people aren’t something called empaths. They are people whose emotional and behavioural calibration is off.

Also there’s a grandiosity associated with claiming special skills. Even more so to make up a name for it. Especially when behaviour suggests you really don’t have those skills or an ability to use them. This is the narcissistic behaviour.

TheFoundations · 23/09/2021 10:00

@CatJumperTwat

My perspective is that I was told by a wonderful counsellor who helped me, in many ways, to change my life for the better, that I was an empath. I read about it, and it helped me understand myself better. I don't declare it to people, and I don't use it as an excuse to make others' pain about me.

You seem to be declaring as a fact that people like me don't exist, and I'm curious to know why you think that.

CatJumperTwat · 23/09/2021 10:00

"I'm not saying I know the facts"

"If somebody is making somebody else's pain about them, they're not an empath. That's not what it means, and they, and you, have misunderstood the term."

TheFoundations · 23/09/2021 09:56

@CatJumperTwat

Why do you get to declare yourself to know the facts

The irony Grin

But there is no irony here. I'm not saying I know the facts, I'm just asking you a question.

Which you haven't answered.

CatJumperTwat · 23/09/2021 09:53

Why do you get to declare yourself to know the facts

The irony Grin

TheFoundations · 23/09/2021 09:43

@CatJumperTwat

The irony.

Exactly my point. So ironic that "empaths" are the more self-involved people you could ever meet.

Only the self involved ones are. The others, you wouldn't know they were empaths, so how do you feel yourself to be such an authority on the subject that if somebody disagrees with your point of view, you call them a narcissist? Why do you get to declare yourself to know the facts about a group of people from whom you've only met a few of the loud mouths and liars?
Alicenwonderland · 23/09/2021 09:39

I also don't advertise it.