Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People who claim to be empaths are narcissists

239 replies

Justreadingtheforum3 · 22/09/2021 11:00

I know a couple of people who claim to be empaths. They say things like "I was crying I feel their pain so deeply". This is normally in response to someone telling them their problem. Everything has to be about them and their feelings.

I'm pretty sure everyone is empathetic bar a few sociopaths, but other people don't have to make other peoples trauma about them?! In fact I think its insulting to the person experiencing the trauma to have person who believes they feel their problems deeper than them.

I'm assuming we all know at least one of these "empaths".

Are people claiming to empaths narcissist?

Yabu no they're not

Yanbu they are

OP posts:
user1471442488 · 23/09/2021 19:47

”I’ve also read that when you subconsciously mirror other people that shows empathy, and I’ve realised that if someone else yawns I do too.”

Lol, literally everyone does this. All the special little snowflakes declaring themselves empaths in here Grin

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 23/09/2021 19:45

I am asking because I don't think anyone on this thread, empath or otherwise,m has said that: it has all been about bad stuff, trauma, and so on. But I don't see why, if there is this Link with all around them, empaths should only pick up on unpleasant emotions and never apparently on pleasant ones.

AskingQuestionsAllTheTime · 23/09/2021 19:44

I ask again: do empaths also feel when people are not unhappy? Do they "feel your pleasure" as well as "feel your pain"?

I have never heard anyone make that claim. I've quite often heard "I am glad for you", but not "I feel your joy."

TheFoundations · 23/09/2021 19:22

@ManifestDestinee

That's not at all the same thing.
Clearly you know best!

Can you explain why it's not the same thing, or are you just stating your opinion as if it's a fact, and that's final?

ManifestDestinee · 23/09/2021 19:01

That's not at all the same thing.

TheFoundations · 23/09/2021 18:49

It's called delusions, and possibly psychosis

No it isn't. Animals can sense when there's trouble and we all just kind of accept that, with an eye roll, and a 'Gosh, aren't dogs amazing, I don't know how they do it!'

We are animals too. Some of us are so far from our natural instincts that they think anybody who can still interpret them is nuts.

ManifestDestinee · 23/09/2021 18:15

@ColorMagicBarbie

And yes I can also tell how people are feeling but not from looking at their face expression. I can tell for example when dH is angry and he is in the garage (and I’m upstairs having a shower…..). I’m not sure WHAT is telling me what’s going on, but I can physically feel it. 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️

Um, is that not called telepathy?

It's called delusions, and possibly psychosis.
ColorMagicBarbie · 23/09/2021 18:12

And yes I can also tell how people are feeling but not from looking at their face expression. I can tell for example when dH is angry and he is in the garage (and I’m upstairs having a shower…..). I’m not sure WHAT is telling me what’s going on, but I can physically feel it. 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️

Um, is that not called telepathy?

LemonTT · 23/09/2021 17:27

@ TheHouseIsOnFire
I didn’t claim empathy was just about reading emotions. I said that emotions are easy to read because it’s a matter of human evolution to be able to read anger, sadness, love and joy.

When someone has feelings we can read and comprehend what those feelings are. They can evoke out own emotional response. But you cannot feel someone else’s emotions.

TheFoundations · 23/09/2021 15:57

@IveGotASongThatllGetOnYNerves

Thinking about those people who go round saying "I'm an EMPATH" What's the difference between being an empath and being someone who has empathy that means it's something to be announced? Do they think having empathy is some superpower or something? Or that they have much more empathy than the rest of us?
It's a matter of degree. Like somebody who likes to spend some time alone wouldn't call themselves 'a loner', but somebody who likes to spend all their time might. It's nothing to do with superpowers.
LizzieW1969 · 23/09/2021 15:56

I guess I could be described as an empath, as I do react strongly to other people’s pain and easily become weepy. It’s because I’m easily triggered as a result of childhood trauma.

I’ve never thought of myself in that way, though, and really don’t like being this way. I do my best to hide it when a friend is confiding in me about something, as obviously it isn’t about me! I can end up crying my eyes out afterwards, though.

I definitely can’t imagine making a thing about it on SM, though, that sounds very self-absorbed to me. Thankfully, it isn’t something my Facebook friends do.

IveGotASongThatllGetOnYNerves · 23/09/2021 15:46

Thinking about those people who go round saying "I'm an EMPATH" What's the difference between being an empath and being someone who has empathy that means it's something to be announced? Do they think having empathy is some superpower or something? Or that they have much more empathy than the rest of us?

GreyEyedWitch · 23/09/2021 15:41

I'm an empath but I don't go around announcing it to people or talk about my feelings when a friend is upset. In fact I really struggle to express when I'm upset to friends for my own issues for fear of how it will impact on them.

I had a difficult childhood, with a volatile parent. I think that is why I'm this way as I always had to be very good at reading their emotions to protect myself and my siblings .

Brindle88 · 23/09/2021 15:31

Yeah, I know one self-proclaimed empath who can’t stop going on about it in Facebook…

Alonelonelyloner · 23/09/2021 15:27

My probably psychotic ex (I say probably as I am not a psychiatrist nor medical professional), claimed to be an empath and also a feminist. He was also a multiple -times rapist, an attacker of his own mother, had a fondness for using broken bottles on people and broke many bones in my body. He broke into my home and also set fire to people's sheds - for fun.
Yes, he claimed to be an EMPATH. Dumb nasty fucker.

TintinIsBack · 23/09/2021 15:21

I think claiming to be ‘an empath’ with its suggestions of super- sensitivity and unusual powers of feeling is definitely a more glamorous/positive self-description that ‘Actually, I’m just not very good at regulating my emotions so that if a friend tells me about her cancer diagnosis/pregnancy loss/bereavement, I am completely overwhelmed’ or ‘I’m hyper vigilant because of an abusive past, so I register other people’s feelings to a disabling extent’.

Actually, for me, being an empath absolutely does NOT mean that.
I’m never overwhelmed when people share that sort of stuff. Partly because I tend to have a much more down to Earth approach to things. And partly because of my job (I wouldn’t be able to do it if I was getting overwhelemed and emotional each time someone is sharing news like that!).

I also do not have an abusive past at all. Quite the opposite tbh.

For me the most obvious it translate is the fact people open up to their issues wo thinking about it. In some ways, they over share (and not because I’m digging and pushing them to do so!) and wouldn’t say those things to other people.
And yes I can also tell how people are feeling but not from looking at their face expression. I can tell for example when dH is angry and he is in the garage (and I’m upstairs having a shower…..). I’m not sure WHAT is telling me what’s going on, but I can physically feel it. 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️

It seems that many people who are ‘empathy’ have issues with boundaries. Again, that has never been my issue etc….

TheHouseIsOnFire · 23/09/2021 15:08

@LemonTT

There’s nothing special about being able to read people’s emotions. We can all do it because as humans we tend to have excellent and obvious ways to signal feelings. We use our facial expressions, body language and actual language and tone to convey how we feel. People respond with varying degrees of emotional intelligence and boundaries. In reality most people are very good at it. For thousand of years it keep us alive.

I don’t dispute that narcissists or ego driven people will seek out those who lack boundaries and emotional intelligence. But these people aren’t something called empaths. They are people whose emotional and behavioural calibration is off.

Also there’s a grandiosity associated with claiming special skills. Even more so to make up a name for it. Especially when behaviour suggests you really don’t have those skills or an ability to use them. This is the narcissistic behaviour.

It empathy isn’t about reading peoples emotions. Being able to read emotions and offer support is sympathy. Empathy is to actually feel those emotions. It’s like being a sponge and you soak up the feelings around you and feel them yourself.

When my DP is stressed and recounts a story about his day, it makes me anxious and my heart beats faster. If he’s upset my throat tightens and my eyes well up. For me that’s empathy.

I’ve also read that when you subconsciously mirror other people that shows empathy, and I’ve realised that if someone else yawns I do too. If someone clears their throat I do the same. It makes me quite uncomfortable now that I’ve noticed I do it but I can’t help myself! (Have just cleared my throat writing this Grin ) so I think there’s something highly suggestible in those who declare themselves empaths. It’s almost like being a chameleon. I can have my own thing going on, but as soon as someone comes into my space with their own issue, I melt away and become an extension of them.

TheFoundations · 23/09/2021 14:51

@AnotherFruitcake

Yes, but you're only looking at half the story. Like most personality traits, there needs to be a balance. Too much either way isn't a good thing. Too much in the way you're stating isn't helpful, but you're focusing on the non-glamorous aspects, then saying that people are avoiding saying those by using the term. But there are also aspects that are helpful/useful, so saying 'I'm an empath' wouldn't be as glamorous as saying something like 'If you are untrustworthy, I'll spot it in a second, even before anybody else does', or 'If you're lying, I'll know before you do'.

Same as being selfish or kind or anything else. A label for it isn't a comparator to make it sound better or worse; it already has good and bad sides.

SoloISland · 23/09/2021 14:50

Why this obsession with labels? It is depersonalising . And as they say labels are for soup tins

BrightYellowDaffodil · 23/09/2021 14:46

I think claiming to be ‘an empath’ with its suggestions of super- sensitivity and unusual powers of feeling is definitely a more glamorous/positive self-description that ‘Actually, I’m just not very good at regulating my emotions so that if a friend tells me about her cancer diagnosis/pregnancy loss/bereavement, I am completely overwhelmed’ or ‘I’m hyper vigilant because of an abusive past, so I register other people’s feelings to a disabling extent’.

That's a very good way of describing it. I also think that 'identifying' as something, in this case as an empath, is a way of putting the issue outside of yourself and therefore not something you can be expected to do anything about. Like it's a physical trait you can't change.

AnotherFruitcake · 23/09/2021 14:22

@TheFoundations

I would say that another available (less glamorous) explanation is that they’re simply unusually poor at regulating their own emotions against stimuli

Is anybody claiming it to be glamorous in the first place?

Also, this is a bit like saying that the person who runs fastest and furthest from an attacker is the least good at dealing with attackers. A more extreme response is sometimes a better response.

I think claiming to be ‘an empath’ with its suggestions of super- sensitivity and unusual powers of feeling is definitely a more glamorous/positive self-description that ‘Actually, I’m just not very good at regulating my emotions so that if a friend tells me about her cancer diagnosis/pregnancy loss/bereavement, I am completely overwhelmed’ or ‘I’m hyper vigilant because of an abusive past, so I register other people’s feelings to a disabling extent’.
20thCenturyGhosts · 23/09/2021 14:20

Yadnbu!! I know a self proclaimed empath who manages to make everyone else's worries/concerns/problems all about them

TheFoundations · 23/09/2021 14:11

I would say that another available (less glamorous) explanation is that they’re simply unusually poor at regulating their own emotions against stimuli

Is anybody claiming it to be glamorous in the first place?

Also, this is a bit like saying that the person who runs fastest and furthest from an attacker is the least good at dealing with attackers. A more extreme response is sometimes a better response.

EmotionalSupportBear · 23/09/2021 14:10

@Angrymum22

A term I saw used on MN for an empath was ‘a grief thief’. Someone who claims to be as bereaved as the close relatives in order to gain attention in rl and online. It is really uncomfortable to see it in action. I’ve recently been diagnosed with cancer and have deliberately not told the family members who would use it to gain attention for themselves. In fact I told very few people because the go to reaction is sympathy which suggests they are already working out what to wear at your funeral. Empathy is spontaneous and uncontrollable. It is a knee jerk reaction to a situation. It is not about feeling someone’s pain but all about being unable to take that pain away.
This isn't empathy, this is nothing about what being an 'empath' is.

Everyone has empathy, its a natural occurence.

However, an 'empath' as such, is supposed to be someone who simply is able to sense emotion in someone on a very deep level.. its mostly simply a very high sensitivity to body language and speech tone that allows you to 'read' the mood the person is in.. some are able to take it to a further level and be able to help that person through any negative emotions with talking, comfort, friendship/councelling...etc.

A Narc will make it ALL about them.. these people aren't empaths, they're emotional vampires who just want to latch onto peoples sadness and grief.

A proper Empath will simply help someone in distress, give them a hug, then carry on with their day and find some other way to ground out any negative emotions they absorbed while they were helping the person without anyone else even being aware they took some of it into themselves.

TheFoundations · 23/09/2021 14:04

how a self-proclaimed ‘empath’ knows they are more empathic than other people — after all, how would you calculate that, given that there’s no scale against which varying degrees of empathy can be measured

I've wondered that. I was told by a counsellor, who has lots of experience of dealing with lots of people's inner feelings, so I suppose someone in that position would have more of an overview of the spectrum. Wouldn't have thought it up on my own though.