Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you be off sick if you weren't being paid?

284 replies

MakeMineALarge1 · 22/09/2021 10:11

I work for the NHS, the sick package is very good, full pay for 6 months then half pay for another 6.

I know that its very stressful at the moment in acute care, sickness in our department is currently at 30% with up to 6 members of staff off per shift.

Lots of people citing stress etc, needing time out, and this is granted on full pay.

If you were self employed or hourly paid, would as people still be off with stress and still need "time out"

It seems a lot of threads on here start with "my anxiety" or I have PTSD or I am depressed. Is it too easy nowadays to ring your GP and be signed off on this basis?

OP posts:
Talktalkchat · 22/09/2021 12:40

I was just about to start a thread about this.

The nhs sick pay is a joke.

ElephantOfRisk · 22/09/2021 12:37

@sst1234

One of the reasons NHS struggles is because of the higher the average sick leave NHS staff take. You could argue that it’s because they are under pressure so more likely to get sick, but then it comes back to the fact that so many people abuse the policy that the organization is likely to be under pressure. And the so the cycle continues
True for some people but you are more likely to pick up illnesses dealing with sick people and also get injuries when dealing with patients that are increasingly overweight, dealing with dying or depressed people constantly. Facing abuse and violence and yes, covering for absent colleagues plus being on constant overtime all takes it toll.
LODReturn · 22/09/2021 12:36

It's a difficult one. Some people do abuse the sick pay scheme & some GP's will sign off people on the basis that a patient tells them they are too ill to work. I work in HR and have seen it all over the years including telling people they can't come back to work just because their sick pay has run out if they are not well enough.

Mental health is the new bad back - subjective and difficult to prove one way or the other. My big concern is that those who claim mental health issues when they are not genuine make it more difficult for those who do have issues. This can make genuine cases reluctant to come forward and get the right support which is a big problem as the earlier we can support people, the easier it is to help them get better.

Whoopy1 · 22/09/2021 12:35

My sil worked for local council, which has sick leave similar to nhs. She was off all week with sinusitis, but come the Friday she felt much better! She went to her bfs on the Friday night. Out for a Chinese, went away for the day on the Saturday, out for lunch on the Sunday. Sunday night she came home to her parents, saying she wasn’t feeling great. Mil just said to her that she should phone work in the morning and tell them she still wasn’t well, which is what she did. Even got gp to write her a week’s sick line! Would she have been off if she wasn’t getting paid? Would she hell!!

I also had a colleague (nhs). When we had works nights out, which were usually on a Friday, if she was due to work the weekend she was absolutely always off sick! Everyone knew she had a hangover, but nothing was ever done and she was always paid.

I also had another colleague, when I worked bank shifts for a community alarm system, who took the piss as well. Once was when I was called in with less than an hour to spare to work the night shift as colleague due to do shift had just phoned in sick. I didn’t want to do shift but the back shift would have had to stay on till morning if I hadn’t. My sister was out at a concert that night and then on to a nightclub. Who did she run into but…..yes, colleague who was off sick! I did report her and offered my boss phone numbers of 3 people who had seen her. Did my boss do anything? No, she didn’t even speak to her about it and she was paid for the full shift at the enhanced rate.

sst1234 · 22/09/2021 12:29

One of the reasons NHS struggles is because of the higher the average sick leave NHS staff take. You could argue that it’s because they are under pressure so more likely to get sick, but then it comes back to the fact that so many people abuse the policy that the organization is likely to be under pressure. And the so the cycle continues

ElephantOfRisk · 22/09/2021 12:28

I'm not NHs but have a similar sick leave policy. I've worked for 38 years in various companies with similar (as far as I know) I've nery rarely been off.

However, i've just had 5 months off with stress and no, i couldn't have worked even if I wasn't being paid. Even though the GP was nothing but helpful, even calling and having to deal with that on a regular basis (to renew sick note) was really hard. I'm on a phased return now but finding it hard so using my holidays to extend it a bit.

Do some people swing the lead? I would say that's highly probable. Are a lot of people burnt out and cant cope anymore? Also highly probable.

Woeismethischristmas · 22/09/2021 12:21

I’m signed off at the moment and only getting Ssp and only till the end of the month. Joys of agency work.don’t think I’ll be better though have been referred to an neuro for a consultation. Tested to the max ct scan, lumbar puncture, mri and bloods. They think it’s migraines with neurological deficiencies or early stages of autoimmune disease. I have another job lined up but the medication makes me drowsy/ woozy. I’m thinking about offering to work a couple of days for them but I don’t know if I can physically manage or I’ll end up exhausted and rehospitalised. Can’t afford not to work though so it’s a real catch 22. Wish I had a decent sickness scheme!

daisypond · 22/09/2021 12:20

Continuing Heathcare Funding is more about getting your care paid for, nothing to do with sick pay, I thought.

MatildaTheCat · 22/09/2021 12:19

@FateHasRedesignedMost has described my experience. I worked in the nhs for a very long time with an exemplary sickness and absence record. Then I was injured and needed surgery then more surgery. My absence was monitored more and more aggressively until I was dismissed after 11 months.

There were undoubtedly a minority of people who played the system and knew exactly how much they could get away with without triggering an hr meeting. Some viewed sickness and emergency leave as part of the annual entitlement to time off. Everyone knew who they were.

DH runs a private sector business who pay full salary to those unwell but in 30 years has never had any issues with piss taking. Maybe he’s been lucky but it’s very noticeably different.

toconclude · 22/09/2021 12:14

@bloodywhitecat

DH has cancer, he doesn't get sick pay but he has had no choice but to take days off for chemo and surgery. Not being paid at a time when he has a terminal diagnosis has made life very difficult indeed.
I may be telling you something you already know, in which case apologies, but it may be worth looking into Continuing Health Care funding?
SpiderinaWingMirror · 22/09/2021 12:12

I'm off sick currently without pay.

Babyroobs · 22/09/2021 12:11

In my experience of working in the NHS, people absolutely take advantage of the six months fully paid. There is no way people people would take time off otherwise. I worked in the new Zealand NHS equivalent for four years and for the first five sick days you got no pay at all.

BiBabbles · 22/09/2021 12:11

I'm not sure why you're connecting the frequency of people posting discussing those conditions with the idea that GPs easily give sick notes. Lots of people with those conditions work and people without them can end up off sick with stress. There isn't much relationship there.

Yes, with good sick pay, some will take the piss and it can be hard to deal, some will be more likely to take sick leave than they would otherwise but they are still managing that as responsibly as they can and there will still be those who work when they really shouldn't.

I can see why some would want better ways to deal with the first group, but many are more concerned that there are so many who have no option but to be in that group even when they aren't self employed. It's put people at risk and contributes to the high under and unemployment of disabled people.

Personally, it would have been better for me to be able to have significant sick leave to recover than what actually happened was having to leave and watch my career go down in flames and watching myself go out of date. That in some ways made rebuilding back up healthwise harder being in the rut that's common for many that go through that. You can end up feeling like it doesn't matter if you get well enough again. I'm in the midst of a flare up, I'm having a lot of muscle weakness this week, and it has fucked with my moods as I struggle not to get pulled under by the feeling I'll never 'properly' work again.

MattDillonsEyebrows · 22/09/2021 12:11

I sent 20 years working in a 'public sector well paid sick pay job'. Whilst most people were honest, there were definitely a lot who took the piss, literally taking the maximum they could, until they stopped being paid and then they seemed to get better.

In one job, I remember a person saying "I've used all my holiday, but I've still got my sick to take"

I think the difficult thing is that Mental health is very subjective, so it's really hard to prove and very easy assume someone is faking or exaggerating.

Physical health issues tend to have a one size fits all recovery plan. eg if you break a bone, you pop in plaster until its healed, some people might need a resetting or a longer healing time, but on the whole you can see it happening.

With mental health everyones trigger is different, which makes it impossible to treat universally and therefore impossible to judge how to help.

I really hope I've not come across as dismissing MH issues with these comments as I know first hand how traumatic and debilitating it can be, so that is not the intention. But with everyone always talking about how bad mental health services are, (playing devices advocate slightly here) is it even possible to actually provide the services when everyones mental health is so different?

ddl1 · 22/09/2021 12:11

No, I'm not off sick, and would only be so if I really couldn't go in.

If you were self employed or hourly paid, would as people still be off with stress and still need "time out"

Yes, I'm sure they would. It might not be so obvious, as you don't need an excuse note for your boss if your boss is yourself!

It seems a lot of threads on here start with "my anxiety" or I have PTSD or I am depressed. Is it too easy nowadays to ring your GP and be signed off on this basis?

No, it's not easy at all; and not everyone with anxiety or PTSD is off work in any case! I think that what is happening is that the pandemic has (a) caused a lot of anxiety and PTSD; (b) means that some (unfortunately not all) workplaces are more willing to allow time off with physical illnesses, so as to prevent possible spread of Covid. I am sure that some people do take advantage of the latter and invent excuses - 'I was pinged'; 'I had a cough and thought it might be Covid' - but better than coming to work when ill and giving everyone else Covid or even 'just' flu.

Gonnagetgoing · 22/09/2021 12:10

I currently am in a contract where I get paid full sick pay.

However, I have been in contracts through employment agencies where you got nothing at all, just SSP and even that I think kicks in after 7 days being off sick, so I rarely took a day off sick, unless very ill, but I did save up a bank of money for this very purpose.

I've also worked in companies though where you do get paid full sick pay, in fact one company (large accountants) they treated their sick pay allowance (approx 10 days or similar) almost like holiday pay and used it up. They were really annoyed when it got reduced from more days to less as they thought they were entitled to it! I also worked in a company a long time ago where I was very depressed for 6 months or so and took the time off (about a day a week maybe less) as sick. But my manager and other staff knew about this and in fact when I asked the office manager re my HR sickness records (small/medium company) she told me there was nothing there (I'd worked there 6 years) to flag up I was taking off more sick days than I was allowed.

Even now, when I get paid full sick pay, I'd only take it off if I was really properly sick, vomiting etc or couldn't work due to aches/pains of a bad cold/flu.

daisypond · 22/09/2021 12:07

@KingsleyShacklebolt
I agree with you. Businesses can’t handle having people absent for a long term, even if they’re only getting SSP. I was just saying it’s very sad.

StinkingCold · 22/09/2021 12:06

Feeling like I do today - yes I would! I feel awful and very sorry for myself !! 🤧🤒🤧🤒

HalzTangz · 22/09/2021 12:03

In answer to your question, if I was sick enough that I couldn't operate my laptop to do my office based job (which I'm currently doing WFH) then yes I would take sick leave.

If I just had a cold but was based in the office I would request WFH rather than sick leave

KingsleyShacklebolt · 22/09/2021 11:59

@daisypond

Genuine long-term sickness would get you dismissed at my workplace. I’ve seen it happen several times. It’s very sad.
But how else do you expect businesses to handle it? Sometimes, an employee develops some sort of illness which means they will never be able to return to work. Or that even with adjustments, they won't be able to work. Should they just stay on the sick forever?
Wadewilson · 22/09/2021 11:56

@PoorCatto it isn't weakness, please don't think of it like that.
I know exactly what you mean about how work will see it though.

WaterAndRichTea · 22/09/2021 11:54

Im not surprised people who work for the NHS , Need time out.

Dont blame them at all

PoorCatto · 22/09/2021 11:53

I work in the NHS. I currently should be off with mental health concerns but as my department is currently under restructure and I'm hoping to progress up a band in the next year or two I can't afford to show the weakness. There are groups within my department with appalling sickness records and it's demoralising how they abuse the system whilst the rest of us work so hard to keep going.

HadEnough798 · 22/09/2021 11:52

I'm self-employed - as a result never ever off sick during a contract -

I've also pushed myself to the edge of a nervous breakdown and severe burnout twice because of that feeling that you can never take time off... was then unable to work as a result (totally unpaid as am self-employed) for 6 months.

There's probably a balance to be struck but I think it's actually a good think that people can say 'do you know what, I'm really struggling'.

EnidFrighten · 22/09/2021 11:49

This is a daft question. You're basically asking 'would you take time off if it was to your financial detriment?' (more than it is already as sick pay is lower than usual pay)

The answer to that would depend on someone's financial situation, job security, and how sick they are. The reason we have sick pay is because you need to rest when you're sick, even if you are poor.