Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you be off sick if you weren't being paid?

284 replies

MakeMineALarge1 · 22/09/2021 10:11

I work for the NHS, the sick package is very good, full pay for 6 months then half pay for another 6.

I know that its very stressful at the moment in acute care, sickness in our department is currently at 30% with up to 6 members of staff off per shift.

Lots of people citing stress etc, needing time out, and this is granted on full pay.

If you were self employed or hourly paid, would as people still be off with stress and still need "time out"

It seems a lot of threads on here start with "my anxiety" or I have PTSD or I am depressed. Is it too easy nowadays to ring your GP and be signed off on this basis?

OP posts:
Shehasadiamondinthesky · 22/09/2021 13:22

At the moment I have no choice as my back has given out.
But I don't go off sick as a rule. Some people are genuine but others just take the piss all of the time.

NamechangeApril21 · 22/09/2021 13:21

Some of the stigma driven comments about mental health on this thread are vile.

Coldilox · 22/09/2021 13:21

Decent sick pay should be normalised, not vilified.

I have 6 months full pay and 6 months half pay. Most people I know will not take sick leave unless completely unavoidable.

I’ve taken some time off for mental health issues. My GP wanted to sign me off sooner but I refused. Eventually I agreed. Had there not been sick pay, no I probably wouldn’t have taken the time off, as I couldn’t have afforded it. But there is a good chance had I not taken time off to get better I wouldn’t be here now. I was having suicidal thoughts at the time.

Nobody should be in the position where they can’t afford to be ill.

RavingAnnie · 22/09/2021 13:21

Having worked with people who work in the NHS if you didn't have the sick leave you have people would just be leaving in droves (more than they are already!)

It's not simply the very difficult emotionally and physically draining work many people in the NHS do, but there seems to also be a horribly toxic culture with expectations on staff not to take breaks, or look after themselves in any way. I have heard many stories of staff being screamed and shouted at by their "managers"; disabled staff not being being given equipment they need to do their job, and other reasonable adjustments being ignored. Others having their health conditions or disabilities disregarded and just being told to get on with their job or similar.

So it doesn't surprise me at all that lots of people are going off on long term sick leave. It sounds horrifically stressful.

Badabingbadabum · 22/09/2021 13:21

I work in the civil service so also very good sick pay the same as in the OP. I didn't get to the point where my pay was reduced but I did have to go under a sick pay performance review period for six months. Any sick time off in that was result in an extended period with performance management. I needed the time off as I did have 'depression and anxiety'; I tried to take my own life so no, the time off wasn't because I felt a little glum. I worked through some pretty awful migraines during that review period and would have done the same if affected my pay.

Unfortunarely I have also worked with people who have been on half pay and then unpaid sick leave while they were having treatment for cancer. Sometimes being off sick cannot be avoided, no matter what your pay policy is.

BrilloPaddy · 22/09/2021 13:20

I used to work in the civil service and you were allowed up to 21 days a year paid self certificated sick leave... so everyone just added the 21 days onto their annual leave entitlement.

DH and I run a small business, and any absence means that the whole place almost grinds to a halt. They're all specialist craftspeople and one cog out the wheel means it's a nightmare. Hence we pay for sick leave at our discretion....... if it means someone stays home with a streaming cold or Norovirus, then we all benefit. We've also given paid leave for bereavement etc.

MH issues are considered along with medical evidence.

ElephantOfRisk · 22/09/2021 13:15

That’s a sickness review rather then a disciplinary?

What are the companies P&P and with it being a workplace injury were HSE informed?

It counts as a warning, can't remember if it's verbal or written.

It was a crash where someone crashed into them and was attended by ambulance, they had an injury which felt better but when they returned to their physical job, it hadn't healed enough,

JudgeJ · 22/09/2021 13:13

@debucnik

I would go one further and say yes people with sick pay take more sick leave. I know I've dragged myself to work many a time when physically or mentally unwell because I simply cany afford to not get paid.
I think that's so true, I recall many years ago, the first day back in school after the Summer holidays, we found out that one teacher, who only ever dealt with three or four pupils at a time, was going to be off until at least half term with stress. It was surprising, once the caravan sites opened, how many were 'ill' on Friday and/or Monday.
Talktalkchat · 22/09/2021 13:11

@Cinderss

I worked somewhere with 6 months paid sick pay and people absolutely took the mick with getting signed off. Everywhere I’ve worked since offers no paid sick pay and it’s completely different coming in and not having to cover everyone’s sick leave all the time. On the negative side though people come in with all sorts of illnesses and spread them around!
Yep being of with a cold should be jormalised
ElephantOfRisk · 22/09/2021 13:11

I was never offered any drugs @Phyllis321, i'm glad that they've helped. I actually would have been back earlier but my bosses just couldn't get their act together. I had to wait weeks for an occ health appointment and then more weeks for them to devise a return to work programme. I've been back 2 weeks and i still haven't been given any work but then I've only managed to get logged on for a few hours. Most of my time has been spent waiting in the queue for IT, speaking to IT or waiting for IT to call me. It's not great as IT issues were part of my stressers. Anyway, now going to use up holidays to stretch out the plan i agreed as I've not really been working yet and I'm back to full time the week after next.

Cinderss · 22/09/2021 13:10

I worked somewhere with 6 months paid sick pay and people absolutely took the mick with getting signed off. Everywhere I’ve worked since offers no paid sick pay and it’s completely different coming in and not having to cover everyone’s sick leave all the time. On the negative side though people come in with all sorts of illnesses and spread them around!

Talktalkchat · 22/09/2021 13:09

@ElephantOfRisk

I think the 3 absences and then disciplinary is counter productive though.

A colleague had had 1 day off with a stomach bug in about February. In November he was injured at work, he was off for a couple of weeks with a shoulder and back injury but wanted to get back so returned to work and realised within a few days that he really wasn't healed enough and then faced a disciplinary meeting when he came back. There was no question that he was not swinging the lead or faking, So if he was off again, he might be tempted to stay off beyond when he felt able to return to ensure that it was only one period of sickness

That’s a sickness review rather then a disciplinary?

What are the companies P&P and with it being a workplace injury were HSE informed?

LastGirlSanding · 22/09/2021 13:08

Been self-employed and employed and have taken time off both times with mental health issues. Was way way worse as self-employed because I kept going too long for fear of not earning enough and when off could not focus enough on recovering because each day felt like I was failing to provide which made my mental health worse. Been off in my sick pay job a couple of times, way shorter, faster recovery because I could tend to myself without that extra stress and go off ill earlier before it got too bad. I’m a more effective employee for it, and highly loyal to the understanding company I work for who ensure my wellbeing is looked after. My last annual appraisal I was assessed as outstanding, despite the pesky MH sick days. Grin

As to if it’s ‘too easy’ to get signed off with mental health - well frankly it’s the sort of thing people can claim to have when they don’t, much like back pain etc used to be. Doesn’t mean it’s not incredibly common and debilitating.

What exactly is your problem with peope having sick pay with mental health as a reason, if you have one ( which it sounds like you do based on your post). And what is your solution to this issue OP? What do you think should happen to people with sick pay who go off with mental health issues? Since you’ve been asking the questions it would be nice to get your views.

PinkiOcelot · 22/09/2021 13:07

I work in the NHS. It’s amazing how some people make a miraculous recovery after 6 months sick when they’re due to go on half pay.

Phyllis321 · 22/09/2021 13:01

I thought about it every day, Elephant.
Thank god for fluoxetine..

Beseen22 · 22/09/2021 13:00

One of the hardest working people i know went into a patients room who had hung themselves in the bathroom with absolutey no risk factors that would have indicated it. She cut him down, resuscitated him, got him up to ICU. Contacted family and explained what happened. Came back down and cleared all the room and an hour later another sick patient (along with another 6 who were already allocated to her) was in the bed ready for her to take care of. She called in sick with anxiety and was off for a week, she didn't sleep for 36 hours following the trauma. Yet she's off for her 'anxiety' so maybe other people might assume its subjective and she's just chilling at home.

Healthcare workers are working in an environment that the majority of the public cannot comprehend being in every day for 40 years. We see crazy, horrible, traumatic things all day every day. Working in such a pressured traumatic environment can cause burnout. Burnout which makes you double at risk to have a medication error and 17%more likely to be named in a malpractice suit. And that's ignoring the stuff that goes unreported. And contributing to the high suicide rates amongst healthcare workers. All this was going on long before covid and the strain has only just become worse. 1 in 5 ICU nurses recently surveyed admitted to thoughts of self harm or suicide.

There will always be pisstakers but that would be a particularly poor reason to penalise those who really need the support of a bit of time off to be able to function.

Viviennemary · 22/09/2021 12:59

So many people take advantage of over generous sick pay schemes. And it's their colleagues who usually have to work twice as hard when those skivers are off 'sick' yet again.

ElephantOfRisk · 22/09/2021 12:58

@Phyllis321

I was off for a month with acute stress earlier this year. I’ve never felt more physically as well as mentally ill. I lost almost a stone as I couldn’t swallow properly, and lived on the brink of a panic attack for weeks. It was hideous. ‘Anxiety and depression’ can be crippling, even deadly.
It's awful isn't it? I hope you are feeling better now. There is also the guilt you feel for your colleagues as well but I learned from counselling that it's not my fault that I was ill.

I've now read the email i sent to management on the day I just couldn't do it anymore and i'd added "don't worry i'm not going to harm myself" but actually I thought about it a lot.

ElephantOfRisk · 22/09/2021 12:54

I think the 3 absences and then disciplinary is counter productive though.

A colleague had had 1 day off with a stomach bug in about February. In November he was injured at work, he was off for a couple of weeks with a shoulder and back injury but wanted to get back so returned to work and realised within a few days that he really wasn't healed enough and then faced a disciplinary meeting when he came back. There was no question that he was not swinging the lead or faking, So if he was off again, he might be tempted to stay off beyond when he felt able to return to ensure that it was only one period of sickness

Phyllis321 · 22/09/2021 12:54

I was off for a month with acute stress earlier this year. I’ve never felt more physically as well as mentally ill. I lost almost a stone as I couldn’t swallow properly, and lived on the brink of a panic attack for weeks. It was hideous.
‘Anxiety and depression’ can be crippling, even deadly.

Yummymummy2020 · 22/09/2021 12:54

Back before I worked in healthcare, I had no choice but to go to work as there was no sick package. This was done by pretty much all staff if you wanted food on your table and bills paid, the pay was awful anyway as it was a retail job. The issue was, there was an occasion where I was genuinely unwell (nothing contagious, long term heart issues) and still went to work over fear of being short of money. Long story short I ended up in hospital and I do believe it was that I over did things (Christmas rush so store was packed and we were run off our feet). So although some people take advantage I do think some people genuinely almost kill themselves going in when they need a letter to sign them off but won’t get it for this reason. Looking back I was a fool but it’s definitely easy for me to say now that I’m in a job that pays you in full for sick leave.

GalaxyPostcard · 22/09/2021 12:51

No one should have to drag themselves to work if they feel awful. I think it's great that the NHS pays sick leave so well especially given the nature of the job.

I am self employed and have chronic illnesses and definitely push myself too far a great deal because I can't afford to not work. Doesn't mean it's right though!

frazzledasarock · 22/09/2021 12:50

I've never taken time off sick unless very sick. I think the last time I was off sick properly was about seven years ago, I was incredibly unwell with a possible cancer diagnosis. Was horrific and scary.

I don't think in general our team does. I sometimes have told people telling me they're coming in because they only have the plague, to stay home.

I've not actually known anyone who has taken time off without being properly unwell. At one point I could have taken time off due to stress, my GP wanted to sign me off and I refused.

If anything I think people tend to go into work when they really really shouldn't. Which annoys me as I really don't want their lurgy.

ElephantOfRisk · 22/09/2021 12:46

In the realms of things that are a joke, i'd maybe start with Politicians getting a full pension after serving only one term in office.

ElephantOfRisk · 22/09/2021 12:45

for me it wasn't easy being off. The worst of my physical symptoms (heart palpitations, panic attacks, struggling to breath and swallow food) started to ease off after about 2 months but thinking of work would trigger things again. I got some counselling to help manage things better which helped but i found the sheer amount of things that needed to be managed to remain off e.g contact with GP, Occupational health, counselling, meetings with management etc. pretty overwhelming in themselves so it's not a jolly holiday. Some days i'd be completely frozen and unable to engage in anything, others I'd be restless and pace the house constantly. I can see now though that if I wanted to be off again in the future, I would know how to get time off even if I wasn't ill. So I guess it might be a temptation for some.