Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you be off sick if you weren't being paid?

284 replies

MakeMineALarge1 · 22/09/2021 10:11

I work for the NHS, the sick package is very good, full pay for 6 months then half pay for another 6.

I know that its very stressful at the moment in acute care, sickness in our department is currently at 30% with up to 6 members of staff off per shift.

Lots of people citing stress etc, needing time out, and this is granted on full pay.

If you were self employed or hourly paid, would as people still be off with stress and still need "time out"

It seems a lot of threads on here start with "my anxiety" or I have PTSD or I am depressed. Is it too easy nowadays to ring your GP and be signed off on this basis?

OP posts:
Phyllis321 · 22/09/2021 14:04

Good luck Elephant. You’ll get there. Take it slowly and don’t expect things to go perfectly.

ElephantOfRisk · 22/09/2021 14:03

toe

ElephantOfRisk · 22/09/2021 14:03

Yep, I agree @Sunshineonmars.

Obviously flexible arrangements are not open to everyone and some employers don't want to risk an employment tribunal if they've allowed someone to work who wasn't fit.

DH once had an op on his tow which meant he wasn't allowed to wear steel toe cap boots for a while and he wasn't allowed to do his job unless wearing them. he was otherwise fine and asked if there were any light duties he could do and was told no. So he was off whilst able to work, albeit not in his normal job.

FAD2016 · 22/09/2021 14:03

In the same way that everyone knows a single mum who is living in luxury on benefits, or is mates with someone who drives a BMW cos they are working cash in hand whilst on JSA, everyone knows someone who uses paid sick leave to supplement their annual leave allowance. Even when you really do know people who manage to screw over the system that does not mean that everyone with access to decent TACOS is cheating.
Do we really want nurses and doctors sniffing and coughing over patients, rushing to the loo with D&V etc. Issuing medication when they are not mentally well? The conversation should be about improved TACOS for those who don’t get paid, not a race to the bottom

TheRebelle · 22/09/2021 14:03

I have had to take unpaid sick leave before because I was so ill I physically couldn’t get out of bed, if I was taking sick leave for stress or similar I’d be using the time to find a less stressful job.

CharityDingle · 22/09/2021 14:02

Worked for an employer who had a good sick pay scheme, for which I was very grateful indeed, when I became ill. I was not physically or mentally able to continue to go to work, at that time.

There may have been employees who abused the scheme, I don't know. Anyone I knew who availed of it, including me, was completely genuine.

Sunshineonmars · 22/09/2021 13:54

@ElephantOfRisk

I am self employed if I am feeling unwell I can structure my work, do half a day and try to work around the illness to get the work done. An employer often won't do that and there is no incentive for an employee to volunteer to work in that way.

For some employed people that is possible to an extent as well. If I had an upset stomach or just a bit below par or coughing and sneezing, i would ask to work from home where i'm not spreading germs and have easy access to the toilet if required. Something like a migraine I couldn't work with but to be honest other than two broken arms or mental health, i would work as much as possible.

I am relating this to my own experience of employers. I used to work for a local authority that had the same sickness benefits as the op. The option to work from home was not on the table and if you were daft enough to go in, you would either be expected to carry on as normal, after all if you were well enough to attend ? Or you would be sent home if you looked sick enough. Its the attitude to sickness that needs to change, its very much geared to clamping down on malingerers, not seeing how we can help people get back to work. ( despite what the policies and HR say)
SlidDownTheElephantsTrunk · 22/09/2021 13:54

I work for a LA. Very good sickness benefits. We had a high level of sickness (15 years ago) in my team. We work shifts in a highly stressful and emotional professional role. We introduced short notice AL for days when you just can't face coming to work but you aren't sick - if we can cover it, you can have the day off.

Worked a treat. Hardly have any sickness now.

Etonmessisyum · 22/09/2021 13:53

I’ve been off sick from my nhs nurse job since last year, so well into 6mo half pay. (Not all of it was sick since then) but wasn’t then, and still not physically fit for work. Currently waiting on 2 consultant appointments that are taking a long time. In a lot of pain. And worried my pay is going to stop soon and I’m going to lose my job. No def wouldn’t be doing this for fun. I’m hoping one of my issues won’t end my career but I don’t know and I also don’t know how i’ll pay the bills in a few months. I wouldn’t have been able to work even if I didn’t have 6mo full pay/half pay. It did help at the time but I’d no idea I’d be off this long and things would get so much worse. It’s not a nice position to be in.

NursieBernard · 22/09/2021 13:52

In answer to your question, yes I would be off sick if I didn't get paid. I have been working for the NHS for 8 + plus years and in that time I have had 1 sickness period of 1 month after a bereavement. I would have taken the leave unpaid if necessary as I was not fit for work.

Please look at updating your mental health training which will hopefully adjust your attitude towards those suffering with poor mental health.

ElephantOfRisk · 22/09/2021 13:50

I'd also have had to be off paid or otherwise, but not being paid adds even more stress. I was asked if I wanted to apply for Income Replacement via a policy that my company has, it would have paid me half pay until whenever I returned, retired or died. If I wanted to I could have really taken the piss.

Peaplant20 · 22/09/2021 13:48

Less people would call in sick but I’m not sure why that’s necessarily a good thing? Dragging yourself to work when you’re not well and then infecting other people or working at half capacity until you’re better when you could have taken a day off and been back to work the next day.

ElephantOfRisk · 22/09/2021 13:48

To be honest all these stories of people being off work for months with stress, especially work related stress seems a bit over the top in some cases. What exactly is going to be different when they get back?

Well in my case they've abandoned the new work practice they were introducing, advertised for more staff, brought in temporary contractors, reduced the amount of work required. That wasn't just down to me though, 4 people resigned and I was off sick all from a team of 12.

I couldn't have worked other than the last couple of weeks where I was wanting to return but they didn't want me back it seems as there were delays from their side not mine.

I'm glad that the odd day works for you, but it wouldn't have for me. I needed the time to get my body as well as my head, on an even keel.

bluetongue · 22/09/2021 13:43

@Shehasadiamondinthesky

Mental health doesn't have to mean you are always off sick. I have complex trauma with depression and anxiety and have had for 50 years. I work in the NHS. With the right medication and the support of my manager I have not had a day off in the last three years. If someone is off sick all of the time then are not receiving the appropriate treatment and this needs to be dealt with. My employer is not paying me a salary to be off sick with my mental health all of the time. i also have a responsibility to be fit for work.
Exactly. I’m on anti depressants long term for depression and anxiety but have very few sick days. Plenty of others in my department take the piss all the time and being civil service it seems to be nearly impossible t get rid of them. Even the one at the moment who is off more than she is in and is pretty much a self confessed skiver.
nomoneytreehere · 22/09/2021 13:43

Yes of course. Sick pay is a benefit that means I don't need to go to work.

Thehop · 22/09/2021 13:43

People that don’t get sick pay don’t take time off unless they’re very very ill. You’re absolutely right. My husband and I have this argument all the time.

He gets sick pay I don’t

bluetongue · 22/09/2021 13:40

@LODReturn

It's a difficult one. Some people do abuse the sick pay scheme & some GP's will sign off people on the basis that a patient tells them they are too ill to work. I work in HR and have seen it all over the years including telling people they can't come back to work just because their sick pay has run out if they are not well enough.

Mental health is the new bad back - subjective and difficult to prove one way or the other. My big concern is that those who claim mental health issues when they are not genuine make it more difficult for those who do have issues. This can make genuine cases reluctant to come forward and get the right support which is a big problem as the earlier we can support people, the easier it is to help them get better.

I do have a history of genuine long term mental health issues. I’ve been very reluctant to take time off because of it. To be honest all these stories of people being off work for months with stress, especially work related stress seems a bit over the top in some cases. What exactly is going to be different when they get back?

There have been occasions when I’ve taken a mental health day because I’m emotionally exhausted or can’t stop crying but I get back to work as soon as I can.

RobinPenguins · 22/09/2021 13:40

I was signed off for 6 weeks last year. Honestly, the state I was in, I’d have done it unpaid. I couldn’t function.

I’ve had individual days off sick before for e.g. a heavy cold that if I wasn’t going to paid I’d probably have struggled in.

Thatusernamewastaken · 22/09/2021 13:39

I work 2 jobs. One has 6 months full pay, 6 months half. The other job doesn’t pay sick.
Am far more flexible and willing with the one that pays sick. Will work odd hours at busy times to get stuff done. The other job I will do my hours and no more. Even when they are begging me to pick up more shifts. Nope.
I understand why some employers don’t want to pay sick but they can’t really expect much of their staff if they don’t.

ElephantOfRisk · 22/09/2021 13:36

I am self employed if I am feeling unwell I can structure my work, do half a day and try to work around the illness to get the work done. An employer often won't do that and there is no incentive for an employee to volunteer to work in that way.

For some employed people that is possible to an extent as well. If I had an upset stomach or just a bit below par or coughing and sneezing, i would ask to work from home where i'm not spreading germs and have easy access to the toilet if required. Something like a migraine I couldn't work with but to be honest other than two broken arms or mental health, i would work as much as possible.

TractorAndHeadphones · 22/09/2021 13:32

@Beseen22

One of the hardest working people i know went into a patients room who had hung themselves in the bathroom with absolutey no risk factors that would have indicated it. She cut him down, resuscitated him, got him up to ICU. Contacted family and explained what happened. Came back down and cleared all the room and an hour later another sick patient (along with another 6 who were already allocated to her) was in the bed ready for her to take care of. She called in sick with anxiety and was off for a week, she didn't sleep for 36 hours following the trauma. Yet she's off for her 'anxiety' so maybe other people might assume its subjective and she's just chilling at home.

Healthcare workers are working in an environment that the majority of the public cannot comprehend being in every day for 40 years. We see crazy, horrible, traumatic things all day every day. Working in such a pressured traumatic environment can cause burnout. Burnout which makes you double at risk to have a medication error and 17%more likely to be named in a malpractice suit. And that's ignoring the stuff that goes unreported. And contributing to the high suicide rates amongst healthcare workers. All this was going on long before covid and the strain has only just become worse. 1 in 5 ICU nurses recently surveyed admitted to thoughts of self harm or suicide.

There will always be pisstakers but that would be a particularly poor reason to penalise those who really need the support of a bit of time off to be able to function.

All of this is very true - but only for healthcare professionals. Maybeeeeee some front liners who see horrible things but that’s about it.

‘Work for the NHS’ conveys zero information as to what category of staff OP is.

Filthycop · 22/09/2021 13:31

I think it should be the other way round and we should be looking at the people who aren't paid should be and should be supported.

People are struggling into work when they are not well because they can't afford to be off sick - whether this is mental health or physical health. I affects performance and can cost more in the long run.

caringcarer · 22/09/2021 13:28

In an.ideal world everyone would be paid full pay however long they were sick but in reality if a person is off sick a replacement has to be paid for as well as the person on sick leave. A huge amount of public money goes on paying extremely generous sick payments. I think all employers both public and private sector should offer at least 4 week fully paid per year. I think 6 months on full pay then 6 months on half pay is too generous. When I was teaching I was on this generous package. I think 3 months full pay followed by 1 month 1/2 pay is more than generous. There are other payment options such as PIP available for people with MH issues affecting their ability to work.

Sunshineonmars · 22/09/2021 13:26

I think sometimes the difference is the flexibility of self employment, over working for an employer.
I am self employed if I am feeling unwell I can structure my work, do half a day and try to work around the illness to get the work done. An employer often won't do that and there is no incentive for an employee to volunteer to work in that way.

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 22/09/2021 13:25

Mental health doesn't have to mean you are always off sick. I have complex trauma with depression and anxiety and have had for 50 years. I work in the NHS. With the right medication and the support of my manager I have not had a day off in the last three years.
If someone is off sick all of the time then are not receiving the appropriate treatment and this needs to be dealt with.
My employer is not paying me a salary to be off sick with my mental health all of the time. i also have a responsibility to be fit for work.

Swipe left for the next trending thread