Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you be off sick if you weren't being paid?

284 replies

MakeMineALarge1 · 22/09/2021 10:11

I work for the NHS, the sick package is very good, full pay for 6 months then half pay for another 6.

I know that its very stressful at the moment in acute care, sickness in our department is currently at 30% with up to 6 members of staff off per shift.

Lots of people citing stress etc, needing time out, and this is granted on full pay.

If you were self employed or hourly paid, would as people still be off with stress and still need "time out"

It seems a lot of threads on here start with "my anxiety" or I have PTSD or I am depressed. Is it too easy nowadays to ring your GP and be signed off on this basis?

OP posts:
Gorl · 22/09/2021 11:01

People who don’t get sick pay probably do take less time off, but that’s not a good thing. People should be able to take time off when they’re unwell. It’s a mark of a civilised society that cares for its citizens. It’s not a moral good to ignore illness and push yourself to breaking point.

cstaff · 22/09/2021 11:01

Our firm does not pay sick leave and as a result about 6 years ago I needed 5 months off to have an operation and had to save in advance to do this. If this had been a sudden accident or illness I am not sure what I would have done.

I think they developed a conscience after that and as a result of this they have since started a scheme whereby if you need longterm sick leave that will be covered but if you take time off for a cold or bug you are still not covered so the choice then is to either go unpaid or use up a days holidays.

It works in the sense that people are less likely to take the piss but a few years ago there was a flu epidemic and people continued to come into work because they couldn't afford not to, and in the long term the company lost out because more people got sick than should have.

ditalini · 22/09/2021 11:00

My partner had a lot of time off sick with mental health issues. He just got SSP.

There's no way he could have done his public facing job at the time. His biggest fear was literally starting screaming in work and not being able to stop.

So no, decent sick pay wouldn't have meant he was off for longer, but it might have allowed us to pay for the help he was unable to access in a timely fashion on the NHS and got him back to work quicker.

IveGotASongThatllGetOnYNerves · 22/09/2021 10:59

I'm self employed so I work when I'm ill unless I'm so I'll that I literally can't move because if I don't work, my family doesn't eat.
Being able to be off when ill is a luxury, not many se people can, people on zero hours contracts, people with crappy employers, etc.
None of that means that those who get sick pay shouldn't be off when ill. Ideally everyone who is ill should be able to take time off to recover.

blubberyboo · 22/09/2021 10:59

Sick pay is frequently “ sold” as part of a remuneration package and often it means employers are offering lower salaries or freezes so that they can include this benefit.

In the case of employees without this benefit or self employed there are insurance products that can be purchased such as income protection policies or key person benefits.

So I guess what I’m saying if you are choosing a job based on salary or potential earnings you also need to consider the entire package. Nobody wants to pay for insurance but if you don’t have then you should pay for it, not judge other people just because they have the benefit or have bought cover.

KylieKoKo · 22/09/2021 10:59

People who don't get sick pay have no choice but to work when they are sick but this isn't a good thing.

For a start, depending on the illness and working environment going in when sick has the potential to infect others, has the last 18 months taught you nothing?

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 22/09/2021 10:58

A bit controversial, but ikwym

I was a self employed barrister for years. We basically never took time off - not just because we wouldn’t be paid for time off but because your cases couldn’t continue without you.

I did show that it was possible to cope with no or very little time off, but it’s not ideal at all.

BippityBoppity87 · 22/09/2021 10:55

Yes I would if it was bad enough. I've just gotten over a nasty stomach bug, or could have been food poisoning. They weren't sure. But did end up in hospital over night on Friday very poorly. Blood coming out of places it shouldn't have been coming from. Took a few days to get over it. Feeling a bit better now, thank goodness. But no, I could not have gone into work like that, no way. I'm on minimum wage, so sick pay isn't that good, but I didn't really have a choice

I get what you mean though, some people might take the piss if they knew they were getting paid (or paid well) but I'd imagine they would be in the minority

Poppins2016 · 22/09/2021 10:55

I think it could go 50/50. If you're genuinely unwell, you'll be taking time off work anyway... on the other hand, if it's just a sniffle/hangover, there would be more incentive to attend work if pay would be reduced.

Years ago I worked for an employer who would pay minimum wage plus an 'attendance bonus' every month which bumped the salary up to the market rate for that position. If you were off sick that month you wouldn't get the 'attendance bonus' portion of your salary. This probably did work to reduce absence 'for no good reason', but on the other hand it also increased office attendance while people were unwell and I've never caught so many illnesses (coughs, cold, norovirus, swine flu) via a workplace before. I worked there during the swine flu epidemic and when I caught it (most likely from colleagues) and was absent from work as a result I felt unfairly penalised as I was genuinely far too unwell to attend work (all because of work)! Surprise surprise, I left the company after about 6 months as I couldn't take the risk of losing salary due to illnesses likely caught via the workplace itself due to their policy!

Dixiechickonhols · 22/09/2021 10:53

I used to do litigation claims and it was very noticeable that people who received full pay were off a lot longer than those on ssp for similar injuries. My old workplace only paid ssp. People worked when ill eg puking in bucket or running to loo. Stuff understandably spread like wildfire. They changed rules to try to ban you coming in with some contagious illnesses. I had a serious health condition and used to have to take time off unpaid for surgery on regular basis. Was difficult financially and I was always back in work too soon. It definitely took its toll on me. Work had no idea how serious my condition was as I took so little time off i’d have general anaesthetic in hospital Friday back in Monday repeatedly.

Diceychoice · 22/09/2021 10:52

I'm paid SSP for sick leave. I've only ever been off when I literally can't do my job because of my health, and more than once that's led to me working when I shouldn't have been, and needing longer to recover because I made the situation worse. SSP is about a quarter of what I earn a week.
It's mainly been physical problems that have meant I've been off work, like when I broke my leg because I physically couldn't go, I had no choice.
I did have a period of stress and depression around 10 years ago that led to 3 months off work following an incident, without my family being off work would have just made the situation a whole lot worse because I'd have had financial problems to deal with too. I probably needed longer off to be honest.
Whenever I'm ill and feel like I need time off I have to weigh up if the following pay day, the hounding for missed payments and the few months of being utterly skint as I scramble to pay things back are worth it.
It has been quite a novelty to have 10 days with no loss of pay when I caught covid at work and had to be off.
There's still a stigma though, even if you're not getting paid full pay, no matter what you're off with , a pressure to return or not be off in the first place, and concequences from being ill too often from work.
Considering the impact it has, it's not a decision I take lightly at all.
I don't resent those that get full pay, I think it's really important that those caring for us are well themselves, and it's not their fault I don't, I just wish it extended to other jobs with a similar remit.

daisypond · 22/09/2021 10:50

I think that’s a very generous sick pay policy. I fail to see how the NHS can claim to be underfunded when they’re paying such generous amounts of sick pay. I’ve been having, and am restarting soon, cancer treatment. I get SSP only. I work in the private sector.

CarrotSticks23 · 22/09/2021 10:50

Well yes people without sick pay probably take less sick leave. But that doesn't mean that they don't need to take sick leave.

It will depend surely if you can afford the time off? When I have been self employed I have taken time off when sick because I am paid enough to accommodate this and make sure I have some money set aside, however I recognise this was a luxury. I am now 100% NHS and am grateful that I can comfortably take time off when I need it and don't have the added stress of wondering how will I afford it. I have yet to be signed of sick but I don't resent those who are completely burnt out and need some time off

Cornettoninja · 22/09/2021 10:49

I’m not sure whether you’re UR or not because I can’t quite work out whether you think it is too easy to get signed off or whether you’re highlighting an inequality for those without sick pay?

I’ve worked various jobs with various packages and on balance I would say people are more likely to take the odd day or two unpaid if they’re unwell and longer stretches if paid. The NHS sickness formula means that if you have more than one or two periods off sick you’re scrutinised which means people tend to take as long as they can get because if they go back before they’re ready it’s harder to go off again. It’s not a sickness policy that lends itself to mental health and the best balance between health (particularly mental health) and attendance.

bloodywhitecat · 22/09/2021 10:49

DH has cancer, he doesn't get sick pay but he has had no choice but to take days off for chemo and surgery. Not being paid at a time when he has a terminal diagnosis has made life very difficult indeed.

slightlysnippy · 22/09/2021 10:45

You're always going to get people who are going to work the system to their advantage. But good sick pay allows people to manage their physical and mental health as required, staff that receive no sick pay, will be more inclined to drag themselves into work when Ill, in the long run this helps neither the staff member or employer.

You mention lots of NHS workers off sick, are they taking the piss or really just a reflection on shit stressful working conditions ?

VestaTilley · 22/09/2021 10:45

I’m currently on sick leave; I’m fortunate that if I didn’t have sick pay I could live off DH’s income anyway.

But I won’t go back to work until I’m recovered regardless of how long that takes. As it is, I don’t yet feel well enough to go back - I’m aware staying off unpaid is not a luxury everyone can afford.

It’s not that easy to be signed off - you do have to be genuinely ill, which I am.

LagunaBubbles · 22/09/2021 10:45

seems a lot of threads on here start with "my anxiety" or I have PTSD or I am depressed. Is it too easy nowadays to ring your GP and be signed off on this basis?

And some people wonder why such stugma against mental illnesses exist?

Karmagoat · 22/09/2021 10:45

I don't get paid if I'm off sick ( I'm a cleaner) but I also have bipolar and GAD which was the cause of me having to leave my full time job ( with full sick pay) and take a part time job.
If I have a wobble (which unfortunately due to the nature of my illness is inevitable) I will have to have time off and just not get paid.
Mental health is shit, wouldn't wish it on anyone, wish people who don't actually really suffer from it would stop using it as an excuse.

GoWalkabout · 22/09/2021 10:43

Different circumstances. SIL has had to stop self employed work due to cancer treatment. I'd hazard a guess that if it was depression she would have had to cut her workload, change role or stop working but of course not off sick

Nofacedetected · 22/09/2021 10:42

I get measly SSP if I'm off. It certainly focuses the mind and I'd bet there would be a lot fewer people going off with "anxiety & depression" or stress if they had to survive on SSP.

HelpMeWorkThisOut · 22/09/2021 10:42

I have diagnosed C-PTSD, bipolar and chronic anxiety. I am self-employed, so generally can't take time off, or I don't get paid.

But I can adjust my workload, and work from home, and turn down work that I can't do - my financial situation allowing, of course. And those aren't options that a lot of people in jobs get.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 22/09/2021 10:40

I would think that this is particularly prevalent in the NHS front line staff more because of the nature of their job - the gruelling and stressful nature of it, massive underfunding meaning there arent enough staff or equipment to care for patients properly, being expected to work overtime and long shifts regularly, and the pandemic causing horrible conditions for everyone and leading to PTSD, we well as a culture of bullying and managing out whistleblowing.

Yes some people will take the piss if they're paid but a lot will be genuine because of the above. Employers who give sick pay but also look after their employees can still have low sickness rates so it is possible

NoEffingWay · 22/09/2021 10:39

I'm on the NHS bank, when I don't work I don't get paid. Injured myself and had to cancel work and will have to suffer for it.
When the choice is made for you financially you are much more likely to go to work!
The trust I work for treats bank staff like we are dim and unreliable but in reality the wards would close without us, in large part due to substantive staff sickness.

PermanentTemporary · 22/09/2021 10:38

One of the big factors in Covid spread/death rates was that nursing homes that didn't have sick pay had hugely increased numbers of deaths.

Swipe left for the next trending thread