Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you be off sick if you weren't being paid?

284 replies

MakeMineALarge1 · 22/09/2021 10:11

I work for the NHS, the sick package is very good, full pay for 6 months then half pay for another 6.

I know that its very stressful at the moment in acute care, sickness in our department is currently at 30% with up to 6 members of staff off per shift.

Lots of people citing stress etc, needing time out, and this is granted on full pay.

If you were self employed or hourly paid, would as people still be off with stress and still need "time out"

It seems a lot of threads on here start with "my anxiety" or I have PTSD or I am depressed. Is it too easy nowadays to ring your GP and be signed off on this basis?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Treesandsheepeverywhere · 25/09/2021 10:18

Work Shy Britain!!
Fine if it's genuine but a lot just aren't. I could never call in sick when I'm not as I'd be feeling guilty all day.

I remember another girl I worked with who was always ill on a Friday and Monday, literally without fail. It fell on the rest of us to pick up her work as it had to be done and couldn't wait for her to get back. It wasn't until she dated a colleague who spilt the beans once they'd broken up about it not being genuine off sickness, she left soon after.

Being signed off when you know you're not ill is not dissimilar to people who would rather be on benefits than work.

My partner's NHS colleague also went off sick the week before her holiday and flew out during the 'sick' period. She then worked from home during her first week back, logging in from her holiday destination. If that isn't taking the pass I don't know what is. She's a known case who when she had to self isolate, took 10 extra days 'just to be sure'.
It's everyone else who picks up the slack including tax payers in some cases. Unfortunately sick fakers are too selfish to care.

ToCutALongStoryShort · 25/09/2021 10:06

@winnieanddaisy your poor daughter, that's awful, no wonder she is traumatised, also working in the ITU where she was a patient. She will have great emapathy for what the patients are going through.

I also do bank around child care, kids going to school so lost some money when off sick as not able to work but at least get sick pay in my part time post, so grateful for that.

caravanman · 25/09/2021 09:49

I work in the 'gig' economy/freelance/self employed. I do not get paid if I do not work or to put it another way, I am only paid for the service I provide. If I cannot work, I do not get paid. What is more, any work that would have been allocated to me, will be allocated to someone else. I can have a holiday or break (unpaid), if I let the company know. So, for example, if I needed minor surgery, I could let the company know that I would be unavailable for a few days, but it would mean I would 'lose' money. I However, if I am unavailable for work for too long, the company will cease to use my services.

I fear becoming too ill to work. I often work when I am not really up to it and my performance is not too good. This also worries me because performance and quality are monitored.

I am lucky because I do not have young children who may need caring for, although I do have two adult sons who have serious MH issues.

So, in answer to the OP's question, no I would not take sick leave if I did not get paid, and, in an increasing number of work based situations, there is no such thing as sick leave. This is a huge step backwards in terms of human rights.

RobinPenguins · 25/09/2021 09:26

@CityMumma78

If people get paid for sick leave they will take advantage! I bet the statistics would show self employed people take far less sick days for this very reason.
And if people don’t get sick leave they will go to work when they shouldn’t, potentially spreading viruses to their colleagues. As demonstrated by the covid 19 pandemic.

My self employed friends probably do take fewer days sick leave. They also have far more control over their work and can juggle it about and reschedule to manage periods of sickness, so it’s not really a fair comparison.

M4J4 · 25/09/2021 09:24

@CityMumma78

If people get paid for sick leave they will take advantage! I bet the statistics would show self employed people take far less sick days for this very reason.
Not true. I have never taken sick leave and nor have most of my colleagues.
CityMumma78 · 25/09/2021 09:22

If people get paid for sick leave they will take advantage! I bet the statistics would show self employed people take far less sick days for this very reason.

LoverOfAllThingsPurple · 24/09/2021 20:08

I read in some training for a new job that since they brought policies and procedures in Acts of Parliament for Safety and manual handling at work, mental health illness absences soared. However, in the social care sector, time off for mental health and burnout issues are very real.

winnieanddaisy · 24/09/2021 18:26

Before I retired I was a nurse in a NHS hospital . I had a couple of long periods on sick leave for approximately 5 months each . One was a major operation and the other was when my husband died suddenly.
I had very few sick days other than these . I would go in with a migraine, I would go in flooding off my feet along with really bad period pains . I wasn't asking for a medal , all the other staff were the same . We all knew that if we took a day off they might not have someone to cover us so the ward would be short staffed and there would be so much more stress on the rest of the nurses .
My daughter is also a nurse and was in ITU of the hospital that she works in last November with covid . She has been back at work now for a few months but she has been diagnosed with PTSD . She is just getting on with it .
She didn't need to go back when she did because her illness was workplace acquired and she would have been on full pay as long as she needed it . She is not the type to take advantage so as soon as she was physically strong enough she returned to her job .
I can see the stress in her face each time she comes home from a shift .
Not everyone is a piss taker in the NHS , in fact very few are .

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 24/09/2021 18:06

There are a lot of chances out there unfortunately who have no shame and spoil it for the genuinely ill people. If you don't have a moral compass, it's easy to take advantage. I know someone who makes up illnesses for time off, gets signed off as it's now a 'chronic issue. No shame whatsoever.

M4J4 · 24/09/2021 13:20

No, I work for a massive company with generous sick policy, but I haven’t called in sick in years. Not even during COVID, as we were WFH. I obviously did less. And of course wouldn’t have gone into the office with CV.

TractorAndHeadphones · 24/09/2021 13:13

Also many workplaces are the cause of mental health issues.
Sick leave policies have to be looked at as part of a holistic OH management process. This includes the leeway given to managers to make flexible working arrangements (for those who are long term sick

TractorAndHeadphones · 24/09/2021 13:03

@Harmonypuss

Don't get me started on people's mental health.

I worked for a National Institute concerned with mental health for over a decade. We worked tirelessly to get Mental Health the same recognition and funding as acute health for years.

The government forced us to disband 10 years ago but at that time we were just starting to see some benefits peeping through as a result of our labours.

Then lots of celebs and Princes William and Harry started talking about their mental health and people started to realise that there was no longer so much stigma attached to mental health issues.

We (myself and many of my colleagues who'd been fighting for this) saw this as a great thing…. UNTIL…. some people started realising that they could go to their doctor saying they were feeling a bit down/depressed and get signed off work for weeks at a time. No-one was forced to have antidepressants, cbt or counselling, so it has become an easy way to get some time off work without having to provide samples or be sent to hospital for tests.

Now, before anyone starts attacking me, please note I did say "some people", I am clearly (based upon my work history), fully aware that there are a great many genuine cases of people struggling with mental health issues, so I'm NOT tarring everyone with the 'faking it' brush, far from it.

In light of the ease with which many people (a few of whom I know personally) are able to fake mental health issues, it sometimes makes me wonder whether my team and I actually did a good thing or not in trying to drag mental health onto the same playing field as acute health issues.

It’s very easy to fake low-level mental health issue because it relies 100% on self-reporting. So there can never be a level playing field.

IMO GP’s shouldn’t be allowed to sign people off for mental health issues. However this relies on MH professionals being available in greater numbers…

Cornettoninja · 24/09/2021 12:03

@Backwaterjunction with respect you don’t know anything beyond what someone has shared regarding PTSD or any other personal issue.

You may feel exasperated, but in the absence of any more information than had been divulged it’s best to keep those thoughts to yourself because it’s not your job to gate-keep diagnoses at the expense of other peoples feelings and credibility.

Thelnebriati · 24/09/2021 10:30

@Toodlepip100

I work in the NHS & i would rather we were not paid for single days off tbh as we are made to feel guilty at being off & episodes of sickness are managed .I don't think we should be going in when we have colds etc .
The answer is to change the culture that makes people feel guilty. Guilt in the workplace is as ridiculous as presenteeism, or imagining that having 'spare' staff is a sign of inefficiency or overstaffing.
EatSleepRantRepeat · 24/09/2021 09:12

Typical mumsnet thread - all #bekind and understanding about mental health issues, until it costs you money. The attitudes of some on here are shocking - including not paying sick pay to your own employees. You have no idea who's headed down the food bank after you've shafted them. Disgusting.

Toodlepip100 · 24/09/2021 09:06

I work in the NHS & i would rather we were not paid for single days off tbh as we are made to feel guilty at being off & episodes of sickness are managed .I don't think we should be going in when we have colds etc .

ElephantOfRisk · 24/09/2021 09:02

And for lots of jobs the work doesn't go away when you are off, you just need to pick that up and do it alongside all the new work when you get back.

ElephantOfRisk · 24/09/2021 09:00

This is only going to get worse with people waiting until 67 (or maybe older) to get their pension.

DH does a very physical NHS job and is 60 soon and his work partner is 62. They are both very fit because they work at it and they need to be, however is it feasible really for them to be still doing that at 67?

I do a stressful mental job and I'm a bit younger but also know there is no way I can do this much into my 60s.

People are going to get injured or mentally ill under these circumstances.

I know there are other jobs, but not for all the older folk who need a light duties type of job.

It's inevitably going to mean that people who get paid sick leave start needing to use it more.

Agree it needs to stop being a race to the bottom and from the government side they need to consider the cost of people needing to be on benefits if they give up work and for companies, the cost of replacing and training new staff vs the cost of some sick leave.

Barney60 · 24/09/2021 08:44

I work in a hospital but im bank, i do more hours than most of the "employed staff" but i dont get paid if im off, yet they do.

WheresTheLambSauce · 24/09/2021 02:10

Should add that part of the reason my anxiety worsened so rapidly was because my workplace was putting increasing pressure on me to go back to work full time, when I didn't feel mentally ready.

WheresTheLambSauce · 24/09/2021 02:08

I'm on SSP, and in a job that is currently short-staffed to the point where one or two absences puts strain on the entire building.

I still try to be honest with myself when I'm at my physical or mental limit, though. Back at the end of lockdown my anxiety took an awful nosedive (to the point of SH and suicidal ideation) and I had to go on LTL. This was after the doctor putting me on anti-depressants and my work trying me on reduced hours, mind.

I really don't know what position I would have been in if I hadn't had that time away from work. I'm still struggling now, but fingers crossed I don't need to go through that process again.

MissTrip82 · 24/09/2021 01:05

Interesting experiences of the health system.

For me and my medical colleagues, covid represents our first experience of sick leave because we can’t work pending a test.

For me a pending covid test was my first sick day in 15 years. Similar for many others.

chicken12 · 24/09/2021 00:49

I have anxiety and depression but i don't take time off not because I'm not sick enough but because I have to have return to work and get told I cannot have any more sick days in 12 months you can't help being off if your vomiting but some people in this country would love if poor people did not get any help because it is our fault we will not get any sick pay maternity pay or pension if this government gets its way

BeanBag21 · 24/09/2021 00:48

6 months full pay and 6 months half pay is only given to NHS employees after 5 years of service.

In the first year it's 1 months full, 2 months half. 2nd year is 2 months full and 2 months half. It gradually increases and being off sick too many times may mean you can't get the sick pay at all.

I think sick pay packages should be a right, if it can be regulated. It is horrible that staff have to work when they shouldn't be.

Many people with mental health issues will drag themselves to work on terrible days because we're already worried about what people will think of us. I think we have to be careful not to tar everyone with the same brush here.

blackheartsgirl · 24/09/2021 00:20

Pressed too soon. Haven't been assessed meant to say but doctor thinks I probably have..been referred